Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Bombay High Court Nullifies Bank of India’s Fraud Classification Against Kishore and Rakesh Biyani

The Bombay High Court has struck down Bank of India’s decision to brand industrialists Kishore Biyani and Rakesh Biyani as “fraud” under the Reserve Bank of India’s 2024 Fraud Risk Management framework, holding that the bank failed to justify its conclusion with a reasoned order.

A Division Bench comprising Justices B.P. Colabawalla and Firdosh P. Pooniwalla ruled that the impugned order did not satisfy the mandatory requirements laid down in the RBI’s Fraud Master Directions, as it lacked independent reasoning and failed to address the explanations placed before the bank.

The dispute arose after Bank of India, on June 21, 2025, classified the account of Future Lifestyle Fashions Ltd. (FLFL) as fraudulent. The decision also resulted in the names of the company’s promoters, Kishore and Rakesh Biyani, being tagged as “fraud.” The brothers challenged not only the classification order but also the preceding show-cause notice and the forensic audit report dated August 7, 2024. They further sought protection against any reporting of their names to the Central Fraud Registry.

FLFL had obtained credit facilities from Bank of India, with Kishore Biyani acting as guarantor. Following the account being declared a non-performing asset, the bank commissioned a forensic audit and initiated fraud proceedings through a show-cause notice, eventually culminating in the disputed order.

Before the High Court, the petitioners argued that the bank had merely reproduced extracts from the forensic audit report before concluding that fraud had occurred, without recording its own findings or explaining why the allegations stood established.

They also pointed out that the company’s Managing Director had submitted a comprehensive response to the show-cause notice, but the final order made no reference to those submissions. According to the petitioners, the forensic audit itself was not conclusive, and an addendum prepared following the intervention of another lending bank had reportedly cleared them of allegations relating to related-party transactions. They further contended that Bank of India had not undertaken the independent internal investigation contemplated under the RBI framework.

The bank defended its action by arguing that the promoters had not personally filed replies to the show-cause notice and therefore could not rely upon the Managing Director’s response. It also maintained that the forensic audit contained adequate reasons and that the bank was not required to reproduce those findings separately in its order.

The High Court was not persuaded by these submissions.

The Bench observed that the RBI’s 2024 Fraud Master Directions obligate banks to issue a speaking and reasoned order before classifying an account as fraud. In the present case, the order neither explained why the findings of fraud were reached nor dealt with the defence raised in response to the show-cause notice.

Holding that the decision failed to meet the standards prescribed by the RBI’s regulatory framework, the Court set aside the fraud classification order.

The Court also directed Bank of India to ensure that the names of Kishore and Rakesh Biyani are not reflected as “fraud” in the Central Fraud Registry.

At the same time, the Bench clarified that it had not examined the merits of the allegations themselves. It left all other issues open, allowing the bank to initiate fresh proceedings, provided they are conducted strictly in accordance with the RBI’s 2024 Fraud Master Directions.

Share this story