Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

28 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 8 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Supreme Court Sends Firm Message to Tribunals: Its ‘Requests’ Must Be Treated as Directions
  2. Supreme Court Upholds ECL Finance’s Exclusion From Creditors’ Committee
  3. Delhi High Court Seeks Centre, Meta’s Response Over Blocking of ‘Bring Back Ballot’ Instagram Account
  4. MP High Court Rebukes Town Planning Official Over Inappropriate Video Hearing Appearance, Orders Disciplinary Action
  5. Delhi High Court Quashes ₹3.91 Crore Tax Demand Against Security Guard, Flags Failure to Probe PAN Misuse
  6. Allahabad High Court Signals Contempt, Disciplinary Action Over Lawyers’ Courtroom Protest
  7. Karnataka High Court Won’t Drop Neighbours’ Criminal Cases Over Garbage Row That Turned Violent
  8. Bengaluru Court Quashes ₹9 Crore Award Against Karnataka Education Department Over Limitation Dispute

Supreme Court Sends Firm Message to Tribunals: Its ‘Requests’ Must Be Treated as Directions

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has drawn a clear line for courts and tribunals, declaring that any request made by the country’s highest court must be treated as a binding direction. Failure to comply, it warned, will invite serious scrutiny.

The observation came while a bench of Justices JB Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran examined the conduct of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT), which had failed to hear an appeal despite a specific request from the Supreme Court.

The matter arose in Sona Bansal v. Vashisht Kumar Goyal & Ors., a dispute linked to insolvency proceedings.

Supreme Court questions NCLAT’s delay

On July 15, the Supreme Court had made an earnest request to the NCLAT to hear the appeal on July 23. The request followed submissions that the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) had already reserved its order on an insolvency petition filed under Section 7 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC).

Despite that intervention, the appeal remained unheard.

When the matter returned to the Supreme Court on October 27, senior advocates Kapil Sibal and Meenakshi Arora, appearing for the applicant, informed the bench that the NCLAT had still not taken up the appeal.

In the meantime, the NCLT had delivered its reserved order and admitted the company into insolvency, adding urgency to the dispute.

The bench expressed its displeasure over the appellate tribunal’s handling of the matter, questioning why the Supreme Court’s earlier request had not been acted upon.

‘A request must be construed as a direction’

The Court used the occasion to clarify how its communications to other judicial forums should be understood.

It said that when the Supreme Court requests a court or tribunal to take a particular step, the communication cannot be dismissed as a mere appeal for cooperation. It must be understood as a direction, and any failure to comply will be examined seriously.

The bench also explained that such requests are made out of institutional respect and deference to the judicial office concerned, not because the Supreme Court lacks the authority to issue directions.

The remarks carry a broader message for judicial bodies: the language of a request should not obscure the obligation to act when the Supreme Court has specifically called for a matter to be addressed.

NCLAT asked to explain the delay

Taking the matter forward, the Supreme Court issued notice returnable on November 19 and directed the NCLAT to submit an explanation for its failure to hear the appeal despite the earlier intervention.

The tribunal has been asked to account for why the matter remained pending after the Supreme Court had specifically called for it to be heard.

Meanwhile, the bench ordered that the Committee of Creditors (CoC) must not be constituted under the ongoing insolvency proceedings until further orders.

The interim protection is significant because the NCLT’s admission of the company into insolvency had already moved the dispute into a consequential stage.

The proceedings will now return to the Supreme Court for further consideration, with the NCLAT’s explanation expected to address the delay and its failure to act on the earlier request.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Upholds ECL Finance’s Exclusion From Creditors’ Committee

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court on 27 October 2026 upheld the exclusion of ECL Finance and its debenture trustee from Palm Developers’ committee of creditors because their contractual rights involved participation in the debtor’s policymaking.

Judge / Bench — J.B. Pardiwala and K. Vinod Chandran, JJ.; judgment by K. Vinod Chandran, J.

In ECL Finance Ltd. v. Abhinav Mukherjee, 2026 INSC 1159, the Court distinguished the stricter control test governing resolution applicants. A role in guiding policy suffices for the related-party restriction on creditor participation.

The financing documents conferred extensive rights over directors, budgets, management and sales. The Court also rejected a recent debt assignment as an attempt to avoid the restriction. Both appeals were dismissed and the contempt petitions closed.

Advocates appearing — Appellants: Gaurav Mitra, Senior Counsel. Respondents: Jayant Mehta and Arijit Prasad, Senior Counsel.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Seeks Centre, Meta’s Response Over Blocking of ‘Bring Back Ballot’ Instagram Account

Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Delhi High Court has sought responses from the Central government and Meta Platforms over a petition challenging the restriction of the Instagram account Bring Back Ballot, which campaigned for a return to paper ballots in Indian elections.

Justice Amit Mahajan issued notice to the respondents on Wednesday and scheduled the next hearing for November 6.

The account was operated by advocate Mehmood Pracha and his organisation, Mission Save Constitution. The petitioners told the court that the account was blocked in India on October 10, coinciding with a protest calling for the replacement of electronic voting machines (EVMs) with paper ballots.

The organisation had planned to hold a demonstration at Jantar Mantar under the slogan “EVM Hatao Desh Bachao”.

Petition challenges lack of notice

According to the petition, the Instagram account was restricted without prior notice, an opportunity to be heard, an explanation of the decision or access to the order directing the block.

Users attempting to access the page were shown a message stating that it was unavailable in India because Instagram had complied with a legal request to restrict the account.

The petitioners said the account had more than 40,000 followers and served as a platform for sharing posters, videos and explanatory material supporting the return of paper ballots. It was also used to mobilise people for the planned demonstration.

Free speech at the centre of the dispute

The plea argues that the restriction imposed by the government and Meta infringes the petitioners’ fundamental rights under Article 19 of the Constitution, including freedom of speech and expression, peaceful assembly and association.

The challenge places the circumstances surrounding the account’s blocking, including the absence of a disclosed order and prior hearing, at the heart of the legal dispute.

The High Court will take up the matter again on November 6, when the responses of the government and Meta are expected to be addressed.

Read current report and source

MP High Court Rebukes Town Planning Official Over Inappropriate Video Hearing Appearance, Orders Disciplinary Action

Madhya Pradesh High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has taken a stern view of a senior town planning official’s appearance during a virtual court hearing, after he joined the proceedings from his bed wearing underpants while buttoning his shirt. The Court has directed the State government to initiate disciplinary action and asked the officer to explain why criminal contempt proceedings should not be launched against him.

The incident came up before Justice Deepak Khot during the hearing of GSB Construction v. Amit Kumar Gahbhiya, a dispute involving the correction of land-use records.

The officer, Amit Kumar Gajbhiye, Joint Director of Town and Country Planning in Bhopal, had been directed by the Court on October 9 to file a compliance report. He was also required to appear in person if the directions were not complied with.

During Tuesday’s hearing, the Court noticed that Gajbhiye had joined the morning session from his bed and was still buttoning his shirt. His attire and manner of appearing before the Court drew sharp criticism.

The Bench observed that the conduct fell well short of the standards expected during judicial proceedings, describing it as misconduct and contemptuous behaviour. The Court consequently called upon the State to take disciplinary action against the official and directed him to submit an explanation on why criminal contempt proceedings should not follow.

Appearing for the State, Deputy Advocate General Swapnil Ganguly assured the Court that he would raise the matter with senior government officials. The State has been directed to initiate appropriate action and submit a report within four weeks.

Land-use dispute also draws the Court’s ire

The virtual hearing controversy was only one part of the proceedings. The Court also expressed dissatisfaction with the way the authorities had handled GSB Construction’s request to correct the classification of its land.

According to the firm, the property had been recorded as industrial land even though the applicable Master Plan designated the area for residential use.

The company submitted that a recommendation to correct the relevant map and land classification had already been forwarded on October 3, 2025, by the Joint Director of Town and Country Planning at Jabalpur to the Joint Director (IT) at the Bhopal directorate.

However, instead of treating the request as a correction of existing records, the authorities processed it as an application seeking a change in land use.

The Court questioned this approach and criticised the manner in which the representation had been dealt with, observing that the order passed on the company’s request was “merely an eyewash.”

Fresh application ordered through ALPASS portal

To move the land-record dispute forward, the Court directed GSB Construction to submit a rectification application through the Automated Layout Process Approval and Scrutiny System (ALPASS) portal.

Gajbhiye has been instructed to facilitate the uploading and acceptance of the application within seven days. Once the application is uploaded, the competent authority must decide it within four weeks.

The directions place two matters under scrutiny: the officer’s conduct during the virtual hearing and the administration’s handling of the company’s land-record correction request.

The case is scheduled to be heard next on November 30.

Advocates Saket Upadhyay and Dinesh Kumar Upadhyay represented GSB Construction. Deputy Advocate General Swapnil Ganguly and advocate Akash Malpani appeared for the State.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Quashes ₹3.91 Crore Tax Demand Against Security Guard, Flags Failure to Probe PAN Misuse

Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees

A tax demand running into crores against a contractual security guard has drawn sharp criticism from the Delhi High Court, which found serious flaws in the assessment process and questioned how transactions worth nearly ₹50 crore were attributed to a man who claimed his PAN had been misused.

Setting aside the assessment, the Court made it clear that revenue collection cannot come at the cost of basic scrutiny and fairness.

The case concerned Lalit, who worked as a contractual security guard and cook at Delhi’s Ashoka Hotel and Vigyan Bhawan between 2015 and 2019. According to his submissions, he had obtained a Permanent Account Number (PAN) primarily as an identity document and had no taxable income that could explain transactions of such magnitude.

The dispute surfaced in February 2024, when Lalit received an income tax notice linking his PAN to transactions involving Montage Enterprises Private Limited, a company dealing in packaging materials.

The notice cited cash payments of ₹24.86 crore and cash sales of ₹24.62 crore. Lalit denied having any connection with the transactions and approached the police and cybercrime authorities, alleging that his identity had been misused.

His explanation, however, did not prevent the tax authorities from raising a demand of approximately ₹3.91 crore.

Court questions the basis of the assessment

A division bench comprising Justices Dinesh Mehta and Aditi Choudhary found the assessment process deeply problematic. The Assessing Officer had combined the two transaction figures, treating ₹49.48 crore as Lalit’s turnover and calculating taxable income at 8%.

The Court pointed out that the approach effectively counted the same transaction twice, including both the gross amount and the amount remaining after tax collection. It also found that the officer had failed to conduct an independent inquiry to establish any link between Lalit and Montage Enterprises.

The bench expressed strong displeasure at the lack of basic examination of the transactions, observing that the officer appeared either not to have understood their accounting implications or not to have made an effort to understand them.

For the Court, the issue went beyond a questionable calculation. The assessment had proceeded without adequately addressing the central allegation: that Lalit’s PAN may have been used by someone else.

Financial circumstances could not be ignored

The Court also considered Lalit’s financial circumstances while examining the impact of the demand.

He had submitted bank statements and explained that he had withdrawn provident fund savings to meet his expenses. He had also obtained an Economically Weaker Section (EWS) certificate and sought a school fee waiver for his children.

These details, the bench indicated, called for careful and objective examination rather than an assessment based on the transaction figures alone.

The Income Tax Department argued that Lalit should pursue the statutory appellate remedy. The Court declined to accept that argument as a sufficient answer in the circumstances.

It noted that obtaining interim protection through the usual process could require a deposit of 20% of the disputed demand — nearly ₹78 lakh in this case. For someone in Lalit’s financial position, that requirement itself could present a formidable obstacle.

Revenue targets cannot replace fair assessment

The bench also highlighted the wider implications of imposing an enormous tax liability on a financially vulnerable individual without adequately establishing his connection to the underlying transactions.

Such action, it observed, could affect a person’s mental and emotional well-being and raise concerns under Articles 14 and 21 of the Constitution, which protect equality before the law and life and personal liberty.

The Court emphasised that tax officials must remain alert to possible fraud while grounding their decisions in verifiable facts. Meeting revenue targets, it made clear, does not excuse a failure to examine the reality of an individual case.

Assessment order set aside

The Delhi High Court accordingly quashed the assessment order dated March 17, 2025, which had resulted in the ₹3.91 crore demand against Lalit.

The relief does not permanently close the matter. The Court left the door open for fresh proceedings if credible evidence establishing Lalit’s connection with the transactions emerges, provided such action remains within the applicable statutory limitation period.

The ruling reinforces an important principle: when a tax assessment rests on transactions allegedly linked to a taxpayer’s identity, the authorities must examine the evidence and address credible claims of identity misuse before imposing a substantial liability.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Signals Contempt, Disciplinary Action Over Lawyers’ Courtroom Protest

Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Allahabad High Court has signalled possible contempt proceedings and professional disciplinary action against advocates who allegedly disrupted court proceedings by shouting slogans and damaging furniture during a protest on the court premises.

The incident came to the fore on Wednesday when Justice Arun Kumar Singh Deshwal, while hearing a bail application in Devendra Kumar v. State of UP, heard slogans and commotion in the corridors outside his courtroom.

The protesting lawyers were reportedly expressing anger over the alleged mistreatment of an advocate by Justice Ajay Bhanot. During the demonstration, some lawyers allegedly damaged furniture and other items inside Courtroom No. 49, where Justice Bhanot was presiding.

The disturbance soon drew the attention of Justice Deshwal, who was informed that the lawyers had gathered to protest the alleged treatment of their colleague. The judge took a stern view of the disruption, noting that the protest was interfering with the functioning of other courts.

In its observations, the Court stressed that litigants approach the High Court seeking justice and should not be made to suffer because of disagreements involving individual members of the Bar and a particular judge.

The bench made it clear that grievances against a judge could not justify shouting slogans, obstructing proceedings or using language intended to intimidate the Court. It described the conduct as wholly unjustified and contemptuous.

CCTV footage to be examined

Taking the matter further, Justice Deshwal directed the Registrar (Protocol) to examine CCTV footage of the area outside the courtroom and identify the advocates allegedly involved in the sloganeering.

Once their identities are established, the matter is to be referred to the Bar Council of Uttar Pradesh for consideration of disciplinary proceedings. The Court also indicated that contempt proceedings should be initiated against those found responsible.

The direction places the focus on identifying the individuals involved before any further action is pursued.

The matter is scheduled to come up again before the Court on November 19.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Won’t Drop Neighbours’ Criminal Cases Over Garbage Row That Turned Violent

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Court says a dispute over waste disposal in a Bengaluru apartment complex must be resolved through legal proceedings, not physical confrontation.

A disagreement over garbage in a shared corridor has landed two neighbouring couples in criminal proceedings, with the Karnataka High Court declining to close the cases before trial and reminding residents that everyday disputes must not descend into violence.

Justice Suraj Govindaraj dismissed petitions seeking to quash cross-cases filed by Chandrashekhar Gupta and his wife, Neha Gupta, and their neighbours, Anant Gopal and Swathi Sharma. The ruling, delivered on October 5, arose from an altercation at Bren Woods Apartments in Bengaluru’s Electronic City, Phase 2.

At the heart of the dispute was a familiar problem in apartment living: garbage allegedly being left in a common area.

A complaint over rubbish spirals into a fight

According to Swathi Sharma’s complaint, tensions began when she and her husband objected to the Guptas allegedly dumping garbage in the common corridor. The issue was reportedly raised through the residents’ association’s complaint register and the MyGate application.

The complaint alleged that the disagreement subsequently turned abusive. Swathi further accused Neha Gupta of smashing her mobile phone and behaving aggressively, while Chandrashekhar Gupta was alleged to have assaulted Anant Gopal when he intervened.

The Guptas disputed this account through a counter-complaint filed on February 18, 2024.

Neha Gupta alleged that Anant Gopal insulted her husband over the garbage issue as he was leaving for work. She claimed that the confrontation escalated when Swathi Sharma approached her, eventually leading to a physical altercation.

Her complaint alleged that Anant Gopal dragged Chandrashekhar Gupta aside, pinned him to the ground and repeatedly punched him near the left eye. The alleged assault reportedly left him with a deep cut and fractures to his nasal bones.

Both sets of allegations arose from the same incident on February 16, 2024, and led to cross-cases being registered at Bengaluru’s Parappana Agrahara police station.

Why the Court refused to intervene

The High Court found that the rival complaints, when considered alongside the medical records, prima facie indicated that a physical confrontation had taken place and that injuries had been sustained.

However, deciding who started the altercation, what each person did and how the injuries occurred would require a closer examination of the evidence.

Those questions, the Court held, could not be conclusively determined at the pre-trial stage. The allegations and supporting material would have to be assessed by the competent trial court in accordance with the law.

Finding no sufficient grounds to terminate the proceedings, the High Court refused to quash the criminal cases.

The decision does not determine the guilt of either couple. Instead, it leaves the competing claims to be examined through the judicial process.

‘Love thy neighbour’ is more than a saying

Beyond the legal question, the Court used the dispute to underline a basic principle of community living: disagreements between neighbours cannot justify physical aggression.

Invoking the familiar expression “Love thy neighbour”, Justice Suraj Govindaraj stressed that violence is never an acceptable way to settle a neighbourhood dispute.

The Court’s observation was not a demand that neighbours agree on everything or give up their legitimate rights. Rather, it called for civility, tolerance, mutual consideration and a willingness to address differences without unnecessary confrontation.

Garbage disposal, parking, noise and the use of shared spaces may appear to be minor issues in isolation. In close-knit residential settings, however, such disagreements can quickly become personal when frustration gives way to hostility.

The Court cautioned against allowing these everyday irritations to become battles of ego, particularly when the people involved are likely to continue living next door to one another for years.

Its message was straightforward: peaceful coexistence does not depend on eliminating disagreements, but on handling them without aggression or violence.

The petitions were therefore dismissed, leaving the criminal proceedings to continue before the appropriate court.

Read current report and source

Bengaluru Court Quashes ₹9 Crore Award Against Karnataka Education Department Over Limitation Dispute

Himachal Pradesh High Court · Sheikh Rayees

A Bengaluru commercial court has overturned an arbitral award exceeding ₹9 crore against Karnataka’s Department of State Education Research and Training (DSERT), holding that the arbitrator failed to address a crucial question: whether the contractor’s claims were filed within the legally prescribed time limit.

The ruling came in a dispute between DSERT and Puthur Infotech over payments for maintaining computer-related equipment in government and aided high schools across Karnataka.

The court found that the arbitrator’s failure to examine the State’s limitation defence amounted to patent illegality, striking at the foundation of the award.

“The omission to record a finding on limitation is a fundamental defect which goes to the root of the matter,” the court observed, noting that a key defence raised by the government had effectively gone unanswered.

How the dispute began

The matter traces back to a 2013 tender floated by DSERT for maintaining UPS systems, printers and LCD projectors in 4,396 schools — 1,763 government high schools and 2,633 aided high schools.

Puthur Infotech won the contract worth ₹7.19 crore, covering the period from April 2014 to April 2015.

Although the government released ₹5.07 crore, the company maintained that a substantial portion of its dues remained unpaid despite fulfilling its contractual responsibilities. After attempts at conciliation failed, the dispute was referred to arbitration through the Micro and Small Enterprises Facilitation Council.

In May 2023, the sole arbitrator, former Himachal Pradesh High Court Chief Justice L Narayana Swamy, directed the department to pay ₹7.75 crore, inclusive of interest, along with a further ₹1.27 crore and interest. The award also rejected the government’s counterclaim of ₹4.34 crore over alleged shortcomings in the services provided.

Court finds limitation defence was overlooked

The Karnataka government challenged the award, arguing that 16 of the 17 invoices relied upon by Puthur Infotech were already time-barred when the company initiated proceedings in 2018.

The commercial court accepted the objection. It noted that the payment deadlines for those invoices had passed more than three years before the company approached the Facilitation Council.

The court also rejected the contractor’s argument that repeated assurances from government officials had extended the limitation period.

In the court’s view, the arbitrator could not disregard the limitation issue and still uphold the claims without determining whether they were legally maintainable.

Government’s counterclaim also wrongly rejected

The court identified a separate flaw in the arbitral award concerning the State’s counterclaim.

The arbitrator had rejected the government’s demand for ₹4.34 crore on the ground that DSERT had not independently approached the MSME Facilitation Council. The commercial court disagreed, clarifying that a buyer need not initiate separate proceedings before the Council merely to raise a counterclaim in arbitration.

With the award combining claims that were time-barred with others that might have been maintainable, and without identifying the amounts attributable to each, the court concluded that the entire award had to go.

The arbitral award was therefore set aside in full, removing the direction requiring DSERT to pay Puthur Infotech more than ₹9 crore.

The judgment underscores the importance of addressing limitation objections and other substantive defences when deciding contractual disputes through arbitration.

Read current report and source