Saved newspaper
19 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 6 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Madras High Court Protects Minor’s Citizenship After Father’s Foreign Naturalisation
- Kerala High Court Declines Interim Relief Against Fresh Waqf Board Appointments
- Karnataka High Court Gives Bar Council 45 Days to Track Advocates Who Fail to Clear AIBE
- Allahabad High Court Suspends Murder Conviction, Citing Plea to Contest 2027 UP Elections
- Calcutta High Court Rejects Bail Plea of Former Minister Indranil Sen in Durga Puja Ticket Case
- Karnataka High Court Backs Construction Curbs Near Heritage Sites, Orders Fresh Survey of Madhugiri Fort Plot
Madras High Court Protects Minor’s Citizenship After Father’s Foreign Naturalisation
Madras High Court · Editorial Team
The Madras High Court has directed reconsideration of a minor’s passport renewal, holding that his father’s acquisition of British citizenship did not automatically end the child’s Indian citizenship.
Judge / Bench — Justice Senthilkumar Ramamoorthy.
In Aarush Shanmugam Gurudev v Regional Passport Officer, decided on 13 October 2026, the child was born in India to Indian parents and his mother remained Indian. The court distinguished a registered renunciation under Section 8 of the Citizenship Act from voluntary acquisition of foreign citizenship under Section 9. The latter did not, by itself, deprive the minor of citizenship.
The passport authority must consider and dispose of the renewal application within three months of receiving the order, subject to submission of other required documents. The court did not order unconditional renewal.
Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — S. Anusha. For respondent 1 — G. Ramanathan, CGSC.
Read current report and source
Kerala High Court Declines Interim Relief Against Fresh Waqf Board Appointments
Kerala High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Kerala High Court has declined to put on hold the State government's decision to reconstitute the Kerala State Waqf Board, leaving the appointment of nine new members undisturbed for now. Justice S Manu passed the order during a special sitting on Saturday, October 17, while hearing two petitions challenging the government's notification issued a day earlier. The petitions, filed by former Board chairperson KS Hamza and member CK Usman Haji, questioned the government's authority to replace the existing members and constitute the Board afresh. At the heart of the dispute is whether the State could cancel the earlier appointments and nominate a new set of members, particularly in light of its previous submissions before a Division Bench in proceedings concerning the Board's composition. The single-judge Bench found no prima facie merit in the petitioners' contention that the reconstitution violated the State's earlier submissions or the directions issued in related public interest litigation. The Court observed that the previous Division Bench had permitted the government to take appropriate steps to ensure that the Board was constituted in accordance with the law. On the question of whether the government could cancel existing appointments, the Court referred to a Supreme Court judgment in The State of Maharashtra v. Shaikh Mahemud & Another. The ruling recognised that the power to appoint members to a Waqf Board also carries the authority to cancel such appointments.
Dispute over statutory safeguards
The petitioners argued that the government could not remove the existing members without following the procedure prescribed under Sections 20 and 99 of the amended Waqf Act, formally known as the Unified Waqf Management, Empowerment, Efficiency and Development Act, 1995. These provisions deal with the removal of members and the supersession of the Board. The State defended its decision by questioning the legality of the earlier Board's constitution. It maintained that the previous appointments did not comply with Section 14 of the Act, particularly the requirements governing representation of different Muslim communities. According to the government, it had exercised its implied authority to cancel the earlier appointments and reconstitute the Board in line with the statutory requirements. The controversy follows earlier public interest litigation concerning the Board's composition, in which a Division Bench had directed the State to fill vacancies in accordance with the law. Questions had also been raised over the continuation of certain members and the overall legality of the Board's structure. While declining to grant an interim stay, the High Court acknowledged that several legal issues required detailed examination, including whether the government could reconstitute the Board at this stage. The Court consequently referred both petitions to the Division Bench already dealing with related challenges to the Board's composition. The October 16 notification will therefore remain unstayed at this stage, with the broader legal dispute left for further consideration.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court Gives Bar Council 45 Days to Track Advocates Who Fail to Clear AIBE
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Karnataka High Court has directed the Karnataka State Bar Council (KSBC) to establish a system for identifying advocates who continue to practise without clearing the mandatory All India Bar Examination (AIBE) within the prescribed period. Justice HP Sandesh has given the State Bar Council 45 days to develop a mechanism that tracks enrolment dates, monitors examination results and flags advocates who fail to meet the eligibility requirements for continuing legal practice. The Court emphasised that the Bar Council’s responsibility extends beyond enrolling law graduates. It must also maintain accurate records of who is eligible to practise and take prompt action against those who are not. “It is not the only duty of the Karnataka State Bar Council to enroll and it is also the duty of the State Bar Council to maintain a roll in respect of those who are eligible and not eligible to practice,” the Court observed in its October 17 order.
Digital records to flag ineligible advocates
The Court directed the KSBC to maintain digital enrolment records capturing the date of admission to the profession and the expiry of the two-year period within which an advocate is required to clear the AIBE. The proposed system must automatically flag advocates who fail to qualify within the stipulated period, enabling the council to identify such cases and initiate appropriate proceedings. The Bench also called for an integrated enrolment database, with examination results verified in coordination with the Bar Council of India. Periodic reviews must be conducted to ensure that the tracking system remains effective. The Court stressed that action against advocates who fail to meet the requirements should not be delayed, describing continued practice without the necessary qualification as a matter of concern for society. At the same time, it clarified that advocates identified through the proposed mechanism must be given an opportunity to present their defence before any penalty is imposed.
Case exposes a gap in monitoring
The directions came while the Court was dealing with a case involving an advocate who enrolled in 2011 and was accused of practising for approximately 11 years without clearing the AIBE. A resident of Bangarpet had lodged a criminal complaint alleging that the advocate had cheated by practising without fulfilling the examination requirement. A trial court subsequently referred the matter for a criminal investigation. The advocate approached the High Court seeking to quash the proceedings. He denied the allegations, claiming that he had been under the genuine impression that his enrolment permitted him to practise without further conditions. He also alleged that the complaint was motivated by malice. The advocate further submitted that he had eventually cleared the AIBE in 2021 and argued that the issue should have been dealt with through the Bar Council’s disciplinary process rather than criminal proceedings. The High Court rejected these arguments and allowed the police investigation to continue. “Existence of a disciplinary mechanism does not, by itself, extinguish the jurisdiction of a competent criminal court to examine conduct which independently satisfies the ingredients of a criminal offence,” the Court held. Expressing concern that the advocate had allegedly been able to practise for more than a decade without appearing for the examination, the Bench said the Bar Council needed a more effective way to identify similar cases before they continued for years. The Court consequently directed the KSBC to put the tracking mechanism in place, maintain updated records and act promptly against advocates found ineligible to continue practising. The matter is scheduled to be heard next on November 30.
Read current report and source
Allahabad High Court Suspends Murder Conviction, Citing Plea to Contest 2027 UP Elections
Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Allahabad High Court has suspended the conviction and life sentence of Nandan Lal Rai, a murder convict who has expressed his desire to enter the electoral fray in Uttar Pradesh’s 2027 Assembly elections, either as an independent candidate or on a Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) ticket. A Bench of Justices Siddharth and Vinai Kumar Dwivedi granted relief while hearing Rai’s plea in an appeal challenging his conviction. He was sentenced to life imprisonment by a Varanasi court in April 2025. The Bench noted that the Supreme Court had previously stayed the convictions of elected representatives and observed that failing to obtain a stay could deprive a person of the opportunity to contest an election. “Under the totality, facts and circumstances we are of the view that the conviction and sentence awarded to the appellant deserves to be stayed during the pendency of this appeal,” the Court held.
Defence questions prosecution evidence
Seeking relief during the pendency of his appeal, Rai’s counsel argued that the victim was politically active and that Rai had been implicated on the basis of suspicion rather than conclusive evidence. The defence questioned the prosecution’s reliance on circumstantial evidence, pointing to the delayed disclosure of Rai’s name during the investigation, doubts surrounding eyewitness testimony and the circumstances in which the alleged murder weapon was recovered. Media reports have identified Rai as one of the persons convicted in the murder of Pramod Kumar Nigam, an active member of the Ram Janmabhoomi movement. Those reports have also linked Rai to gangster-turned-politician Mukhtar Ansari.
Election plans form part of plea
During the hearing, Rai’s counsel submitted that he had been an active BJP worker before his conviction and wished to contest the 2027 Uttar Pradesh Assembly elections, either independently or, if possible, as a BJP candidate. The High Court considered these submissions while deciding the application. In its order dated October 5, it suspended Rai’s conviction and sentence during the pendency of his appeal. The Bench also referred to the importance of livelihood, observing that the ability of an ordinary person to sustain himself was no less significant than a politician’s opportunity to contest an election. “Keeping in view the right to livelihood of a common man which is not less important than the right to contest election by a politician, conviction and sentence of appellant deserves to be stayed so that he may be able to survive for hearing the final verdict in his above noted appeal,” the Court said. The suspension of the conviction is an interim measure while Rai’s appeal remains pending; it does not amount to an acquittal or a final determination of the murder case.
Read current report and source
Calcutta High Court Rejects Bail Plea of Former Minister Indranil Sen in Durga Puja Ticket Case
Calcutta High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Calcutta High Court has refused anticipatory bail to former West Bengal minister Indranil Sen in a case involving alleged financial irregularities linked to the sale of Durga Puja preview tickets and the purported use of UNESCO’s name. Justice Tirthankar Ghosh, while rejecting Sen’s plea, observed that the allegations raised questions about the possible misuse of his official position and the diversion of government funds for private benefit. The Court noted that the allegations pointed towards possible corruption, with public money allegedly channelled through a tender process in a manner that benefited Sen and his family members. It also took into account his position as the then Minister of Information and Cultural Affairs, which placed him at the centre of the department’s affairs. The case was registered by Bowbazar police station on June 9. According to the allegations, between 2022 and 2024, people were induced to purchase tickets for Durga Puja preview shows through an organisation called Mahanirban Road Mass Art Society, which was purportedly presented as being associated with UNESCO. During the hearing, Sen’s side argued that the sale of tickets and donor passes was limited in scale and did not require government backing or ministerial intervention. It was also contended that the allegations concerning the diversion of public funds stemmed from a change in the State government. The defence further maintained that Sen’s financial assets could be explained by his earnings over the years as an established singer. Opposing the bail application, the State alleged that Sen had misused his ministerial position to route government money into bank accounts linked to himself and his family members through shell entities. The State also named Mahanirban Road Mass Art Society among the entities allegedly involved in the transactions. After considering the rival submissions, the Court declined to grant anticipatory bail on October 15, holding that Sen had failed to establish sufficient grounds for the relief sought. The ruling concerns Sen’s request for protection from arrest. The allegations of financial wrongdoing remain accusations to be examined in the course of the proceedings.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court Backs Construction Curbs Near Heritage Sites, Orders Fresh Survey of Madhugiri Fort Plot
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Karnataka High Court has upheld the constitutional validity of legal provisions restricting construction around centrally protected monuments, ruling that safeguarding the country’s historical heritage can justify limits on how private land is used. At the same time, the Court has directed authorities to re-examine the exact distance between a property near Madhugiri Fort and the protected monument before deciding whether construction can be permitted. In its October 9 judgment in BR Ramakrishna v. Union of India & Others, Justice MGS Kamal rejected a challenge to Sections 20A, 20B and 20C of the Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, 1958. The provisions were introduced through amendments in 2010 to regulate activities around protected monuments.
Court Finds No Constitutional Flaw in Monument Protection Rules
The case arose after BR Ramakrishna, a resident of Tumkur, was denied permission to construct a residential building on his plot near Madhugiri Fort. In 2016, the Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) refused permission, stating that the proposed construction site was only 59 metres from the fort. The land therefore fell within the prohibited zone extending 100 metres from the protected monument, where construction is barred. Ramakrishna challenged the restrictions, arguing that they were arbitrary, lacked a scientific basis and infringed his constitutional rights. He maintained that the classification of land into restricted zones was unreasonable and imposed excessive limitations on property owners. The Court was not persuaded by his challenge. Emphasising the purpose of the legislation and the constitutional obligation to protect monuments, the Court held that the restrictions could not be considered unreasonable or disconnected from their intended objective. It also observed that decisions concerning the rationale behind such classifications fell within the domain of the competent expert authorities under the law. The Court concluded that Ramakrishna had failed to establish that the challenged provisions were unconstitutional. “Rejection of permission to put up construction in furtherance of a statute, which is regulatory in nature, cannot be the ground to quash, set aside, and declare the statute unconstitutional,” the Court held, noting that the petitioner had not discharged the burden required to invalidate the law.
Property Rights Do Not Override Heritage Protection
The ASI had opposed the proposed construction, warning that it could affect the fort’s visual appeal and surrounding cultural landscape. It also cautioned that approving the project could encourage similar demands from other landowners in the vicinity. The Court referred to Article 49 of the Constitution, which directs the State to protect monuments and places of national importance. It also invoked Article 51A(f), which places a fundamental duty on citizens to value and preserve India’s rich cultural heritage. Ramakrishna had further argued that the restrictions effectively deprived him of the use of his property without compensation. According to him, the vacant plot had become virtually unusable, while the compensation provision under Section 27 did not adequately address the situation. The Court rejected this argument as well. It clarified that the legislation did not transfer ownership of the property to the government or extinguish the owner's title. Instead, it regulated how the land could be used. Restrictions that reduce the utility of a property, the Court held, cannot automatically be treated as compulsory acquisition or expropriation. The Court also declined to direct the authorities to prepare site plans and heritage bye-laws under the relevant 2011 Rules. It observed that such matters concerned administrative implementation and legislative prerogative and did not provide grounds to invalidate the substantive provisions of the Act.
Fresh Measurement Ordered for Madhugiri Fort Property
Although the Court upheld the law, it identified a separate issue concerning the measurement used to reject Ramakrishna’s construction proposal. The petitioner disputed the authorities’ assertion that his land was 59 metres from the fort. He maintained that the property was approximately 200 metres from the southern wall of Madhugiri Fort and, therefore, might not fall within the prohibited zone. The Court found that the survey report submitted by the authorities did not adequately explain how the 59-metre measurement had been calculated. It consequently directed the authorities to conduct a fresh survey to establish the precise distance between the property and the protected monument. Following the survey, they must reconsider Ramakrishna’s request for construction permission. The exercise must be completed within three months of the authorities receiving a certified copy of the judgment. The petitioner must also be informed of the decision in writing. The ruling thus preserves the statutory restrictions designed to protect ancient monuments while requiring the authorities to verify the facts before applying those restrictions to an individual property.
Read current report and source