Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Madhya Pradesh High Court

AI-Generated Fake Supreme Court Judgment Triggers Strong Rebuke from Madhya Pradesh High Court

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has taken serious exception to the State government’s reliance on a non-existent Supreme Court judgment in its court submissions, observing that the fabricated legal precedent appeared to have been generated using an Artificial Intelligence (AI) tool.

Justice Vivek Kumar Singh criticised the State for filing pleadings containing an invented case name alongside an unrelated case citation. The Court described the manner in which the reply was prepared as careless and irresponsible, warning against such reckless use of AI in legal proceedings.

The issue arose in Piyush Mani Tiwari v. State of Madhya Pradesh, a case concerning the dismissal of a police officer from service.

In its reply, the State relied heavily on a purported Supreme Court decision titled State of Andhra Pradesh v. S.S. Mohammad Nisar, citing it as (2008) 5 SCC 230. The judgment was cited to support the argument that courts exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution cannot re-examine evidence.

However, the High Court discovered that no such Supreme Court judgment existed. The citation actually belonged to Sidhartha Vashisht @ Manu Sharma v. State (NCT of Delhi), a case dealing with the suspension of a sentence during a criminal appeal.

The Court observed that the mismatch strongly suggested that the State had blindly relied on AI-generated material without carrying out even basic verification.

Court warns against blindly relying on AI-generated legal material

Justice Singh emphasised that pleadings submitted before a Constitutional Court carry significant responsibility and cannot be treated as documents prepared through casual or unchecked methods.

The Bench pointed out that inserting fictitious judgments without verifying their existence wastes valuable judicial time and risks misleading the Court.

It specifically cautioned the State against repeating such practices and directed that a copy of the judgment be sent to the State Law Secretary and the Advocate General.

The Court also stressed that the Advocate General’s office must ensure that every legal proposition and judicial citation is properly checked by the drafting counsel before documents are sworn and submitted before the High Court.

Police officer’s dismissal also set aside

Apart from the issue of fabricated case law, the Court examined the legality of the petitioner’s dismissal from service.

Piyush Mani Tiwari was serving as an Acting Sub-Inspector at the State Situation Room, Special Branch, Police Headquarters, Bhopal, when he was dismissed in 2024.

The action followed a complaint by a woman working as a cleaner/sweeper, who accused him of inappropriate behaviour.

Tiwari challenged the dismissal on the ground that the State had removed him without conducting either a preliminary inquiry or a regular departmental investigation.

Defending its decision, the State invoked Article 311(1), read with Articles 311(2)(b) and 311(3) of the Constitution, to justify dispensing with a formal inquiry.

It argued that conducting an inquiry into a complaint involving a woman employee could prolong the matter, cause distress and trigger public outrage. The State also expressed concerns that witnesses could face intimidation and that immediate action was necessary to preserve discipline and public confidence in the police force.

The High Court found these explanations insufficient to justify bypassing the constitutional safeguards governing dismissal from public service.

In its November 17 judgment, the Court noted that there was no material on record demonstrating that Tiwari had threatened or intimidated the complainant or any other witness. There was also no evidence of an atmosphere of violence or insubordination that could have prevented witnesses from participating in an inquiry.

Consequently, the Court quashed the dismissal order and directed the State to reinstate Tiwari. It nevertheless permitted the government to initiate a regular departmental inquiry in accordance with the law.

Share this story