Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Bank of Baroda Pledges to Preserve Key Records in BR Shetty’s $15 Billion Legal Battle

Bank of Baroda has assured the Bombay High Court that it will preserve documents and records sought by former NMC Health founder Dr. Bavaguthu Raghuram Shetty in his $15 billion damages suit against the public sector bank.

Justice Arif S Doctor recorded the assurance on November 19 after Shetty sought urgent protection of documents that could be relevant to his allegations against the bank.

Senior Advocate Birendra Saraf, appearing for Bank of Baroda, told the Court that all documents listed in Shetty’s interim application and held or controlled by the bank would be preserved in their existing condition. The Court accepted the undertaking.

The dispute arises from Shetty’s allegations of fraud, collusion, negligence and reputational damage involving Bank of Baroda and former NMC executives Prasanth Manghat and Promoth Manghat.

In his suit, Shetty has alleged that the bank closed anti-money laundering alerts without conducting proper inquiries and facilitated financial round-tripping after he stepped down as NMC Health’s chief executive in March 2017.

Through interim applications, Shetty has sought forensic imaging of the bank’s electronic systems, disclosure of information on oath by the bank and ten of its officers, and suspension of existing data-deletion policies. He has also sought security or balance-sheet provisioning of $15 billion, equivalent to approximately ₹1.43 lakh crore.

During the hearing, Senior Advocate Zal Andhyarujina, representing Shetty, pressed for interim disclosure of documents identified in the applications. He submitted that even if the Court was not inclined to order immediate disclosure, the bank should at least be directed to preserve the material to prevent its alteration or destruction.

Opposing the request, Saraf argued that the documents were already part of proceedings before a court in Abu Dhabi and described Shetty’s apprehensions as baseless. He nevertheless gave the assurance regarding preservation of records in the bank’s custody or control.

Saraf also informed the High Court that Bank of Baroda had filed an application seeking deferment of the hearing. Referring to an earlier Abu Dhabi court judgment that held Shetty complicit in the healthcare fraud at the centre of the dispute, he questioned the basis of the Bombay High Court proceedings.

The bank further argued that the cause of action arose in 2020 and that Shetty’s suit was barred under Rule 89 of the Abu Dhabi Global Market (ADGM) Court of First Instance Court Procedure Rules, 2016.

Andhyarujina disputed the bank’s objections.

The Bombay High Court recorded the bank’s undertaking to preserve the documents but did not grant the requested disclosure at this stage.

The matter is scheduled to be heard next on December 17.

Share this story