Saved newspaper edition with 2 court reports.
Delhi High Court Shields PM’s Air Travel Security Records from RTI Disclosure
Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Delhi High Court has refused to allow the disclosure of detailed Indian Air Force records concerning foreign trips made by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and former Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, holding that transparency cannot come at the cost of national security. Setting aside an earlier order of the Central Information Commission (CIC), Justice Amit Mahajan ruled that information revealing the security arrangements surrounding the Prime Minister’s overseas travel could pose risks to his safety and compromise the agencies responsible for protecting him. The dispute centred on Special Flight Returns (SFR) Parts I and II, records that contain details of aircraft, aircrew and members of the travelling entourage, including personnel deployed by the Special Protection Group (SPG). In its October 15 order, the High Court emphasised that the possible consequences of releasing such information for national security and the Prime Minister’s security apparatus could not be overlooked. The Court also made it clear that judicial authorities and the CIC could not replace the assessment of specialised security agencies when determining whether disclosure might endanger the Prime Minister. Such decisions, it observed, primarily fall within the responsibility of agencies tasked with protecting the Prime Minister, whose security assessments cannot simply be substituted by the Court’s own judgment.
How the RTI dispute began
The matter originated in June 2018, when retired Navy Commodore Lokesh K Batra sought information about foreign visits undertaken by Indian Prime Ministers aboard Indian Air Force aircraft between April 2013 and June 2018. The request covered the period during which both Manmohan Singh and Narendra Modi served as Prime Minister. The Air Force furnished information concerning certain visits but declined to release the requested SFR Part I and Part II records. Its Central Public Information Officer cited security concerns and also relied on the exemption relating to information held in a fiduciary capacity. Batra subsequently approached the Central Information Commission, which directed the Air Force to provide certified copies of the available and relevant SFR-II records after removing the names of security personnel. The Air Force challenged that direction before the Delhi High Court.
Public expenditure versus security concerns
During the proceedings, Batra argued that the requested records were relevant to understanding how public money was spent on the Prime Minister’s foreign visits. He maintained that the request was driven by public interest and concerned private individuals accompanying the Prime Minister at public expense, rather than the identities of security personnel. The High Court, however, found that the use of public funds did not automatically make every associated record suitable for public disclosure. It held that expenditure on official foreign visits, by itself, could not justify releasing information capable of exposing or undermining the security arrangements established for those journeys. Finding the CIC’s direction to be erroneous, the Court set aside its order requiring disclosure of the SFR-II records. The ruling reinforces the distinction between public accountability over government expenditure and access to operational information that could affect the safety of the country’s highest constitutional officeholder.
Read current report and source
Allahabad High Court Flags Alleged Police Fabrication, Orders Probe Into Arrest Records
Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Allahabad High Court has ordered an inquiry into suspected fabrication of an arrest memo by Uttar Pradesh Police after finding discrepancies between the document submitted before a magistrate and the version later presented to the High Court. The matter came up during a habeas corpus petition filed by Junaid, who challenged his arrest by Aligarh police on August 6. He argued that the arrest memo supplied to him did not adequately disclose the grounds for his arrest, making his continued detention unlawful. A Bench of Justices Atul Sreedharan and Achal Sachdev examined the records and found that the two versions of the arrest memo contained significant differences. The document submitted before the High Court included additional entries setting out the grounds of arrest that were absent from the original record placed before the magistrate during remand proceedings. The discrepancy prompted the Court to question whether the document had been altered after the accused was remanded to custody.
Court Suspects Entries Were Added After Remand
During the hearing, Junaid's counsel produced a certified copy of the arrest memo that had been submitted before the remand magistrate. The defence pointed out that the version later filed by the police in response to the habeas corpus petition contained additional details. After comparing the documents, the Bench observed that the grounds of arrest recorded in the original memo were perfunctory. It further concluded that the version placed before the High Court appeared to have been fabricated. The judges noted that the additional entries in items 12 and 13 on the second page of the document appeared to have been inserted after the remand proceedings, possibly after the habeas corpus petition had been filed. The Court expressed concern that the investigating officer may have been involved in preparing the altered document, describing the alleged conduct as a serious matter requiring further examination.
Registrar General Asked to Initiate Perjury Proceedings
Taking note of the suspected fabrication, the High Court directed its Registrar General to conduct an inquiry under Section 379 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), which deals with the procedure for cases involving offences covered by Section 215. The Court said that if the inquiry established a prima facie case of document fabrication and perjury in connection with the judicial proceedings, the Registrar General should initiate the necessary steps to bring the matter before a competent court against those found to be involved. The direction places the focus not only on the alleged irregularities in Junaid's arrest but also on the integrity of documents submitted by police authorities during court proceedings.
Accused Ordered to Be Released
Separately, the Bench found that the grounds of arrest communicated to Junaid were inadequate. Holding that the arrest did not meet the applicable legal requirements, the Court ordered his release. The case, titled Junaid and another v. State of UP and 4 Others, arose from a challenge to the legality of his detention in a forgery-related matter. The High Court's order underscores the importance of properly documenting the grounds of arrest and ensuring that records presented before judicial authorities accurately reflect the original proceedings. The inquiry will determine whether the suspected alterations warrant further action against those responsible. Senior Advocate Mohit Singh and advocate Subir Lal appeared for the petitioner.
Read current report and source