The Allahabad High Court has acquitted an 80-year-old man who had been sentenced to 20 years in prison in a POCSO case, holding that the evidence presented by the defence raised serious doubts about his presence at the scene of the alleged offence.
A Bench of Justice Santosh Rai found that the trial court had failed to properly consider records showing that the accused, Swamideen, was undergoing eye treatment in Chitrakoot—around 150 kilometres away from the place where the incident was alleged to have occurred.
The Court said the medical and hospital records, supported by defence witnesses, presented a plausible and unrebutted alibi.
“The documentary evidence produced by the defence… establishes a plausible and unrebutted case that the appellant was away from the place of occurrence, undergoing eye treatment at Chitrakoot, on the date of the alleged incident,” the Court observed.
The case arose from an alleged incident involving a four-year-old girl in December 2021. According to the prosecution, the child was allegedly taken inside a house after being offered a toffee, where the accused was alleged to have committed sexual acts against her.
A trial court in Hamirpur convicted Swamideen under Section 6 of the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act and sentenced him to 20 years in prison.
While challenging the conviction, the accused pointed to the five-day delay in lodging the FIR, inconsistencies in the complainant’s statements and the fact that the original complaint did not allege penetrative sexual assault.
The High Court found these arguments significant. It held that the delay in registering the case had not been satisfactorily explained and noted that the initial FIR invoked provisions relating to outraging modesty and sexual assault, but did not allege penetrative sexual assault.
The Court also found material contradictions in the evidence of the complainant. It said these inconsistencies affected the reliability of the testimony and raised the possibility that the child, who was four years old when first examined and six when examined again, could have been influenced while remaining in constant contact with her mother.
Medical evidence, the Court added, did not provide support to the prosecution’s case. The examination recorded a normal hymen without injury or swelling.
The Bench clarified that the absence of physical injuries alone would not be enough to defeat a POCSO prosecution. However, in the present case, it said the medical evidence was neutral, the eyewitness account contained serious contradictions and the accused had produced an unrebutted alibi.
Taken together, the Court concluded that the prosecution had failed to establish the charge through clear and reliable evidence. Swamideen was accordingly acquitted of all charges.