Suspended directors cannot claim unrestricted access to resolution plans during insolvency proceedings without also agreeing to keep commercially sensitive information confidential, the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) has held.
The ruling came in Mandava Prabhakar Rao v. Navneet Gupta, where Technical Member Naresh Salecha was called upon to resolve a disagreement between two members of an earlier NCLAT Bench.
Salecha held that a resolution professional is entitled to require members of a company’s erstwhile board to furnish a confidentiality undertaking before allowing them access to resolution plans and other sensitive material placed before the Committee of Creditors (CoC).
According to the tribunal, the statutory right of suspended directors to participate in the corporate insolvency resolution process (CIRP) does not exist separately from the obligation to preserve the confidentiality of information shared during the process.
Dispute over CoC meeting
The proceedings arose from the insolvency resolution of NSL Nagapatnam Power and Infratech Limited.
Mandava Prabhakar Rao, a suspended director of the company, had nominated Nelluri Bapuji to represent the suspended management at CoC meetings.
Bapuji had attended several earlier meetings. However, when the 20th CoC meeting was held on July 16, 2024, he was asked to leave after failing to submit written authorisation along with the required confidentiality undertaking.
The meeting was significant as resolution plans submitted for the company were being considered.
Rao challenged the decision, contending that excluding his representative prevented the suspended management from exercising its statutory right to participate in the CIRP and to access information necessary to place its views before the CoC.
The resolution professional, on the other hand, maintained that the material under consideration contained commercially sensitive information and that confidentiality safeguards were therefore necessary before access could be provided.
Earlier Bench delivered split verdict
The dispute was initially considered by a two-member NCLAT Bench comprising Justice Sharad Kumar Sharma and Technical Member Jatindranath Swain.
The members differed in their conclusions in November 2025.
Justice Sharma found no ground to interfere with the insolvency proceedings. Swain, however, took the view that preventing the suspended director’s representative from attending the 20th CoC meeting was impermissible and that the process should be reopened from that stage.
The disagreement resulted in the matter being referred to Naresh Salecha as the third member.
Salecha ultimately agreed with Justice Sharma and found no reason to disturb the 20th, 21st and 22nd CoC meetings.
He also declined to interfere with the resolution plan submitted by Rungta Mines.
Implemented resolution plan weighed with tribunal
The tribunal also took note of the fact that the resolution plan had already been implemented.
Rungta Mines had paid ₹176.83 crore, covering amounts under the resolution plan, CIRP expenses and the upfront payment.
Salecha observed that setting aside an approved and implemented resolution plan over a procedural objection, particularly where no substantive prejudice had been demonstrated, could have consequences extending well beyond the alleged irregularity.
The tribunal emphasised that such an outcome would also be inconsistent with the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code’s objective of ensuring timely resolution and preserving the value of distressed assets.
The tribunal also agreed that the costs imposed on Rao should be reduced to ₹2 lakh.
With the third member’s opinion now recorded, the matter will be placed before the appropriate NCLAT Bench for a final order in accordance with the majority view.