Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

15 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 17 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Supreme Court Rejects Grant-In-Aid Absorption, Awards ₹10 Lakh
  2. Supreme Court Orders University to Issue Withheld Degree Records
  3. Supreme Court Rejects Automatic Backward Class Status After Conversion
  4. Supreme Court Questions Criminal-Civil Split in Article 226 Appeals
  5. Supreme Court Restores Sand Mining Bids Rejected Without Current Valuation
  6. Supreme Court Clarifies IBC Appeal Limitation Starts at Pronouncement
  7. Supreme Court Draws a Line on College Fee Hikes, Says Students Must Know Full Course Costs Before Admission
  8. Delhi High Court Restores Minority School Appeal, Limits Suspension
  9. Allahabad High Court Defines Wilful Neglect Under SC/ST Act
  10. Madras High Court Awards Priest’s Post-Vow Assets to Religious Society
  11. Karnataka High Court Imposes Cost After Counsel’s ‘God’ Argument
  12. Uttarakhand High Court Quashes Rape Trial After Consensual Relationship Ends
  13. Allahabad High Court Lets Adult Corpus Return to Husband
  14. Allahabad High Court Sets Aside Unreasoned Police Probe Order
  15. Gujarat High Court Quashes FIR Over Recording Police
  16. SEBI Keeps Rajesh Exports Chairman Out of Markets, Flags ₹77 Crore Court Deposit Concealment
  17. Karnataka High Court Says Mallya’s Lavish Lifestyle Continues to Cast a Shadow Over Kingfisher Loan Recovery

Supreme Court Rejects Grant-In-Aid Absorption, Awards ₹10 Lakh

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has rejected a lecturer’s claim to absorption into a grant-in-aid post, holding that service in a no-grant college created no legal entitlement to appointment against a government-funded position.

It also found the writ petition procedurally defective because Maharashtra, the entity bearing the financial liability, had not been impleaded in its juristic capacity. The court reiterated that unequal or unlawful benefits granted elsewhere cannot create a claim to “negative equality”.

Allowing the state’s appeals on 13 October 2026, the bench set aside the direction requiring absorption. However, using Article 142, it ordered Maharashtra to pay lecturer Sudhir ₹10 lakh within eight weeks. Compensation already paid by the college management will remain with him.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Orders University to Issue Withheld Degree Records

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has directed a university to issue a former student’s withheld academic records, finding that she was deprived of them because of administrative and clerical failures for which she was not responsible.

Stuti Sharma completed her course, but Manav Bharti University withheld marksheets for semesters seven to ten, her degree and related certificates amid questions over admission records. The court said a student who had pursued and completed the programme could not bear the consequences of the institution’s errors.

Allowing her appeal on 24 September 2026, the bench set aside the High Court order to the extent it affected her. The university must provide the remaining marksheets, degree, character certificate and migration certificate within four weeks.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Rejects Automatic Backward Class Status After Conversion

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has held that conversion to Islam does not automatically place a person within any notified Backward Class Muslim community in Tamil Nadu.

The dispute concerned a convert who had belonged to a backward Hindu community and sought a community certificate as a Labbai Muslim. The court said former caste status cannot simply be transposed after conversion, and a private religious certificate cannot conclusively establish statutory entitlement.

Affirming the Madras High Court, the bench struck down the government order that created such a route without proof of the required social and legal connection to a notified community. It stressed that a community certificate declares an existing status; it does not create one or override constitutional conditions. The special leave petition was dismissed on 15 October 2026.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Questions Criminal-Civil Split in Article 226 Appeals

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has asked a larger bench to reconsider whether Article 226 proceedings can be divided into “civil” and “criminal” categories when deciding if an intra-court appeal is maintainable.

Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu expressed respectful disagreement with Ram Kishan Fauji v State of Haryana. They questioned whether that decision correctly interpreted the Letters Patent and whether its approach restricts access to an appellate bench through a distinction not found in Article 226.

The 14 October 2026 order did not decide the underlying dispute on merits. It allowed the appellant to file a Special Appeal within a fortnight, stayed contempt proceedings for two months and directed that the constitutional questions be placed before the Chief Justice for assignment to an appropriate bench.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Restores Sand Mining Bids Rejected Without Current Valuation

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has restored two winning bids for sand-mining groups in Madhya Pradesh, holding that a public authority cannot reject the highest offer merely by comparing it with the bidder’s earlier, higher contract price.

The court said the corporation lacked current material showing that the October 2025 bids for Shahdol and Katni were inadequate. Earlier surrenders and a later participation restriction could not retrospectively justify cancelling a completed auction.

In its 14 October 2026 judgment, the court directed the bidders to confirm their offers and complete security requirements. The corporation must then finish approval and allotment, while the later tender process for the two groups cannot proceed. Disputes concerning dues under earlier contracts were left open.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Clarifies IBC Appeal Limitation Starts at Pronouncement

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has ruled that the limitation period for an appeal under section 62 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code begins when the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal pronounces its order, not when a certified copy is received.

In Assistant Commissioner of Central Tax v Sreenivasa Rao Ravinuthala, the appellant applied for a copy on the thirty-fifth day after pronouncement. Even after excluding the time needed to obtain it, the appeal was filed after 76 actionable days.

The court said section 62 permits 45 days to appeal and a further condonable period of only 15 days. Receipt of the certified copy cannot postpone that statutory starting point. It upheld the preliminary objection and dismissed the appeal as time-barred on 14 October 2026.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Draws a Line on College Fee Hikes, Says Students Must Know Full Course Costs Before Admission

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has ruled that professional colleges must determine and disclose the fee structure for the entire duration of a course before admissions begin, stressing that students and their families should not face unexpected financial burdens midway through their studies. In its judgment in Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College v. State of West Bengal, a bench of Justices PS Narasimha and Alok Aradhe held that fees ordinarily cannot be increased once students have enrolled, except in exceptional circumstances involving unforeseen expenditure. The Court emphasised that students enrolling in four- or five-year professional programmes must have a clear understanding of the financial commitment they are taking on. Fee-setting authorities, it said, must plan ahead rather than leave students uncertain about future costs. The ruling places particular responsibility on fee fixation committees to assess institutional expenses, account for foreseeable cost increases and make recommendations sufficiently early for the competent authorities to finalise fees before the admission process starts.

Engineering colleges' fee revision challenged

The case arose from a fee dispute involving Dr. B.C. Roy Engineering College and other private institutions in West Bengal. Students admitted to four-year BTech programmes for the 2023–27 batch joined in September 2023. The state government subsequently issued a notification on October 16, 2023, raising the annual tuition fee ceiling for self-financing professional colleges to ₹1.10 lakh. The college revised its fee structure on December 15, 2023, implementing the increase from the second semester in January 2024. Under the revised structure, semester tuition fees for certain engineering branches rose from ₹44,000 to ₹60,500, while fees for other branches increased from ₹40,000 to ₹55,000. A development fee was also introduced. Students challenged the decision, arguing against the imposition of higher charges after they had already secured admission. A single-judge bench of the Calcutta High Court initially dismissed their petitions on January 15, 2026, relying on a clause in the admission prospectus that allowed fees to change in accordance with government decisions. However, a division bench overturned that decision on March 23, 2026. It ruled that the revised fees could apply only to students admitted on or after October 16, 2023. The colleges were consequently directed to refund the excess amounts collected from students admitted before that date or adjust the sums against their fees for the following semester. The institutions then challenged the High Court's decision before the Supreme Court.

Existing students protected, but High Court's reasoning modified

The Supreme Court upheld the directions protecting students who had enrolled before the government's fee notification from the subsequent increase. However, it disagreed with the High Court's reliance on the principles of equity and estoppel, as well as its reasoning on retrospectivity. The bench set aside that part of the High Court's judgment, holding that the legal basis adopted for restricting the fee hike was unsustainable. It nevertheless maintained the protection granted to students against the revised charges. The Court's approach centred instead on the need for advance fee determination and certainty throughout a student's course. It clarified that a student should ordinarily know the applicable financial liability at the time of admission, and that changes to the fee structure during the course must remain exceptional.

Fee committees must plan for the entire course

The judgment calls for fee fixation committees to operate as continuing regulatory institutions rather than bodies that make isolated or delayed assessments. Such committees must examine legitimate institutional expenses, including infrastructure, faculty salaries, maintenance, technology, statutory obligations and other necessary costs. They must also estimate foreseeable increases in expenditure over the full duration of a programme. Their recommendations should reach the competent authorities well before admissions commence, allowing institutions to announce a reliable fee structure from the outset. The Court observed that advance disclosure serves several purposes: it promotes transparency, enables students to make informed choices and helps families plan their finances. It also stressed that High Courts must ensure that fee fixation committees discharge their responsibilities efficiently, with the necessary expertise and integrity.

Fee increases still possible in exceptional cases

The ruling does not prohibit every future adjustment to college fees. The Supreme Court acknowledged that extraordinary economic conditions, changes in statutory requirements or other genuinely unforeseeable circumstances could lead to expenses that could not reasonably have been anticipated when the original fee structure was fixed. A narrowly defined mechanism may therefore be established to accommodate such situations. However, the bench made clear that exceptional revisions cannot become a routine practice or serve as an excuse for inadequate planning. The central principle, it held, is that students must have certainty about their financial obligations, with fee variations during a course permitted only in exceptional circumstances, such as an unforeseen increase in expenditure. The appeals were partly allowed, with the Court maintaining the protection against the disputed fee increase for students who had already enrolled while modifying the High Court's reasoning on the issue.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Restores Minority School Appeal, Limits Suspension

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court has restored a minority school’s appeal against a teacher’s dismissal, holding that the absence of a formal minority-status certificate was not by itself conclusive.

The court set aside the Delhi School Tribunal’s order and revived the appeal on the limited grounds available to a recognised minority institution. It directed the tribunal to decide the matter on priority, preferably within four months.

In a connected dispute, the court held that a teacher’s suspension lapsed because approval was not obtained within the statutory 15-day period. The Directorate of Education’s salary directions therefore remained operative, and the school must pay the balance suspension-period salary within eight weeks. The judgment was delivered on 13 October 2026.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Defines Wilful Neglect Under SC/ST Act

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court has held that dissatisfaction with a police investigation, without more, cannot establish “wilful neglect” of official duties under section 4 of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act.

The court said liability requires identification of a specific statutory duty and evidence that a public servant deliberately failed to perform it. The Act also contemplates an administrative inquiry and recommendation before criminal action is pursued for such neglect.

In its 13 October 2026 decision, the court found no material demonstrating an intentional breach by the investigating officers. It dismissed the complainant’s appeal and affirmed the Special Judge’s refusal to proceed against them. A copy of the order was directed to be transmitted within 48 hours.

Read current report and source

Madras High Court Awards Priest’s Post-Vow Assets to Religious Society

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court has held that assets acquired by a Catholic priest after entering a religious order belonged beneficially to his society, despite standing in his personal name.

The dispute concerned ₹56 lakh in fixed deposits left by Father Devakumar Arulanantham. The court distinguished property acquired through a priest’s vocation after perpetual vows from assets independently inherited from family. Only the former was at issue.

Allowing the society’s appeals on 13 October 2026, the bench set aside succession orders favouring the priest’s relatives and recognised the society’s claim. Because the relatives had withdrawn the deposits during the appeal, they must return the money within one month. A failure to repay will attract nine per cent annual interest from the judgment date.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Imposes Cost After Counsel’s ‘God’ Argument

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court has dismissed a petition seeking to quash criminal proceedings over the sale of temple property and imposed ₹15,000 in exemplary costs after an objectionable submission by counsel.

The petitioners argued that the allegations should be terminated at the threshold. Justice H.P. Sandesh held that disputed questions about their knowledge of the land grant and subsequent sale required trial; their defence could not be tested under the court’s limited inherent jurisdiction.

After the court indicated its conclusion, counsel submitted that “God cannot represent” before a court or land tribunal. The 9 October 2026 order described the conduct as improper and potentially contemptuous, but chose costs instead. The amount must be paid to the Registry within one week, failing which it may be recovered as land revenue.

Read current report and source

Uttarakhand High Court Quashes Rape Trial After Consensual Relationship Ends

Uttarakhand High Court · Editorial Team

The Uttarakhand High Court has quashed a rape prosecution arising from a relationship between two educated adults who met through a matrimonial website.

The complaint referred to sexual relations during trips to Rishikesh and Coorg with common friends. The court noted that the complainant raised no prompt protest and initially sought action under domestic-violence law months later. It found that the record described a voluntary relationship that subsequently failed.

Justice Alok Mahra said the criminal law cannot be used to criminalise the mere breakdown of a consensual adult relationship. The 9 October 2026 order set aside the trial court’s refusal to discharge Kunal Bhakat and quashed the sessions case against him.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Lets Adult Corpus Return to Husband

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court has permitted a woman to leave court with her husband after finding, for purposes of a habeas corpus petition, that the available statutory evidence treated her as an adult.

Her family relied on a Class V transfer certificate stating that she was born in 2010. The court said no school birth certificate, matriculation record or municipal certificate was produced in the hierarchy prescribed by section 94 of the Juvenile Justice Act. An ossification test assessed her age at about 18.

The 5 October 2026 order allowed the petition but expressly insulated the pending POCSO trial: its factual observations cannot be used by the defence or considered by the trial court. A copy was also sent to the Law Commission amid broader concerns about cases involving marriage and young families.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Sets Aside Unreasoned Police Probe Order

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court has set aside an order directing a criminal investigation against police personnel because the Special Judge failed to apply the safeguards introduced by sections 175(3) and 175(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita.

The court said the judge treated allegations in Sandhya Jaiswal’s complaint as conclusive without deciding whether a preliminary inquiry was necessary, considering the police report already obtained or examining the requirements governing complaints against public servants.

Calling the 2 September order non-speaking and unreasoned, Justice Santosh Rai held that the omission amounted to material non-application of mind. The 13 October 2026 judgment allowed the appeal, set aside the investigation order and quashed consequential proceedings arising from it.

Read current report and source

Gujarat High Court Quashes FIR Over Recording Police

Gujarat High Court · Editorial Team

The Gujarat High Court has quashed a criminal case against lawyer and social activist Mehul Mansukhbhai Boghara, finding that video footage contradicted allegations that he obstructed or assaulted police personnel during a roadside encounter.

In its 14 October 2026 judgment, the court said the recording showed no aggressive gesture or use of force by Boghara. It found the police version of attempted extortion inherently implausible and noted that he was the person injured in the episode.

The court held that the complaint disclosed none of the essential ingredients of offences under sections 332, 353, 385 and 427 of the Indian Penal Code or the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. It quashed the FIR and all consequential proceedings against him.

Read current report and source

SEBI Keeps Rajesh Exports Chairman Out of Markets, Flags ₹77 Crore Court Deposit Concealment

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) has upheld its interim restrictions barring Rajesh Mehta, chairman of Rajesh Exports Limited (REL), from buying, selling or otherwise dealing in the company’s securities, citing serious concerns over financial reporting, fund transfers and corporate governance. In an order dated October 14, Whole Time Member Kamlesh C Varshney confirmed the earlier directions against Mehta and the company, requiring them to cooperate with an ongoing forensic audit and provide complete and accurate disclosures. The regulator’s intervention follows allegations of significant financial discrepancies, transactions that could not be independently verified and lapses in corporate governance at the listed gold refining company.

Revenue figures raise questions

One of SEBI’s major concerns was the substantial gap between REL’s reported consolidated revenues and the figures recorded by its Swiss operating subsidiary, Valcambi SA. According to the order, REL reported consolidated revenues exceeding ₹15 lakh crore between FY21 and FY25, while Valcambi’s standalone revenue during the period stood at ₹3,027.38 crore. SEBI highlighted the nearly 99% disparity as a matter requiring explanation. The regulator also questioned an investment of ₹1,035.27 crore in African gold mines that could not be verified. Additionally, it flagged the netting-off of ₹2,914 crore in overdue trade receivables.

₹77 crore routed through chairman’s personal account

The movement of company funds through the personal bank accounts of Rajesh Mehta and his son, Siddharth Mehta, emerged as another key issue in the proceedings. SEBI rejected the argument that Mehta was merely acting as an authorised intermediary for commercial transactions. It maintained that routing corporate money through a director’s personal account raises concerns about unauthorised financial arrangements and compliance with disclosure requirements. The regulator stressed that the eventual use of the money does not automatically legitimise the manner in which it was transferred. Particular concern was expressed over REL’s admission that ₹77 crore had been routed through Mehta’s personal account for a court deposit to avoid revealing the company’s identity before the Karnataka High Court. During the hearing, Mehta reportedly argued that the arrangement was intended to preserve plausible deniability regarding the liability of the actual judgment debtor. SEBI took a dim view of the explanation, stating that deliberately withholding such information from a court undermined confidence in the company’s governance practices. The order described the admission as a serious concern, particularly because the transaction involved directions issued by the Karnataka High Court.

Swiss confidentiality cannot override SEBI requirements

The regulator also rejected REL’s reliance on Swiss confidentiality laws and private non-disclosure agreements to withhold customer and vendor information from the investigation. SEBI held that private contractual arrangements cannot restrict the exercise of its statutory powers or allow listed companies to sidestep regulatory obligations. Accepting such a defence, it said, could enable companies to avoid necessary disclosures under the cover of confidentiality agreements, potentially compromising investor interests.

Trading restrictions to continue

SEBI has directed the forensic auditor and investigating authority to accelerate their examination of the matter. It also maintained that continuing the trading restrictions against Mehta was necessary to safeguard public investors and protect the integrity of the securities market. The order keeps the restrictions in force until further directions, leaving the company’s financial disclosures, disputed transactions and governance practices under regulatory scrutiny.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Says Mallya’s Lavish Lifestyle Continues to Cast a Shadow Over Kingfisher Loan Recovery

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Karnataka High Court has criticised Vijay Mallya’s extravagant lifestyle and personal excesses, observing that they appear to be standing in the way of bringing the long-running bank recovery dispute linked to the collapse of Kingfisher Airlines to a close. The remarks came as a Division Bench of Justice D K Singh and Justice T M Nadaf ruled in favour of Diageo Holdings Netherlands BV in a dispute over shares in United Breweries Limited (UBL) pledged as security for a loan. At the heart of the case was a contest between Diageo and a consortium of banks led by the State Bank of India over the right to claim the shares held by Mallya, including those jointly owned with his son, Sidhartha Mallya.

Banks Have Recovered More Than Double the Loan Amount

The Court pointed out that the banking consortium had recovered assets worth ₹14,131.6 crore against the ₹6,203 crore loan extended to the now-defunct Kingfisher Airlines. In light of those recoveries, the Bench questioned why the banks were continuing to pursue the United Breweries shares as well. The judges observed that the substantial recovery already achieved left little justification for an additional claim over the shares, adding that the remaining proceedings could be brought to an end by the banks and the Government of India. The Bench also delivered a sharp assessment of Mallya’s business downfall, linking the collapse of his corporate empire to excessive personal indulgence, vanity, recklessness and an overreliance on personal image. His reputation as the “King of Good Times”, the Court noted, became closely tied to the flamboyant lifestyle that defined his public persona. But the debt-heavy expansion of Kingfisher Airlines ultimately ended in financial ruin. The judges remarked that the experience illustrated how decades of disciplined work could be undone within a few years when financial prudence gives way to lavish spending and unchecked ambition. The Bench said Mallya’s personal excesses and vanity appeared to be obstructing the settlement of the consortium’s claims arising from the airline’s ₹6,203 crore borrowing.

Diageo’s Earlier Pledge Takes Priority

The dispute arose from a $135 million loan that Standard Chartered Bank extended to Watson Ltd, an overseas company associated with Mallya, in July 2013. United Breweries shares were pledged as security, while Diageo guaranteed the borrowing. When Watson defaulted, Diageo paid Standard Chartered $140.97 million in January 2016. It subsequently asserted that it had acquired the bank’s rights and could enforce the existing pledge over the shares. However, interim orders obtained by the banking consortium during recovery proceedings against Kingfisher Airlines had placed restrictions on the shares. The banks argued that the shares could be used to recover the airline’s outstanding dues and disputed the effectiveness of Diageo’s claim. Their position was also linked to a Master Debt Recast Agreement executed on December 21, 2010, under which Mallya and United Breweries had guaranteed repayment of the airline’s borrowing. After the Debt Recovery Tribunal and the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal ruled against Diageo, the company approached the High Court. The High Court concluded that the pledge created in favour of Standard Chartered in 2013 had priority over the banking consortium’s claim arising from the earlier 2010 agreement.

Son’s Jointly Held Shares Also Examined

The Bench separately considered the position of shares jointly held by Mallya and his son, Sidhartha Mallya. It noted that Sidhartha was not a party to the Master Debt Recast Agreement with the banks. It further held that Mallya’s personal guarantee did not, on its own, establish a proprietary charge over shares jointly owned by the two. The ruling therefore addressed not only the competing claims over the pledged shares but also the limits of the banks’ ability to assert rights over jointly held assets. Allowing Diageo’s appeal, the High Court set aside the orders passed by the Debt Recovery Tribunal and the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal. The decision places Diageo’s earlier share pledge ahead of the banking consortium’s competing claim, while the Court’s broader observations put renewed focus on the prolonged effort to resolve the financial fallout of Kingfisher Airlines’ collapse.

Read current report and source