Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

7 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 9 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Bombay High Court Holds Father-Son Lawyers Guilty of Contempt After Courtroom Threats
  2. Following Bulli Bai app not enough for criminal liability, Mumbai court discharges Vishal Jha
  3. Allahabad High Court Frees Man Held Illegally for 31 Hours, Invokes ‘Fruit of the Poisonous Tree’ Doctrine
  4. Delhi High Court Orders Criminal Complaint Against Six CBI Officers Over Alleged False Statement
  5. Bail Granted, Yet Jail Continued: Calcutta High Court Awards ₹5.36 Lakh for 60-Day Illegal Detention
  6. Karnataka High Court Upholds IAF Title Over Yelahanka Land, Flags ‘Highest Order’ Trickery
  7. Karnataka Court Puts RSS Defamation Proceedings Against Priyank Kharge, Mohammed Nalapad on Hold
  8. Kerala High Court Keeps Abhimanyu Murder Trial Open, Bars Courtroom Recording
  9. Madras High Court Upholds FCRA Denial to Zen Centre, Cites Concerns Over Religious Conversion

Bombay High Court Holds Father-Son Lawyers Guilty of Contempt After Courtroom Threats

Bombay High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Bombay High Court's Nagpur Bench has found two lawyers guilty of criminal contempt after they allegedly shouted at and threatened a trial judge during proceedings, observing that lawyers cannot be permitted to disrupt or intimidate judicial officers.

A Bench of Justices Urmila Joshi-Phalke and Raj D Wakode held that threatening a judge, raising one's voice in court and attempting to prevent the judicial officer from passing an order amounted to serious interference with the administration of justice.

The case concerned advocates Sagar Durgadas Rathod and Durgadas D Rathod, a father-son duo. Durgadas Rathod was serving as President of the Arni Bar Association when the incident occurred in 2021 before the Judicial Magistrate First Class at Arni.

The controversy began after the magistrate issued a non-bailable warrant against an accused who was absent from the proceedings. Durgadas Rathod sought cancellation of the warrant without producing the accused before the court.

When the magistrate declined the request, the two advocates allegedly raised their voices and threatened the judicial officer with complaints of corruption.

The incident was subsequently brought before the High Court for contempt proceedings.

The High Court took a stern view of the conduct, stressing that an advocate, as an officer of the court, has an added responsibility to preserve courtroom discipline rather than undermine it.

The Bench observed that threats against judicial officers and attempts to interfere with their orders can have a wider impact on the justice system by intimidating and demoralising judges.

The Court also refused to accept the unconditional apologies tendered by the two advocates. It said an apology must reflect genuine remorse and cannot be deployed as a convenient escape from the consequences of contempt.

The judges made it clear that a belated or merely formal apology, without genuine regret, cannot wipe away contemptuous conduct.

The Court imposed a fine of ₹2,000 each on the two lawyers and directed them to deposit ₹50,000 each towards costs in the High Court's public welfare account, taking the total financial liability to ₹1.04 lakh.

The matter has also been sent to the disciplinary committee of the Bar Council of Maharashtra and Goa for appropriate action against the advocates.

The proceedings arose from Sajiduzzaman Mhammad Hanif Shahid v. Sagar Rathod & Anr.

Read current report and source

Following Bulli Bai app not enough for criminal liability, Mumbai court discharges Vishal Jha

Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees

A Mumbai court has discharged Vishal Sudhirkumar Jha in the Bulli Bai app case, holding that merely following the controversial application or maintaining contact with other accused persons cannot, by itself, make someone criminally liable.

The order was passed by Bandra judicial magistrate RT Ingle on October 6, marking the first discharge in the case involving the online display of photographs of more than 100 Muslim women for a purported auction.

The court found no material in the charge-sheet showing that Jha had any direct role in creating the Bulli Bai application or assisting others in developing it.

The magistrate noted that Jha may have followed the application because of his familiarity with some of the co-accused, but there was no evidence of any further participation that could connect him to the alleged offences.

The court also referred to an Allahabad High Court ruling concerning the act of merely following a page on a website, observing that such conduct, without more, does not constitute a criminal offence.

The Bulli Bai controversy centred on an application hosted through GitHub that featured photographs of Muslim women without their consent and presented them as part of a purported online auction.

Jha, along with two other accused, had earlier been granted bail. The court had at that stage observed that the older accused persons had allegedly taken advantage of their immaturity.

Jha faced charges under Sections 153(a), 153(b) and 295(a) of the Indian Penal Code, along with Section 67 of the Information Technology Act, relating to the alleged publication or transmission of obscene material in electronic form.

His counsel, Marmik Shah, argued that the prosecution's own charge-sheet did not attribute any substantive act to Jha beyond allegedly following the application. It was also argued that investigators had failed to produce evidence supporting the allegation that Jha had shared the application on his Twitter account.

The court accepted the defence submissions and discharged Jha from all the charges.

Additional Public Prosecutor Kalpana Hire represented the State.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Frees Man Held Illegally for 31 Hours, Invokes ‘Fruit of the Poisonous Tree’ Doctrine

Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Allahabad High Court has ordered the immediate release of a man whose arrest followed more than 31 hours of illegal detention, holding that a subsequent formal arrest cannot erase the constitutional violations committed by the police.

The Court applied the American legal doctrine of the ‘fruit of the poisonous tree’ to the law of arrest and detention, ruling that an unlawful detention can invalidate the arrest and the subsequent judicial remand proceedings arising from it.

The ruling came in the case of Ravi Chaurasiya And Another v. State of UP and 4 Others, in which a bench of Justice Atul Sreedharan and Justice Achal Sachdeva examined the circumstances surrounding Ravi Chaurasiya’s detention.

The Court found that Chaurasiya had been taken into custody by the police at 3:40 am on September 15, 2026, but his detention was not recorded in the General Diary. He was formally arrested only at 10:45 am the following day.

The formal arrest took place after Chaurasiya’s mother approached the High Court on September 15 through a habeas corpus petition seeking information about her son’s whereabouts.

Rejecting the police explanation that the failure to record his custody was an inadvertent mistake, the Court concluded that the omission was deliberate and intended to avoid allegations of illegal detention.

The bench made it clear that the police could not retrospectively legitimise an unlawful detention by preparing an arrest memo and producing the accused before a magistrate.

“The subsequent arrest memo and the remand does not legitimize the initial unlawful detention,” the Court observed, holding that the initial detention had violated the constitutional protections guaranteed under Article 22.

Illegal detention taints subsequent arrest and remand

In reaching its conclusion, the Court examined the doctrine of the ‘fruit of the poisonous tree’, which originated in the United States and generally concerns the inadmissibility of evidence obtained through unlawful means.

The bench extended its application beyond the law of evidence, examining how the principle operates in the context of constitutional rights and personal liberty.

The Court held that when an arrest is preceded by unlawful detention, the illegality does not disappear merely because the police subsequently follow the formal procedure for arrest and remand.

It observed that where the initial detention violates Articles 21 and 22 of the Constitution, the subsequent arrest and remand proceedings can also be rendered unlawful, even if the stated grounds for arrest and the proceedings before the magistrate might otherwise appear valid.

The bench emphasised that the legality of an arrest cannot be assessed in isolation from the circumstances that led to it.

Police explanation rejected

The case arose after Chaurasiya was detained in connection with the purchase of a property belonging to a gangster.

In its response to the habeas corpus petition, Deen Dayal Singh, the Station House Officer of Soraon police station, admitted that Chaurasiya had been taken into custody on September 15 but that the fact had not been entered in the General Diary.

The Court rejected the suggestion that the omission was simply a clerical lapse.

It noted that the formal arrest occurred only after the police became aware of the petition filed by Chaurasiya’s mother, observing that the timing indicated an attempt to shield the authorities from liability for the earlier detention.

The bench also expressed its displeasure over the conduct of the station house officer and directed the Prayagraj Commissioner to conduct an inquiry into the matter.

It further ordered that if the inquiry established negligence on the officer’s part, the Court’s recorded displeasure should be entered into his service record.

Court flags denial of access to legal counsel

The bench also raised concerns over Chaurasiya’s right to consult a lawyer during police questioning.

It found that he had not been informed of his right to legal assistance of his choice. Although the Court noted that this right formally arises upon arrest, it warned against police practices that could circumvent constitutional safeguards.

The Court observed that authorities cannot avoid the obligations attached to a formal arrest by keeping a suspect at a police station, questioning him for several hours and subsequently treating him as an accused based on self-incriminating statements.

Such a practice, the bench said, could undermine the right against self-incrimination, particularly when the individual is questioned without access to legal counsel.

Referring to Section 38 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), the Court said the police must inform a person taken into custody, even before formal arrest, of the right to have an advocate of their choice present during interrogation.

Failure to comply with this requirement, it held, would vitiate information supplied by the suspect, particularly self-incriminating statements.

₹30,000 compensation, release ordered

Allowing the habeas corpus petition, the High Court directed the State to pay Chaurasiya ₹30,000 in compensation for his unlawful detention.

The bench ordered his immediate release, provided he was not wanted in any other case. It further clarified that any future arrest in the matter could be made only pursuant to an arrest warrant issued by the magistrate concerned.

The Court’s ruling underscores that constitutional protections against unlawful detention cannot be defeated by completing arrest formalities after the violation has already occurred.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Orders Criminal Complaint Against Six CBI Officers Over Alleged False Statement

Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Delhi High Court has directed the initiation of criminal proceedings against six CBI officials over allegations that a misleading statement was placed before the court concerning communication with the government in a case involving former IRS officer Ashok Kumar Aggarwal.

Justice Madhu Jain allowed Aggarwal's plea and directed the Special Judge dealing with CBI matters to lodge a written complaint against Sushil Dewan, Vineet Vinayak, Amit Kumar, Raman Tyagi, Prem Kumar Gautam and Md Azad.

The complaint has been ordered in relation to alleged offences under Sections 191, 193 and 209 of the Indian Penal Code, concerning false evidence and the making of a false claim before a court.

The Special Judge has been given four weeks from receipt of the High Court's October 6 judgment to prepare and forward the complaint to the jurisdictional Magistrate.

Dispute over CBI's correspondence

The matter traces back to a corruption case against Aggarwal, who had been accused of possessing assets disproportionate to his known sources of income.

In January 2016, the High Court found the sanction for his prosecution invalid and he was subsequently discharged.

The CBI considered challenging that decision before the Supreme Court. However, the Ministry of Law and Justice advised in June 2016 that there were no sufficient grounds to pursue an appeal. The Department of Personnel and Training conveyed that position to the CBI the following month.

The dispute arose when Aggarwal later sought the return of documents seized during the investigation.

In a reply dated August 2, 2016, the CBI stated that discussions with the Ministry regarding further legal action were still underway.

The High Court, however, found that the records told a different story.

Drafts became central to the case

While examining successive versions of the CBI's response, the Court found that an earlier draft had specifically recorded that the DoPT had rejected the proposal to challenge the discharge before the Supreme Court.

That portion was later removed. In its place, a handwritten statement was inserted suggesting that correspondence with the Ministry was continuing.

For the High Court, this went beyond an innocent or imprecise use of language.

The Court said the sequence of events provided a "reasonable foundation" for the allegation that a false statement had been made before the court and that an inquiry was necessary in the interests of justice.

The subsequent correction made by the CBI in another reply dated August 9, 2016 did not persuade the Court to drop the matter. Nor did the absence of demonstrable prejudice to Aggarwal.

The judgment noted that the preparation, alteration, vetting, approval and filing of the disputed response, viewed alongside the earlier drafts and official file records, provided a prima facie basis to conclude that the officials concerned may have advanced a position inconsistent with what was already known within the department.

The Court therefore ordered the Special Judge to initiate the complaint process against the six officials.

The proceedings stem from Ashok Kumar Aggarwal v. Sushil Dewan & Ors.

Read current report and source

Bail Granted, Yet Jail Continued: Calcutta High Court Awards ₹5.36 Lakh for 60-Day Illegal Detention

Calcutta High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Calcutta High Court has directed the West Bengal government to pay ₹5.36 lakh to a tea garden worker who remained behind bars for nearly two months even after securing bail in three criminal cases.

A Division Bench of Justices Debangsu Basak and Aryak Dutt held that the man's continued detention from August 6, 2018 to October 5, 2018 had no legal basis and warranted compensation.

The worker had been granted bail in all three cases and, according to the Court, should have walked out of jail on August 6. Instead, he remained in custody until October 5, when he was finally released.

Seeking his release, the man approached the High Court through a habeas corpus petition. He later sought ₹20 lakh in compensation, pointing to the loss of employment and the mental distress caused by remaining in custody despite having obtained bail.

The State attempted to explain the continued detention by referring to a separate Miscellaneous Record (MR) case. It was claimed that the worker had allegedly violated a bond executed for maintaining peace and therefore had to remain in custody until October 5.

The explanation failed to convince the Court.

The Bench found that the State had not satisfactorily established why the petitioner continued to remain incarcerated after the bail orders in the three criminal cases. His detention during the 60-day period was consequently held to be unlawful.

The Court agreed that compensation was warranted, but did not accept the ₹20 lakh amount sought by the petitioner.

It awarded ₹5 lakh for the unlawful detention and an additional ₹36,000 towards the loss of employment, taking the total compensation to ₹5.36 lakh.

The State has been directed to make the payment within four weeks.

The ruling underlined a basic consequence of a bail order: once a person's detention is no longer supported by law, administrative lapses or an inadequate explanation cannot justify keeping that person in prison.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Upholds IAF Title Over Yelahanka Land, Flags ‘Highest Order’ Trickery

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Karnataka High Court has rejected a private claim over land being used as an aircraft taxi track by the Indian Air Force at its Yelahanka station, holding that government records clearly established the Defence Ministry’s ownership.

A Division Bench of Justice D K Singh and Justice H Shanthi Bhushan overturned an earlier single-judge decision that had accepted the claim of Mohsin Sharieff over land at Sonnappanahalli in Bengaluru.

In strong observations, the Bench said an attempt had been made decades after the original acquisition to create a private title over land that had long been used for defence purposes.

“The taxi track of the Indian Air Force has been subjected to trickery of the highest order,” the Court observed, adding that the attempt to assert private rights over the property had not survived judicial scrutiny.

The dispute concerns land in Survey Nos. 32 and 33. Sharieff based his claim on a 1995 agreement of sale executed with the heirs of the property's original owner.

He later filed a suit for specific performance in 2008. The civil court ruled in his favour, and a sale deed was subsequently executed in January 2015 through a court-appointed commissioner.

The Defence Ministry challenged the claim, maintaining that the relevant portion of Survey No. 33 had already been acquired by the government in 1943 for defence purposes and that compensation had been paid to the original owner.

An earlier single-judge ruling had taken a different view, noting that Survey No. 33 was not expressly mentioned in the 1943 gazette notification. The single judge concluded that the land fell outside the acquisition and directed revenue authorities to record Sharieff's name.

The Division Bench, however, found that the wider documentary record told a different story.

It relied on the acquisition papers, survey records, compensation documents, village map and Military Land Register. These records, the Court said, demonstrated that the disputed property had formed part of the 1943 acquisition and had subsequently been used by the IAF.

The Bench found that the reference to “Survey No. 30” in the gazette was a typographical mistake. A survey report prepared in February 1944 specifically referred to Survey No. 33 and recorded that 3 acres and 12 guntas had been used for the aircraft taxi track.

The Military Land Register also recorded the same extent as Defence property. The Bench treated the official defence record as decisive evidence of the Union government's title.

The Court consequently held that Sharieff could not have obtained valid title from the original owner's heirs in 1995 because the government had already acquired the property and paid compensation more than five decades earlier.

The timing of the later transactions also drew sharp criticism from the Bench. It noted that the 1995 agreement came long after the acquisition, while the specific performance proceedings were initiated only in 2008.

The sequence, the Court said, “shocks the conscience of the Court and calls for closer scrutiny.”

The Bench further held that the decree passed in the civil suit could not bind the Union government because the Defence Department had not been a party to those proceedings. A decree in such circumstances could not be used to create title against government property.

Emphasising the strategic role of the Air Force, the Court observed that air defence is fundamental to national security and described the IAF as a critical part of India's defence infrastructure.

The Division Bench accordingly set aside the earlier single-judge order and restored decisions issued by the Assistant Commissioner in 2022 and the Deputy Commissioner in 2023. The Defence Ministry's title over the disputed land therefore stands affirmed.

Read current report and source

Karnataka Court Puts RSS Defamation Proceedings Against Priyank Kharge, Mohammed Nalapad on Hold

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

A Bengaluru special court has put on hold proceedings in a criminal defamation case involving Karnataka Home Minister Priyank Kharge and Congress leader Mohammed Nalapad over remarks concerning the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS).

Special Judge KB Shivaprasad, while hearing revision petitions filed by the two accused, questioned the lower court's decision to leave the issue of the complainant's standing to be determined only during the trial.

The court observed that establishing whether a person has the legal authority to initiate a criminal defamation complaint is a threshold requirement and therefore cannot necessarily be deferred until evidence is recorded.

The dispute stems from an order passed by the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate in Bengaluru on June 27, 2026. The Magistrate had taken cognizance of an alleged offence under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) and issued summons to Kharge and Nalapad.

The special court has now issued notice to complainant A Tejas and called for the lower court records.

During the hearing, arguments centred on whether Tejas was legally entitled to maintain the complaint. Senior Advocate Sandesh Chouta, representing Kharge, argued that Tejas had offered varying accounts about his association with the RSS but had not produced material demonstrating that he was a member of the organisation.

According to the argument, a person seeking to pursue a private defamation complaint must show that they are an identifiable individual who has suffered a specific legal injury. Without evidence establishing Tejas's connection with the RSS, it was argued, the complaint could not be sustained.

Senior Advocate Vikram Huilgol, appearing for Nalapad, pointed to Section 222(1) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), which requires a complaint for an offence under Section 356 of the BNS to come from an aggrieved person.

Huilgol also challenged the reasoning behind the Magistrate's decision to take cognizance, arguing that sufficient reasons had not been recorded.

The special court found that the question of locus standi deserved scrutiny at this stage. It noted that summons had already been issued and evidence had begun to be recorded before the Magistrate.

Allowing the proceedings to continue, the court said, could undermine the purpose of the revision petitions if the underlying order were subsequently found to require interference.

The trial proceedings have consequently been stayed for the time being.

The matter is scheduled to come up next on October 30.

Read current report and source

Kerala High Court Keeps Abhimanyu Murder Trial Open, Bars Courtroom Recording

Kerala High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Kerala High Court has refused to order a closed-door trial in the murder case involving Students' Federation of India (SFI) leader Abhimanyu, while directing authorities to prevent photographs or video recordings of the accused inside the courtroom.

Justice CS Dias upheld the decision of the Ernakulam Principal Sessions Court, which had earlier rejected a request by the 13 accused for the entire trial to be conducted in-camera.

The High Court referred to Section 366 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), 2023, which establishes open court proceedings as the general rule in criminal cases. At the same time, the provision allows a trial judge to exclude the public, or specific individuals, from the courtroom when circumstances warrant it.

Against that backdrop, the Court found no sufficient reason to keep the entire proceedings away from public view.

The Court nevertheless put safeguards in place. The trial court and police were directed to ensure that nobody photographs or records video of the accused or the proceedings from inside the courtroom.

The trial judge was also given liberty to limit public access while particular eyewitnesses are being examined, if such a step becomes necessary to protect the fairness of the proceedings.

The case stems from the July 1, 2018 killing of 21-year-old Abhimanyu at Maharajas College in Ernakulam. He was fatally stabbed during a clash that followed a dispute involving the placement of campus posters. Four other SFI activists were also attacked and suffered serious injuries.

Police subsequently registered a case under several provisions of the Indian Penal Code, including those relating to unlawful assembly, rioting, murder and criminal conspiracy. A charge sheet was filed in September 2018.

The matter was subsequently placed before the Principal Sessions Court in Ernakulam, where the trial has remained pending for more than seven years.

The High Court's ruling therefore leaves the proceedings open to the public, while allowing the trial court to impose targeted restrictions where witness protection or the integrity of the trial requires them.

Read current report and source

Madras High Court Upholds FCRA Denial to Zen Centre, Cites Concerns Over Religious Conversion

Madras High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Madras High Court has upheld the Union government's refusal to grant Foreign Contribution (Regulation) Act (FCRA) registration to a charitable trust operating a Zen meditation centre in Kodaikanal, holding that organisations involved in religious conversion cannot claim registration under the law.

A Division Bench comprising Justices GR Swaminathan and MD Sumathi delivered the ruling in the case involving Kanzeon Public Charitable Trust.

The trust had maintained that Zen meditation formed part of India's traditional Dhyana practices and that its activities were not religious in nature. Government authorities, however, viewed the organisation's activities as having a religious character.

The Court examined Section 12(4)(a)(ii) of the FCRA, which concerns organisations involved in religious conversion, and said the provision applies irrespective of the religion involved.

The Bench observed that a Hindu organisation involved in activities such as Ghar Wapsi would similarly be ineligible for FCRA registration. It warned that unrestricted foreign funding for conversion-related activities could have implications for India's sovereignty and social balance.

The judgment also discussed India's religious diversity, describing the country as a plural society whose character could be affected if one religious community were to acquire disproportionate influence.

At the centre of the dispute was the background of the trust's founder, Rev. Fr. Ama Samy SJ, an ordained Christian priest. The Court considered this fact while assessing the nature and character of the organisation's activities.

The Bench drew a distinction between Hindu philosophical and cultural traditions and what it described as the more exclusive theological claims associated with Abrahamic faiths. The judgment said that Judaism, Christianity and Islam traditionally regard their respective revelations as uniquely authoritative.

The Court also referred to arguments concerning the use of indigenous cultural practices and symbols by missionary traditions, while stressing that it was not the Court's role to resolve broader theological or ideological disputes.

On the specific question before it, the Bench concluded that Zen Buddhism is associated with the Mahayana Buddhist tradition. It therefore held that the trust should have disclosed the religious character of its activities when seeking FCRA approval.

The judges rejected the suggestion that the trust could present itself solely as a non-religious organisation while seeking foreign funding.

The Court further emphasised that receiving foreign contributions is not an absolute legal entitlement. Under the FCRA framework, such funding is subject to statutory conditions and cannot be claimed as a vested right.

At the same time, the judgment drew a distinction between religious organisations and institutions engaged in the study or promotion of Indian knowledge traditions. Bodies teaching subjects such as Vedanta, the Bhagavad Gita, the Upanishads, Yoga and related disciplines could ordinarily fall within the educational or cultural sphere rather than being treated automatically as religious organisations, the Bench said.

The Court ultimately found no grounds to interfere with the government's decision to deny FCRA registration to the trust.

In a final wordplay referring to the founder's name, the Bench remarked that the authority was effectively required to say “Illa Samy” — meaning “No, Sir” — to Rev. Fr. Ama Samy.

Read current report and source