Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

13 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 17 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Contract as Whole Determines Arbitration Seat, Supreme Court Rules
  2. Arguable Limitation Cannot Defeat Necessary Pleading Amendments
  3. Compelled Separation Does Not Establish Marital Desertion
  4. Private Email Services Are Not Public Functions
  5. Anti-Corruption Exemption Does Not Block RTI Disclosure
  6. Karnataka Adopts Rapid Response Protocol for Underage Pregnancies
  7. Family Members Need Abetment Evidence for Bigamy Charges
  8. Decades-Long Delay Defeats Compassionate Appointment Claim
  9. Proposed Accused Cannot Challenge Pre-Cognizance Investigation
  10. Married Daughters Retain Shares in Land-Reform Property
  11. Written Arrest Grounds Mandatory, Madras High Court Says
  12. Religious Promotion Alone Cannot Support Criminal Charges
  13. Karnataka High Court Slaps ₹1 Lakh Penalty on Officer for Leaving 102-Year-Old Landowner Waiting for Justice
  14. Karnataka High Court Seeks State’s Reply to Challenge Over ‘Er’ Title for Engineers
  15. Delhi High Court Grants NDPS Bail, Says Marginal Excess Over Commercial Drug Limit Calls for Closer Scrutiny
  16. Delhi High Court Rejects ‘First-Come, First-Served’ Rule for Ramleela Ground Allotments
  17. Allahabad High Court Warns Police: Disrespecting State Counsel While Enforcing Court Orders Can Invite Contempt

Contract as Whole Determines Arbitration Seat, Supreme Court Rules

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has ruled that a named venue does not automatically become the juridical seat of arbitration where the agreement identifies two different places.

Justices Manoj Misra and Vijay Bishnoi examined a franchise agreement that described Delhi as the “precise location” of arbitration but separately stated that proceedings would be held in Goa. The Delhi High Court had appointed an arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act.

In its 12 October judgment, the Supreme Court said the parties’ intended seat must be identified from the contract as a whole. Reading the arbitration clause alongside the agreement’s governing-law and jurisdiction provisions, it concluded that Goa was the juridical seat.

The court therefore held that the Delhi High Court lacked jurisdiction, set aside the appointment order and left the parties free to approach the competent High Court.

Read current report and source

Arguable Limitation Cannot Defeat Necessary Pleading Amendments

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has allowed plaintiffs in a long-running property dispute to amend their pleadings after discovering a compromise decree that affected the disputed chain of title.

Justices B.V. Nagarathna and R. Mahadevan held on 12 October that an amendment should not be rejected merely because limitation is arguable and depends on disputed facts. The proposed pleading was necessary to determine the full controversy and avoid fragmented proceedings over the same land.

The court found that the plaintiffs had explained when they obtained certified copies of the earlier suit and decree, satisfying the due-diligence requirement under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

It set aside the trial court and Orissa High Court orders, allowed the amendment subject to ₹25,000 costs and preserved all objections—including limitation, maintainability, title and the effect of the compromise decree—for trial.

Read current report and source

Compelled Separation Does Not Establish Marital Desertion

Jharkhand High Court · Editorial Team

The Jharkhand High Court has granted a woman a divorce after finding that she left the matrimonial home because of cruelty rather than any intention to abandon the marriage.

Justices Sujit Narayan Prasad and Sanjay Prasad held on 9 October that desertion requires voluntary withdrawal from cohabitation with an intention to end marital life. A spouse forced to leave by the other partner’s conduct cannot be treated as the deserter.

The wife testified that her husband drank habitually, assaulted her for money and mistreated their children. The Family Court rejected cruelty partly because no formal police case had been registered. The High Court said that approach wrongly discounted matrimonial evidence and her prior police complaint.

Finding the marriage had become incapable of revival after separation since 2018, the court dissolved it. The children’s inheritance rights remain intact, and the mother may separately seek maintenance for them.

Read current report and source

Private Email Services Are Not Public Functions

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court has dismissed a writ petition seeking restoration of a Gmail account disabled after suspected unauthorised access.

Justice Amit Mahajan held on 8 October that providing email, hosting and related digital services is a commercial activity, not a public function ordinarily enforceable through Article 226 of the Constitution.

The importance of an account to a media business, or the scale and reach of the service provider, did not change the nature of that function. The court distinguished cases involving privacy and de-indexing of judicial records, where different public-law concerns were engaged.

It also held that intermediary obligations under the Information Technology Act and 2021 Rules do not automatically convert customer-support or account-restriction disputes into public duties. The petition was dismissed as not maintainable, while leaving the company free to pursue other legal remedies.

Read current report and source

Anti-Corruption Exemption Does Not Block RTI Disclosure

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court has upheld an order requiring Tamil Nadu’s vigilance directorate to disclose records of an enquiry concerning a retired police officer.

Justice Hemant Chandangoudar held on 9 October that the agency’s exemption under Section 24(4) of the Right to Information Act does not extend to information concerning allegations of corruption or human-rights violations.

The state had also relied on the risk-to-sources exemption and the volume of material. The court found no basis for withholding the entire record. Identifying details of other officers could be masked, and exempt passages could be severed under Section 10.

Where a particular document contains confidential third-party information, the statutory consultation procedure must be followed. That requirement cannot justify suppressing the remaining disclosable material. The court confirmed the Information Commission’s order and dismissed the state’s petition.

Read current report and source

Karnataka Adopts Rapid Response Protocol for Underage Pregnancies

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court has closed a minor survivor’s petition after the state notified a comprehensive protocol for early identification and timely response to underage pregnancies.

Justice S. Sunil Dutt Yadav’s 7 October order records procedures linking hospitals, police, child-welfare bodies, legal-services authorities and support persons. The protocol requires counselling on available choices, rapid medical coordination and confidentiality safeguards.

For pregnancies below 24 weeks, the framework states that no judicial or third-party authorisation is required for lawful termination. Where gestation exceeds 24 weeks, legal-services authorities must arrange urgent High Court representation, with designated lawyers expected to file within 48 hours.

The protocol also calls for training, statewide monitoring, compliance audits and a dashboard tracking delays from detection to medical care. After reviewing the notified safeguards and departmental responsibilities, the court found that no further orders were required and disposed of the petition.

Read current report and source

Family Members Need Abetment Evidence for Bigamy Charges

Patna High Court · Editorial Team

The Patna High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against three relatives of a man accused of concealing an earlier marriage.

Justice Soni Shrivastava held on 9 October that Section 495 of the Indian Penal Code targets the spouse who contracts the later marriage while hiding the former one. Relatives do not become liable merely by attending a wedding or being related to the accused.

Family members could face prosecution only if the complaint disclosed specific facts showing abetment or conspiracy. Here, the allegations of deception, financial demands and physical confrontation were directed at the alleged husband, while the petitioners were said to have informed the complainant of his earlier marriage.

The court found no ingredients of cheating, hurt or concealment offences against the relatives. It set aside the cognizance and discharge orders, holding that continued prosecution would abuse the court’s process.

Read current report and source

Decades-Long Delay Defeats Compassionate Appointment Claim

Madhya Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has rejected a compassionate appointment claim brought more than two decades after the death of the employee concerned.

Justice Vivek Agarwal held on 7 October that compassionate employment exists to provide immediate support when a family loses its breadwinner. It is an exception to open public recruitment and cannot become a deferred entitlement after the family has survived for a substantial period.

The petitioner’s father died in October 1998, but she applied only in August 2019. The court said granting relief 28 years after the bereavement would conflict with Supreme Court authority treating delay as fundamentally inconsistent with the scheme’s purpose.

The petition was dismissed. However, because counsel disputed whether the employee’s widow was receiving family pension, the court allowed the petitioner to seek revival if no pension was in fact being paid.

Read current report and source

Proposed Accused Cannot Challenge Pre-Cognizance Investigation

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court has held that a proposed accused cannot challenge an order directing investigation before a court takes cognizance or issues summons.

Justice S. Karthikeyan dismissed two applications filed by a police inspector seeking to appeal orders of a special court under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. The inspector also sought condonation of a 317-day delay.

The court ruled on 6 October that a person who has not yet been summoned is not an “aggrieved person” entitled to appeal under Section 14A of the Act. It agreed with earlier High Court authority that a prospective accused has no standing at the pre-cognizance stage to attack an investigation direction under the criminal procedure law.

Because the appeals were not maintainable, there was no basis to condone the delay. The court nevertheless left the applicant free to pursue any legally available remedy before the proper forum.

Read current report and source

Married Daughters Retain Shares in Land-Reform Property

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court has confirmed that married daughters can claim shares in joint family land granted to their predecessor under the Karnataka Land Reforms Act.

Justice B. Muralidhara Pai held on 24 September that the Hindu Succession Act governs inheritance and overrides the land-reform legislation on succession questions. A daughter’s marriage does not extinguish her right where the property continues to be joint.

The dispute concerned family members who traced their claims through the same predecessor. The defendants argued that daughters could not seek partition because the holdings were formerly tenanted lands and occupancy rights had been granted under the state statute.

Rejecting that argument, the court followed earlier Karnataka and Supreme Court authority and found no material justifying a different view. It dismissed the regular second appeal and left intact the lower courts’ recognition of the daughters’ shares.

Read current report and source

Written Arrest Grounds Mandatory, Madras High Court Says

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court has granted bail to a man accused in a ₹2.62 crore coaching-deposit case after finding that police failed to provide written grounds for his arrest.

Justice N. Ramesh held on 7 October that an arrest memo containing only general statutory phrases did not explain the factual basis for detention. An oral explanation could not cure that defect, particularly where the memo was in a language the accused could not read.

The court said Supreme Court precedent requires written grounds in a language understood by the arrested person. It directed Tamil Nadu’s police leadership to treat non-compliance as dereliction of duty capable of attracting departmental proceedings.

Bail was granted subject to financial security, cooperation with the investigation, travel restrictions and witness-protection conditions. The police chief was also asked to report on statewide instructions and officer training.

Read current report and source

Religious Promotion Alone Cannot Support Criminal Charges

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against four people accused of pressuring a man and his wife to convert from Hinduism to Christianity.

Justice M.W. Chandwani held on 6 October that promoting one’s own religion is not the same as insulting another faith or deliberately wounding religious feelings. Even accepting the prosecution case at face value, the allegations did not satisfy Sections 299 or 302 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.

The court also noted that the alleged conduct occurred in 2025, before Maharashtra’s new law restricting conversion by allurement came into force on 28 August 2026. Criminal liability could not be imposed retrospectively.

Finding that the FIR disclosed no offence, the court applied the Supreme Court’s Bhajan Lal principles and set aside both the FIR and charge-sheet against the applicants.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Slaps ₹1 Lakh Penalty on Officer for Leaving 102-Year-Old Landowner Waiting for Justice

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Karnataka High Court has ordered a Special Land Acquisition Officer to pay ₹1 lakh in compensation to a 102-year-old man after years of inaction over his demand for a judicial review of the compensation awarded for his acquired land. Justice R Nataraj took a stern view of the officer’s failure to act despite repeated representations and a specific direction from a civil court. The Court observed that the officer had subjected the elderly petitioner to deplorable treatment by allowing the dispute to remain unresolved for years. The officer, who was in charge when the man submitted a representation in 2022, must pay the amount within one month. If the payment is not made within the stipulated period, the drawing officer has been directed to recover the sum from the officer’s salary. The case arose from the acquisition of 29 guntas of land in Bengaluru Rural district in 2004. The State had taken over the property to construct an alternative road connecting Bettakote Village to the international airport at Devanahalli. Believing that the compensation offered by the government was inadequate, the landowner sought a reference to a civil court under Section 18 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, which allows disputes over compensation to be examined by a court. He submitted representations to the land acquisition officer in June and October 2005, requesting that the dispute be referred for judicial consideration. However, no action followed. The elderly man subsequently approached the High Court, which directed him to pursue the matter before the civil court. He filed a petition before the Civil Judge, Senior Division, at Devanahalli in 2007. In 2022, the civil court ordered the land acquisition officer to refer the dispute within 30 days. Despite this direction, the officer failed to act even after the petitioner submitted copies of the order through further representations in 2022 and 2025. With the matter still unresolved, the petitioner returned to the High Court seeking enforcement of the direction to refer his compensation dispute to the civil court. The High Court found the officer’s continued inaction unacceptable, pointing to the apparent negligence in discharging a statutory responsibility and complying with the civil court’s order. Taking particular exception to the manner in which the 102-year-old man had been treated, the Court remarked that the officer was liable to face action for having played with the petitioner’s life in such a reprehensible manner. In its August 31 order in B Ramaiah v. State of Karnataka, the Court directed the officer to refer the compensation dispute to the competent court under Section 18 of the 1894 Act within one month. It also imposed the ₹1 lakh compensation payment for the prolonged harassment caused by the failure to act. The ruling underscores the consequences of public officials ignoring statutory duties and court directions, particularly when their inaction leaves an elderly citizen waiting years for a chance to challenge the compensation awarded for his land.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Seeks State’s Reply to Challenge Over ‘Er’ Title for Engineers

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Karnataka High Court has sought the State government’s response to a petition questioning its decision to allow engineers to use the prefix ‘Er’ before their names, with the petitioner alleging that the move unfairly privileges one profession over others. Justice CM Poonacha issued notice on October 9 in the case, Beerappa N v State of Karnataka. The matter is scheduled for its next hearing on November 16. The controversy stems from a government order issued on September 15, 2026, permitting engineers in Karnataka to adopt the honorific ‘Er’. The petition challenges both the rationale behind the decision and the government’s authority to confer such a professional title. It argues that the order does not provide a clear or reasonable explanation for extending the distinction to engineers alone. According to the petitioner, the decision raises concerns under Article 14 of the Constitution, which guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws. The plea contends that granting an honorific to members of one profession risks creating an artificial hierarchy among different occupational groups. It further argues that the State’s decision is arbitrary because it extends a distinction to engineers without establishing a consistent principle for treating other professions. The petitioner has also claimed that the decision undermines the standing and dignity associated with his own profession, arguing that the government’s approach places engineers in a position of distinction over other professional groups. The High Court will consider the challenge after receiving the State government’s response. Advocate Trivikram SS appeared for the petitioner.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Grants NDPS Bail, Says Marginal Excess Over Commercial Drug Limit Calls for Closer Scrutiny

Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Delhi High Court has held that the stringent bail restrictions under the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act may warrant a more nuanced approach when the quantity of drugs allegedly recovered is only marginally above the prescribed commercial threshold. Justice Amit Bansal made the observation while granting bail to Sunny, who was arrested in July 2025 following the alleged recovery of 259.3 grams of morphine — just 9.3 grams above the 250-gram commercial quantity limit. “In such circumstances, the strict application of the rigours of the NDPS Act may not be justified and warrants a more nuanced consideration,” the Court observed in Sunny v. State of NCT of Delhi. According to the prosecution, Sunny was apprehended during routine police patrolling. Information allegedly provided by him subsequently led the police to another accused, from whom 114 grams of morphine was recovered. The co-accused was granted bail by a Sessions Court in May this year. Opposing the allegations, Sunny argued that he had been falsely implicated in the case. His counsel also questioned the search procedure, pointing out that no independent public witness had been associated with the recovery despite people being present at the spot. The defence further submitted that charges had already been framed, but the examination of witnesses had not begun. The State opposed the bail application, maintaining that the restrictions under Section 37 of the NDPS Act applied to the case. It also argued that Sunny could not claim parity with the co-accused, whose alleged recovery involved an intermediate quantity rather than a commercial quantity. A previous FIR against Sunny was cited as an additional ground for opposing relief. The High Court, however, emphasised that the stringent conditions under Section 37 do not rule out bail where undue delay in the conclusion of the trial becomes a relevant consideration. Relying on a series of Supreme Court decisions, the Court noted that the evidence was yet to begin and that the trial would take considerable time to conclude. Taking these circumstances into account, the Court granted bail to Sunny, finding that the case called for a more measured assessment rather than an inflexible application of the statutory restrictions.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Rejects ‘First-Come, First-Served’ Rule for Ramleela Ground Allotments

Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The race to secure public grounds for Ramleela celebrations cannot be decided simply by who applies first, the Delhi High Court has ruled, directing authorities to establish a transparent and fair allocation system for religious and cultural events. Justice Amit Mahajan, in an order dated October 8, held that the first-come, first-served approach is constitutionally unreasonable because it can give some applicants an unfair advantage over others. Although the policy may appear neutral on the surface, the Court observed that it rewards those who gain information about the availability of public spaces before competing organisers. This can create an uneven playing field, particularly when some applicants have better access to administrative information. The Court has directed the authorities to introduce comprehensive guidelines every year for allotting grounds for Ramleela and similar events. Under the proposed framework, allocation notices must be published at least 90 days before the first scheduled event. These notices should clearly identify the available grounds, application deadlines, eligibility requirements, assessment criteria and mechanisms for raising grievances. Where several eligible organisations apply for the same location, authorities must compare their applications using a predetermined scoring system or other evaluation criteria made public in advance. The Court also addressed the position of organisers who have conducted events at a particular venue in previous years. While their compliance record may justify limited preference, past allotment cannot create an automatic entitlement to the same ground. Such preference must not continue beyond two consecutive years when other eligible applicants are competing for the site. Authorities must also ensure that the allotment process and the regular grievance-redressal procedure are completed well before the celebrations begin.

Dispute over a Ramleela venue

The ruling came in a petition filed by Rays of New Beginning Foundation, which challenged the rejection of its application to organise Ramleela at a Delhi ground. The foundation had organised the event at the same location in 2023 and 2024. It argued that the Delhi Development Authority's policy provided preference to previous organisers. However, the Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board allotted the ground to another organisation that had applied earlier, relying on its first-come, first-served policy. Examining the dispute, the High Court found the approach flawed and emphasised the need for an allocation process that offers applicants a fair opportunity to compete for public spaces. Despite finding fault with the policy, the Court declined to cancel the existing allotment or transfer the ground to the petitioner for the 2026 festivities. With the events about to begin, it decided against disrupting the arrangements already in place. The decision in Ray of New Beginning Foundation v. Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board & Ors. establishes a broader framework for future allotments, placing transparency, published criteria and equal opportunity at the centre of decisions involving public grounds. The ruling makes clear that access to a public venue for religious or cultural celebrations should not depend merely on who reaches the authorities first, but on a process that treats competing applicants fairly.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Warns Police: Disrespecting State Counsel While Enforcing Court Orders Can Invite Contempt

Allahabad High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Allahabad High Court has cautioned police officials against mistreating government counsel performing court-related duties, observing that such conduct could amount to contempt of court. Justice Arun Kumar Singh Deshwal issued the warning in Sachin Yadav v. State of Uttar Pradesh, directing the Uttar Pradesh Director General of Police (DGP) to circulate instructions to police personnel across the state. The circular must make it clear that misbehaviour with State law officers tasked with communicating court orders will be viewed seriously and dealt with in accordance with the law. The court's intervention followed allegations that Rajesh Kumar Singh, the public relations officer (PRO) attached to a Senior Superintendent of Police (SSP), had behaved improperly over the phone with Additional Government Advocate Anurag Pandey. Pandey was reportedly attempting to inform the police official about orders passed by the court in a bail matter when the incident occurred. Emphasising the responsibility carried by government counsel, Justice Deshwal observed that they act in furtherance of the court's directions when communicating its orders to government officials. Any officer who mistreats them in that process, regardless of their position in the state administration, could face contempt proceedings. Rather than issuing a formal reprimand alone, the court ordered that Singh remain in its custody until 5 pm on the day of the hearing, after which he was to be released.

Case traces back to alleged lapses in police compliance

The controversy emerged during the hearing of a bail application filed by a man accused of posting obscene videos of a victim on social media. In September, the court had summoned the investigating officer after finding that the State's counter-affidavit omitted several relevant details. When investigating officer Vinay Kumar Mishra failed to appear, the court directed the SSP of Azamgarh to execute a non-bailable warrant against him. Mishra subsequently told the court that he had not been informed about the directions requiring his presence. The court then ordered the SSP of Azamgarh and the station house officer of Maharajganj to appear personally. It also summoned the SSP's PRO after being informed of the alleged altercation with the government counsel. During the October 12 hearing, SSP Dr Anil Kumar informed the court that show-cause notices had been issued to the Maharajganj station house officer and Sub-Inspector Subhash Singh over alleged negligence in handling the matter. A separate notice had also been issued to Singh, who was subsequently removed from his position as the SSP's PRO. The court acknowledged the SSP's prompt action but made clear that protecting the authority of judicial orders requires cooperation from every level of the police administration. By directing the DGP to issue a statewide circular, the court sought to reinforce a broader message: government officials must not obstruct or intimidate those responsible for communicating and facilitating compliance with judicial directions.

Read current report and source