The Court restrained Novex Communications from interfering with a wedding-related cocktail event and dinner, observing that the couple should not face embarrassment or disruption while celebrating their marriage.
A copyright dispute over music threatened to cast a shadow over a Chennai couple’s wedding celebrations, prompting them to seek urgent protection from the Madras High Court.
On November 5, Justice PB Balaji granted interim relief to the couple, restraining copyright licensing company Novex Communications Pvt Ltd and its representatives from disrupting their cocktail event and dinner scheduled for November 15 at Chennai’s Taj Connemara hotel.
The dispute began after Novex contacted the hotel on October 27, claiming that playing music at the proposed event would infringe its copyright. The company maintained that the organisers needed to obtain its permission and pay the applicable licence fee before using the music.
The couple, however, had already secured a No Objection Certificate (NOC) from the Indian Performing Right Society (IPRS) for the use of music licensed to it. They subsequently approached the High Court, challenging Novex’s demands and seeking a declaration that its copyright infringement threats were unjustified.
Their petition also sought a permanent restraint against the company issuing similar demands. As immediate relief, they requested an order preventing Novex or its representatives from entering the vicinity of the venue, approaching guests or taking any action that could interfere with the celebrations.
The couple argued that Section 52(1)(za) of the Copyright Act, 1957, exempts the use of copyrighted music during religious ceremonies and associated marriage festivities from copyright infringement. According to them, the cocktail gathering and dinner formed part of their wedding celebrations and therefore fell within this statutory exemption.
They further questioned how Novex could claim infringement without establishing which songs proposed to be played at the event were actually covered by its copyright repertoire. The couple also explained that an event management company had been engaged to organise the celebrations.
Court prioritises uninterrupted wedding celebrations
While considering the plea, the High Court observed that the broader question of whether playing songs licensed to Novex at the event would constitute copyright infringement could be examined during the subsequent hearing.
The Court also noted that if Novex ultimately established its entitlement to collect licence fees as a legitimate copyright holder, monetary compensation could be considered at a later stage.
However, allowing the company to interfere with the wedding celebrations in the meantime could expose the couple and their guests to unnecessary inconvenience and embarrassment.
Emphasising the possibility of disruption, the Court observed that the couple could suffer irreparable harm if the company arrived at the venue and created a disturbance in front of their guests.
Accordingly, it granted an interim injunction restraining Novex and its representatives from interfering with the cocktail event and dinner.
The interim protection does not settle the underlying copyright dispute. Whether Novex can legally demand licence fees for music played during the wedding-related celebrations remains to be decided.
The matter is scheduled for further hearing on December 3.