Saved newspaper edition with 3 court reports.
Application and Fee Weren’t Enough: Calcutta High Court Rejects CPI(M)’s Bid to Save Durga Puja Book Stall
Calcutta High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Calcutta High Court has refused to stop the removal of a temporary book stall run by the Communist Party of India (Marxist) near Jadavpur Coffee House during Durga Puja, holding that an application for permission and payment of the prescribed fee do not authorise the stall’s operation without formal approval. Justice Partha Pratim Roy dismissed the party’s plea, observing that a valid permission to set up the stall was a necessary condition for seeking judicial protection against its removal. The dispute arose after individuals allegedly associated with the Kolkata Municipal Corporation (KMC), accompanied by a large police contingent and a bulldozer, attempted to dismantle the stall on October 17. The CPI(M) approached the High Court seeking protection for the stall, which it has traditionally operated in front of Jadavpur Coffee House during Durga Puja for the past 49 years. In keeping with its longstanding practice, the party had submitted an application on September 19, 2026, to the office of the Assistant Director, SWM-I, Borough X, of the KMC. It also paid ₹3,208 towards the requisite fee and sent a letter to the officer-in-charge of the nearby police station. However, the Court noted that the payment receipt was subject to police permission and did not establish that the necessary approval had actually been granted. Justice Roy pointed out that the very act of applying for permission and depositing the fee demonstrated that the party understood approval to be mandatory before operating the book stall. Despite these steps, no permission had been issued. The Court also relied on the legal position laid down by a Division Bench in MAT 1881 of 2026, which required parties seeking judicial protection for a stall to first establish that they possessed valid permission to operate it. Since the CPI(M) could not demonstrate that such authorisation had been granted, the Court held that it was not entitled to the relief sought and dismissed the petition. The ruling draws a clear distinction between completing the formalities for seeking permission and actually receiving the approval required to run a temporary stall.
Read current report and source
Chorebagan Stampede: Calcutta High Court Leaves Inquiry Panel Choice to Bengal Government
Calcutta High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Calcutta High Court has declined to commit a sitting judge to an inquiry into the deadly Chorebagan Durga Puja stampede, making it clear that the West Bengal government can appoint a retired High Court judge if no serving judge is made available. The decision came while the Court was hearing a public interest litigation seeking an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the tragedy at the Chorebagan Sarbojonin Durga Puja pandal on October 17, 2026, in which 19 people, including a seven-year-old child, lost their lives. A Bench comprising Chief Justice Ravindra Vithalrao Ghuge and Justice Shabbar Rashidi clarified that the decision to release a serving judge for the proposed inquiry rests with the Chief Justice in his administrative capacity. If no sitting judge is spared, the State government can constitute a commission under the Commissions of Inquiry Act, 1952, and appoint a retired judge of the High Court in accordance with the law. The Bench also drew a clear boundary around the Court's role, stating that it would not supervise the commission's investigation. The responsibility for considering the findings and acting on the eventual report would lie with the State government.
Court cites shortage of serving judges
The State had approached the Chief Justice through a letter from Chief Secretary Manoj Agarwal, requesting that a serving judge be made available to head the proposed commission. However, the Bench took note of the High Court's existing judicial strength before deciding against issuing any direction to spare a sitting judge. Although the sanctioned strength of the Court is 72 judges, only 50 were in position at the time. The Bench further noted that Justice Shampa Dutt (Paul) was due to retire on October 27, while Justice Apurba Sinha Ray was scheduled to retire on November 25. Their departures would bring the working strength down to 48. Against this backdrop, the Court left the question of appointing a serving judge to the Chief Justice's discretion and allowed the State to consider a retired judge instead.
What the proposed inquiry will examine
The State's communication to the Chief Justice outlined several issues for the commission to investigate. These include the factors that contributed to the stampede, the sequence of events leading to the deaths and the adequacy of arrangements for crowd control and disaster management. The proposed inquiry is also expected to examine CCTV footage, call records, police station records and control room logs to reconstruct what happened and assess the response of the authorities. During the hearing, senior advocate Kalyan Bandopadhyay, appearing for the petitioner Tapas Kumar Dey, raised concerns about the arrangements at Durga Puja pandals. He argued that narrow access routes, elaborate decorative installations, elevated platforms, poor ventilation and inadequate lighting could have contributed to dangerous crowd conditions at the Chorebagan venue. He also alleged that a shortage of police and management personnel aggravated the situation. Bandopadhyay further contended that changes in the composition of Durga Puja committees had placed inexperienced people in positions of responsibility. A sudden spell of rain, he submitted, added to the difficulties and heightened the panic among visitors. Representing the State, Additional Advocate General Billwadal Bhattacharyya told the Court that the government had already approached the Chief Justice with a request to appoint a judge to investigate the incident. On that basis, he argued that the petition did not require extensive examination at that stage.
PIL remains pending
While declining to monitor the inquiry or direct the appointment of a serving judge, the High Court has not disposed of the public interest litigation. The matter will remain pending, allowing the parties to approach the Court again if circumstances warrant further consideration. The ruling leaves the West Bengal government to move ahead with the proposed commission, while making clear that the inquiry's findings and subsequent action will remain the State's responsibility.
Read current report and source
Patna High Court Flags NDPS Act Overreach in Codeine Cough Syrup Seizures
Patna High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Patna High Court has raised concerns over the frequent use of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act in cases involving codeine-based cough syrups, observing that police are invoking the stringent law even when the preparations fall within limits exempted by the Central government. Justice Ashok Kumar Pandey said such cases should ordinarily be dealt with under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act when the codeine content and other conditions meet the prescribed exemption criteria. The Court described the repeated invocation of the NDPS Act in these circumstances as a misuse of legal procedure. The observations came while hearing the bail application of Bharat Kumar, who was arrested in May 2026 after 484 litres of codeine-based cough syrup were seized from a pickup van in Bihar's Khagaria district. Kumar claimed he was merely standing near the vehicle and had no connection with either the van or the seized material. His defence also pointed out that nothing had been recovered directly from him, he had no criminal antecedents, and another accused in a similar position had already secured bail. A key part of the argument concerned a Central government notification dated November 14, 1985, which excludes certain codeine preparations from the definition of manufactured drugs under the NDPS Act, provided they satisfy specified conditions. These include a maximum of 100 milligrams of codeine per dosage unit and a concentration not exceeding 2.5 per cent, along with requirements relating to their recognised therapeutic use.
Court questions the routine use of the NDPS Act
The State opposed the bail plea, relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Hira Singh v. Union of India. The judgment holds that the total weight of a mixture containing a narcotic substance must be considered when determining the applicable quantity under the NDPS Act. The distinction is significant because Section 37 imposes stringent conditions for granting bail in cases involving commercial quantities. Courts must have reasonable grounds to believe that the accused is not guilty and is unlikely to commit another offence while on bail. However, Justice Pandey observed that the commercial-quantity question would not arise in the first place if the seized preparation did not qualify as a narcotic drug under the applicable legal framework. The defence maintained that the cough syrup recovered in Kumar's case contained less than 2.5 per cent codeine, bringing it within the exemption claimed under the Central government's notification. On that basis, it argued that the matter fell under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act rather than the NDPS Act.
Bail granted after examining the exemption argument
The Court accepted the bail plea and released Kumar on bail. In its order dated October 1, it returned to what it considered a troubling pattern in the handling of such seizures. Justice Pandey noted that police frequently register NDPS cases involving codeine cough syrup despite the Central government's notification providing an exemption for qualifying preparations. Where the concentration remains below the prescribed threshold and the other conditions are satisfied, the substance may fall outside the category of contraband under the NDPS Act. The ruling underscores the importance of examining the composition of seized cough syrup and the applicable notification before invoking the stringent provisions of narcotics law. It also highlights the distinction between regulatory violations involving pharmaceutical products and offences that genuinely fall within the scope of the NDPS Act.
Read current report and source