Saved newspaper
27 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 11 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Supreme Court Upholds Cooperative Bank Member’s Access To Records Through RTI
- Supreme Court Quashes Fraudulent Housing Acquisition, Orders Land Restored
- Supreme Court Draws the Line: Creditors Cannot Backtrack on Approved Insolvency Plans
- Kerala High Court Expunges Remarks Against Advocate, Reiterates Professional Duties
- Bombay High Court Sets Aside School Peon’s Reinstatement Order
- Kerala High Court Convicts Cheque Drawer Despite Time-Barred Debt Defence
- Karnataka High Court Keeps Forgery Probe Alive Against PSI Over Alleged Birth Date Manipulation
- Bengaluru Court Orders Company to Clear ₹2.75 Lakh Legal Bill, Shields Directors From Personal Liability
- Allahabad High Court Rejects Challenge to 18% GST on Digital Legal Research Platforms
- Sabarimala Gold Theft Probe Complete, Kerala High Court Pushes for Swift Legal Clearance
- Bombay High Court Moves Against Fake Websites Misusing Naturals Ice Cream Brand
Supreme Court Upholds Cooperative Bank Member’s Access To Records Through RTI
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court on 26 October 2026 upheld a cooperative-bank member’s right to obtain its construction agreement and general-body minutes through the statutory Registrar under the RTI Act.
Judge / Bench — J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.; judgment by K. Vinod Chandran, J.
Dismissing Muppathadam Service Co-Operative Bank’s appeals, the Court held that information includes private-body records a public authority can lawfully access, even without physical custody. The Registrar’s access was not conditional on an inquiry already being initiated.
The Court rejected the claimed commercial-confidence and personal-information exemptions for these documents sought by a member, while distinguishing requests by unrelated outsiders. The Registrar must obtain and supply both records within two weeks.
Advocates appearing — Appellant bank: S.P. Chaly, Senior Counsel. Respondent 1: Abhilash M.R. Other respondents’ counsel: Not named in the judgment.
Party-in-person — Respondent 4, a bank member; name not identified in the judgment.
Read current report and source
Supreme Court Quashes Fraudulent Housing Acquisition, Orders Land Restored
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court on 26 October 2026 quashed a Karnataka cooperative housing acquisition tainted by fraud, directing restoration of land to its original owners.
Judge / Bench — J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.; judgment by K. Vinod Chandran, J.
In N. Arasappa’s connected appeals, the Court held that government approval must cover an actual housing scheme with a layout and blueprint. It found improper intermediary arrangements, defective membership verification and colourable exercise of acquisition powers. Earlier litigation and delay could not shield the established fraud.
Landowners recovering possession must refund government compensation without interest. Private payments are excluded. Unrestored plots must be auctioned under judicial supervision for victim compensation. Costs were increased to ₹50,000 per original petitioner or group of legal representatives; contempt directions were removed because of elapsed time.
Advocates appearing — Appellants: Kiran Suri and Basava Prabhu S. Patil, Senior Counsel. Respondent 4/society: Vikas Singh, Senior Counsel. State: Sanjay R. Hegde, Senior Counsel, assisted by Omar Hoda, Additional Advocate General.
Read current report and source
Supreme Court Draws the Line: Creditors Cannot Backtrack on Approved Insolvency Plans
Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Supreme Court has ruled that a Committee of Creditors (CoC) cannot withdraw its approval of an insolvency resolution plan simply because the corporate debtor's financial position has improved since the plan was agreed upon. Once approved by the CoC and placed before the adjudicating authority, the plan cannot be unilaterally abandoned by either the creditors or the successful resolution applicant. A Bench of Justices JB Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran delivered the ruling in Bank of India & Ors. v. S.M. Kamal Pasha & Ors., emphasising that the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) does not allow parties to walk away from an approved plan merely because changing circumstances make the original arrangement less financially attractive. The Court clarified that withdrawal is permissible before the CoC approves a resolution plan. Once the approved plan is submitted to the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), however, neither the application nor the plan can ordinarily be withdrawn at the parties' discretion.
Financial turnaround triggered a dispute
The case arose from insolvency proceedings initiated by the Bank of India against a company involved in toll collection on National Highway 45. The company's financial position had weakened during the Covid-19 pandemic, prompting a resolution plan worth ₹172.55 crore. At that stage, the corporate debtor had an opening cash balance of around ₹30 crore. Implementation of the plan was subsequently held up by prolonged litigation. During the delay, the company's finances improved substantially, with its opening cash balance rising to approximately ₹165 crore. The improved position changed the creditors' assessment of the original arrangement. The CoC unanimously decided to withdraw its approval and invite fresh expressions of interest, arguing that implementing the existing plan would give the successful resolution applicant an unexpected financial advantage. The creditors maintained that a fresh bidding process could unlock greater value from the company's assets and improve recoveries.
NCLAT rejected the withdrawal
The NCLT initially permitted the CoC to withdraw the resolution plan. The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), however, overturned that decision, holding that the creditors could not retract their approval once the plan had crossed the relevant statutory stage. The creditors challenged the appellate tribunal's ruling before the Supreme Court. Senior Advocate Gopal Sankaranarayanan, appearing for the creditors, argued that reopening the process and inviting new bids could maximise the value of the corporate debtor and benefit those owed money. Senior Advocate Nidhesh Gupta, representing the successful resolution applicant, opposed the move. He contended that creditors could not abandon a commitment already made simply because the company's financial circumstances had changed.
IBC does not permit opportunistic reversals
The Supreme Court upheld the NCLAT's view that an improvement in the corporate debtor's finances was not, by itself, a valid ground for the CoC to withdraw an approved resolution plan. The Bench relied on its earlier ruling in Ebix Singapore v. Committee of Creditors of Educomp Solutions, reiterating that the statutory insolvency framework does not provide a general right to unilaterally withdraw or modify an approved resolution plan. The Court also took note of the successful resolution applicant's contention that the creditors' decision appeared to reflect a desire for a more favourable financial outcome rather than a change in their legitimate commercial assessment. The judgment observed that the allegation that the CoC had reversed course because of “shortsighted opportunism” and “institutionalized rapacity” could not simply be disregarded. The central principle, the Bench stressed, is that the binding effect of an approved resolution plan applies equally to creditors and the successful resolution applicant. Neither side can treat the arrangement as provisional merely because subsequent developments alter its financial appeal.
NCLT to examine the company's present position
While settling the question of withdrawal, the Supreme Court did not itself decide whether the resolution plan should ultimately receive approval from the NCLT. The matter was left to the tribunal, which must also consider a pending application seeking to conclude the corporate insolvency resolution process through a one-time settlement. The NCLT was directed to examine the company's current financial position, including its available cash balance, while considering the resolution plan. At the same time, the Court made clear that improved profitability alone would not justify rejecting a plan that otherwise meets the statutory requirements. The Bench clarified that its observations on the merits of the resolution plan were prima facie and would not bind the NCLT in its final determination. Its ruling on the binding nature of a CoC-approved plan, however, remains the key legal takeaway. The decision reinforces a fundamental principle of the insolvency process: a better financial outlook does not give creditors a free hand to reopen a resolution deal after committing to it.
Read current report and source
Kerala High Court Expunges Remarks Against Advocate, Reiterates Professional Duties
Kerala High Court · Editorial Team
The Kerala High Court on 13 October 2026 expunged part of a judgment’s adverse remarks against advocate Sadiqali M., while reiterating lawyers’ duties to verify documents and make fair disclosures.
Judge / Bench — Devan Ramachandran and Basant Balaji, JJ.; judgment by Devan Ramachandran, J.
In Writ Appeal 2113/2026, the Court said counsel act on clients’ instructions but must exercise caution when there is reason for suspicion. Advocates must protect clients through fair means without becoming their personal alter egos.
The Court regarded the earlier admonition as intended to mentor a young lawyer, but found its continuing adverse professional impact unintended. It removed the specified portion of paragraph 5; the underlying judgment otherwise remains unchanged.
Advocates appearing — Appellant: J. Sai Deepak, Senior Counsel, instructed by Manas P. Hameed; Ipsita Ojal also recorded. Respondent 1/Federal Bank: Mohan Jacob George, Standing Counsel. Respondents: P.M. Rafeek, Senior Government Pleader; other individual counsel not named in the judgment.
Read current report and source
Bombay High Court Sets Aside School Peon’s Reinstatement Order
Bombay High Court · Editorial Team
The Bombay High Court on 23 October 2026 set aside a School Tribunal order reinstating a dismissed peon, finding that procedural defects had caused no real prejudice to his defence.
Judge / Bench — M.M. Sathaye, J.
In Writ Petition 2115/2005, concerning Husen Kasam Shaikh, the Court held that the tribunal had misconstrued the disciplinary charges and overlooked the opportunities afforded during the inquiry. It also rejected attempts to supplement a fully argued case through later representations.
The management’s petition succeeded. Shaikh may withdraw the back-wages deposited in court under the 2005 interim order, with accrued interest, if any; no costs were ordered.
Advocates appearing — Petitioners/management and school: Kiran Bapat, Senior Advocate, with Samir Suryawanshi. Respondent 1: Kumud Bhatia. Respondents 2–3/State: Kavita N. Solunke, Additional Government Pleader, with S.L. Babar, AGP.
Party heard personally — Husen Kasam Shaikh, respondent 1, was also heard after his counsel.
Read current report and source
Kerala High Court Convicts Cheque Drawer Despite Time-Barred Debt Defence
Kerala High Court · Editorial Team
The Kerala High Court on 8 October 2026 overturned Sujith’s acquittal in a ₹9,30,230 cheque-dishonour case, holding that issuance of a cheque can revive liability for a time-barred debt.
Judge / Bench — A. Badharudeen, J.
In Criminal Appeal 2002/2024, the Court found the transaction and execution proved. It held that the debt’s earlier limitation bar did not itself defeat prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
Sujith was sentenced to imprisonment until the court rises and a ₹14 lakh fine, with six months’ imprisonment upon default. Of the recovered fine, ₹13.5 lakh is compensation and ₹50,000 goes to the State. He must appear before the Varkala magistrate on 31 October 2026.
Advocates appearing — Appellant/complainant: P. Rahul and Abhina L. Respondent 1/accused: Prasanth M.P., appointed State Brief after N. Sunil Joseph relinquished his engagement. State: Sajeev P.K., Senior Public Prosecutor.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court Keeps Forgery Probe Alive Against PSI Over Alleged Birth Date Manipulation
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Karnataka High Court has declined to halt criminal proceedings against a Police Sub-Inspector accused of allegedly fabricating vaccination records to change his date of birth and qualify for police recruitment. Justice Suraj Govindaraj dismissed a petition filed by Kashilingegowda SB in Kashilingegowda S B v. State of Karnataka, ruling that a civil court order permitting a change in birth date could not automatically shield him from an investigation into the alleged fabrication of documents used to secure that order. The Court also directed that the investigation be completed without unnecessary delay.
Dispute centres on vaccination register
The case stems from allegations that Kashilingegowda manipulated entries in a vaccination register to change his date of birth from April 15, 1988, to April 15, 1987. The alleged alteration was intended to make him eligible for recruitment as a Police Sub-Inspector. Vidhana Soudha Police registered a criminal case in December 2024, invoking provisions of the Indian Penal Code relating to the use of false certificates, cheating, forgery and the use of forged documents as genuine. Kashilingegowda approached the High Court seeking to quash the proceedings, arguing that his revised date of birth had been recognised through a decree issued by a competent civil court. That decree had directed corrections to his school records and marks cards. He also relied on a July 2025 order of the Karnataka State Administrative Tribunal, which had ruled in his favour in a challenge to disciplinary proceedings. The tribunal had observed that the civil court decree could not simply be treated as void without being set aside by a competent forum. On that basis, Kashilingegowda argued that criminal proceedings concerning the same change in date of birth could not continue while the civil court's order remained in force.
Civil court decree does not end the criminal inquiry
The complainant opposed the petition, maintaining that the alleged fabrication of the vaccination document lay at the heart of the civil court proceedings themselves. The existence of the decree, therefore, could not prevent the police from examining whether the document relied upon to obtain it was genuine. The High Court accepted that distinction, observing that the civil court had ordered the correction of the birth date on the strength of a vaccination document that was now alleged to have been fabricated. “The very documents on the basis of which the decree came to be passed are alleged to be fabricated,” the Court observed. The Bench made clear that the legal effect of the civil court decree and the criminal allegations raised separate questions. While the decree remained relevant to the correction of the officer's records, it did not automatically foreclose an investigation into suspected forgery or cheating. The allegations also warranted scrutiny because the revised birth date was said to have helped the officer meet the eligibility requirements for recruitment.
Investigation must establish the facts
The Court refrained from deciding whether the vaccination records had actually been fabricated or whether Kashilingegowda had any role in the alleged wrongdoing. Those questions, it said, must be examined during the investigation, along with whether the alleged acts satisfy the requirements of the offences invoked. “Whether the documents were in fact fabricated, whether the petitioner was involved in any such fabrication, and whether the ingredients of the alleged offences are made out are matters to be ascertained in the course of investigation,” the Court said. With these observations, the High Court rejected the plea to quash the criminal case, leaving the investigation to proceed. The ruling does not establish that the officer forged the records; it allows the authorities to investigate the allegations despite the existing civil court decree.
Read current report and source
Bengaluru Court Orders Company to Clear ₹2.75 Lakh Legal Bill, Shields Directors From Personal Liability
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
A Bengaluru civil court has directed Moerheim Roses and Trading India Private Limited to pay ₹2.75 lakh in unpaid legal fees to Krishnamurthy & Co. (K Law), along with 9% annual interest, while ruling that the company’s directors cannot be held personally responsible for the debt merely because they managed its affairs. Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge Shirin Javeed Ansari held that the company’s contractual obligations could not automatically be transferred to its directors without evidence of a separate personal commitment or guarantee. The dispute stemmed from legal work undertaken by K Law in connection with proceedings before the Karnataka High Court in 2017. According to the firm, it was engaged through Delhi-based law firm Anand & Anand in January that year. Its work included filing objections, seeking the vacation of an interim stay and arranging representation by senior counsel. K Law raised invoices amounting to ₹6.10 lakh for the services. Moerheim Roses paid ₹3.35 lakh, leaving ₹2.75 lakh unpaid. The firm maintained that repeated reminders and a formal legal notice failed to secure the remaining payment. It also relied on email exchanges from 2021 and 2022, which it said showed that the company had acknowledged the outstanding dues and discussed possible payment arrangements. After the amount remained unsettled, K Law filed a recovery suit in November 2023, seeking the unpaid fees along with interest at 24% per annum. Neither the company nor its four directors appeared in court despite receiving summons, and the matter proceeded ex parte.
Directors cannot automatically inherit company debts
The court found that the invoices, payment records and evidence relating to the legal work established the company’s liability to pay the outstanding professional fees. However, it drew a clear distinction between the company’s obligation and the personal liability of those serving on its board. The judge observed that holding a directorship does not, by itself, make an individual personally responsible for every contractual or commercial debt incurred by the company. The court further held that an allegation that the directors were involved in the company’s day-to-day operations was insufficient to establish an independent promise to pay its dues. Without evidence of a personal guarantee or a separate contractual undertaking, the directors could not be made liable for the unpaid legal bill.
Interest claim reduced from 24% to 9%
The court also declined to grant the 24% annual interest sought by K Law, noting the absence of evidence establishing an agreement between the parties for interest at that rate. Instead, it directed Moerheim Roses and Trading India Private Limited to pay ₹2.75 lakh with interest at 9% per annum from the date the suit was instituted until the amount is fully recovered. Litigation costs were also awarded to the firm. The ruling thus secured recovery of the unpaid professional fees from the company while rejecting the attempt to extend that liability to its directors in the absence of a separate legal basis.
Read current report and source
Allahabad High Court Rejects Challenge to 18% GST on Digital Legal Research Platforms
Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Allahabad High Court has refused to entertain a public interest litigation questioning the imposition of 18% Goods and Services Tax (GST) on online legal research platforms, including SCC Online and Manupatra, citing the delay in bringing the challenge. A Bench comprising Chief Justice Arun Bhansali and Justice Kshitij Shailendra declined to examine whether the tax classification was constitutionally valid. Instead, the Court dismissed the petition at the admission stage, questioning why the petitioner had challenged a tax structure that had remained in place since 2017 only after several years of legal practice. The petition was filed by advocate Aniket Gupta in Aniket Gupta v. Union of India and 4 Others. The Bench observed that the petitioner, who enrolled as an advocate in 2020 and claimed to have practised for approximately six years, had demonstrated a sudden realisation that the existing tax rate was unreasonable. The Court found this delay sufficient to reject the plea without examining its substantive arguments.
Petition highlights unequal tax treatment
The petition challenged the classification of digital legal research and educational database services under Services Accounting Code (SAC) 998431, which attracts GST at 18%. Platforms and publications cited in the plea included SCC Online, Manupatra, LexisNexis, LiveLaw and Bar & Bench. The petitioner argued that legal research services were being taxed more heavily than comparable resources available in other formats. Printed law reports are exempt from GST, while e-books attract a 5% rate. Online journals supplied to educational institutions are also exempt under the applicable provisions, the petition stated. According to the plea, imposing an 18% tax on substantially similar material merely because it is accessed through an online legal database creates an unjustified distinction between print and digital formats. The petitioner maintained that access to these platforms is not a discretionary expense for advocates. They are essential professional tools for locating judgments, researching legal principles and preparing accurate submissions before courts.
Subscription costs cited as a burden on junior advocates
The petition also drew attention to the financial pressure the tax places on young practitioners. An annual single-user subscription to SCC Online can cost as much as ₹39,530, including approximately ₹6,030 in GST, according to the plea. The amount, it argued, represents a significant expense for junior advocates, particularly those working on limited stipends. The petition further pointed out that advocates who are not registered under GST, along with legal aid counsel who cannot claim input tax credit, must absorb the tax as an additional cost. This, the petitioner contended, makes access to reliable legal research more expensive and potentially affects the ability of practitioners to provide affordable legal services.
AI-related judicial scrutiny cited in support
The plea also relied on recent Supreme Court decisions in Pooja Ramesh Singh and Vijay Ghanshyam Gadiya, delivered in July and September 2026, respectively. According to the petitioner, these rulings underscored the need for strict verification of judicial precedents and addressed the professional consequences of relying on fabricated or AI-generated citations without proper verification. The petition argued that commercial legal research databases have consequently assumed greater importance as tools for checking judgments and ensuring the accuracy of court submissions. In this context, the petitioner maintained that the higher GST rate places an additional financial burden on services that advocates increasingly need to meet their professional obligations. The High Court, however, did not assess these arguments or determine whether the tax classification was arbitrary or unconstitutional. By dismissing the petition on the ground of delay, the Bench left the substantive challenge to the 18% GST levy undecided.
Read current report and source
Sabarimala Gold Theft Probe Complete, Kerala High Court Pushes for Swift Legal Clearance
Kerala High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The investigation into the alleged theft of gold from the Sabarimala temple’s sanctum sanctorum doorframes has been completed, but the filing of the final report remains on hold pending prosecution sanction. The Kerala High Court has now directed the authorities to speed up the process and remove the administrative delays holding up the case. A Division Bench of Justices Raja Vijayaraghavan V and KV Jayakumar issued the direction after the Special Investigation Team (SIT) informed the Court that it had concluded its investigation into the alleged disappearance of gold from the temple’s gold-plated copper coverings. The case centres on the alleged misappropriation of gold from the doorframes, sides and roof of the Sreekovil, the inner sanctum of the Sabarimala temple. The Court directed the concerned authorities to obtain the necessary legal opinion without delay and place the request for prosecution sanction before the competent authority. Once approval is secured, the SIT must submit its final report before the jurisdictional court promptly.
Legal opinion holds up final report
SIT chief Sasidharan IPS told the Court that the investigation concerning the doorframes had been completed and that both a factual report and a draft chargesheet were ready. However, the team has yet to seek prosecution sanction under Section 19(1)(c) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, a requirement before the chargesheet can be filed. The delay stems from a pending opinion from an Assistant Legal Advisor who has been appointed but has not yet assumed charge, the Court was informed. Director General of Prosecution T Asaf Ali assured the Bench that necessary steps would be taken to ensure the advisor takes charge and provides the required opinion without further delay. Taking note of the situation, the Court called on the authorities to expedite the process so that the investigation can move towards its next stage without unnecessary administrative hurdles. The Bench also directed the SIT to complete its investigation into a separate case involving the temple’s Dwarapalaka idols and seek prosecution sanction within the timelines already fixed by the Court.
How the alleged gold loss came to light
The case traces back to gold donated by a devotee in 1999 for the Dwarapalaka figures, along with the gold coverings fitted over the sides and roof of the temple’s sanctum. In 2019, the coverings were removed and transported to Chennai for repair work. However, records prepared by the Travancore Devaswom Board at the time reportedly described the removed material as copper sheets rather than gold-plated copper plates. The discrepancy gained significance when measurements taken after the repair work indicated that several kilograms of gold were missing. In 2025, the temple’s special commissioner brought the removal of the gold-clad plates to the Court’s attention. The High Court subsequently initiated suo motu proceedings and constituted the SIT to investigate the alleged irregularities. Since then, the Court has been monitoring the investigation and its progress. The latest directions were issued during an in-camera hearing in the suo motu proceedings titled Suo Motu v. The State of Kerala & Ors. With the doorframes investigation complete, the immediate focus is now on securing the pending legal opinion and prosecution sanction, allowing the SIT to place its final report before the competent court.
Read current report and source
Bombay High Court Moves Against Fake Websites Misusing Naturals Ice Cream Brand
Bombay High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Bombay High Court has stepped in to protect the ‘NATURAL’ ice cream brand, restraining unidentified individuals and associated entities from misusing its trademarks, copying copyrighted material and cheating people through fraudulent franchise offers. Justice Madhav J Jamdar granted interim relief to Siddhant Ice Creams LLP, the registered owner of the brand’s family of trademarks, and its master franchisee. The Court found that the company had established a strong prima facie case for protection, considering its longstanding reputation and commercial presence since 1984. The dispute centres on websites and online communications allegedly designed to impersonate the established ice cream business. The company told the Court that unidentified operators were exploiting the anonymity of the internet to create fake websites, circulate forged letters and send misleading emails to potential franchise investors. According to the allegations, unsuspecting individuals were being asked to pay money for franchise licences that were not genuine. The fraudulent websites also allegedly misrepresented the brand’s origins by claiming that an individual named RK Gupta was its founder. The company, however, was established in Juhu, Mumbai, in 1984 by the late Raghunandan Kamath. While considering the request for urgent protection, the Court took note of the brand’s established goodwill, sales figures and promotional expenditure. Justice Jamdar observed that the alleged misuse of the NATURAL name was intended to capitalise on the company’s substantial market presence. The interim injunction bars the defendants and their associated entities from using the NATURAL trademark, similar logos or deceptive variations across websites, domain names, email accounts and social media platforms. The order also prohibits copyright infringement and passing off through the promotion of fraudulent franchise opportunities under the brand’s identity. The ruling seeks to prevent further misuse of the ice cream company’s reputation while the dispute proceeds. It also provides interim protection against online impersonation that could mislead prospective franchisees and damage consumer trust in the established business.
Read current report and source