Saved newspaper
14 Nov 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 11 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Madras High Court Hands Isha Yoga Centre Missing Volunteer Case to CB-CID Over Investigation Delay
- Calcutta High Court Halts Demolition of TMC Leader Jahangir Khan’s Residence, Seeks Proof of Notice
- Delhi High Court: Stamp Duty Cannot Turn on Where the First Signatory Happens to Be
- Punjab & Haryana High Court Refuses to Revoke Bail of Former DLF CFO in ₹311 Crore Extortion Case
- Karnataka High Court scraps 11-year-old SC/ST Act case against Baba Kalyani over NICE road land dispute
- Calcutta High Court Slams Mizoram’s ‘Regime Revenge’, Orders Completion of ₹38.3 Crore Kolkata Land Deal
- Tripura High Court upholds compensation over death in prison
- Madhya Pradesh High Court orders lender to return possession of home
- Delhi High Court imposes ₹2 lakh costs for repeated petitions
- Punjab and Haryana High Court counts waiter’s tips in accident award
- Karnataka High Court orders uniform conduct of entrance tests
Madras High Court Hands Isha Yoga Centre Missing Volunteer Case to CB-CID Over Investigation Delay
Madras High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Madras High Court has transferred the investigation into the disappearance of a volunteer associated with the Isha Yoga Centre in Coimbatore to the Crime Branch-Criminal Investigation Department (CB-CID), expressing dissatisfaction over the police's failure to make meaningful progress in the case. Justice GK Ilanthiraiyan passed the order on October 27 in Thirumalai v. Superintendent of Police, Coimbatore, observing that the local police had not completed the investigation despite previously assuring the Court that a final report would be filed within three months. The Court noted that even after receiving additional time, the investigating authorities had failed to take the necessary steps in Crime No. 26 of 2023. "Even till today, the second respondent did not even proceed with the investigation and did not take steps to complete the investigation," the Court observed. The matter relates to the disappearance of Ganesan, a 46-year-old volunteer associated with the Isha Yoga Centre, founded by Jaggi Vasudev. He reportedly went missing from the Coimbatore centre in March 2023. Concerned after being unable to reach his brother for several days, Thirumalai contacted the ashram. He was reportedly informed that Ganesan, who worked at the centre, had not turned up for duty for two days. A missing person complaint was subsequently lodged at the Alandurai Police Station in Coimbatore. With no breakthrough in the search, Thirumalai approached the High Court through a habeas corpus petition, alleging that the police had failed to trace his brother. The case also brought wider attention to reports of missing persons associated with the Isha Foundation. During proceedings in March 2024, the Tamil Nadu Police informed the High Court that six people had gone missing from the institution since 2016. In a subsequent hearing in April 2024, the police told a Division Bench of Justices MS Ramesh and Sunder Mohan that they had questioned 36 people, including employees and volunteers connected with the centre. The authorities sought further time to submit details of the investigation. Thirumalai later filed the present petition seeking to remove the case from the local police and hand it over to the CB-CID. During the proceedings, the police submitted a status report on June 9 this year, assuring the Court that the investigation would be completed and a final report filed within three months. However, the assurance did not translate into action. Taking note of the continued delay, Justice Ilanthiraiyan concluded that the investigation could no longer remain with the Alandurai Police Station and ordered its transfer to the CB-CID. The Court directed the CB-CID, Coimbatore, to undertake a proper and fair investigation and submit its final report within 12 weeks from the date of receiving the complete case diary. With these directions, the High Court disposed of the petition.
Read current report and source
Calcutta High Court Halts Demolition of TMC Leader Jahangir Khan’s Residence, Seeks Proof of Notice
Calcutta High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Calcutta High Court has put a temporary stop to the demolition of Trinamool Congress (TMC) leader Jahangir Khan’s residence, questioning whether the authorities had properly informed him about the proceedings while he was lodged in jail. Justice Suvra Ghosh passed the interim order in Jahangir Khan v. The State of West Bengal and Ors., directing the State government to establish that notices relating to the demolition hearings were duly served on Khan before any further action could be taken against his house. The Court took note of the fact that Khan and his wife are currently in judicial custody and questioned how he could have participated in the proceedings if the authorities had not attempted to serve him with notices in prison. "The petitioner was admittedly in custody at the relevant time. No attempt was made to serve notice upon him at the correctional home," the Court observed. It further directed the State to substantiate the service of hearing notices issued by the Hearing Officer and Executive Officer before proceeding with the demolition. Consequently, the authorities have been restrained from carrying out any further demolition until the next hearing. Khan approached the High Court after learning about the demolition drive through social media. According to his petition, his son informed him about the development when he visited him in prison earlier this month. Khan maintained that he had received no formal communication regarding the proposed action. Senior Advocate Kishore Dutta, appearing for Khan, argued that the authorities had failed to serve him with notice. He also disputed the State's claim that notices had been pasted at the property. Dutta further informed the Court that the residence had allegedly been vandalised and that the sanctioned building plan had been stolen. He submitted that the property was lying vacant and had already suffered damage. The State, however, defended the demolition proceedings. Advocate General Surojit Nath Mitra told the Court that notices had been affixed to the property and that the process had also been videographed. Mitra argued that no sanctioned building plan had been issued for the construction of Khan's residence. He also maintained that the TMC leader had failed to participate in the demolition hearings despite the notices being served. After considering the rival submissions, Justice Ghosh directed the State to produce the video recordings showing the alleged service of notices. The Court made it clear that demolition could not resume until the issue was examined. Khan has remained in judicial custody since June 8 following his arrest in connection with several criminal cases involving allegations of extortion, murder, robbery, criminal intimidation and electoral offences. His petition also accused State authorities of targeting political opponents, particularly members of the Muslim community, through executive action. These allegations are part of Khan's plea and have not been adjudicated by the Court.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court: Stamp Duty Cannot Turn on Where the First Signatory Happens to Be
Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The location where the first person signs an agreement cannot automatically decide which State's stamp duty law will govern it, the Delhi High Court has ruled, cautioning against making tax liability dependent on the “accidental location” of a signatory. Justice Om Prakash Shukla observed that determining the applicable stamp duty legislation requires a closer examination of the agreement, including the nature of the instrument and the signatures necessary to bring it into existence. The Court noted that relying exclusively on the geographical location of the first physical signature could produce arbitrary outcomes, particularly in transactions involving multiple parties. It also pointed out that the physical location of a signatory may not be identifiable in agreements executed electronically. Emphasising the changing nature of commercial transactions, the Court said traditional concepts of execution, developed when agreements were routinely prepared, stamped and signed physically, cannot be applied mechanically to modern digital arrangements. The ruling came while setting aside an interim arbitral award concerning four loan agreements entered into in March 2014 between companies belonging to the Zee Group and Religare Finvest Limited. The dispute centred on whether the agreements attracted stamp duty under the Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958, or the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as applicable in Delhi. According to the facts placed before the Court, the borrower companies signed the agreements in Mumbai, while Religare Finvest, the lender, executed them in Delhi on the same day. The arbitrator had concluded that the Maharashtra Stamp Act governed the agreements. However, the High Court disagreed with this interpretation. Justice Shukla explained that the agreements required signatures from both the borrowers and the lender to become complete. Consequently, execution took place only when Religare signed the documents in Delhi. On that basis, the Court held that the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as applicable in Delhi, would govern the four loan agreements. The Court also examined the principle of territorial nexus, observing that a State seeking to impose a tax must demonstrate a genuine and meaningful connection between its territory and the subject matter of taxation. It clarified that the territorial connection establishing a State's authority to levy stamp duty and the event marking the completion of execution are distinct considerations. The Court explained that taxation cannot rest on an artificial territorial connection, while the point at which an agreement becomes fully executed must be determined by examining the requirements of that particular instrument. By setting aside the arbitrator's contrary finding, the High Court made it clear that stamp duty liability cannot be decided merely by identifying where the first signature on a multi-party agreement was placed.
Read current report and source
Punjab & Haryana High Court Refuses to Revoke Bail of Former DLF CFO in ₹311 Crore Extortion Case
Punjab and Haryana High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Punjab and Haryana High Court has declined DLF Limited's attempt to get the bail of its former Group Chief Financial Officer, Ramesh Sanka, cancelled in an alleged ₹311 crore extortion case, holding that approaching different courts through legal proceedings cannot, by itself, be treated as a breach of bail conditions. Justice Vikram Aggarwal dismissed the company's plea, which accused Sanka of disclosing confidential corporate information through petitions filed before the Supreme Court, Delhi High Court, Telangana High Court and Madras High Court. DLF had argued that Sanka was using these proceedings to reveal sensitive company information and put pressure on the company as well as prosecution witnesses. The Court, however, found no merit in treating the filing of such petitions as an attempt to intimidate or influence anyone. It observed that Sanka had approached various courts with allegations concerning tax evasion and other alleged irregularities by DLF. The Bench made it clear that pursuing available legal remedies cannot automatically amount to a violation of bail conditions. While making observations about Sanka's conduct, the Court was far from complimentary. It remarked that he did not appear to be a saint and seemed to have tendencies associated with blackmailing. The Court also pointed out that he had spent 11 months in custody before securing bail. Nevertheless, it stressed that the allegations against him were yet to be tested at trial. Similarly, the allegations raised by Sanka against DLF would have to be examined by the respective courts dealing with those matters. The Bench refrained from expressing any conclusion on the truthfulness of either side's accusations. Sanka joined DLF as Chief Financial Officer in 2004 and later became the company's Group CFO. He subsequently took over as Managing Director of DLF Cyber City Developers Limited, a position he held until 2014. The dispute escalated in 2024 when DLF lodged a criminal complaint against him. The company alleged that Sanka had threatened to misuse or disclose confidential corporate information unless it paid him ₹311 crore. He was arrested in January 2025 and remained in custody until December 2025, when he was granted bail. DLF approached the High Court approximately a month later, seeking to have that relief withdrawn. The company maintained that Sanka's subsequent court proceedings involved the disclosure of confidential material and were intended to threaten and influence the company and witnesses. Rejecting the request, the High Court underlined that cancellation of bail is an extraordinary step and cannot be ordered mechanically. The Court found no sufficient grounds to interfere with the bail order at this stage. Accordingly, DLF's plea for cancellation of Sanka's bail was dismissed. Senior Advocates RS Cheema, RS Rai and Rajeev Anand, along with advocates Kartikeya, Radhika Mehta, Satish Sharma, Farhad Kohli and Prince Bharol, appeared for DLF. Additional Advocate General Deepak Sabharwal represented the Haryana government. Senior Advocate Ashok Aggarwal, assisted by advocates Nilesh Bhardwaj, Shrenik Jain, Vineet Sehgal and Haripal, appeared for Ramesh Sanka.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court scraps 11-year-old SC/ST Act case against Baba Kalyani over NICE road land dispute
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Karnataka High Court has quashed criminal proceedings under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act against Bharat Forge chairman Baba Kalyani and two others, ruling that an unexplained delay of 11 years in lodging the complaint rendered the case an abuse of the legal process. Justice M Nagaprasanna observed that the allegations revolved around an incident said to have taken place in 2007, but the complainants approached the court only in 2018 without offering any convincing explanation for the prolonged delay. Describing the case as an example of the misuse of the SC/ST Act, the Court noted that although the complaint narrated events spanning several years, the alleged incident itself remained confined to 2007. The November 4 ruling in Baba Kalyani v. Rajendran also extended relief to businessman Ashok Kheny and D Ravishankar, who were named as accused in the proceedings. Kalyani, whose full name is Babasaheb Neelkanth Kalyani, heads the Pune-based Kalyani Group and serves as Chairman and Managing Director of Bharat Forge. He is also associated with Nandi Infrastructure Corridor Enterprises Limited (NICEL), the company responsible for developing the NICE road project in Bengaluru. Kalyani personally holds a 5 per cent stake in the company, while BF Utilities, a Kalyani Group entity, owns another 75 per cent. The dispute originated from allegations made by S Rajendran, S Meganathan and S Sampath, who claimed that their family land in Kodigehalli village had been unlawfully taken over for the NICE project. According to the complainants, their father had received a two-acre land grant from the Karnataka government. They alleged that the land was subsequently acquired using forged documents and that a building belonging to their educational society was demolished in March 2007. They further accused the respondents of trespassing, damaging property and subjecting them to caste-based abuses. Despite the alleged incident taking place in 2007, the complainants initiated proceedings before a special court only in 2018, invoking provisions of the SC/ST Act and other criminal offences. The police later submitted a closure report. However, in February 2025, the special court directed further investigation into the allegations. Challenging the continuation of the proceedings, Kalyani, Kheny and Ravishankar approached the High Court, arguing that the complaint was hopelessly delayed and failed to disclose the necessary ingredients of the alleged offences. The complainants, on the other hand, maintained that delay by itself could not be a ground to terminate proceedings, particularly when allegations of land fraud and caste-based harassment were involved. The High Court was unconvinced by their explanation. Justice Nagaprasanna questioned why the complainants had remained silent for more than a decade if the alleged offences had occurred in March 2007. The Court observed that the complaint contained several embellishments but offered no satisfactory account of the 11-year gap between the alleged incident and the initiation of criminal action. It further held that an unexplained and deliberate delay could justify interference by the High Court where allowing the proceedings to continue would amount to an abuse of the process of law. The judge concluded that even if the allegations were accepted at face value, they would not sustain the criminal proceedings in the circumstances of the case, particularly given the extraordinary delay in bringing the complaint. Accordingly, the High Court quashed the criminal case against all three accused. Senior Advocate Prabhuling K Navadgi, instructed by advocate SB Mathapati, appeared for the petitioners. Advocates Prabhugoud B Tumbigi and Syed Khaleel Pasha represented the private respondents, while High Court Government Pleader Waheeda MM appeared for the Karnataka government.
Read current report and source
Calcutta High Court Slams Mizoram’s ‘Regime Revenge’, Orders Completion of ₹38.3 Crore Kolkata Land Deal
Calcutta High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Mizoram government cannot abandon a land sale agreement simply because a new political dispensation has taken charge, the Calcutta High Court has ruled, holding that a change in government does not give the State a licence to walk away from contractual commitments. A Division Bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray described the cancellation of a ₹38.3 crore property sale to Excel Vincom Private Limited as an apparent instance of “regime revenge”. The Court observed that the government could not withdraw a promise on which a private party had acted and fulfilled its obligations merely because the political leadership had changed. Setting aside the State government's decision to cancel the transaction, the Bench directed Mizoram to execute the sale deed within eight weeks. The dispute revolves around a property at 24, Ashutosh Chowdhury Avenue in Kolkata, which Mizoram had acquired in 1973. The premises housed Mizoram House, serving as a government guesthouse and office facility. In May 2023, the State government initiated an electronic tender-cum-auction process to dispose of the property. Excel Vincom emerged as the highest bidder, following which an agreement for sale was signed on October 6, 2023. The transaction, however, ran into trouble after a change of government in Mizoram in December 2023. The new administration cancelled the tender process, citing public interest and opposition from sections of the Mizo community. The proposed sale had triggered concerns among Mizo residents and organisations in Kolkata. The Kolkata Mizo Students and the Calcutta Mizo Welfare Association had approached the government, highlighting the property's historical and heritage value, as well as its importance as a place of support for Mizo students and professionals living in the city. Appearing for the State, Advocate General Biswajit Deb maintained that the cancellation had nothing to do with political differences. He argued that the government had reconsidered the transaction in response to the sentiments of the Mizo community. He further submitted that the entire amount received from Excel Vincom had been returned. Since the ownership transfer could take effect only after execution of the final sale deed, which had not taken place, the government was entitled to withdraw from the tender process, he contended. Senior Advocate SN Mookherjee, representing Excel Vincom, disputed this position. He argued that the transaction had progressed well beyond the stage at which the government could simply cancel the tender. According to the company, communications exchanged between the parties made it clear that all substantive steps had been completed and only execution of the sale deed remained. The abrupt reversal, it argued, followed the change in political leadership. The High Court found considerable merit in the company's submissions. It noted that Mizoram had received the entire sale consideration and had even accepted additional money towards interest arising from a delayed instalment. These actions, the Bench observed, demonstrated that the government had proceeded with the transaction and taken concrete steps towards completing it. The Court also took note of the fact that the agreement had emerged after detailed discussions between the parties. The State had indicated that formal steps to execute the sale deed would follow the completion of the 2023 Assembly elections. However, after a new government assumed office, the approach towards the transaction changed. The sale was cancelled unilaterally, without any meaningful discussion with the company. The Bench found that the State had failed to establish any compelling public interest that could justify abandoning the agreement after the transaction had reached such an advanced stage. It held that the cancellation was arbitrary, unjustified and contrary to Article 14 of the Constitution, which guarantees equality before the law and protection against arbitrary State action. Emphasising the obligations of governments entering into commercial agreements, the Court observed that the State must act fairly, reasonably and justly in its contractual dealings. A change in political leadership cannot erase commitments already made by the government. Finding no legally sustainable reason for scrapping the sale process, the High Court dismissed Mizoram's appeal against the single-judge order passed in 2024. The earlier order had directed the State to complete the sale within six weeks. The Division Bench has now directed execution of the sale deed within eight weeks.
Read current report and source
Tripura High Court upholds compensation over death in prison
Tripura High Court · Editorial Team
The Tripura High Court upheld a direction to pay ₹4 lakh to a prisoner’s family after his death in custody. It ordered the prisons department to implement the Human Rights Commission’s directions within one month and report compliance.
Judge / Bench — Chief Justice M. S. Ramachandra Rao, who delivered the judgment, and Justice Biswajit Palit.
In W.P.(C) 710/2026 (2026:THC:1476-DB, 11 November 2026), the court held that a magistrate’s inquiry under Section 196 of the BNSS determines the apparent cause of death and cannot decide whether prison officials were negligent. It dismissed the prisons chief’s writ petition and upheld the direction for a departmental inquiry.
Advocates appearing — Inspector General of Prisons: Dipankar Sarma, Additional Government Advocate. Respondents: Somik Deb, Senior Advocate, assisted by Abir Baran; Rijuka Roy Barman also appeared.
Read current report and source
Madhya Pradesh High Court orders lender to return possession of home
Madhya Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team
The Madhya Pradesh High Court ordered a housing lender to unlock a borrower’s home after a vacancy at the Debt Recovery Tribunal prevented a hearing on interim relief.
Judge / Bench — Justice Subodh Abhyankar and Justice Jai Kumar Pillai, who delivered the order.
In Vinod Dwivedi v Principal Secretary (2026:MPHC-IND:28903, 7 October 2026), the court set aside the dismissal of his petition. He must file an undertaking within three working days and return possession if the Tribunal refuses interim relief. The court confined its order to the exceptional facts.
Advocates appearing — Appellant: Anil Kumar Namdev. State respondents: Amit Bhatia, Government Advocate. Respondent 4: Rohit Saboo.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court imposes ₹2 lakh costs for repeated petitions
Delhi High Court · Editorial Team
The Delhi High Court dismissed a petition seeking an inquiry into a registered society and imposed ₹2 lakh in costs after finding that the petitioner repeatedly sought relief the court had already refused.
Judge / Bench — Justice Amit Mahajan.
In Satya Prakash Ravidas v SDM/Registrar of Societies (W.P.(C) 16674/2026, 6 November 2026), the court found that the petitioner had failed to disclose earlier proceedings. It ordered payment to the Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee within four weeks and told the Registry not to list any new case filed by him until he pays.
Advocates appearing — Delhi government: Abhinav Singh and Antara Mishra. Respondent 2: Anil Dutt. Petitioner Satya Prakash Ravidas appeared in person.
Read current report and source
Punjab and Haryana High Court counts waiter’s tips in accident award
Punjab and Haryana High Court · Editorial Team
The Punjab and Haryana High Court upheld a ₹38,77,360 accident compensation award that counted regular customer tips as part of an injured waiter’s earnings.
Judge / Bench — Justice Mandeep Pannu.
In United India Insurance v Vipin Kumar (2026:PHHC:199075, 11 November 2026), the court rejected the insurer’s argument that only the salary certificate should count. The record supported monthly earnings of ₹8,000 in wages and ₹4,000 in tips. The court dismissed the insurer’s appeal.
Advocates appearing — Insurer: Harsh Aggarwal and Parit Aggarwal. Claimant, respondent 1: Arun Takhi. Other respondents: Not named in the judgment.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court orders uniform conduct of entrance tests
Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team
The Karnataka High Court directed the state examination authority to issue instructions for conducting entrance tests uniformly across Karnataka.
Judge / Bench — Justice Anu Sivaraman, who delivered the judgment, and Justice K. S. Bharath Kumar.
In W.P. 12499/2025 (2026:KHC:61247-DB, 4 November 2026), a registered society complained that some candidates had been made to remove sacred threads. The authority said its guidelines imposed no such requirement and promised steps to prevent a recurrence. The court recorded that assurance and disposed of the petition.
Advocates appearing — Petitioner: Ashwini N. Ravindra for Sumana Naganand. State, respondents 1 and 2: Pramodhini Kishan, Additional Government Advocate. Examination authority, respondent 3: N. K. Ramesh.
Read current report and source