Saved newspaper
11 Nov 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 9 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Supreme Court restores bail for Bihar hospital administrator
- Delhi High Court narrows injunction against Rana Kapoor biography
- Sikkim High Court dismisses challenge to judicial service recruitment
- Madras High Court orders criminal investigation into library procurement
- Calcutta High Court Rejects APDR Plea for Probe into Durga Puja Book Stall Demolition
- Speaking to a Male Friend Is No Ground for Adultery Allegations; Such Accusations Amount to Mental Cruelty: Jharkhand High Court
- Delhi High Court Shields Singapore Law Firm From Coercive Tax Recovery, Questions PAN Allotment
- Aadhaar Card Cannot Override Medical Evidence on Age, Rules Madhya Pradesh High Court
- Himachal Pradesh High Court upholds Section 354 conviction
Supreme Court restores bail for Bihar hospital administrator
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court restored a Bihar hospital administrator’s bail in an alleged bribery case. It said the High Court could have rejected the Sessions Court’s reliance on the amount allegedly demanded without cancelling bail nearly a year after his release.
Judge / Bench — Justice J.B. Pardiwala and Justice Manmohan.
In Vishwajeet Singh @ Bishwajeet Ramanand v State of Bihar & Ors. (SLP(Crl.) 13108/2026, 6 November 2026), the Court noted that custody beyond 48 hours triggers deemed suspension for a public servant. It asked Bihar to examine his return to the same post.
Advocates appearing — Appellant: Awanish Sinha (AOR), Prem Ranjan Kumar, Sanjib Kumar Mohanty, Desh Ratan Nigam, Sumit Kumar. State: Aditi Tripathi (AOR), Udayan Sinha. Respondent 2: Karan Verma (AOR). Respondent 3: Not named in the judgment/order. Respondent 4: Himanshu Shekhar (AOR), Parth Shekhar, Ambali Vedsen, Shubham Singh, Arvind Kumar Tomar.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court narrows injunction against Rana Kapoor biography
Delhi High Court · Editorial Team
The Delhi High Court lifted the blanket ban on Yes Man, a book about former Yes Bank chief Rana Kapoor. The interim restraint now covers only four passages.
Judge / Bench — Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar.
In FAO 228/2024 and 230/2024 (2026:DHC:9973, 6 November 2026), the court held that three passages were prima facie defamatory and one derogatory. It found a book-wide restraint disproportionate and left final findings to trial.
Advocates appearing — HarperCollins (appellant, 228; respondent 2, 230): Essenese Obhan, Ashima Obhan, Yogita Rathore, Tushar Chauhan. Pavan Chand Lall (respondent 2, 228; appellant, 230): Percival Billimoria, Senior Advocate, with Nattasha Garg, Anubhav Dubey, Thakur Ankit Singh, Rachita Sood, Priyamvada Paneru, Liza Arora, Anandi Katiyar. Rana Kapoor (respondent 1, both): Naman Joshi, Guneet Sidhu, Aakash Deep Singh. Respondents 3–4: no appearance.
Read current report and source
Sikkim High Court dismisses challenge to judicial service recruitment
Sikkim High Court · Editorial Team
The Sikkim High Court dismissed a challenge to recruitment for five entry-level judicial posts. None of the petitioning lawyers had applied by 30 October, and their request for interim relief came after applications closed.
Judge / Bench — Chief Justice A. Muhamed Mustaque.
In Anirudh Gupta and Others v State of Sikkim and Others (WP(C) 88/2026, 4 November 2026), the court held that the petitioners lacked standing at that stage. It left the validity of the Certificate of Identification requirement open for an appropriate case.
Advocates appearing — Petitioners in person: Anirudh Gupta and the other petitioners, whose names are not stated. Respondents 1–3: Zangpo Sherpa, Additional Advocate General, with Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate. Respondent 4: none.
Read current report and source
Madras High Court orders criminal investigation into library procurement
Madras High Court · Editorial Team
The Madras High Court directed the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption to register an FIR into suspected fraud in Tamil Nadu’s public library book purchases.
Judge / Bench — Justices G. R. Swaminathan, authoring judge, and M. D. Sumathi.
In Ramasubbu’s contempt petition 3763/2026, the 10 November 2026 order found that earlier procurement safeguards had gone unenforced. It directed immediate account freezes, disciplinary action including suspension of implicated officials, removal of suspect books from public access, and an affidavit identifying those responsible.
Advocates appearing — Petitioner: K. P. S. Palanivel Rajan, Senior Counsel, for P. M. Vishnu Varthanan. Respondents: B. Saravanan, Additional Advocate General, assisted by M. Kannan, Special Government Pleader; John Sathyan, State Public Prosecutor.
Read current report and source
Calcutta High Court Rejects APDR Plea for Probe into Durga Puja Book Stall Demolition
Calcutta High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Calcutta High Court has declined to order an independent investigation into the demolition of a temporary book stall belonging to the Association for Protection of Democratic Rights (APDR) near Jadavpur 8B Bus Stand during Durga Puja celebrations. Justice Rishad Medora dismissed the organisation's petition, holding that the demolition did not involve a violation of its fundamental rights warranting intervention under the Court's writ jurisdiction, as the stall had been set up without the requisite permission. However, the Court clarified that APDR remained free to pursue other remedies available under the law to seek an enquiry into the incident. "It does not appear that any fundamental right of the petitioner has been violated for it to approach this Court in its writ jurisdiction," the Court observed. It also clarified that since no affidavit had been sought from the respondents, the allegations in the petition could not be treated as admitted. The case arose from an incident during Durga Puja when individuals allegedly identifying themselves as Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC) officials, accompanied by a large police contingent, entered the area and forcibly dismantled APDR's temporary book stall. According to the organisation, the demolition took place without prior notice, a written order or any formal communication explaining the action. APDR maintained that it had approached the Joint Commissioner of Police and the Assistant Director of Borough X of the KMC seeking permission to establish and operate the stall. It also claimed to have deposited the prescribed municipal fee. The organisation argued that none of the authorities had communicated any objection or rejection of its application before the stall was demolished. Following the incident, APDR submitted representations to the State Home Minister, the Municipal Commissioner, the Inspector General of Police and the Vigilance Authority, seeking an investigation and accountability for the demolition. It alleged that these complaints failed to produce any meaningful response. Through its petition, the organisation sought a direction requiring the authorities to examine its representations and initiate an impartial, time-bound enquiry to identify those responsible. It also sought compensation for the financial losses suffered following the destruction of the stall. Opposing the plea, the State government argued that the organisation had never received formal permission to set up the book stall. It contended that judicial consideration of the representations would serve no useful purpose in the absence of such approval. The Court ultimately declined to order an investigation or grant the compensation sought by APDR, while leaving the organisation at liberty to explore other available legal remedies. Case: Association for Protection of Democratic Rights v. State of West Bengal and Others Advocates Debangana Dey and Bhaskar Roy appeared for APDR. Senior Advocate Piyush Chaturvedi, assisted by Advocate Nilanjan Chatterjee, represented the Kolkata Municipal Corporation. The State was represented by Government Pleader DN Roy, along with Advocates Anindya Basu and Indradeep Pal.
Read current report and source
Speaking to a Male Friend Is No Ground for Adultery Allegations; Such Accusations Amount to Mental Cruelty: Jharkhand High Court
Jharkhand High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Jharkhand High Court has ruled that questioning a wife's character and accusing her of having an extramarital relationship merely because she speaks to a male friend amounts to mental cruelty. The Court described such allegations as rooted in gender-based stereotypes and rejected the notion that a woman's friendship with a man can automatically invite suspicions of infidelity. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice MS Sonak and Justice Manoj Prasad made the observations while dismissing a husband's appeal seeking dissolution of his marriage. The husband had alleged that his wife was involved in an extramarital relationship because she frequently spoke to a male acquaintance over the telephone. Rejecting this line of reasoning, the Court observed that such accusations reflect a stereotypical mindset in which a woman's conversation with a male friend is treated as evidence of adultery. "To our considered view, such allegations are typical gender-based stereotypes, where, if a woman talks to a man, even if he is a friend, charges of adultery or of an extramarital relationship are levelled. We are, therefore, of the considered view that such allegations amount to cruelty towards the wife," the Bench stated. Background of the Dispute The couple married in 2005 and have two children. Their matrimonial relationship eventually deteriorated, prompting the husband to approach the Family Court in 2021 seeking a divorce. He claimed that his wife showed little interest in continuing the marriage and that their relationship was marked by frequent arguments. He specifically complained about her regular telephone conversations with a male friend. The husband further alleged that his wife had left the matrimonial home in 2015 and moved to her parental residence. The wife, however, presented a different account. She alleged that she had been subjected to harassment over dowry demands at her matrimonial home. She also maintained that her husband had made no genuine attempt to restore their marital relationship or bring her back. In 2023, the Family Court rejected the husband's allegations, finding that the grounds of cruelty had not been established. The husband subsequently challenged the decision before the High Court. Husband's Witnesses Failed to Establish Cruelty Upholding the Family Court's decision, the High Court found that the husband had failed to produce convincing evidence to substantiate his claims. The Bench pointed out that the witnesses brought forward by him were not family members but appeared to be colleagues and personal acquaintances. Their statements, therefore, required closer scrutiny. The Court observed that testimony from a family member, particularly the husband's mother, could have provided meaningful corroboration, especially since she was also allegedly involved in the matrimonial disputes. However, no such evidence was presented. The Bench also declined to place reliance on the testimony of the couple's 11-year-old daughter. It noted that the child had admitted that her entire statement had been prepared at her father's dictation. Examining the husband's own testimony, the Court found that his allegations of physical and mental harassment were unsupported by credible material. It further noted that he had neither approached any competent authority with a complaint nor made any meaningful effort towards reconciliation. "These facts lead to the conclusion that the allegations of cruelty were not proved by the present appellant," the Court held. Wife Cannot Be Blamed for Desertion, Court Says The High Court also rejected the husband's argument that his wife had deserted him. It noted that the wife had expressed her willingness to resume married life, but the husband had refused to accept her proposal. The Bench additionally referred to a compromise entered into between the couple in 2015. Although the agreement required them to resume living together, the Court observed that its terms appeared to have been followed only to facilitate the settlement of a criminal case. The parties, in reality, did not resume their matrimonial life as contemplated under the compromise. Finding no evidence to establish either cruelty or desertion on the wife's part, the High Court dismissed the husband's appeal and upheld the Family Court's decision. The ruling reinforces that ordinary interactions between women and male acquaintances cannot be treated as proof of infidelity, and baseless allegations questioning a wife's character may themselves amount to mental cruelty.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court Shields Singapore Law Firm From Coercive Tax Recovery, Questions PAN Allotment
Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Delhi High Court has granted interim protection to Singapore-based maritime law firm Holman Fenwick Willan Singapore LLP, restraining the Income Tax Department from taking coercive action to recover tax dues arising from an assessment order passed against the firm. The dispute centres on the department's decision to assess the firm's income despite its alleged absence of any business establishment or physical presence in India. A Division Bench comprising Justice Dinesh Mehta and Justice Aditi Choudhary passed the interim order on October 16 after the firm challenged an assessment order dated May 9, 2025, a penalty order dated December 24, 2025, and a consequential demand notice issued on the same day. Representing the Singapore law firm, advocate Vibhooti Malhotra submitted that the firm had never operated from India and had not even applied for a Permanent Account Number (PAN). Despite this, the Income Tax Department allegedly allotted a PAN to the firm on its own and initiated assessment proceedings without bringing the matter to its knowledge. The firm contended that the assessment and subsequent penalty proceedings were initiated despite the absence of any Indian presence, raising questions about the basis on which the tax authorities proceeded against it. Taking note of the submissions, the High Court directed the Income Tax Department not to initiate coercive recovery measures in connection with the disputed assessment. "The respondents shall not take any coercive measure for recovery of the demand raised by assessment order dated 09.05.2025 and consequential demand notice dated 24.12.2025 issued to the petitioner," the Bench ordered. The Court also directed Puneet Rai, Senior Standing Counsel appearing for the Income Tax Department, to obtain instructions and submit a short counter-affidavit within three weeks. The matter is scheduled to come up for further hearing on November 18. Advocates Bhuvnesh Satija and Aniket Khanduri also appeared for the law firm, while Junior Standing Counsel Ashwini Kumar and Rishabh Nangia represented the Income Tax Department. The interim protection will remain relevant as the High Court examines the firm's challenge to the assessment, penalty and recovery proceedings.
Read current report and source
Aadhaar Card Cannot Override Medical Evidence on Age, Rules Madhya Pradesh High Court
Madhya Pradesh High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has clarified that an Aadhaar card cannot be treated as conclusive evidence of a person's age, holding that a postmortem report supported by medical assessment can carry greater evidentiary value when the two records differ. Justice Amit Seth made the observation while deciding an appeal seeking higher compensation for the parents of a 13-year-old boy who died in a road accident in December 2019. The case, Rajesh Singh & Anr. v. Rahul Singh & Ors., arose from a dispute over the boy's age, which had a direct bearing on the compensation payable to his parents. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal (MACT), Bhind, had assessed the boy's age at 14 years, seven months and nine days based on his Aadhaar card. The insurance company challenged this assessment, arguing that the postmortem report had recorded his age as 13 years. Accepting the insurance company's contention, the High Court said Aadhaar is primarily an identity document and cannot independently establish a person's age beyond doubt. The Court noted that a postmortem report records age following a medical examination, making it a more dependable source in the circumstances of the case. It observed that the medical opinion documented during the postmortem examination provided a more reliable basis for determining the deceased boy's age than the Aadhaar entry. Dispute over the compensation multiplier The parents had approached the High Court seeking enhancement of the ₹5.45 lakh compensation awarded by the MACT in September 2022. Apart from challenging the age assessment, the insurance company disputed the multiplier used to calculate compensation. It argued that since the boy was below 15 years old, a multiplier of 15 should apply instead of 18. The parents opposed the argument, relying on the Supreme Court's 2025 decision in Ku Aarti v. Udayveer Singh, where a multiplier of 18 had been adopted in a case involving the death of a nine-year-old child. However, the High Court relied on the Supreme Court's ruling in Divya v. National Insurance Company Limited (2022) and held that a multiplier of 15 was applicable in cases involving children below 15 years of age. Compensation increased to ₹8.25 lakh The High Court also accepted the parents' submission that the boy's notional income should be assessed with reference to the minimum wages payable to an unskilled worker. Accordingly, it fixed his monthly income at ₹7,950. After deducting 50 per cent towards personal expenses and applying the multiplier of 15, the Court calculated the loss of dependency at ₹7,15,500. The compensation was further enhanced through the following amounts:
₹40,000 each to the father and mother towards loss of parental consortium.
₹15,000 towards funeral expenses.
₹15,000 towards loss of estate.
With these additions, the total compensation payable to the parents was revised from ₹5.45 lakh to ₹8,25,500. The Court partly allowed the appeal and directed that the enhanced amount of ₹2,80,500 would carry interest at 6 per cent per annum from the date of filing of the original compensation claim until payment. The ruling underscores an important distinction between identity documentation and evidence used to establish age in compensation proceedings, particularly where conflicting records have a direct impact on the amount payable to accident victims' families.
Read current report and source
Himachal Pradesh High Court upholds Section 354 conviction
Himachal Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team
The Himachal Pradesh High Court upheld Punnu Ram’s Section 354 IPC conviction, one-year prison sentence and ₹5,000 fine.
Judge / Bench — Justice Rakesh Kainthla.
Deciding Criminal Revision 194/2015 on 2 November 2026 (2026:HHC:47931), it accepted the woman’s account, corroborated by prompt reporting and her immediate narration to witnesses. A denied suggestion of a money dispute did not prove the defence. The court found no basis to disturb reasonable concurrent findings in revision.
Advocates appearing — Petitioner: N.S. Chandel, Senior Advocate; Sidharth, Advocate (appearance list); Shwetima Dogra, assisting counsel (hearing paragraph 9). State: Additional Advocate General P.K. Nadda (appearance list), Pawan Kumar Nadda (hearing paragraph 9).
Read current report and source