Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Supreme Court

Supreme Court Sets Out Five-Category Plan to Settle PACL Plot Claims After Years of Uncertainty

The Supreme Court has established a framework to resolve claims by investors who were allotted plots in PACL’s residential projects in Mohali and Bhatinda, allowing eligible claimants to either secure ownership documents or receive refunds with 8% annual interest.

A Bench of Justice Pamidighantam Sri Narasimha and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar accepted the recommendations of the committee overseeing the liquidation of PACL’s assets and repayment of investors, while introducing certain modifications.

Under the framework, the outcome for each allottee will depend on how much was paid, the mode of payment and when the transaction took place.

The dispute stems from action initiated by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) against PACL over allegations that the company operated an unregistered Collective Investment Scheme.

In 2016, the Supreme Court constituted a committee headed by former Chief Justice of India R.M. Lodha to oversee the sale of PACL’s land assets and facilitate repayment to investors.

While examining claims relating to three residential projects, the committee divided plot allottees into five categories according to their payment records and the timing of their transactions. The Supreme Court has now approved this classification, subject to modifications.

Five categories of plot allottees

Category I: Full payment through banking channels

Allottees who have paid the entire consideration through banking channels will receive sale certificates or No Objection Certificates (NOCs) within eight weeks. Those who have not yet received possession certificates will also be provided with them.

Category II: More than 50% payment through banking channels

Allottees who have paid over half of the total consideration through banking channels will be given an opportunity to clear the outstanding amount and obtain sale certificates.

If they fail to make the balance payment within the prescribed period, the plots will be treated as unsold. Their verified payments will then be refunded in accordance with Category III.

Category III: Less than 50% payment through banking channels

Those who have paid less than 50% of the consideration through banking channels will be entitled to a refund of their verified payments, carrying 8% interest.

The refund will be made within three months after the concerned plot is successfully auctioned.

Category IV: Cash payments and transactions after February 2, 2016

Claims based on cash payments will not be considered by the committee for either allotment or refunds. Claimants in this category will have the option of approaching the appropriate civil court.

However, payments made through banking channels after February 2, 2016, will be refunded with 8% interest.

Category V: Allottees who sold their plots during the proceedings

Those who transferred or sold their allotments while the proceedings were underway will be dealt with according to the category they would otherwise have qualified for, based on their original payment details.

Committee to examine additional claims

The Supreme Court has also directed the committee to scrutinise certain additional applications from allottees seeking placement in Category I.

Their inclusion will remain subject to SEBI’s approval or objections.

The framework seeks to bring clarity to claims that have remained unresolved amid the liquidation of PACL’s assets, while linking the relief available to each allottee with verifiable payment records and the status of the concerned plot.

Share this story