A consumer dispute in Punjab has ended with a restaurant being directed to compensate a customer after adding a service charge to a dining bill without obtaining prior consent.
The District Consumer Commission in Jalandhar ruled that imposing a mandatory service charge without the customer’s approval amounts to an unfair trade practice, ordering the establishment to refund the amount collected and pay ₹15,000 in compensation.
The case arose from a complaint filed by advocate Sanjeev Duggal following a family buffet dinner in November 2023. According to the complaint, the restaurant added a 3 percent service charge to two bills, resulting in an additional ₹151.53 being collected. Duggal argued that the charge was imposed automatically and without his permission.
He also alleged that the restaurant billed four adults despite the group consisting of three adults and one child. Further claims included accusations of rude behaviour by staff when he questioned the charges and concerns regarding the quality of some food items served during the meal.
The restaurant defended its billing practice by arguing that the amount was collected as a “staff contribution,” a charge it said was disclosed in its menu and could be removed if customers requested it.
The consumer commission was not persuaded by that explanation. It observed that changing the label from “service charge” to “staff contribution” did not eliminate the restaurant’s responsibility to clearly inform diners in advance and obtain their consent before imposing such charges.
After reviewing the record, the commission found no evidence showing that the customer had been adequately informed of the charge beforehand or had agreed to pay it. The panel concluded that the restaurant had engaged in an unfair trade practice by collecting the amount without explicit consent.
However, the commission declined to grant relief on several other allegations. It noted that claims relating to poor food quality, staff misconduct and incorrect buffet billing were not supported by sufficient evidence such as witness statements or contemporaneous complaints.
As a result, the order focused solely on the disputed service charge. The restaurant has been directed to refund ₹151.53 along with interest from the date the complaint was filed. In addition, it must pay ₹15,000 towards compensation and litigation costs for the inconvenience and mental distress caused to the complainant.
The total award stands at ₹15,151.53, excluding interest, and must be paid within 45 days.
The ruling comes amid continuing scrutiny of service charge practices in the hospitality sector. Consumer protection guidelines issued in 2022 state that hotels and restaurants should not automatically add service charges to food bills, a position that has been upheld by the courts and remains the subject of ongoing legal proceedings.