Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Flags Missing Shariat Rules, Seeks Answers from Centre and Uttar Pradesh

The Supreme Court of India has turned the spotlight on a decades-old law that appears to be only half alive on paper. On Monday, the court asked the Union Government and the State of Uttar Pradesh to explain why crucial procedural rules under Section 4 of the Muslim Personal Law (Shariat) Application Act, 1937 have not been framed.

A Bench of Justices Sanjay Karol and Augustine George Masih issued notice after being told that, without these rules, a key provision of the Act may be practically unusable.

A Law Without a Mechanism?

At the heart of the issue lies a simple but significant gap.

Section 3 of the 1937 Act allows a Muslim individual to formally declare that matters such as marriage, maintenance, inheritance, and guardianship should be governed by Shariat law. Once such a declaration is accepted by the prescribed authority, the individual — and even their descendants — would be bound by Muslim Personal Law in those matters.

But who is this “prescribed authority”? What form should the declaration take? What procedure governs its acceptance?

That is where Section 4 steps in — or is supposed to. It mandates that the State Government frame rules specifying the authority and process for making such declarations. The court was informed that in Uttar Pradesh, these rules have never been framed.

The Bench observed that without rules laying down the form, authority, and procedure, the statutory right to declare governance under Shariat may remain illusory. In effect, a person may be granted a right under Section 3 but denied the means to exercise it.

The Case That Sparked the Question

The issue surfaced in an appeal challenging a 2011 judgment of the Delhi High Court. The High Court had invalidated a 1992 Will put forward by Gohar Sultan, daughter of the deceased testatrix, Mst. Nawab Begum.

The Will failed under the strict proof requirements of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 after the sole attesting witness did not support the case. Since there was no formal declaration under Section 3 of the Shariat Act, the High Court held that the Will had to satisfy the rigorous standards of the secular succession law, including the requirement of two attesting witnesses.

Before the Supreme Court, it was argued that the deceased could not have made a Section 3 declaration even if she wanted to — because Uttar Pradesh had not framed the necessary rules under Section 4.

The Bench took note of the submission that there has been “no compliance” with Section 4 so far. Seeing a possible statutory vacuum, the court decided to formally implead the Union of India (through the Department of Legislation) and the State of Uttar Pradesh (through its Chief Secretary) as respondents.

The reasoning was straightforward: the testatrix hailed from Uttar Pradesh. If the rules were absent there, the ability to invoke Shariat governance might never have been operational in practice.

What Happens Next?

The matter is scheduled to be taken up again on February 18, 2026. The newly added respondents have been asked to file affidavits clarifying the current status of the rules.

Beyond the individual dispute over a Will, the case now carries broader implications. If Section 4 rules have indeed not been framed in Uttar Pradesh, it raises a deeper constitutional and administrative question: can a statutory right meaningfully exist without the machinery to exercise it?

For now, the Supreme Court wants answers — and possibly, a long-overdue administrative response to a law enacted nearly nine decades ago.

Share this story