Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Delhi High Court Turns to RBI to Resolve PayU–Banks Dispute Over Merchant Codes

The Delhi High Court has brought the Reserve Bank of India into the middle of a payment-sector dispute involving PayU Payments, Yes Bank, ICICI Bank and Visa over the classification of merchants.

Justice Subramonium Prasad, in an order passed on September 14, directed the RBI to nominate a senior officer with expertise in the payments industry to facilitate discussions between the parties and attempt to settle the dispute within 30 days.

Until the mediation is completed, the Court directed the parties to maintain status quo with respect to the disputed past transactions.

The Court said RBI intervention was preferable to sending the parties through the usual pre-litigation mediation route, given that the payment framework involved in the dispute operates under certificates issued by, and regulatory oversight of, the central bank.

According to the Court, an RBI officer familiar with the payments ecosystem would be best placed to help the parties find a workable solution while ensuring that their regular business operations are not disrupted.

Dispute centres on merchant classification

At the heart of the case are Merchant Category Codes (MCCs), four-digit classifications used to identify a merchant’s principal line of business. The codes also play a role in determining the interchange fees applicable to transactions.

ICICI Bank, which issues Visa cards, alleged that certain merchants processed through PayU had been assigned incorrect MCCs. It claimed that the alleged misclassification resulted in lower interchange fees and consequently raised claims against acquiring banks through Visa’s Interchange Reimbursement Fee (IRF) mechanism.

PayU has disputed the claim, maintaining that it does not itself allocate MCCs to merchants.

The company said its role is limited to collecting and verifying information about a merchant’s business before passing that information to the acquiring bank. According to PayU, it is the acquiring bank that independently determines and assigns the appropriate MCC.

₹6.88 crore remains disputed

The dispute escalated after Yes Bank deducted amounts from PayU’s settlements towards alleged IRF liabilities.

Although Yes Bank subsequently reversed deductions amounting to more than ₹5.95 crore, PayU told the Court that approximately ₹6.88 crore continued to remain with the bank.

PayU also expressed concern that further deductions could follow in relation to outstanding IRF claims involving other acquiring banks.

The company has separately questioned Visa’s IRF mechanism, contending that disputes of this nature ought to be dealt with under the Payment and Settlement Systems Act, 2007.

The High Court, however, has not ruled on the underlying legal questions at this stage. Instead, it has opted to give the parties an opportunity to resolve the dispute with RBI’s assistance.

Restrictions during mediation

The Court directed that Visa should not issue final IRF determinations concerning the disputed past transactions while the mediation process is underway.

Similarly, the acquiring banks have been restrained from making additional deductions from PayU in relation to those disputed claims during the process.

At the same time, the Court clarified that its directions would not interfere with or alter the parties’ routine transactions carried out in the ordinary course of business.

The RBI-appointed officer is now expected to facilitate discussions between the parties and attempt to bring the long-running disagreement over merchant classifications and related payment liabilities to a resolution within the prescribed 30-day period.

Share this story