Saved newspaper
4 Nov 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 11 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Supreme Court Expunges Remarks Against Police Officer, Preserves Detention Quashing
- Supreme Court Sustains Bigamy Case Despite Foreign Divorce Decree
- Supreme Court Directs Centre To Set Up Special Cell For Strict Enforcement Of Child Labour Law
- Gold Possession Limits Cannot Shield Public Servants In Disproportionate Assets Cases: Supreme Court
- Delhi High Court Rejects RTI Direction To Create Judgment-Delay Data
- Allahabad High Court Rejects Limitation Objection In Domestic-Violence Proceedings
- Allahabad High Court Restores Promotion Challenge For Verified Qualification Review
- Karnataka High Court Strikes Down Land Panel Created to Rehabilitate Defeated Congress Leader
- Gujarat High Court Calls for Greater Representation of Women, Technical Experts in Arbitration
- Karnataka High Court Draws the Line: Police Stations Cannot Become Courts for Civil Disputes
- Karnataka High Court Scraps Case Over ‘Pakistan Zindabad’ Slogan at BJP Protest
Supreme Court Expunges Remarks Against Police Officer, Preserves Detention Quashing
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court on 2 November 2026 expunged adverse remarks against IPS officer A. Arun after accepting his unconditional apology. The detention-quashing decision remains intact.
Judge / Bench — Vikram Nath, R. Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh, JJ.; judgment by Vikram Nath, J.
In the appeal arising from SLP(Crl.) 16725/2026 (2026 INSC 1186), the Court removed the High Court’s remarks in paragraphs 6, 8, 10 and 19–23. It cautioned that an apology cannot substitute for due care when exercising powers affecting personal liberty.
Advocates appearing — Appellant: Sidharth Luthra, Senior Counsel; respondent 1: Vairawan A.S.; respondents 2–5: Prashanto Chandra Sen, Additional Advocate General.
Read current report and source
Supreme Court Sustains Bigamy Case Despite Foreign Divorce Decree
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court on 3 November 2026 refused to quash a husband’s bigamy prosecution based on a British divorce decree, while clearing his parents and second wife.
Judge / Bench — Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar, JJ.; judgment by Prashant Kumar Mishra, J.
In Criminal Appeals 5187–5189/2026 (2026 INSC 1191), the Court held that the foreign decree did not automatically dissolve the subsisting Indian marriage. A later nationality change did not defeat its legal consequences. However, criminal liability required individual evidence of knowing participation; relationship or cohabitation alone did not establish conspiracy. The husband’s case must proceed without treating these preliminary findings as a final merits determination.
Advocates appearing — Appellants, respondent State and first wife: Not named in the judgment.
Read current report and source
Supreme Court Directs Centre To Set Up Special Cell For Strict Enforcement Of Child Labour Law
Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Supreme Court has directed the Union government to establish a dedicated monitoring mechanism to ensure the effective implementation of the Child and Adolescent Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Act, 1986, as amended in 2016.
A bench comprising Justice SVN Bhatti and Justice NV Anjaria instructed the Secretary of the Ministry of Women and Child Development to constitute a special cell tasked with monitoring compliance with the legislation. The Centre has also been directed to communicate necessary instructions to enforcement agencies through the Chief Secretaries of the respective States. The directions came while the Court was considering a writ petition challenging provisions of the 1986 Act, particularly Section 3, which initially restricted the employment of children only in certain hazardous occupations.
2016 Amendment Changes Scope Of Child Labour Prohibition
The petition questioned the legal framework governing child labour. However, the Court noted that the 2016 amendment had substantially altered the position of law. The amendment introduced a comprehensive prohibition on employing children below the age of 14 in all occupations and processes, subject to limited statutory exceptions. Under the amended provisions, children are permitted to assist in non-hazardous family enterprises after school hours or during vacations, provided the prescribed statutory conditions are fulfilled. In view of these legislative changes, the bench observed that the reliefs sought in the petition no longer required judicial consideration. However, the Court stressed that the amended law must be implemented effectively, with the authorities bearing responsibility for ensuring strict compliance.
Centre Asked To Ensure Effective Enforcement Across States
While disposing of the petition, the Supreme Court underscored that the legislative changes introduced through the Child and Adolescent Labour (Prohibition and Regulation) Amendment Act, 2016, must translate into effective protection for children and adolescents. The bench observed: "We take note of the writ prayers, the orders passed by this Court and also the amendment to the parent Act. We are of the view that the prayer, as made, in the writ petition does not survive for further consideration but what remains to be taken note of is giving complete and full effect to the changes introduced by way of amendment Act No. 35 of 2016." The Court further stated that strict implementation of the amended legislation was the responsibility of the concerned authorities. Emphasising the need to safeguard the rights of children and adolescents, the bench directed the Ministry of Women and Child Development to establish a special cell, continuously monitor the enforcement of the Act and issue appropriate directions to enforcement agencies through the Chief Secretaries of the States. The petition was accordingly disposed of, with the Court declining to examine the original prayers in light of the changes brought about by the 2016 amendment. The focus now shifts to ensuring that the amended law is enforced in practice and that the statutory safeguards against child labour are fully implemented.
Read current report and source
Gold Possession Limits Cannot Shield Public Servants In Disproportionate Assets Cases: Supreme Court
Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Supreme Court has clarified that government circulars prescribing permissible gold possession limits cannot, by themselves, serve as an explanation for gold jewellery recovered or found in a disproportionate assets investigation involving a public servant. The Court stressed that being legally permitted to possess gold and accounting for its source are two entirely different matters. Simply relying on Income Tax Department guidelines or government press releases does not establish that the gold was acquired through legitimate income. A bench comprising Justice KV Viswanathan and Justice Arun Palli set aside a Patna High Court judgment that had quashed corruption proceedings against a former Child Development Project Officer accused of possessing assets disproportionate to her known sources of income under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.
Patna High Court Relied On Permissible Gold Limits
The High Court had relied on Instruction No. 1916 dated May 11, 1994, along with a press release issued by the Ministry of Finance on December 1, 2016. These guidelines indicate permissible gold possession limits of 500 grams for a married woman, 250 grams for an unmarried woman and 100 grams for a male. In the case under consideration, the gold jewellery held by the accused public servant and her unmarried daughter weighed 646.400 grams. Since the quantity fell within the limits prescribed under the government guidelines, the High Court concluded that the possession of gold could not justify prosecution under the anti-corruption law. The State challenged this reasoning before the Supreme Court, arguing that the circulars had no bearing on whether the accused possessed assets beyond her known sources of income.
Supreme Court Draws A Clear Distinction
Accepting the State's contention, the Supreme Court held that the High Court had adopted an untenable approach while quashing the proceedings. The bench observed that in a prosecution under Sections 13(1)(e) and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, the accused is required to explain allegations concerning assets disproportionate to known sources of income. The Court made it clear that merely producing government circulars or press releases permitting possession of gold up to a specified quantity does not amount to accounting for the assets. The guidelines may indicate the extent of gold a person is permitted to hold, but they do not establish how that gold was acquired or whether its value can be reconciled with the person's known income.
Prosecution Proceedings Restored
Finding the High Court's reasoning legally unsustainable, the Supreme Court allowed the State's appeal and restored the disproportionate assets prosecution against the former government officer. The ruling reinforces an important distinction in corruption investigations: permissible possession does not automatically establish a legitimate source of acquisition. An accused public servant cannot rely solely on prescribed gold limits to avoid explaining the assets under scrutiny.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court Rejects RTI Direction To Create Judgment-Delay Data
Delhi High Court · Editorial Team
The Delhi High Court on 29 October 2026 set aside an information commission direction requiring its Public Information Officer to supply a compilation of delayed judgments that was not maintained.
Judge / Bench — Amit Mahajan, J., authoring judge.
In W.P.(C) 7340/2011 (2026:DHC:9686), the Court held that the RTI Act provides access to existing information; it does not require creating or collating unavailable records. Confidential monthly lists sent to the Chief Justice did not establish that judge-wise historical data was preserved. Public interest could not supply that missing factual basis.
Advocates appearing — Petitioner: Priyam Mehta, Advocate. Respondent P.D. Gupta: None appeared.
Read current report and source
Allahabad High Court Rejects Limitation Objection In Domestic-Violence Proceedings
Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team
The Allahabad High Court on 30 October 2026 rejected a husband’s limitation objection to domestic-violence relief proceedings and urged courts to endeavour to conclude pending matters, including execution, within 60 days.
Judge / Bench — Praveen Kumar Giri, J., authoring judge.
In Criminal Revision 6433/2026 (2026:AHC:225827), Section 468 Cr.P.C. did not bar an application seeking statutory relief under Section 12 of the Domestic Violence Act. Filing that application is not an offence; breach of a protection order is treated separately. The revision was dismissed, leaving the challenged orders undisturbed.
Advocates appearing — Revisionist: Anand Mohan Pandey and Krishan Mohan Pandey; State: Pankaj Kumar, Additional Government Advocate; opposite party 2: Not named in the order.
Read current report and source
Allahabad High Court Restores Promotion Challenge For Verified Qualification Review
Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team
The Allahabad High Court on 28 October 2026 partly restored Ashok Kumar’s promotion challenge for fresh consideration, preserving the existing officiating arrangement.
Judge / Bench — Shekhar B. Saraf and Abdhesh Kumar Chaudhary, JJ.; judgment by Abdhesh Kumar Chaudhary, J.
Special Appeal 20/2026 (2026:AHC-LKO:77650-DB) requires verified qualification evidence. The promotion-committee direction remains intact; fresh disposal was requested preferably within two months.
Advocates appearing — Appellant: Gaurav Mehrotra, Senior Advocate, assisted by Abhineet Jaiswal and Saurabh Pandey; Harsh Vardhan Mehrotra (caption). Respondents 1–3: Sudip Kumar, Additional Advocate General, assisted by Anand Singh, Standing Counsel. Respondent 4: J.N. Mathur, Senior Advocate, assisted by Apoorva Tewari, Shobhit Mohan Shukla and Akriti Agarwal. Respondents (caption; allocation unstated): C.S.C. (not named), Aditya Kumar Tiwari, Anoop Kumar, Sangini Jha and Vijai Kumar Shukla.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court Strikes Down Land Panel Created to Rehabilitate Defeated Congress Leader
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
Court says public appointments cannot become political rewards, quashes additional land regularisation committee in Byndoor and directs Karnataka government to frame transparent appointment guidelines. The Karnataka High Court has delivered a sharp rebuke to the State government over the creation of an additional land regularisation committee in Byndoor, observing that public offices cannot be used to restore the political fortunes of leaders who have lost elections. Setting aside the committee headed by Congress leader K Gopal Poojary, the Court remarked that public authority must serve administrative needs rather than provide a route back to political power. “A public office cannot be treated as a consolation prize for a defeated politician, nor can it be converted into a reward for political loyalty,” the Division Bench of Justices DK Singh and H Shanthi Bhushan observed. The ruling came in Gururaj Gantihole v State of Karnataka, a case concerning the constitution of an additional land regularisation committee under Section 94-A(2-A) of the Karnataka Land Revenue Act, 1964.
Court questions the purpose behind the additional committee
The dispute arose after BJP MLA Gururaj Gantihole, who won the 2023 Assembly election from Byndoor, was appointed Chairman of the principal land regularisation committee constituted under Section 94-A of the Act. The Karnataka government subsequently created another committee under Section 94-A(2-A), appointing Congress leader K Gopal Poojary as its Chairman. Applications seeking land regularisation were then divided between the two committees. Gantihole challenged the government's decision, arguing that the additional committee had no genuine administrative justification and was intended to dilute his authority as the head of the principal committee. Poojary, who had lost the 2023 Assembly election, maintained that electoral defeat did not disqualify him from being appointed to the position. The State government defended the move, claiming that the additional committee was necessary to ensure the speedy disposal of a large number of pending land regularisation applications. A single-judge Bench had earlier accepted the government's explanation and declined to interfere. Gantihole subsequently approached the Division Bench.
Political requests cannot justify creation of public offices
The Division Bench found that the government had failed to demonstrate that it had independently assessed the need for an additional committee before issuing the notification. The judges noted that the committee appeared to have been constituted following requests made by Poojary after his electoral defeat. The government had also adopted the names of the members proposed by him. The Court expressed concern that such arrangements could allow political figures to regain positions of influence through indirect means. It observed that personal requests, political influence or the desire to rehabilitate a leader who has lost electoral ground cannot, on their own, justify the creation of an additional public position. “The desire of an individual to cling on to power cannot be permitted to dictate the course of public administration,” the Bench said. It added that government decisions must be guided by public interest and genuine administrative necessity, rather than attempts to accommodate individuals seeking to recover lost political influence.
Government's later explanation fails to satisfy the Court
A key issue before the Bench was the State government's claim that the additional committee had been set up to address the substantial backlog of land regularisation applications. The judges pointed out that the notification issued on December 4, 2023, did not mention any such backlog as the reason for establishing the committee. The explanation regarding pending applications appeared only in an affidavit filed in 2026, after Gantihole had challenged the constitution of the committee. The Court held that a subsequent affidavit could not retrospectively supply reasons that were absent when the original decision was taken. “An affidavit can disclose the position of the applications as on the date it was filed; it cannot establish what material was considered nearly three years earlier,” the Bench observed. It further noted that the State had failed to produce convincing material demonstrating that relevant considerations had been examined before the notification was issued.
Karnataka directed to frame appointment guidelines
The Division Bench ultimately quashed the notification constituting the additional land regularisation committee headed by Poojary. It also set aside the consequential notification through which land regularisation applications had been divided between the principal and additional committees. The Court additionally flagged the absence of clear guidelines governing the appointment of chairpersons to additional committees under the Karnataka Land Revenue Act. Directing the State government to formulate appropriate guidelines, the Bench said appointments must be based on objective considerations, including administrative ability, relevant experience, integrity and unimpeachable conduct. The guidelines, it said, should ensure that the discretion exercised under Rule 108-EE is fair, transparent and free from arbitrariness. The ruling reinforces the principle that the creation of public bodies and appointments to positions of authority must be backed by genuine administrative requirements, not political considerations. Senior Advocate Aruna M Shyam, along with advocate Shivani Shetty, appeared for Gantihole. Additional Advocate General I Tharanath Poojary and Additional Government Advocate SH Raghavendra represented the State and its officials. Advocate PD Surana appeared for K Gopal Poojary.
Read current report and source
Gujarat High Court Calls for Greater Representation of Women, Technical Experts in Arbitration
Gujarat High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Gujarat High Court has called for a broader and more inclusive pool of arbitrators, urging parties, legal professionals and arbitral institutions to consider more qualified women and technical experts for appointments. The Court made the observation while deciding two connected arbitration petitions in Shilpaben v. Jasmine, highlighting the continued under-representation of women and professionals with specialised technical knowledge in arbitration proceedings. Justice DN Ray referred to an October 2026 study by the Milon K Banerji Centre for Arbitration Law at NALSAR University of Law, Hyderabad, which analysed arbitrator appointments made in cases registered before the Supreme Court and the Delhi and Bombay High Courts during 2025. The study, titled Arbitrator Appointments in Numbers, revealed that women received only 29.97 per cent of the 2,283 appointments for which gender data was available. Technical experts, meanwhile, accounted for just 3.10 per cent of the appointments. Taking note of the findings, the High Court stressed that arbitration appointments should not remain confined to a narrow professional circle. “Without derogating from the primacy of competence, integrity and independence, this Court is of the considered view that such under-representation merits due attention,” the Court observed. It encouraged parties, counsel and arbitral institutions to expand the range of candidates considered for appointments, while ensuring that competence, integrity and independence remain the foremost considerations.
Technical expertise must find a place in arbitration
The Court also referred to Section 11(8) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The provision requires courts, while appointing arbitrators, to take into account the qualifications agreed upon by the parties and other considerations necessary to ensure the independence and impartiality of the appointee. The High Court relied on the Supreme Court's ruling in Voestalpine Schienen GmbH v. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation Ltd., which emphasised the need for broad-based arbitrator panels. The Supreme Court had made it clear that such panels should not be restricted to judges and lawyers but should also include engineers and other professionals. The Gujarat High Court noted that bringing technical experts into arbitration could be particularly useful in disputes involving specialised issues, where professional knowledge beyond conventional legal expertise may be necessary.
Dispute over partnership assets led to arbitration petitions
The observations arose from two connected petitions concerning disputes between partners of a business firm. In the principal petition, the legal heirs of Sanjay Pravinchandra Shah sought the appointment of an arbitrator to resolve differences with Jasmin Pravinchandra Shah over the affairs and assets of their partnership firm, Corus Metal. The petitioners stated that the firm was established in June 2020, with both partners holding equal shares. They alleged that the respondent had sold land belonging to the partnership for ₹1.81 crore without paying the deceased partner his 50 per cent share of the sale proceeds. Following Sanjay Shah's death in December 2025, his legal heirs sought the settlement of the firm's accounts and distribution of its assets. The dispute also involved capital amounting to ₹74.73 lakh. The respondent opposed the appointment of an arbitrator, raising the defence of accord and satisfaction. The High Court, however, rejected the objection by relying on the Supreme Court's decision in SBI General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Krish Spinning. With the parties subsequently agreeing to the appointment of an appropriate arbitrator through the Gujarat High Court Arbitration Centre, the Court allowed the petitions. It appointed former Gujarat High Court judge Justice Mauna M Bhatt as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes under the Arbitration Centre (Domestic and International), High Court of Gujarat Rules, 2021. The Court's observations on diversity and professional expertise underscore the importance of ensuring that arbitration appointments draw from a wider pool of qualified individuals, particularly in disputes where specialised knowledge can make a meaningful difference.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court Draws the Line: Police Stations Cannot Become Courts for Civil Disputes
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Karnataka High Court has made it clear that police stations cannot be turned into platforms for resolving private civil disputes, particularly those involving property, possession, contractual obligations or other civil claims.
Taking serious note of allegations that police personnel were intervening in disputes between private parties, a Division Bench of Justice DK Singh and Justice H Shanti Bhushan directed the registration of a suo motu public interest litigation (PIL) to examine the issue. The Bench stressed that police officers must operate strictly within the limits of their statutory powers and cannot assume the role of authorities deciding civil rights. “A police station cannot be converted into a forum for adjudication of civil rights or settlement of disputes relating to property, possession, contractual obligations or other civil claims,” the Court observed. The judges further underlined that such practices must stop immediately.
Court flags police interference in private disputes
The proceedings followed representations submitted by the Advocates' Association, Bengaluru (AAB) and the Karnataka State Bar Council (KSBC). The representations highlighted the recent murders of advocates Sriram V and Manjunath, along with an alleged attempt to murder Senior Advocate Venkataramanappa Sannakki. Among the concerns raised by the Advocates' Association was the alleged involvement of police personnel in civil disputes between private individuals. The High Court said the issue was serious and required judicial attention to prevent unlawful practices inside police stations. “The police personnel involving themselves in civil disputes between private parties is a serious issue and requires attention and direction to put an end to such illegal activities in the police station forthwith,” the Bench said.
Instructions and SOPs must be enforced, not merely circulated
The Court also questioned the apparent failure to implement directions and standard operating procedures (SOPs) issued by senior police authorities. The Bench observed that repeated instructions would serve little purpose if they remained confined to official documents without effective monitoring. It called for proper supervision to ensure compliance and appropriate action against officers who violate the prescribed rules. The judges emphasised that accountability must accompany administrative instructions, particularly when police personnel are allegedly stepping beyond their legal authority.
State asked to ensure police stations stay within their jurisdiction
The High Court said the State government and the Police Department must issue clear instructions prohibiting police stations from entertaining or settling civil disputes. The Bench clarified that police intervention would remain permissible where the facts disclose a criminal offence requiring action in accordance with law. “The State Government and the Police Department must ensure that all police stations are specifically instructed not to entertain or settle civil disputes between parties, except where any criminal offence requiring action in accordance with law is disclosed,” the Court stated. The Court said the strict enforcement of existing directions and SOPs against police interference in civil litigation would require further examination. The suo motu PIL will thus focus on ensuring that police stations do not become informal venues for settling private civil claims, while police authorities remain responsible for acting within the boundaries of their lawful powers.
Read current report and source
Karnataka High Court Scraps Case Over ‘Pakistan Zindabad’ Slogan at BJP Protest
Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Karnataka High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against a man accused of raising the controversial slogan ‘Pakistan Zindabad’ at a BJP-organised protest, observing that it was difficult to imagine participants at such a demonstration deliberately raising the slogan. Justice V Srishananda, while hearing a petition filed by DS Ravi Kumar, took note of the petitioner’s explanation that the words had been uttered inadvertently, with ‘Pakistan Murdabad’ being the intended slogan. The Court held that continuing the criminal case, in the circumstances, would serve no purpose and would amount to an abuse of the legal process.
How the Controversy Began
The matter originated from a demonstration held on December 18, 2022, by individuals described as BJP supporters in Mandya. According to the complaint, participants at the protest raised the slogan ‘Pakistan Zindabad’. The complainant, Kannambadi Kumar, claimed that watching a video of the incident had caused him mental distress, prompting him to approach the police. The Mandya West Police registered a case in 2024 under Sections 153B and 505(1)(b) of the Indian Penal Code, dealing with acts allegedly prejudicial to national integration and public mischief. DS Ravi Kumar, one of the accused, subsequently approached the High Court seeking to have the proceedings set aside.
Petitioner Says Slogan Was Raised by Mistake
Ravi Kumar’s counsel argued that the alleged slogan was not raised intentionally and that there was no attempt to provoke unrest or target any section of society. The petitioner maintained that during the heated exchange of slogans, ‘Zindabad’ had mistakenly replaced ‘Murdabad’. His counsel submitted that the alleged utterance did not reflect any intention to disturb public peace. The State opposed the petition, relying on a video clip submitted by the complainant. The prosecution contended that the footage clearly captured the slogan and alleged that Ravi Kumar had deliberately raised it to create social unrest. The State also submitted that the demonstration had been organised in response to an allegedly objectionable remark made by Pakistan’s Foreign Minister on December 18, 2022.
Court Questions the Prosecution's Case
The High Court found the petitioner’s explanation worthy of consideration, noting that deliberately raising a pro-Pakistan slogan at a BJP-organised protest appeared highly improbable. The Court also took into account the considerable delay in filing the complaint, which was lodged nearly two years after the demonstration. It further observed that the investigation had failed to establish who had participated in the protest or what consequences, if any, followed from the alleged slogan. The prosecution could not demonstrate that the incident had triggered unrest within any community or among the general public.
Missing Sanction and Legal Ingredients
The Court also examined the procedural requirements for prosecuting the accused under Section 505(1)(b) of the IPC. It noted that the Magistrate had taken cognizance of the offence without the requisite prior sanction. The Court additionally found that the essential ingredients of Section 153B were not established in the case. Considering these shortcomings, the High Court concluded that the criminal proceedings could not be allowed to continue. The petition was accordingly allowed, and the case against DS Ravi Kumar was quashed. The ruling was delivered in DS Ravi Kumar v. State of Karnataka.
Read current report and source