Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Madras High Court

Madras High Court frees man jailed for 25 days over social media post targeting CM Vijay

The Court found that the accused had been wrongly denied bail three times despite facing only bailable charges, and ordered its judgment to be circulated among judicial officers in Tamil Nadu and Puducherry.

The Madras High Court has granted bail to a man who spent 25 days in prison over allegedly offensive social media remarks directed at Tamil Nadu Chief Minister Vijay, despite the offences registered against him being bailable.

Justice N Ramesh, while hearing the case titled Raja Gopal Vs State, held that three earlier orders rejecting the man’s bail applications were legally unsustainable.

The Court observed that the accused was entitled to bail from the day of his arrest upon furnishing the required bond. It also directed the Registrar General to circulate the ruling among judicial officers across Tamil Nadu and Puducherry to prevent similar errors.

“What the record does show is that he has been in prison for more than three weeks in a case in which the law entitled him to be released on the day of his arrest, upon his furnishing bail,” the Court remarked.

Arrest followed social media post against Vijay

The petitioner, P Raja Gopal, was booked under Section 296(b) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) and Section 67 of the Information Technology Act for allegedly posting obscene and abusive comments against Chief Minister Vijay on X (formerly Twitter) on June 12.

Although the FIR was registered earlier, police arrested him only on October 22, nearly four months later.

Following his arrest, a Metropolitan Magistrate in Chennai rejected his bail application, citing the seriousness of the allegations, the pending investigation and concerns that he might abscond or tamper with evidence.

Two subsequent applications seeking bail were also rejected by the Principal Sessions Court.

High Court says courts applied wrong legal standards

Examining the sequence of orders, the High Court pointed out that both provisions invoked against Gopal dealt with bailable offences.

Justice Ramesh observed that considerations such as the gravity of allegations, the stage of investigation and the possibility of tampering with evidence were relevant while deciding bail in non-bailable cases. They could not be used to deny an accused the statutory right to bail in a bailable offence.

The Court further clarified that a person seeking bail in a bailable case was not required to demonstrate a change in circumstances merely because an earlier bail application had been rejected.

It also highlighted the statutory obligation of police officers to inform an arrested person, in a bailable case, about their entitlement to secure release upon furnishing bail.

However, the case records contained nothing to establish whether Gopal had been informed of this legal right following his arrest.

The High Court clarified that its decision to correct the earlier orders should not be understood as an adverse finding against the judicial officers who had passed them.

Bail granted with ₹25,000 bond

Allowing the petition, the High Court directed that Gopal be released on bail upon executing a bond of ₹25,000 and furnishing two sureties for an equivalent amount.

In a further step aimed at ensuring judicial officers follow the correct legal position in bailable cases, the Court directed the Registrar General to circulate the judgment among judicial officers handling remand and bail matters across Tamil Nadu and Puducherry.

A copy was also ordered to be forwarded to the Tamil Nadu State Judicial Academy.

Advocate S Ganesh appeared for Gopal, while Government Advocate Durai Gunasekaran represented the State.

Share this story