Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Grants ₹10 Lakh Compensation Each to Two Wrongfully Dismissed School Clerks, Blames Poor Pleadings for Defeating Their Case

The Supreme Court has directed a private school to pay ₹10 lakh each to two former clerks who were wrongfully dismissed from service, observing that their legitimate grievances had failed to receive proper consideration before the Bombay High Court because of inadequately drafted writ petitions.

A Bench of Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Sheel Nagu made the observations while dealing with appeals challenging the Bombay High Court’s decision to dismiss the clerks’ petitions.

Describing the case as an example of how a potentially meritorious claim can be defeated by poor legal drafting, the Bench observed that the substance of the dispute had been overshadowed by procedural shortcomings.

The two clerks had faced departmental proceedings over allegations of misappropriation of public money and other misconduct, along with the school’s in-charge headmaster.

Following an inquiry conducted under the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981, the charges against them were treated as established. Neither clerk had participated in the inquiry, and their services were subsequently terminated.

However, the final inquiry reports were never supplied to them before the termination orders were issued.

Challenging their dismissal, the clerks approached the School Tribunal in Mumbai. The Tribunal initially stayed the termination orders and directed the school to reinstate them on 50% of their salaries.

The school challenged this interim arrangement before the High Court. During those proceedings, the High Court permitted the school to approach the Tribunal to lead evidence in support of the alleged misconduct.

However, the school never filed such an application, and the Tribunal did not insist that evidence be produced.

The Tribunal eventually dismissed the clerks’ appeals, observing that they had deliberately avoided participating in the inquiry. It also relied on documentary material to deny them relief.

The clerks subsequently approached the Bombay High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, primarily arguing that they deserved treatment similar to the in-charge headmaster, whose termination had been modified to compulsory retirement by the Tribunal.

The High Court rejected their petitions, holding that the headmaster’s circumstances were different from those of the two clerks.

When the matter reached the Supreme Court, the Bench noted that the appellants were attempting to raise several substantive challenges to the Tribunal’s decisions that had not been properly pleaded in their original writ petitions.

In particular, they had failed to specifically allege that the school violated the High Court’s earlier order by not seeking permission to lead evidence. They had also not challenged the Tribunal’s failure to consider the absence of such evidence.

The Court reiterated that litigants must clearly establish the factual and legal grounds supporting the relief they seek. A court is not required to entertain arguments that are unsupported by the necessary pleadings.

The Bench observed that the Bombay High Court could not be faulted for failing to examine issues that had never been properly raised before it.

Nevertheless, the Supreme Court identified serious irregularities in the disciplinary proceedings.

It noted that the school had not explained why it failed to comply with the High Court’s order permitting it to seek an opportunity to establish the charges through evidence.

Consequently, there was no meaningful evidence before the Tribunal to establish the allegations of misconduct against the two clerks.

The Bench also highlighted that the inquiry reports had not been furnished to the employees before their termination, identifying this as a significant procedural defect in the disciplinary action.

Although the Supreme Court acknowledged that constitutional courts cannot ordinarily grant relief on grounds that have not been properly pleaded, it found the circumstances of the case sufficiently exceptional to warrant intervention.

Relying on the principle discussed in Ram Saran Varshney v. State of Uttar Pradesh, the Court observed that an action or order directly contrary to an express direction issued by a competent court cannot be treated as legally acceptable.

Taking into account the failure to establish the charges through evidence, the procedural shortcomings in the inquiry and the school’s failure to comply with the earlier judicial direction, the Supreme Court granted compensation of ₹10 lakh to each of the two former clerks.

Share this story