Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

14 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 15 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Probation Cannot Follow Grievous Assault and Adverse Antecedents
  2. Impossible Tender Formality Cannot Defeat Valid E-Payment
  3. Misbehaving With State Counsel May Amount to Contempt
  4. Absconding Requires Proof of Deliberate Evasion, Gujarat High Court Rules
  5. Prison Leave May Be Split Into Two Instalments Annually
  6. Victim’s Sexual History Cannot Establish Consent at Charge Stage
  7. Patient Charges Do Not Erase Hospital’s Charitable Character
  8. Kissing Child’s Lips Can Constitute Aggravated Sexual Assault
  9. Named Co-Adulterers Must Be Heard Before Adverse Findings
  10. Forged Writ Filings Justify Summary Dismissal, Gauhati High Court Warns
  11. J&K&L High Court Rejects PMGSY’s Bid to Reopen ₹7.2 Lakh House Damage Compensation Case
  12. Zubeen Garg Murder Case: Gauhati High Court Grants Bail to Amritprava Mahanta, Cites Lack of Supporting Evidence
  13. Delhi High Court Raises Compensation for 74-Year-Old Accident Victim, Says Unpaid Household Work Has Real Value
  14. J&K High Court Tightens Practice Rules: AIBE Now Compulsory for Lawyers Enrolled Since 2009-10
  15. Kerala High Court Wants Illegal Vehicle Modifications Captured on Camera in Accident Reports

Probation Cannot Follow Grievous Assault and Adverse Antecedents

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has ruled that probation was inappropriate for offenders convicted of a grievous group assault where their antecedents and conduct were not adequately examined.

In its 7 October 2026 judgment, the court said the Allahabad High Court had released the accused on probation without properly addressing the gravity of the attack or relevant adverse material. The discretion to avoid imprisonment must be exercised on a reasoned assessment of the offence and the offender, it held.

The bench set aside the probation order and directed the accused to surrender within two weeks. It restored their criminal appeals before the High Court’s Lucknow Bench for reconsideration after they are taken into custody.

Read current report and source

Impossible Tender Formality Cannot Defeat Valid E-Payment

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has held that a public tender cannot be rejected for failure to submit an “original” document that exists only as an electronically generated payment receipt.

Hardev Construction’s bid was disqualified because it did not provide an original receipt for an online earnest-money payment. In its 12 October 2026 judgment, the court said compliance was impossible: the transaction produced no physical original, and the payment itself was not disputed.

The bench set aside the rejection and allowed the bidder to furnish fresh security. It directed the authorities to open and consider the financial bid alongside the other bids, while leaving the procurement decision to be taken under the tender terms.

Read current report and source

Misbehaving With State Counsel May Amount to Contempt

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court has warned that official misconduct toward government counsel may interfere with the administration of justice and invite contempt action.

In its 12 October 2026 order, the court recorded allegations that a police public-relations officer misbehaved with an additional government advocate. It directed that the officer remain in custody until 5 p.m. and asked the Director General of Police to issue instructions aimed at preventing similar conduct.

The court separately rejected Sachin Yadav’s bail application after considering cyber evidence linking him to a fake Facebook account. The order emphasised both institutional respect for court officers and the need to assess electronic material when deciding bail.

Read current report and source

Absconding Requires Proof of Deliberate Evasion, Gujarat High Court Rules

Gujarat High Court · Editorial Team

The Gujarat High Court has held that a person cannot be declared an absconder without reliable material showing deliberate evasion of legal process.

In its 5 October 2026 decision, the court found that the proclamation proceedings rested on a police report that was later shown to be forged. It said the label “absconding” carries serious legal consequences and cannot follow from mechanical reliance on unverified service material.

The court quashed the proclamation order and directed the applicant to appear before the competent court. It also ordered criminal proceedings against the responsible police officer and called for statewide safeguards to ensure that future proclamation reports are authentic and properly verified.

Read current report and source

Prison Leave May Be Split Into Two Instalments Annually

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court has clarified that an eligible prisoner’s 40 days of annual ordinary leave may be taken in two instalments within the same year.

The case concerned S. Babu, a life convict whose request for 14 days’ leave without escort was rejected because he had taken leave earlier in 2026. In its 12 October 2026 order, the court said the prison authorities’ interpretation would defeat the rule permitting two instalments by effectively forcing prisoners to take all 40 days at once.

The bench held that both instalments may be used within one year from the first day of the first instalment. The separate one-year interval under Rule 22(3) begins after the second instalment ends, or after one year from the end of the first instalment if no second instalment is used. It ordered 14 days’ leave without escort, subject to reporting and surrender conditions.

Read current report and source

Victim’s Sexual History Cannot Establish Consent at Charge Stage

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court has ruled that a complainant’s alleged immorality or previous sexual conduct cannot be used to infer consent while deciding whether rape charges should be framed.

The revision challenged the discharge of an accused in a case alleging that he secretly recorded the complainant bathing, threatened to circulate the video and compelled repeated sexual relations. In its 13 October 2026 judgment, the court said the trial judge had prematurely assessed credibility and resolved disputed facts instead of asking whether the investigation disclosed sufficient grounds to proceed.

The court noted that Section 53A of the Evidence Act makes a victim’s character or previous sexual experience irrelevant to consent in prosecutions for specified sexual offences. It set aside the discharge order and remanded the matter for fresh consideration of charge, while clarifying that it expressed no view on guilt.

Read current report and source

Patient Charges Do Not Erase Hospital’s Charitable Character

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court has ruled that charging patients does not, by itself, deprive a hospital of its philanthropic character or disqualify it from income-tax approval.

Breach Candy Hospital Trust challenged orders refusing approval under Section 10(23C)(via) of the Income-tax Act. In its 12 October 2026 judgment, the court found that the authority had imposed requirements not found in the statute and failed to assess the institution’s objects and application of income in the legally required manner.

The bench quashed both refusal orders. It directed the competent authority to grant approval for assessment years 2002-03 through 2010-11 and separately for 2011-12 through 2021-22, within eight weeks of the judgment’s upload. The petitions will be listed on 14 December 2026 to report compliance.

Read current report and source

Kissing Child’s Lips Can Constitute Aggravated Sexual Assault

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court has upheld the conviction and five-year sentence of a man who sexually assaulted a six-year-old neighbour, holding that a kiss on a child’s lips may fall within the POCSO Act even without touching private parts.

The appellant challenged his conviction under Section 354 of the Penal Code and Section 10 of the POCSO Act, arguing that the child’s account was inconsistent and tutored. In its 13 October 2026 judgment, the court found her testimony coherent, credible and consistent on the material facts.

The court said a conviction may rest on the sole testimony of a child witness when it inspires confidence. Minor variations do not invalidate such evidence, and an allegation of tutoring must be supported through meaningful contradictions, doubtful conduct or incompatibility with the surrounding record. Finding none, the court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the trial court’s judgment and sentence.

Read current report and source

Named Co-Adulterers Must Be Heard Before Adverse Findings

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court has held that a specifically named alleged co-adulterer must receive an opportunity to be heard before a court records an adverse finding against that person.

The ruling came while dismissing a husband’s revision against monthly maintenance of ₹20,000 for his wife and ₹10,000 for their minor son. The court found that electronic material relied upon to allege adultery had not been satisfactorily authenticated and could not conclusively establish the charge.

In its 13 October 2026 judgment, the court affirmed the Family Court’s maintenance order but identified a procedural gap in Section 125 proceedings. It directed the Registrar General to place the issue before the Chief Justice for considering rules governing impleadment or notice to a named alleged co-adulterer. The court stressed that natural justice protects a person from condemnation without hearing, regardless of the ultimate merits.

Read current report and source

Forged Writ Filings Justify Summary Dismissal, Gauhati High Court Warns

Gauhati High Court · Editorial Team

The Gauhati High Court has dismissed Nurul Hoque’s challenge to a Foreigners Tribunal opinion declaring him a foreigner who entered India after 25 March 1971.

In its 12 October 2026 judgment, the court found that copies of the written statement and evidence affidavit filed with the writ petition materially differed from the Tribunal record. It described the use of forged or fabricated pleadings to mislead the court as sufficient ground for summary dismissal, although it still examined the citizenship claim on its merits.

The bench held that the Tribunal had properly assessed the evidence and that Hoque failed to discharge the statutory burden of proving Indian citizenship. It recalled his interim bail, allowed the Tribunal’s consequences to follow, and directed that copies of the writ filings and vakalatnama be sent to the relevant Bar Council.

Read current report and source

J&K&L High Court Rejects PMGSY’s Bid to Reopen ₹7.2 Lakh House Damage Compensation Case

Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court has refused to give road construction authorities another opportunity to build a defence they failed to pursue during trial, upholding a ₹7.2 lakh compensation award to a Ramban resident whose house was damaged during road work. Justice Shahzad Azeem dismissed the appeal filed by the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY) authorities, ruling that a party cannot remain silent during the trial, allow the case to reach an unfavourable conclusion and then seek a fresh hearing by pointing to issues that were not separately framed. The Court upheld the decree passed by the Principal District Judge, Ramban, directing the authorities to pay Mohd. Iqbal ₹7.2 lakh, along with interest at 7.5% per annum from the date the suit was instituted until the amount is recovered.

How road construction damaged the house

Iqbal had approached the trial court seeking compensation for damage to his double-storey house along the Karol-Kumate road in Village Kumate, Ramban. According to his case, earth cutting carried out during road construction created a risk of landslides near the property. Although the department built a protection wall to prevent the soil from slipping, Iqbal alleged that poor-quality construction materials left the structure unable to perform its intended function. The situation worsened in March 2014 after rainfall, when the wall allegedly gave way, leaving cracks and damage to the house. The department disputed responsibility. It maintained that ₹1.75 lakh had already been paid for damage to the earlier house and alleged that Iqbal later demolished the structure and built a multi-storey building at the same location without technical approval. It also attributed the damage to rainfall and the homeowner's own negligence. The trial court, however, ruled in Iqbal's favour and awarded ₹7.2 lakh in compensation, with interest at 7.5% per annum.

Authorities could not revive a defence they never pursued

Before the High Court, the department argued that the trial court had failed to frame specific issues concerning the alleged use of substandard materials in the protection wall and the reconstruction of the house without technical approval. On that basis, it sought additional issues and a remand so the case could be reconsidered. Justice Azeem examined whether the authorities, having participated in the trial without objecting to the issues or seeking their amendment under Order XIV Rule 5 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), could later rely on that omission to challenge the decree. The Court noted that Iqbal had examined four witnesses whose evidence, taken together, supported his claim that road cutting and the failure of the protection wall had contributed to the damage. The department had an opportunity to challenge their testimony. It could have questioned whether the wall was properly constructed or whether the damage stemmed from the homeowner's decision to rebuild without technical advice. However, the relevant suggestions were not put to the witnesses during cross-examination. The Court held that the authorities could not leave the central allegations substantially unchallenged at trial and then use the absence of more specific issues as grounds to reopen the proceedings.

Absence of a separate issue does not automatically invalidate a trial

The High Court clarified that a trial does not become defective merely because a particular issue was not separately framed. What matters is whether the parties understood the dispute and had a fair opportunity to present their respective cases. The decisive consideration, it said, is whether the omission caused prejudice — such as misleading a party about the case it needed to answer or preventing it from producing relevant evidence. The Court found that the authorities had participated in the proceedings with knowledge of the controversy and had the opportunity to challenge the evidence. Their failure to use that opportunity could not subsequently be converted into a ground for a fresh trial. Justice Azeem also pointed to Order XIV Rule 5 CPC, which empowers courts to amend existing issues or frame additional ones at any stage before passing a decree. The department had not invoked that provision during the trial. The High Court consequently declined to send the matter back for another round of proceedings and upheld the compensation decree in Iqbal's favour. The ruling reinforces a basic principle of civil litigation: parties must put their defences to the test when the trial is underway, rather than keeping them in reserve and seeking another chance only after an adverse judgment.

Read current report and source

Zubeen Garg Murder Case: Gauhati High Court Grants Bail to Amritprava Mahanta, Cites Lack of Supporting Evidence

Gauhati High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Gauhati High Court has granted bail to Amritprava Mahanta, one of the accused in the alleged murder of Assamese singer Zubeen Garg, holding that the evidence collected during the investigation and testimonies recorded during the trial had not established a prima facie case against her. Justice Pranjal Das observed that keeping Mahanta behind bars despite the absence of material supporting the allegations would be unjust, particularly given that she had spent nearly a year in custody as an undertrial. “Considering the nature of the materials found on record so far, with regard to A-4 Amritprava Mahanta, it would be a travesty of justice to deny her bail at this stage,” the Court observed in Amritprava Mahanta v. State of Assam. Garg died in Singapore on September 19, 2025, following an incident during a yacht trip. The case was subsequently investigated by the Assam Police's Criminal Investigation Department, which filed a chargesheet against seven people in connection with the alleged murder. Mahanta was accused of being part of a conspiracy to kill the singer by supplying him with alcohol despite allegedly knowing about his medical condition, including epilepsy and seizures. However, the High Court found that the evidence examined so far did not substantiate this allegation. None of the 250 witnesses questioned during the investigation reportedly stated that Mahanta had served alcohol to Garg, administered it to him or forced him to consume it. The Court also noted that the statements of 124 prosecution witnesses examined during the trial had failed to support the accusation. Further, the investigation material did not indicate that Mahanta had arranged Garg's visit to Singapore, organised the yacht trip or encouraged him to swim without a life jacket. In light of these findings, Justice Das concluded that the material available at this stage did not establish a prima facie case of Mahanta's involvement in a conspiracy to murder the singer. The Court also underlined that judicial decisions must remain grounded in evidence rather than public pressure or prevailing sentiment. “A court has to be conscious of society’s sense of justice, but cannot be captive to it,” the judge observed. While granting bail, the High Court considered Mahanta's prolonged undertrial detention, the absence of any criminal antecedents and the statutory provisions relating to bail for women. She was directed to furnish a bail bond of ₹50,000 along with two sureties. The Court also imposed conditions requiring her to cooperate with the trial, refrain from influencing witnesses and obtain permission before travelling abroad. The High Court clarified that its observations were limited to the consideration of bail and would not influence the final determination of the case, which remains pending trial.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Raises Compensation for 74-Year-Old Accident Victim, Says Unpaid Household Work Has Real Value

Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees

A woman’s contribution to her family does not lose its worth with age. Reinforcing this principle, the Delhi High Court has ruled that unpaid household and caregiving services performed by a homemaker cannot be ignored while calculating motor accident compensation simply because she is above 70 years old. Justice Anish Dayal observed that assumptions about old age must not determine whether a person’s contribution to the household deserves recognition. Women continue to perform domestic duties and care for family members well into their seventies and beyond, the Court noted. The ruling came in an appeal filed by Ganga Devi, who was 74 when a bus accident in February 2019 crushed both her legs, leaving her with 74% permanent disability affecting both lower limbs. The Motor Accident Claims Tribunal had awarded her ₹14.42 lakh in compensation but rejected her claims for loss of income and future income. Its reasoning was that she was an elderly woman who had never held formal employment and had not sufficiently established her contribution to household work. The High Court found this approach unacceptable, cautioning against age-based assumptions that effectively erase the economic value of unpaid domestic labour. The Court pointed out that older people are not merely recipients of care within families. They also continue to contribute through everyday household responsibilities and activities such as looking after grandchildren. It further emphasised that domestic work has tangible economic value, even when no salary is paid for it. Cooking, childcare and other household responsibilities would otherwise require families to spend money on paid services. In its observations, the Court said the absence of monetary remuneration cannot become a reason to reduce compensation payable to an injured person or benefit the party responsible for the harm. Compensation recalculated using skilled-worker wages Rejecting the tribunal’s assessment, the High Court directed that Ganga Devi’s notional monthly income be calculated on the basis of the minimum wages applicable to a skilled worker in Delhi at the time of the accident. The applicable monthly wage was ₹16,962. Using this figure, the Court enhanced the compensation by ₹6.37 lakh. The judgment in Ganga Devi v. Rajesh Kumar & Ors. underscores that the economic worth of a homemaker’s work cannot be measured solely by whether she earns a salary. It also makes clear that advancing age, by itself, cannot justify overlooking the services a person continues to provide to their family.

Read current report and source

J&K High Court Tightens Practice Rules: AIBE Now Compulsory for Lawyers Enrolled Since 2009-10

Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court · Sheikh Rayees

Advocates enrolled with the Bar Council of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh from the 2009-10 academic year onwards will have to clear the All India Bar Examination (AIBE) to continue practising law, following a fresh directive issued by the Jammu and Kashmir High Court. The requirement, already prescribed by the Bar Council of India (BCI) for law graduates from 2009-10 onwards, had not been formally enforced for advocates enrolled with the regional Bar Council. The High Court has now moved to bring the enrolment process in line with the national rules. A notification issued by Registrar General MK Sharma on October 10 sets out the requirements for both existing advocates and newly enrolled law graduates. Under the directive, law graduates who enrolled with the Bar Council of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh after completing their degrees in the 2009-10 academic year or later must pass the AIBE if they have not already done so. Newly enrolled advocates face a two-year deadline Fresh law graduates and advocates holding provisional enrolment will receive an absolute certificate of enrolment only after clearing the AIBE and submitting the Certificate of Practice (COP) issued by the Bar Council of India. The prescribed deadline for completing these requirements is two years. The High Court has also directed advocates enrolled after July 1, 2010, who have already passed the examination, to submit copies of their Certificates of Practice to the Registry within one month. The move follows a Full Court decision taken on October 8 to accept a recommendation made by the Rules Committee on August 19. The recommendation called for the implementation of Rules 9, 10 and 11 of Chapter III, Part VI of the Bar Council of India Rules, which govern the examination and certification requirements for advocates. AIBE clearance linked to the right to practise Rule 9 of the BCI Rules requires advocates to pass the All India Bar Examination to become eligible to practise under Chapter IV of the Advocates Act, 1961. Rule 11 deals with the issuance of Certificates of Practice to candidates who successfully clear the examination. With the High Court's latest notification, advocates covered by the directive will have to ensure that their examination and certification requirements are fulfilled within the prescribed timelines.

Read current report and source

Kerala High Court Wants Illegal Vehicle Modifications Captured on Camera in Accident Reports

Kerala High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Kerala High Court has directed the Motor Vehicles Department (MVD) to include photographs and videos documenting unauthorised vehicle modifications in accident inspection reports uploaded to the Electronic Detailed Accident Report (e-DAR) portal. The direction aims to strengthen road safety monitoring by ensuring that potentially dangerous alterations are properly documented whenever a modified vehicle is involved in an accident. A Bench of Justices Anil K Narendran and Muralee Krishna S issued the order on October 8 while hearing a suo motu case concerning road safety and unauthorised modifications to vehicles in Kerala. The Court directed the Transport Commissioner to ensure that inspecting officers record details of vehicle modifications and upload supporting photographs and videos to the online portal. The documentation must cover alterations that violate safety standards and could increase the risk of injury to people struck by a vehicle or coming into contact with its bodywork. Particular attention must be given to illegal engine modifications intended to boost performance and changes to braking systems.

Court flags gaps in accident inspection reports

The order followed instructions issued by the Transport Commissioner on September 17, directing transport officials to document modifications found during inspections of accident-involved vehicles. Although the e-DAR portal already provides designated fields for recording such alterations and uploading visual evidence, the Court was informed that some inspecting officers had failed to upload photographs as required. The Transport Commissioner subsequently instructed officials to ensure that colour photographs showing unauthorised modifications were uploaded during inspections. A separate technical issue also came to light. While photographs uploaded to the portal could be viewed and downloaded online, they were not appearing in printed versions of the accident inspection reports. The Court impleaded the National Informatics Centre (NIC) to address the problem and directed the State Police Chief to ensure compliance with its earlier road safety directions.

₹5,000 fine for each unauthorised modification

The latest order also reiterates the Court's concern over vehicles fitted with excessively bright or prohibited lighting systems that can temporarily impair the vision of approaching drivers and pedestrians. Unauthorised installations, including illegal LED lights, neon lights, laser lights and strobe lights, attract a fine of ₹5,000 for each modification, as specified in the Court's earlier directions. By requiring visual evidence alongside inspection findings, the Court has sought to make the reporting process more comprehensive and ensure that hazardous alterations do not go undocumented when accident cases are examined.

Read current report and source