Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

9 Nov 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 14 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Supreme Court rejects grandson’s claim to father’s divided inheritance
  2. Supreme Court Upholds Compulsory Retirement of Two Chhattisgarh Clerks, Says No Prior Hearing Required
  3. Andhra Pradesh High Court dismisses unserved cheque-acquittal appeal
  4. Karnataka High Court remits legislator’s prosecution to Special Court
  5. Madhya Pradesh High Court quashes journalist’s communal-enmity FIR
  6. Bombay High Court quashes copyright FIR over branded tin sheets
  7. Bombay High Court refuses discharge in transgender complainant’s harassment case
  8. Bombay High Court remands customs order citing nonexistent judgments
  9. Delhi High Court upholds refusal of entry to OCI holder
  10. J&K Government Promises Advocate General Appointment Within a Month Before High Court
  11. Manipur HC Extends Census 2027 Suspension Until April 2027, Seeks Review of Population Concerns
  12. Allahabad High Court Slams ‘Baseless’ Cattle Slaughter Suspicion, Orders ₹15 Lakh Compensation for Seized Vehicle
  13. Sikkim High Court Pushes Centre, State to Act on 40 Dangerous Glacial Lakes After 2023 Flood Disaster
  14. Gujarat High Court Slaps ₹1 Lakh Personal Penalty on Ahmedabad Collector for Defying Earlier Order

Supreme Court rejects grandson’s claim to father’s divided inheritance

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court rejected J. Rajesh’s partition claim over property that had become his father’s individual share following succession and a compromise partition.

Judge / Bench — Justices Augustine George Masih and Sunita Agarwal; judgment by Justice Sunita Agarwal.

Dismissing Civil Appeal 7020/2012 on 6 November 2026 (2026 INSC 1208), the court applied Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act. The grandson acquired no birthright in this divided property merely by invoking coparcenary principles. Neither the earlier compromise decree nor the father’s subsequent sale deeds had been challenged. No costs were ordered.

Advocates appearing — Appellant: K. Paari Vendhan. Respondent: K.K. Mani.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Upholds Compulsory Retirement of Two Chhattisgarh Clerks, Says No Prior Hearing Required

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has upheld the compulsory retirement of two employees of Chhattisgarh’s Legal Metrology Department, ruling that such an order, when based on an assessment of an employee’s service record, is neither punitive nor stigmatic and does not require a prior hearing. The Court also made it clear that an employee cannot challenge compulsory retirement simply because another officer with a comparable service record was allowed to continue in service. A bench of Justice Manmohan and Justice Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed the appeals filed by Chatur Singh Dhruw and Manharan Lal Sahu, who were compulsorily retired in 2017. The bench emphasised that the authority’s decision must be based on relevant material and formed in good faith, rather than on arbitrary considerations.

Service Record Review Led to Retirement

Dhruw and Sahu were initially appointed as Peons (Class IV) in the Legal Metrology Department in Raipur in 1989 and 1993, respectively. Both were subsequently promoted to Assistant Grade-III, with their promotions taking place in 2012 and 2013. Their services were regularised in 2015. In 2017, the Chhattisgarh General Administration Department issued a circular requiring a review of government employees who had either completed 50 years of age or 20 years of qualifying service. The assessment was designed to examine an employee’s honesty, integrity, physical fitness, reputation and work efficiency. The committee was also required to consider the employee’s complete service record, including performance during the preceding five years and whether there had been a decline in work output. A Screening Committee examined the records of 14 clerical employees and recommended five for compulsory retirement. Dhruw and Sahu were subsequently retired under Fundamental Rule 56 and Rule 42(1)(b) of the Chhattisgarh Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1976. Their challenge before the Chhattisgarh High Court failed at both the single-judge and division-bench levels, prompting them to approach the Supreme Court.

Employees Alleged Unequal Treatment, Bypassing of Disciplinary Proceedings

Before the Supreme Court, the employees argued that the retirement criteria had not been applied consistently and that other officers with similar service records had been allowed to continue working. They further claimed that the retirement orders were punitive in nature and carried an element of stigma, effectively allowing the authorities to avoid initiating formal disciplinary proceedings. The employees also contended that their entire service records had not been properly examined and that adverse entries had not been communicated to them. They relied on earlier Supreme Court decisions, including Dev Dutt v. Union of India and Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India, in support of their arguments. They also cited Baikuntha Nath Das v. Chief District Medical Officer, arguing that their promotions and subsequent regularisation should have neutralised earlier adverse entries in their service records. Opposing the appeals, Additional Advocate General Rajat Nair submitted that the review had been conducted in accordance with the government circular. He stated that all 14 employees had been assessed using a uniform numerical grading system, ranging from A+ (5 marks) to D (1 mark), and that five employees failed to meet the prescribed benchmark.

Compulsory Retirement Does Not Require a Prior Hearing

Rejecting the employees’ challenge, the Supreme Court reiterated the settled legal position that compulsory retirement is not a punishment and does not, by itself, amount to a finding of misconduct. The bench observed: “Such an order does not cast any aspersion upon the conduct of the employee nor does it imply any finding of misconduct.” The Court accordingly held that the principle of audi alteram partem — the requirement to hear the other side — and the safeguards under Article 311(2) of the Constitution do not apply to compulsory retirement ordered in accordance with the relevant service rules. However, the Court clarified that the power cannot be exercised on a whim or through arbitrary decision-making. Referring to Nand Kumar Verma v. State of Jharkhand, the bench stated that the authority’s subjective satisfaction must be founded on objective and relevant material available on record.

Courts Cannot Reassess Service Records Like an Appellate Authority

The Supreme Court also explained the limits of judicial review in cases involving compulsory retirement. It observed that courts are not expected to re-examine or reweigh the material considered by the competent authority as though they were hearing an appeal against the decision. The scope of judicial scrutiny is confined to determining whether relevant material was available, whether the authority actually considered it, and whether the conclusion reached could reasonably have been drawn from that material. The Court thus underscored that judicial intervention is warranted where the decision is arbitrary, unsupported by relevant records or otherwise legally unsustainable — not merely because a different assessment might have been possible.

No Right to Challenge Retirement Based on Another Employee’s Treatment

Addressing the claim of discrimination, the bench rejected the argument that the employees’ retirement could be questioned because other similarly placed officers had not faced the same action. The Court observed that an employee cannot successfully challenge compulsory retirement merely by pointing to another officer with a comparable service record who was retained in service. The principle of “negative equality” cannot be invoked to demand similar treatment on the ground that another employee was not subjected to the same decision. The Court’s ruling reinforces the distinction between compulsory retirement, which is intended to assess an employee’s continued utility in public service, and disciplinary action, which is directed at establishing misconduct and imposing punishment.

Read current report and source

Andhra Pradesh High Court dismisses unserved cheque-acquittal appeal

Andhra Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team

The Andhra Pradesh High Court dismissed National Cooperative Bank’s long-pending appeal after repeated failures to serve the acquitted accused.

Judge / Bench — Justice Alapati Giridhar.

In Criminal Appeal 1022/2009, decided 3 November 2026, the court distinguished appeals against conviction from a complainant’s unprosecuted acquittal appeal. It held that the accused could not be convicted without notice and an opportunity to be heard. The bank’s counsel reported having no instructions.

Advocates appearing — Appellant: K.V. Akhileswra Reddy, on behalf of N. Ravi Prasad. State: Public Prosecutor (AP), individual name not given. Respondent1: Not named in the judgment/order.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court remits legislator’s prosecution to Special Court

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court quashed ordinary-magistrate proceedings against B.M. Farooq alias Bava Mohammed Farookh and remitted the matter to the designated Special Court.

Judge / Bench — Justice M. Nagaprasanna.

The 4 November 2026 order in Criminal Petition 7484/2024 held that special courts may try sitting or former legislators regardless of whether the alleged offence preceded their legislative tenure. The jurisdictional ruling did not extinguish the underlying investigation; the Special Court must regulate further procedure according to law.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner: M. Aruna Shyam, Senior Advocate, with Suyog Herele E., Advocate. Respondent1: B.N. Jagadeesha, State Public Prosecutor-I. Respondent2: Sathyanarayana Chalke, Advocate, for S. Rajendra, Advocate.

Read current report and source

Madhya Pradesh High Court quashes journalist’s communal-enmity FIR

Madhya Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team

The Madhya Pradesh High Court quashed an FIR against journalist Uvesh Khan alias Uvesh Reporter because the allegations identified no specific reporting that promoted enmity between communities.

Judge / Bench — Justice Himanshu Joshi.

The 28 October 2026 order in MCRC 51666/2025 (2026:MPHC-JBP:86748) concerned coverage of violence during a procession. The court stressed that journalistic status confers no immunity, but general assertions of fear or possible discord cannot replace the ingredients of Section 196(1) BNS. Crime 328/2025 and consequential proceedings against the applicant were quashed.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner: Sankalp Kochar, Advocate. State: Pramod Pandey, Government Advocate. Respondent2: Raman Choubey, Advocate.

Read current report and source

Bombay High Court quashes copyright FIR over branded tin sheets

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court quashed a copyright FIR concerning allegedly counterfeit tin sheets bearing JSW Steel’s name, finding no allegation of infringement of a protected artistic work.

Judge / Bench — Justice M.W. Chandwani.

The 6 November 2026 judgment in APL 918/2026 (2026:BHC-NAG:15223) distinguished a company’s name from an artistic logo. The allegations might concern trademark offences, but the court also found the sub-inspector’s search and seizure contrary to the required officer-rank safeguard. Saoner FIR 62/2026 under Sections 51 and 63 of the Copyright Act was quashed.

Advocates appearing — Applicant: Shoeb Asgar Khan and Syed Salman Ali, Advocates. State: Abhijeet G. Mate, Additional Public Prosecutor. Non-applicant2: Kartik N. Shukul with Gaurav Khatwani, Advocates.

Read current report and source

Bombay High Court refuses discharge in transgender complainant’s harassment case

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court refused discharge in a sexual-harassment prosecution involving a transgender complainant who identified as a woman, finding sufficient grounds for trial.

Judge / Bench — Justice Mehroz K. Pathan.

The 3 November 2026 decision in Criminal Revision 270/2026 (2026:BHC-NAG:15063) applied the law in force when the alleged 2025 incidents occurred. A later identity certificate did not itself defeat the transgender-protection charge. The court held that the complainant’s self-identification could not be questioned at this discharge stage; consent and proof of the allegations remained trial issues.

Advocates appearing — Applicant: Anil Thakkar, Advocate. State: Swati V. Kolhe, Additional Public Prosecutor.

Read current report and source

Bombay High Court remands customs order citing nonexistent judgments

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court set aside a customs adjudication order after Quanta Logistics challenged its reliance on allegedly nonexistent Supreme Court precedents.

Judge / Bench — Justices M.S. Karnik and Sandesh D. Patil; judgment by Justice Sandesh D. Patil.

The 30 October 2026 decision in WP 5093/2026 (2026:BHC-OS:24069-DB) recorded the respondents’ consent to remand for fresh adjudication. The court referred to precedent rejecting reliance on hallucinated authorities while distinguishing legitimate assistive AI use. Proceedings were directed to conclude within eight weeks from 5 November 2026.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner: Venkatesh Dhond, Senior Advocate, with Bimal Rajasekhar and Sunand Subramaniam, Advocates. Respondents1–2: Jitendra B. Mishra with Sangeeta Yadav.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court upholds refusal of entry to OCI holder

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court dismissed Charnjit Singh Bains’s challenge to refusal of entry into India, accepting the authorities’ reliance on information identifying him as a registered child sex offender abroad.

Judge / Bench — Justice Amit Mahajan.

The 3 November 2026 order in WP(C)2683/2026 stressed sovereign authority over foreign nationals’ entry. Bains disputed that the foreign proceedings involved a minor, while acknowledging a no-contest plea and probation. The court found no ground for discretionary writ relief; it recorded that the underlying security material was confidential.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner: Dr. Anand Duggal, Advocate, through video conference. Union of India: Amit Tiwari, Central Government Standing Counsel, with Ayushi Srivastava, Kushagra Malik, Arpan Narwal and Ujjwal Tyagi, Advocates.

Read current report and source

J&K Government Promises Advocate General Appointment Within a Month Before High Court

Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Jammu and Kashmir government has informed the High Court that the vacant post of Advocate General in the Union Territory will be filled within a month, bringing a prolonged wait for the appointment closer to an end. The assurance was given on November 5 during the hearing of a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) in Harsh Dubey v. UT of J&K, which seeks the immediate appointment of an Advocate General. Senior Additional Advocate General Monika Kohli told the Court that the appointment process was underway and would be completed within the stipulated one-month period. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Dr Pushpendra Singh Bhati and Justice Rajnesh Oswal recorded the government's submission and deferred the matter to December 8.

Advocate General's post vacant since October 2024

The post has remained vacant since October 18, 2024, when the then Advocate General, DC Raina, resigned following the formation of the Omar Abdullah-led National Conference government in Jammu and Kashmir. The continued absence of a full-time Advocate General has raised concerns over the functioning of the constitutional office and the responsibilities attached to it. The PIL, filed by advocate Harsh Dubey, seeks directions to the competent authority to take immediate steps to fill the vacancy. According to the petition, the prolonged vacancy is affecting the administration of justice and the discharge of statutory functions associated with the office.

Impact on Advocates' Welfare Fund Committee

The petitioner has also highlighted the impact of the vacancy on the Jammu and Kashmir Advocates Welfare Fund Trustee Committee. Under the Advocates’ Welfare Fund Act, 2001, the Advocate General serves as the ex-officio Chairperson of the Committee. The petition contends that the absence of an Advocate General has consequently affected the functioning of the statutory body. With the government now committing to complete the appointment process within a month, the High Court will take up the matter again on December 8.

Read current report and source

Manipur HC Extends Census 2027 Suspension Until April 2027, Seeks Review of Population Concerns

Manipur High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Manipur High Court has directed that the Census 2027 exercise in the State remain suspended until April 30, 2027, asking the Central government to examine concerns over displaced residents, population records and the accuracy of the proposed census. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice M Sundar and Justice A Guneshwar Sharma directed the Registrar General and Census Commissioner of India to consider seven representations and issue a common, reasoned decision by April 30, 2027. The Court also ordered that the existing notifications keeping the census on hold remain in force without any modification until that date. “ To put it differently, the census exercise for the State of Manipur will continue to be put on hold/kept in abeyance till 30.04.2027,” the Bench stated. The suspension will continue for another four weeks after the authorities decide the representations, giving affected parties an opportunity to challenge the decision before the Court.

Displacement and population records at the centre of the dispute

The November 4 judgment was delivered in a public interest litigation filed by the Kangleipak Students' Association (KSA) and the International Peace and Social Advancement (IPSA), along with a connected petition filed by Shanta Singh Nahakpam. The petitioners questioned the feasibility of conducting the census amid the continuing impact of ethnic violence in Manipur, which has left several residents displaced from their homes. Their concerns centred on the reliability of population data, the identification and enumeration of internally displaced persons, and the consequences of proceeding with the census without resolving these issues. The proceedings also brought into focus resolutions unanimously adopted by the Manipur Legislative Assembly on August 5, 2022 and March 1, 2024, calling for the introduction and enforcement of the National Register of Citizens (NRC). The petitioners had sought a postponement of the census until their concerns were addressed.

Centre and State had already agreed to defer the exercise

During an earlier hearing on August 31, the Central government informed the High Court that it had decided to postpone the house-listing operations for Census 2027 in Manipur. The State government also undertook not to begin the exercise scheduled for September 1, 2026. Following these developments, the Registrar General and Census Commissioner issued notifications on September 5 and October 30 concerning the deferment. The High Court took note of the existing suspension and the agreement among the parties that the representations should be examined before the census proceeds. The Bench directed the Census Commissioner to assess the seven representations on their merits and dispose of them through a common, reasoned order.

Public consultations permitted

The Court allowed the petitioners and other individuals or organisations to submit additional representations until November 25, 2026. The authorities may also conduct public consultations to examine the concerns raised. If they decide against holding such consultations, they must provide reasons for doing so. The final decision must be communicated to the lawyers representing the petitioners within five working days. It must also be uploaded to the official websites of the Manipur government and the Census Commissioner. The Bench clarified that parties dissatisfied with the outcome would be free to approach the High Court again. Any such challenge would be considered independently. While disposing of the petitions, the Court appreciated the balanced approach adopted by the parties and their representatives, noting the wider public and national interest involved in the matter. The Bench observed that the proceedings had been handled without being reduced to a routine adversarial contest. Senior Advocate Kh Tarunkumar appeared for the PIL petitioners, while Advocate Hijam Chandrakumar Singh represented the connected petitioner. Senior Advocate and Deputy Solicitor General Kh Samarjit appeared for the Centre. Senior Advocate and Manipur Advocate General Lenin Hijam represented the State.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Slams ‘Baseless’ Cattle Slaughter Suspicion, Orders ₹15 Lakh Compensation for Seized Vehicle

Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Allahabad High Court has ordered the Uttar Pradesh government to pay more than ₹15 lakh to a vehicle owner whose commercial vehicle was seized and confiscated over allegations of transporting two bullocks for slaughter. The Court found that the action was based on assumptions rather than evidence, leaving the owner without his primary source of income for an extended period. In Tej Prakash v. State of Uttar Pradesh and 4 Others, Justice Sandeep Jain held that the authorities could not presume that cattle were being transported for slaughter merely because the vehicle was intercepted in Mirzapur, a district bordering Bihar. “The existence of an international or inter-State boundary by itself cannot constitute proof of illegal transportation,” the Court observed. The Court emphasised that any conclusion about the intended destination or purpose of transportation must be supported by concrete evidence. Merely intercepting a vehicle in a border district cannot justify an assumption that the animals were being taken outside Uttar Pradesh for slaughter.

₹40,000 monthly compensation for loss of income

The Court quashed the confiscation order and directed the authorities to release the vehicle. It further ordered the State to pay compensation at the rate of ₹40,000 per month, calculated from September 18, 2023, the date of seizure, until the vehicle's actual release. The Court noted that the petitioner had purchased the DCM Eicher vehicle through a loan and was deprived of his principal means of livelihood due to the State's unlawful action. Considering the vehicle's commercial nature, the loan repayments and its ordinary earning capacity, the Court assessed the owner's monthly income loss at ₹40,000. An additional ₹25,000 was awarded for the mental anguish, financial distress and harassment caused by the illegal confiscation. The Court also made it clear that the State could recover the compensation paid from the officials responsible for the unlawful action, subject to an appropriate departmental inquiry.

No evidence of slaughter or animal cruelty

The case arose after Mirzapur police seized the petitioner's vehicle while it was transporting two bullocks. The authorities alleged that the transportation violated the Uttar Pradesh Prevention of Cow Slaughter Act, 1955. Challenging the confiscation, the petitioner argued that there was no evidence to establish that the animals were being taken to West Bengal for slaughter or that they had been subjected to cruelty during transportation. The High Court found that the authorities had failed to produce any material indicating the vehicle's intended destination. It also rejected the allegation of animal cruelty, noting that the bullocks had not been examined by a veterinary doctor. In the absence of such evidence, the Court held that cruelty could not be presumed merely from the alleged manner in which the animals were transported.

Permit not required for transportation within Uttar Pradesh

The Court further examined the applicable rules governing the transportation of cows and their progeny. It observed that a permit was required only when the animals were proposed to be transported outside Uttar Pradesh. The relevant rules did not mandate a permit for transportation within the State. Since the authorities had failed to establish that the bullocks were being taken beyond Uttar Pradesh, the confiscation could not be justified on the ground of a missing permit. The Court also noted that neither beef nor the remains of slaughtered cattle had been recovered from the vehicle. It concluded that the essential facts required to invoke the statutory presumption were absent, rendering the confiscation proceedings illegal and demonstrating a failure to properly apply the law. The Court accordingly set aside the confiscation order and granted relief to the vehicle owner. The judgment was delivered on November 3. Advocates Ashish Jaiswal and Sushil Kumar Mishra appeared for the petitioner.

Read current report and source

Sikkim High Court Pushes Centre, State to Act on 40 Dangerous Glacial Lakes After 2023 Flood Disaster

Sikkim High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Sikkim High Court has called for urgent steps to install early warning systems across 40 high-risk glacial lakes in the State, warning that preparedness is essential to prevent another devastating glacial lake outburst flood (GLOF). A Division Bench of Chief Justice A Muhamed Mustaque and Justice Bhaskar Raj Pradhan made the appeal in the ongoing case, Re: Climatic Justice in the State of Sikkim, while highlighting the need to avoid a repeat of the catastrophic flooding triggered by South Lhonak Lake in October 2023. The Bench noted that Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand and Bhutan had already introduced early warning mechanisms to tackle GLOF risks. It urged both the State and Central governments to move swiftly on procuring and installing similar systems. The Court observed that the October 2023 disaster should serve as a warning against delays in putting essential safeguards in place.

South Lhonak disaster remains a grim reminder

The glacial lake outburst at South Lhonak Lake in North Sikkim unleashed massive flooding along the Teesta River. The disaster damaged the Chungthang dam, swept away bridges and sections of National Highway 10, and caused extensive destruction across four districts. Several people lost their lives in the calamity. Against this backdrop, the High Court, through its November 5 order, sought details from the State government on the measures being taken to address the risks posed by the 40 identified glacial lakes. The Bench also asked the government to examine a proposal for appointing five nodal officers to oversee the monitoring and management of these lakes.

Five officers proposed for coordinated monitoring

The proposal was placed before the Court by amicus curiae Advocate Sudhir Mishra. Under the suggested arrangement, one senior nodal officer would be appointed within the Sikkim State Disaster Management Authority (SSDMA), supported by four additional officers. Each of the four officers would be responsible for monitoring ten glacial lakes. The proposed team would coordinate early warning measures, disaster preparedness, glacial movement monitoring and the collection of relevant information from various government departments. The Court sought the State's response on the proposal as part of its broader examination of disaster preparedness in the Himalayan region.

Climate change threatens Sikkim's black cardamom economy

The Bench also turned its attention to another growing concern: the impact of climate change on black cardamom cultivation in Sikkim. Referring to a report published by The Economic Times on October 11, the Court noted the deteriorating condition of black cardamom plantations in the State. Changing weather patterns, warmer winters and erratic rainfall have reportedly increased the vulnerability of crops to diseases. The decline has also raised concerns over the livelihood of rural households that depend heavily on black cardamom cultivation. The Court sought information from the State government on the steps being taken under the 'Mero Alaichi, Mero Dhan' (My Cardamom, My Wealth) initiative, which aims to revive the crop. The Bench stressed that climate change was likely to create several interconnected challenges and that these needed to be addressed with urgency.

Matter listed for November 18

The High Court will take up the matter again on November 18, when the State government's response on the glacial lake safety measures and black cardamom revival programme is expected to be considered. The proceedings bring together two pressing concerns for Sikkim: the growing threat of climate-related disasters in the Himalayan landscape and the economic vulnerability of communities dependent on climate-sensitive agriculture.

Read current report and source

Gujarat High Court Slaps ₹1 Lakh Personal Penalty on Ahmedabad Collector for Defying Earlier Order

Gujarat High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Gujarat High Court has directed the Ahmedabad Collector to pay ₹1 lakh from his own salary after he rejected a woman's application for non-agricultural land use on grounds that had already been declared legally unsustainable. Justice MK Thakker took a stern view of the Collector's repeated refusal to follow the Court's earlier directions in Bhumikaben v Collector, Ahmedabad & Anr., holding that government authorities cannot act as though judicial orders are optional. The Court observed that the Collector had once again relied on issues relating to past land transactions, despite an earlier ruling restricting the scope of scrutiny in applications seeking conversion of agricultural land for non-agricultural purposes. Taking strong exception to the conduct, the Court remarked: "This is not the first instance where the Collector has acted as a superpower authority and considering himself as a person, who can act according to his own whims and wish.... every person is required to respect and obey the orders of the Court with due dignity for the institution. The Government Departments are no exception to it." The Bench said the financial burden arising from the Collector's conduct should not be shifted to the State exchequer. Instead, the officer himself must compensate the litigant for the hardship caused by forcing her to approach the Court again.

Repeated rejection despite earlier judicial directions

The dispute originated from a landowner's application under Section 65 of the Gujarat Land Revenue Code, 1879, seeking permission to convert agricultural land for non-agricultural use. The Collector had rejected the application in February 2025, citing concerns over previous land transactions and the absence of permission under Section 63 of the Gujarat Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, which regulates transfers of agricultural land to non-agriculturists. The woman challenged the decision before the High Court. On March 2, 2026, the Court quashed the rejection and directed her to submit a fresh application, which the Collector was required to decide within the prescribed statutory period. The earlier judgment had clearly defined the limits of the Collector's authority while considering an application under Section 65. The inquiry, the Court had held, was confined to determining whether the applicant was the occupant of the land and whether the land was held or assessed for agricultural purposes. Questions concerning ownership rights or the legality of previous land transactions could not be examined in such proceedings. Despite those directions, the Collector rejected the woman's fresh application, submitted in April 2026, on August 6. The decision once again referred to previous land transactions and relied on adverse opinions from the Mamlatdar, the Agricultural Lands Tribunal and the Deputy Collector (Land Reforms). The Collector also cited a proposal by the State government to challenge the March 2 judgment. However, the High Court noted that no appeal had been filed against the earlier ruling.

Court warns government officers against undermining judicial authority

The High Court also took note of the Collector's failure to decide the fresh application within the prescribed timeframe. It made clear that government departments facing difficulties in implementing a judicial order must approach the Court for appropriate relief rather than disregard its directions. The Court observed that when an authority neither complies with an order nor seeks clarification or relief, its conduct can only be viewed as disobedience. It further cautioned that blatant violations of judicial directions reflect an officer's attempt to undermine the authority of the Court, its institutional dignity and the administration of justice. The Bench said: "The hardship which is caused to the litigants is required to be compensated by Collector himself from his own pocket."

₹1 lakh to be deposited within one month

Allowing the woman's plea, the High Court quashed the Collector's order dated August 6 and restored her application for fresh consideration in accordance with the directions issued in the earlier judgment. The Court ordered the Collector to deposit ₹1 lakh towards litigation costs with the High Court Registry within one month. The amount must be paid from his personal salary. It further directed that if the Collector fails to make the payment, the State government must deposit the amount and subsequently recover it from his salary. The money, once deposited and verified, is to be transferred electronically to the petitioner. Advocates Sunil S Joshi and Amit M Lashwani appeared for the petitioner, while Additional Government Pleader Jay Trivedi represented the Collector and the State government.

Read current report and source