Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

6 Nov 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 12 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Supreme Court Clears Ashram School Officials in Fatal Pillar Collapse Case, Says Negligence Alone Cannot Establish Criminal Liability
  2. Supreme Court Orders Punjab, Haryana To Clear Himachal Pradesh’s 11,973 MU Power Dues Over 20 Years
  3. Bombay High Court Upholds Eligibility Cutoff For Judicial Recruitment Exam
  4. Karnataka High Court Quashes Defamation Case Against Siddaramaiah, Shivakumar And Congress Unit
  5. Allahabad High Court Upholds Refusal To Register FIR Over Rahul Gandhi Speech
  6. Allahabad High Court Quashes Concert Alcohol Restriction Imposed Under Noise Rules
  7. Madhya Pradesh High Court Rejects Family Claim Over Partitioned Land
  8. J&K High Court Seeks Fire Station Data By Risk Category
  9. Madras High Court Orders Relocation Of Unauthorised Statue From Temple Land
  10. Allahabad High Court Orders FIR Against Police Officer for Allegedly Fabricating Arrest Grounds
  11. Facebook Post on Ambedkar, Priyank Kharge: Karnataka High Court Rejects Plea to Scrap Criminal Case, Imposes ₹25,000 Cost
  12. Delay Must Be Condoned Before Appeal’s Merits Are Examined — J&K High Court

Supreme Court Clears Ashram School Officials in Fatal Pillar Collapse Case, Says Negligence Alone Cannot Establish Criminal Liability

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has quashed criminal proceedings against the president and hostel superintendent of an Ashram School in Maharashtra over the death of a 12-year-old student, holding that a breach of the duty of care, by itself, does not establish the criminal offence of culpable homicide. A bench of Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice Manmohan set aside the Bombay High Court's refusal to terminate the proceedings, observing that the material on record did not establish the requisite intention or knowledge on the part of the school officials. The Court, however, expressed deep pain over the tragic death of the young student. The incident took place on February 15, 2020, at a school in Amravati district. The Class 7 student was on the school premises when a pillar under construction collapsed on her, causing fatal injuries. Following the incident, the girl's father lodged a complaint alleging that the school's director and hostel superintendent had permitted substandard construction and failed to ensure adequate safety precautions. The two officials were subsequently charged under Section 304 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), corresponding to provisions under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).

High Court Had Relied on Construction Defects

The school officials had approached the Bombay High Court seeking to quash the criminal case. Their plea was rejected after the High Court considered the findings of a Chemical Analyser's report and the spot panchnama. The chemical analysis indicated that the prescribed cement, sand and aggregate ratio had not been maintained in the mortar. The panchnama, meanwhile, recorded that the pillar lacked a solid foundation. The High Court concluded that there had been a breach of duty, observing that although there was no intention to cause death, the officials allegedly knew that the use of substandard construction material could result in injury or death. Challenging this conclusion, the officials moved the Supreme Court.

Poor Construction Does Not Automatically Establish Knowledge of Likely Death

Before the Supreme Court, the appellants contended that the prosecution's allegations did not establish the voluntary commission of an offence punishable under Section 304 IPC. They also argued that Section 304A, which deals with death caused by a negligent act, could not be invoked merely because a failure to exercise due care might have contributed to the incident. According to them, such negligence had not been established as the direct cause of the student's death. The prosecution, on the other hand, maintained that the material was sufficient to make out a prima facie case of rashness and negligence. It argued that the question of guilt should be left for determination during trial. Examining the rival submissions, the Supreme Court explained the distinction between culpable homicide not amounting to murder under Section 304 IPC and causing death by negligence under Section 304A. The bench emphasised that a conviction under Section 304 cannot follow unless the necessary intention or knowledge is established through evidence. It noted that Section 304A applies where an act causes death without any intention to cause death or knowledge that the act is likely to result in death. The Court found that the allegations against the school officials did not cross this threshold. “The mere failure to attain the standard of care prescribed by the law, thereby committing breach of such duty as observed by the High Court would not be a criminal act,” the bench observed. It added that the contractor entrusted with the construction work could, at the most, be prima facie guilty of negligence, particularly if aware that poor construction could lead to an accident. However, the Court made it clear that the possibility of an accident arising from inferior construction did not, by itself, establish that the appellants knew that such construction was likely to cause the death of a student. The bench consequently held that the allegations did not disclose a voluntary commission of an offence against a person.

Court Examines Whether Negligence Was the Direct Cause of Death

The Supreme Court also considered the applicability of Section 304A IPC, explaining that the prosecution must establish a direct connection between the accused's rash or negligent act and the death. The act in question must be the proximate and efficient cause of the fatal outcome, without the intervention of another person's negligence. For this purpose, the bench referred to the principles laid down in Sushil Ansal v. State through CBI and Kurban Hussein Mohamedalli Rangawalla v. State of Maharashtra, particularly in relation to the concept of causa causans — the immediate and effective cause of an event. Applying these principles, the Court concluded that the criminal proceedings against the school officials could not be sustained. The Supreme Court accordingly allowed their appeal and quashed the case, overturning the Bombay High Court's order refusing to interfere with the prosecution.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Orders Punjab, Haryana To Clear Himachal Pradesh’s 11,973 MU Power Dues Over 20 Years

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has directed Punjab and Haryana to supply 11,973 million units (MU) of electricity to Himachal Pradesh over the next 20 years, putting an end to a decades-old dispute over the distribution of power generated from the Bhakra-Nangal and Beas hydroelectric projects. A bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana ordered the two States to deliver the outstanding electricity at the rate of approximately 598 million units annually during the lean season, spanning October to March. The ruling brings fresh momentum to a dispute that has remained unresolved despite years of litigation and repeated attempts at settlement.

Capital Cost Liability To Be Adjusted Against Power Dues

The Court has also directed that Himachal Pradesh’s liability towards its 7.19% share of the capital cost of the hydroelectric projects, calculated at ₹420.77 crore, be adjusted against the outstanding electricity dues. For this adjustment, the power has been valued at ₹3.85 per unit, translating into an equivalent of approximately 1,093 million units. Himachal Pradesh will, however, be required to pay the charges fixed by the Bhakra Beas Management Board for the year in which each instalment of electricity is supplied.

Dispute Stretches Back To 1996

The proceedings originated in a suit filed by Himachal Pradesh in 1996 under Article 131 of the Constitution. The State had sought its rightful share in the electricity generated from the two major hydroelectric projects. In 2011, the Supreme Court had ruled that Himachal Pradesh was entitled to 7.19% of the power attributable to the erstwhile composite State of Punjab. However, enforcing that decision proved far from straightforward. Disagreements continued over the volume of electricity due, the applicable tariff and the financial liabilities arising from the projects' capital costs. The Union Government subsequently calculated Himachal Pradesh’s outstanding power entitlement at 13,066 million units for the period between November 1, 1966, and October 2011. It proposed that the arrears be supplied over 15 years, with the capital-cost liability adjusted against the electricity entitlement.

Punjab’s Objections Rejected As ‘Vague And Superficial’

Punjab challenged the calculation, arguing that the outstanding quantity should be reduced after accounting for additional electricity already supplied to Himachal Pradesh. It also disputed the method used to determine the capital-cost liability. Haryana, meanwhile, raised objections concerning the extent of its own responsibility. The Supreme Court declined to accept Punjab’s objections, describing them as “vague and superficial”. The bench observed that the arguments effectively sought to reopen issues already settled through its 2011 judgment. The Court also expressed concern over the extraordinary length of the dispute, noting that successive efforts by the Union Government to facilitate a settlement had failed to bring the matter to a conclusion. “It is particularly unfortunate that a dispute which has remained pending for several decades continues to be prolonged, requiring further judicial time and attention,” the bench remarked.

20-Year Timeline To Ease Burden On States

Although the Union Government had proposed a 15-year schedule for supplying the outstanding electricity, the Supreme Court extended the period to 20 years. The bench said the longer timeline would ease the financial and operational burden on Punjab and Haryana while ensuring that Himachal Pradesh ultimately receives its due share. The Court made it clear that the directions could not be treated as optional, stressing that a judgment which had remained unenforced for decades must not be rendered meaningless through continued resistance. “The directions issued by this Court are binding and are required to be acted upon without reservation,” the bench stated. It further observed that the prolonged pendency of the decree could not justify its failure to be implemented due to the unwillingness or reluctance of the States responsible for complying with it. With these directions, the Supreme Court disposed of the suit, bringing a long-running inter-State power-sharing dispute to a close.

Read current report and source

Bombay High Court Upholds Eligibility Cutoff For Judicial Recruitment Exam

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court upheld a Maharashtra judicial recruitment corrigendum limiting transitional credit for one year of practice to candidates who earned law degrees before 22 August 2025. On 5 November 2026, it dismissed two petitions by 2026 graduates.

Judge / Bench — Sarang V. Kotwal, Judge (author); Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale, Judge.

Reading the Supreme Court’s directions together, it held that the transitional concession did not cover these petitioners. The ruling is reported as 2026:BHC-AS:45143-DB.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner, W.P. 15160: Dr. Uday Warunjikar, Advocate, with Anirudh Rote and Jinesh J. Koli. Party in person, W.P. 15159: Satish Maulyawan Patole. Respondents 1–2 (State and MPSC), both petitions: Neha Bhide, Government Pleader, with O.A. Chandurkar, Additional Government Pleader; also R.A. Salunke, AGP (15160), and T.N. Bhatia, AGP (15159). Respondent 3 (High Court administration), both petitions: Dr. Milind Sathe, Senior Advocate, with Rahul Nerlekar and Shailendra Kanetkar.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Quashes Defamation Case Against Siddaramaiah, Shivakumar And Congress Unit

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court quashed a criminal defamation case against Siddaramaiah, D.K. Shivakumar and the Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee over a campaign advertisement. It decided their petitions on 4 November 2026.

Judge / Bench — M. Nagaprasanna, Judge.

The court had already quashed proceedings against co-accused Rahul Gandhi. It found that the BJP’s complaint rested on the same advertisement and evidence, with no basis to treat the remaining petitioners differently. It quashed proceedings in C.C. 7399/2024 against them.

Advocates appearing — Petitioners: K. Shashi Kiran Shetty, Senior Advocate, with S.A. Ahmed, Surya Mukundaraj L., Sanjay Yadav B. and Anishka Vaishnav. BJP: Vinod Kumar M.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Upholds Refusal To Register FIR Over Rahul Gandhi Speech

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court upheld lower court orders refusing to direct registration of an FIR over remarks Rahul Gandhi made about concerns among Sikhs. It dismissed the applicants’ challenge on 5 November 2026 in Nageshwar Mishra and another v. State of U.P. and another.

Judge / Bench — Vikram D. Chauhan, Judge.

The court found that the material did not disclose the intent or incitement required by Section 152 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. It treated the remarks as protected speech on the record before it and held that another person’s use of them did not establish Gandhi’s intent.

Advocates appearing — Applicants: Aman Singh Visen and Satyendra Kumar Tripathi. State: Manish Goyal, Additional Advocate General. Opposite party 2: Not named in the judgment/order.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Quashes Concert Alcohol Restriction Imposed Under Noise Rules

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court set aside a concert permission that barred alcohol service. In Atlani Brothers Live v. State of Uttar Pradesh and others, decided on 8 October 2026, the court held that the authority had imposed a restriction beyond the Noise Pollution Rules and treated the organiser differently from others.

Judge / Bench — Alok Mathur and Abdhesh Kumar Chaudhary, Judges.

It directed the authority to issue a fresh permission without that condition by 11:30 a.m. on 9 October. The District Excise Officer had until 5 p.m. to consider a separate FL-11 licence application, subject to fees and other requirements.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner: Suryansh Narula, Ankit Verma and Pali Anurag. Respondents: Chief Standing Counsel; Not named in the judgment/order.

Read current report and source

Madhya Pradesh High Court Rejects Family Claim Over Partitioned Land

Madhya Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team

The Madhya Pradesh High Court upheld the dismissal of a suit by a wife and two sons who claimed title to land that Ramswaroop had received on partition. The court decided Prembai and others v. Ramswaroop and others on 26 October 2026.

Judge / Bench — Ashish Shroti, Judge.

Applying the Hindu Succession Act and Supreme Court precedent to the pleaded facts, the court treated the allotted land as Ramswaroop’s separate property. It held that the plaintiffs had no claim to it during his lifetime and dismissed the appeal because it raised no substantial question of law.

Advocates appearing — Appellants: Ashish Shrivastava. Respondent 2 (State): Rajendra Jain, Government Advocate. Other respondents: Not named in the judgment/order.

Read current report and source

J&K High Court Seeks Fire Station Data By Risk Category

Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court · Editorial Team

The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh directed the Union Territory to account for gaps in fire station coverage. Its 27 October 2026 order in Mohd Rahoof Khan v. Union Territory of J&K and others requires a single chart supported by an affidavit.

Judge / Bench — Dr. Pushpendra Singh Bhati, Chief Justice; Yash Paul Bourney, Judge.

The chart must show how many areas fall in each of the four risk categories, how many firefighting facilities the applicable norms require and how many are operational. The court listed the petition for 17 November.

Advocates appearing — Respondents: Monika Kohli, Senior Additional Advocate General. Petitioner in person: Mohd Rahoof Khan, Advocate.

Read current report and source

Madras High Court Orders Relocation Of Unauthorised Statue From Temple Land

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court on 30 October 2026 directed the District Collector to safely remove an unauthorised E.V. Ramasamy statue from temple land and relocate it suitably.

Judge / Bench — P. Velmurugan and K.K. Ramakrishnan, JJ.; order by P. Velmurugan, J.

In W.P.(MD) 22916/2026, the Court required action within four weeks and a compliance report. It disposed of Rama. Ravikumar’s petition and closed the connected impleadment application because the proposed party was unnecessary.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner: J. Jaaswant; respondents 1–3: K.K. Udayakumar, Government Advocate; 4 and 6: S.I. Muthiah, Additional Government Pleader; 5 and 8: J. Vishnu, Government Advocate (Criminal Side); 7: Chandrasekar, Standing Counsel.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Orders FIR Against Police Officer for Allegedly Fabricating Arrest Grounds

Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Allahabad High Court has directed the registration of a criminal case against a police investigating officer accused of inserting reasons for arrest into official records after the arrest, allegedly to prevent the accused from securing release. Taking a stern view of the alleged manipulation, the Court observed that the officer's conduct appeared to involve offences concerning false evidence and interference with the administration of justice. A Division Bench of Justice Atul Sreedharan and Justice Achal Sachdev, hearing the habeas corpus petition in Mohd. Yaseen v. State of UP and 3 Others, found that the grounds of arrest had not been communicated to the petitioner when he was taken into custody. Instead, the investigating officer allegedly added the missing particulars to documents subsequently placed before the remand magistrate and the trial court. The Bench strongly criticised the police action, observing that evidence appeared to have been fabricated to justify an arrest memo that had never been furnished to the accused, thereby denying him relief during remand and bail proceedings. The Court directed the Farrukhabad Superintendent of Police to ensure that an FIR was registered against the investigating officer without delay. A compliance report must be submitted within seven days.

Arrest Declared Illegal Over Non-Communication of Grounds

The case arose after Mohd. Yaseen was arrested on September 14. He had visited the police station a day earlier to participate in an investigation into a suicide case. Yaseen approached the High Court, contending that the police had failed to provide him with the reasons for his arrest, as required under law. Examining the arrest memo, the Bench found that the document supplied to him mentioned only Section 108 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), which deals with abetment of suicide. The allegations that a case had been registered and that evidence indicated the deceased had taken her own life due to harassment allegedly inflicted by Yaseen were missing from the copy provided to him. The Court noted that these crucial particulars were subsequently reflected in the records submitted before the judicial authorities, raising serious concerns about the manner in which the arrest documentation had been prepared. Holding that the arrest violated the legal requirements governing communication of the grounds of arrest, the Bench declared it illegal and directed Yaseen's release.

Police Officer's Conduct Under Scrutiny

The High Court made it clear that the alleged retrospective insertion of arrest grounds could not be treated as a mere procedural lapse. The Bench said the apparent fabrication of evidence to justify the arrest and influence remand and bail proceedings warranted criminal action. The Farrukhabad SP has been directed to register the FIR and submit the required compliance report within seven days.

Read current report and source

Facebook Post on Ambedkar, Priyank Kharge: Karnataka High Court Rejects Plea to Scrap Criminal Case, Imposes ₹25,000 Cost

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Karnataka High Court has refused to terminate criminal proceedings against a man accused of posting derogatory remarks on Facebook about Dr BR Ambedkar and Karnataka Minister Priyank Kharge, holding that the allegations must be examined through a trial.

Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde dismissed the petition seeking to quash the chargesheet, observing that the material collected during the investigation did not justify any interference with the proceedings. The Court went a step further, describing the petition as a “gross abuse of the process of the Court” and directing the accused to pay ₹25,000 to the Mysuru District Legal Services Authority (DLSA). “Not a single ground is made out to quash the proceedings. On the other hand, the charge sheet materials clearly indicate that the matter has to be tried,” the Court observed.

What triggered the criminal case?

The case concerns Mahesha KC, also known as Mahesh Gowda, who was booked following a complaint by S Vijaykumar, a functionary of the Karnataka Pradesh Congress Committee (KPCC). The complaint alleged that Mahesha had published objectionable remarks about Priyank Kharge on Facebook. The post allegedly referred to the Minister’s caste and questioned his respect for Dr BR Ambedkar, stating that Ambedkar was born into the same caste. Following the complaint, Mysuru South Police investigated the matter and filed a chargesheet against the accused. The chargesheet invoked Sections 352, 338 and 241 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, along with provisions of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.

Accused questioned complainant’s authority

Seeking to have the chargesheet quashed, Mahesha argued that the complaint had been filed by someone who was not the alleged victim of the Facebook post. His counsel contended that the complainant had no right to initiate criminal proceedings in the matter. It was also argued that the contents of the Facebook post did not disclose the commission of any criminal offence. Opposing the petition, Additional State Public Prosecutor MV Anoop Kumar defended the police investigation and the filing of the chargesheet, maintaining that the allegations warranted criminal proceedings.

Court says allegations must face trial

After examining the submissions and the material placed on record, the High Court found no justification to terminate the case at this stage. The Court concluded that the allegations and supporting materials required judicial examination during trial, rather than being dismissed through a plea to quash the chargesheet. With the petition rejected, the criminal proceedings against Mahesha will continue. The accused has also been directed to deposit ₹25,000 with the Mysuru DLSA as costs.

Read current report and source

Delay Must Be Condoned Before Appeal’s Merits Are Examined — J&K High Court

Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court · Hania Zahoor

The Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has held that an appellate authority cannot examine a time-barred appeal on merits without first deciding whether the delay should be condoned.

Justice Shahzad Azeem delivered the ruling on November 3 in Prem Singh v. UT of J&K and others, concerning a land mutation in Kathua based on a civil court decree. The mutation was attested in January 2011 and challenged in February 2013. The Deputy Commissioner set it aside without addressing limitation. The Divisional Commissioner and Financial Commissioner upheld that decision. The High Court noted that Section 22 of the J&K Agrarian Reforms Act, 1976 prescribes a 60-day appeal period, with delay condonable upon sufficient cause. “Only after the delay is condoned does the authority acquire the jurisdiction to examine the merits,” the Court held. Finding a jurisdictional error, the Court set aside the Divisional Commissioner’s and Financial Commissioner’s orders. It directed the Deputy Commissioner, Kathua, to decide limitation afresh and examine the merits only if the delay is condoned. The Court expressly declined to decide the merits of the underlying land dispute. Case — WP(C) No. 24/2023

Read current report and source