Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Supreme Court

Benches May Change, the Law Does Not: Supreme Court Reasserts the Rule of Precedent

The Supreme Court has delivered a pointed reminder to constitutional courts: judicial consistency is not optional. In a ruling favouring Adani Power Ltd., the Court held that a coordinate bench cannot dilute or sidestep an earlier binding decision merely because the composition of the bench has changed.

The dispute arose from customs duty imposed on electricity supplied from a Special Economic Zone in Gujarat to the Domestic Tariff Area. In 2015, a division bench of the Gujarat High Court had struck down such a levy as unconstitutional. That verdict later received the Supreme Court’s imprimatur, sealing the issue in law.

Yet four years later, another division bench of the same High Court took a different route. Instead of applying the settled position, it limited the 2015 ruling to a specific notification and time period, refusing to extend its benefit to subsequent years. This move effectively reopened a question that had already been closed.

Adani Power carried the matter to the Supreme Court—and succeeded.

Allowing the appeal, a bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and N.V. Anjaria took sharp exception to the High Court’s approach. The judges stressed that precedent is not a matter of judicial convenience but an institutional discipline essential to the rule of law.

The Court underscored that if a later bench believes an earlier ruling is flawed or unsuitable for new circumstances, there is only one legitimate path: a reference to a larger bench. What is impermissible, the Court said, is an attempt to shrink, reinterpret, or quietly bypass a binding judgment.

Reiterating settled principles, the Court noted that once a coordinate bench has declared the law, another bench of equal strength is duty-bound to follow it when the same issue arises. Any departure, however well-intentioned, undermines certainty and predictability in the legal system.

Quoting earlier precedent, the Court warned that courts cannot treat binding rulings as case-specific indulgences or carve-outs to be narrowly confined. Stability in law, it said, demands fidelity to what has already been decided.

With these observations, the Supreme Court set aside the Gujarat High Court’s 2019 ruling and restored the benefit of the earlier decision to Adani Power.

The appeal was allowed.

Share this story