Setting aside the discharge order, the High Court held that the trial court had effectively conducted a premature mini-trial by examining defence arguments and weighing evidence before charges were framed.
The Calcutta High Court has revived criminal proceedings against a senior State Bank of India (SBI) manager accused of facilitating an alleged banking fraud involving more than ₹164.99 crore, holding that the trial court committed a serious legal error by discharging him without properly examining the incriminating material.
Justice Uday Kumar observed that the allegations against Jyoti Ranjan Kanungo, who served as Chief Manager and Relationship Manager at an SBI branch, disclosed serious grounds for proceeding with the trial.
The Court found that the available material raised strong suspicion of his involvement in criminal conspiracy, cheating, misuse of official position and alleged diversion of public funds.
It held that the trial court had exceeded the permissible limits of scrutiny at the stage of considering an application for discharge by effectively conducting a mini-trial.
The High Court noted that the lower court had prematurely evaluated defence explanations, overlooked important incriminating documents and failed to properly examine the alleged role of the bank official in the larger conspiracy.
Describing the discharge order as legally unsustainable, the Court set it aside and directed the trial court to restore the CBI case against Kanungo.
In its November 12 order, the High Court directed the trial court to proceed with framing formal charges against him under the applicable provisions of the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. His trial must take place jointly with the remaining accused.
The ruling came on a revision petition filed by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), which challenged the trial court’s decision to discharge Kanungo from the proceedings.
Allegations of ₹164.99 crore banking fraud
The case concerns an alleged financial fraud involving M/s Shree Mahalaxmi Corporation Private Limited (SMCPL), which is accused of fraudulently obtaining substantial credit facilities from SBI, causing an alleged loss of more than ₹164.99 crore to the bank.
According to the CBI, the alleged irregularities involved unauthorised accounts, unsupported transfers of funds between companies and the use of signed monthly reports to conceal substantial overdue amounts.
The investigating agency alleged that Kanungo played an active role in facilitating the company’s access to credit facilities and helping sustain the alleged fraudulent transactions.
During the proceedings before the High Court, CBI Special Public Prosecutor Amajit De relied on documentary records, audit trails and system logs to establish the alleged involvement of the bank official.
The CBI argued that the financial irregularities could not be dismissed as ordinary administrative mistakes, claiming that the material pointed towards deliberate assistance from an insider.
Manager denied conspiracy allegations
Kanungo opposed the CBI’s challenge, maintaining that he had neither any prior association nor any motive to enter into a conspiracy with the borrowing company.
His counsel argued that the credit assessments and restructuring proposals processed by him were carried out in accordance with established banking procedures.
It was further submitted that the relevant decisions were subject to supervision and approval by senior bank officials, including the Deputy General Manager, and were not taken independently by Kanungo.
The High Court, however, found that these defence explanations could not be subjected to an exhaustive examination at the pre-charge stage.
Justice Kumar observed that the trial court had improperly assessed witness statements, internal audit findings and departmental warnings while deciding whether the accused should face trial.
The Court emphasised that the purpose of examining a discharge application is not to conduct a detailed assessment of the entire evidence or determine the accused’s guilt before the trial begins.
Holding that the trial court had committed a fundamental jurisdictional error by undertaking an extensive evaluation of evidence under Section 239 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the High Court restored the proceedings against Kanungo.
The trial court has now been directed to frame charges and conduct the trial jointly with the other accused persons.
Kanungo was represented by advocates Aritra Bhattacharya, Saptarshi Basu and Suman Dutta.