Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Kerala High Court

Common Ship Management Not Enough to Justify Vessel Arrest for Another Ship’s Unpaid Crew Wages: Kerala High Court

The Kerala High Court has ruled that a vessel cannot be detained to recover unpaid crew wages arising from employment on entirely different ships merely because all the vessels are managed by the same shipping company.

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar VM, in Light House Marine Service India Pvt Ltd v. Charter and Parties Interested in the Vessel MT Ocean Faye & Ors., held that arresting another vessel in such circumstances would require, at the very least, a prima facie showing of commonality of interest between the shipowners and a clear intention to defraud creditors.

The Bench made it clear that a common ship manager does not automatically establish common ownership. Managing multiple vessels and owning them are legally distinct relationships.

The ruling came while dismissing an appeal filed by Light House Marine Service India Pvt Ltd, a manning agency that had sought the arrest of MT Ocean Faye over unpaid crew wages relating to three other vessels managed by Star Voyages Shipping Services LLC.

Dispute arose over wages paid to crews of three vessels

Light House Marine Service claimed that it had paid the wages of crew members serving aboard MT Eastern Pearl, MT Fast Kathy and MT Sea Fidelity after Star Voyages allegedly failed to fulfil its contractual obligations.

According to the agency, the ship management company subsequently refused to reimburse the payments despite repeated demands.

Seeking to secure recovery of the amount, the agency approached the High Court for the arrest of MT Ocean Faye, another vessel managed by Star Voyages.

A single-judge Bench initially ordered the vessel’s arrest in May 2024. MT Ocean Faye was later released after security was furnished. However, parties interested in the vessel challenged the arrest, following which another single judge set aside the order. Light House Marine then approached the Division Bench.

Manning agent cannot claim rights of a shipowner

Before the Division Bench, the appellant relied on Sections 4(1)(o) and 4(1)(p), read with Section 5(2) of the Admiralty (Jurisdiction and Settlement of Maritime Claims) Act, 2017.

It argued that these provisions permitted the arrest of a vessel to secure maritime claims arising from obligations connected with other ships under the same management.

The respondents countered that the wage dispute concerned three separate vessels and that the appellant had no contractual relationship with MT Ocean Faye.

Accepting the respondents’ position, the High Court distinguished the legal standing of a manning agent from that of a bareboat or demise charterer.

The Bench observed that Light House Marine was merely a crew supplier operating under a contractual arrangement with the ship manager. Such an arrangement did not give it a legal position comparable to that of a charterer with rights connected to the vessel.

The Court emphasised that the appellant had failed to establish the essential ownership connection required to justify the arrest.

Section 5(2) cannot operate independently

The Bench also examined the scope of Section 5 of the 2017 Admiralty Act.

It clarified that Section 5(2), which permits the arrest of another vessel in specified circumstances, cannot be read in isolation from the conditions laid down under Section 5(1).

The Court found no established common ownership between MT Ocean Faye and the three vessels whose crews were involved in the wage dispute. It also noted that the owners of those three vessels had not even been impleaded in the proceedings.

More importantly, the agency’s claim arose from its contractual dealings with Star Voyages over reimbursement of crew wages. It had not demonstrated any independent legal entitlement against MT Ocean Faye.

The Bench concluded that a dispute between a crew-supplying agency and a ship management company cannot, by itself, become grounds for detaining an unrelated vessel simply because the same entity manages both.

Finding no legal justification for the arrest, the Kerala High Court upheld the decision setting it aside and dismissed the appeal.

Share this story