Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Calcutta High Court

Calcutta High Court Confirms Death Sentence in Brutal Rape and Murder of Five-Year-Old Girl

The Calcutta High Court has upheld the death sentence imposed on a man convicted of raping and murdering his five-year-old neighbour, ruling that the horrific nature of the crime places it firmly within the “rarest of rare” category.

A Division Bench of Justices Arijit Banerjee and Apurba Sinha Ray, while dismissing the convict Ashok Singh’s appeal in State of West Bengal v. Ashok Singh, observed that the brutality involved in the assault and the subsequent killing left no room to treat the case as an ordinary criminal offence.

The Court noted that Singh had sexually assaulted the child and later inflicted fatal injuries by repeatedly striking her head against a hard surface. According to the Bench, the extreme cruelty and depravity displayed in the crime justified the imposition of capital punishment.

The incident occurred on November 24, 2024. The child had reportedly gone to visit a neighbour but failed to return home for several hours. When her parents began looking for her, the neighbour informed them that she had already left.

A search involving local residents eventually led to Singh’s house, where the child was discovered unconscious, unclothed and bleeding. She was rushed to a hospital, but doctors declared her dead.

During the investigation, witnesses described seeing Singh approach the child as she was returning from a neighbour’s house. He allegedly persuaded her to accompany him by promising to give her chocolates.

Since Singh was familiar to the family and the child addressed him as ‘jethu’ (uncle), his conduct did not initially raise suspicion.

The investigation later produced forensic evidence linking Singh to the crime. A forensic examination detected his DNA on the victim’s body.

Singh denied the allegations, claiming that he had no knowledge of how the child’s body came to be inside his house.

The trial court convicted him of rape of a child below 12 years of age, aggravated sexual assault and murder. It also concluded that he had carefully monitored the child’s movements and chosen the timing of the crime to avoid attracting attention or being seen by others.

Finding the circumstances sufficiently grave to qualify as a ‘rarest of rare’ case, the trial court awarded him the death penalty.

Challenging the verdict before the High Court, Singh argued that the prosecution had built its case entirely on circumstantial evidence. His counsel maintained that the last-seen theory could not, by itself, establish guilt in the absence of direct eyewitness testimony.

The defence also questioned whether the prosecution had established that Singh was the only person inside the house when the crime occurred. It argued that fastening responsibility on him without conclusive evidence could result in a miscarriage of justice.

Opposing the appeal, Special Public Prosecutor Jayanta Narayan Chatterjee submitted that the witness accounts were consistent and supported one another. He also pointed out that Singh had failed to offer a convincing explanation for the child’s presence in his house.

The prosecution further relied on the forensic findings, particularly the recovery of Singh’s DNA from the victim’s body.

After examining the evidence, the High Court also considered whether a lesser punishment could serve the ends of justice.

The Bench took into account the medical and expert evidence indicating that Singh was mentally sound, fully aware of his actions and did not suffer from any mental or emotional disorder.

The Court also questioned his conduct during the proceedings, observing that he continued to project innocence despite the forensic evidence connecting him to the assault.

It noted that his ability to maintain a false account in his defence demonstrated that he could deliberately present himself as innocent.

The Bench was additionally informed that Singh had previously come under suspicion over allegations of inappropriate touching involving another five-year-old girl. Taking the overall circumstances into consideration, the Court concluded that there was no realistic possibility of his reformation.

Consequently, the High Court found no justification to interfere with the death sentence.

However, the Bench directed that the execution of the death penalty remain suspended for three months to allow Singh an opportunity to approach the Supreme Court.

The Court also expressed displeasure over the State’s failure to provide adequate compensation to the victim’s parents. It directed the authorities to pay them an enhanced compensation of ₹15 lakh within two months.

The matter has been listed for further hearing on January 30, 2027, to review compliance with the compensation direction.

Share this story