Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

22 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 16 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Supreme Court Acquits Murder Accused As WhatsApp Messages Fail To Establish Guilt
  2. WhatsApp ‘OK’ Is Not Enough to Prove Leave Approval, CAT Rules in Railway Employee’s Transfer Case
  3. Bombay High Court Awards Compensation To Passenger Injured On Bus Footboard
  4. Kerala High Court Quashes Preventive Detention After Unexplained Delay
  5. Bombay High Court Rejects Adverse Possession Defence By Permissive Occupants
  6. Karnataka High Court Retains Homicide Charge Against Father In Minor’s Fatal Driving Case
  7. Bombay High Court Rejects Compassionate Pension Claim After Disciplinary Finding Of Theft
  8. Chhattisgarh High Court Quashes COVID Wedding Fines Imposed Without Adjudication
  9. Madras High Court Requires Written Summons And Diary Records For Police Enquiries
  10. Karnataka High Court Orders Contempt Proceedings After Dismissing FIR-Quashing Petition
  11. Delhi High Court Protects Property Share From Auction Amid Mortgage Forgery Dispute
  12. Delhi High Court Rejects Vague Lawyer-Negligence Plea To Reopen Commercial Decree
  13. Mumbai’s Pollution Crisis Alarms Bombay High Court as Judges Slam Lax Enforcement of Firecracker Ban
  14. Telangana High Court: Accepting Sale Money for Years Undermines Fraud Claim Against Lok Adalat Award
  15. Karnataka High Court: Archived Court Hearing Recordings Cannot Be Claimed as a Right Without Judicial Approval
  16. Kerala High Court Stands Firm on 10-Year Sentence in Assault Case Involving 73-Year-Old Woman

Supreme Court Acquits Murder Accused As WhatsApp Messages Fail To Establish Guilt

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court has acquitted Kusumlal Sao of murder and destruction-of-evidence charges, finding that disputed WhatsApp messages and inconclusive recoveries did not complete the prosecution’s circumstantial chain.

Judge / Bench — Justices Manoj Misra and Vijay Bishnoi; judgment by Justice Manoj Misra.

The 13 October 2026 judgment found no substantive evidence that the deceased was last seen with Sao. The alleged message sender denied sending it, and both relevant witnesses denied witnessing the incident. Extraction of messages did not establish the author’s personal knowledge or prove an assault.

Bloodstains were not connected to the deceased through matching forensic evidence, and recovery witnesses differed. An accidental fall from a motorcycle also remained a reasonable possibility. Setting aside the trial and High Court judgments, the court ordered Sao’s immediate release unless required in another case.

Advocates appearing — For the appellant — Yasharth Kant. For the respondent State — Ankita Sharma.

Read current report and source

WhatsApp ‘OK’ Is Not Enough to Prove Leave Approval, CAT Rules in Railway Employee’s Transfer Case

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

A brief ‘OK’ on WhatsApp may acknowledge a message, but it does not necessarily establish that an employee’s leave has been formally approved. The Allahabad Bench of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) has made this distinction while rejecting a railway employee’s challenge to his transfer, holding that the response alone could not conclusively establish sanction by the competent authority. In Priya Ranjan v. Union of India, Judicial Member Rajnish Kumar Rai also ruled that a transfer cannot automatically be branded punitive simply because disciplinary proceedings follow. The case concerned Priya Ranjan Kumar, an employee of North Central Railway, who challenged his transfer from Prayagraj to Fatehpur. According to Kumar, he had taken three days of leave from July 14 to 16, 2025, to visit his native village. He later sought an additional two days through WhatsApp, claiming that Senior Divisional Commercial Manager Himanshu Shukla had approved the extension by replying ‘OK’. However, Kumar was suspended when he returned to duty on July 21. A transfer order followed on July 25, moving him to Fatehpur, and a disciplinary charge-sheet was issued on July 31. Kumar maintained that the sequence of events indicated that the transfer was intended to punish him over the leave dispute rather than serve a genuine administrative purpose. The Railways disputed this claim, explaining that the transfer was required in connection with the development of a new entry and booking office at Fatehpur Railway Station.

Tribunal finds no conclusive proof of leave sanction

The Tribunal declined to accept the WhatsApp exchange as definitive evidence that the leave extension had been authorised by the competent authority. It observed that the employee’s reliance on the ‘OK’ response could not, by itself, establish that the leave had been sanctioned. The Bench also examined whether the transfer was a disguised form of punishment. Referring to the Supreme Court’s ruling in Somesh Tiwari v. Union of India, it reiterated that an administrative transfer used as a substitute for punishment would not be legally sustainable. In this case, however, the Tribunal found that the Railways had provided an independent administrative reason for shifting Kumar to Fatehpur. The circumstances did not sufficiently establish that the transfer was driven by mala fide intentions or designed to penalise him. Finding no grounds to interfere with the transfer order, the Tribunal dismissed Kumar’s application. The ruling underscores an important distinction in workplace communications: a brief acknowledgement on a messaging platform may not, on its own, settle whether formal approval has been granted. It also reinforces that the legality of a transfer depends on its underlying purpose and justification, rather than merely on the timing of subsequent disciplinary action.

Read current report and source

Bombay High Court Awards Compensation To Passenger Injured On Bus Footboard

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court has awarded ₹2,10,365 to an injured bus passenger, overturning dismissal of his compensation claim after finding fault with both the passenger and the moving bus’s driver.

Judge / Bench — Justice S.M. Modak.

Deciding Mohan Laxman Chavan’s appeal on 22 October 2026, the court said the tribunal had concentrated on his footboard position while overlooking the driver’s failure to take precautions when overtaking a stationary bus. Negligence could be inferred from the circumstances and oral evidence; police papers were not conclusive.

The Transport Manager and Director of Insurance must pay jointly and severally within twelve weeks, with 7.5% annual interest from the claim petition until realisation, deducting any no-fault payment.

Advocates appearing — Appellant — T.J. Mendon. Respondent 1 — Vedant Bende, instructed by Mandar Limaye. Respondent 2 — P.M. Bhansali with Arafat Siddique. Respondent 3 — Rashmi S. Tendulkar, Assistant Government Pleader.

Read current report and source

Kerala High Court Quashes Preventive Detention After Unexplained Delay

Kerala High Court · Editorial Team

The Kerala High Court has quashed a preventive-detention order after finding that unexplained delay broke the connection between the alleged drug activity and the need for detention.

Judge / Bench — Justices Anil K. Narendran and Muralee Krishna S.; judgment by Justice Muralee Krishna S.

The 8 October 2026 judgment allowed Sajina C.V.’s challenge to her mother Kamarunnisa C.V.’s detention under the PITNDPS Act. Although officials described earlier processing steps, they did not explain the period from 8 September 2025 until the detention order of 17 October 2025. Mere listing of administrative steps was insufficient where liberty was curtailed without trial.

The court rejected a separate challenge based on failure to seek bail cancellation, holding that its necessity depends on the facts. It directed immediate release unless detention was required in another case.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner — Anagha Krishna and Shabnam Kodalil. Respondents — Ratheesh P.R., Central Government Counsel, and Chethan Krishna, Government Pleader.

Read current report and source

Bombay High Court Rejects Adverse Possession Defence By Permissive Occupants

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court has dismissed a property second appeal, holding that merely pleading adverse possession does not shift the burden of proof to the true owner where occupation began with permission.

Judge / Bench — Justice Sandeep V. Marne.

The 21 October 2026 judgment in Chandrahas Jethalal Patel’s appeal affirmed findings that a relative had entered permissively and later built partly on the owners’ land. Long occupation did not establish possession hostile to their title.

The court also rejected a belated objection to the property description: the defendants understood the encroachment, which the survey map identified. Permissive possession did not start Article 65’s limitation period. The appeal was dismissed with costs, leaving the possession and demolition decree intact.

Advocates appearing — Appellants — R.D. Soni, instructed by Ram & Co. Respondent 2 — D.S. Mhaispurkar. Respondents 5–6 — Rajendra M. Haridas. Other respondents — Not named in the judgment.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Retains Homicide Charge Against Father In Minor’s Fatal Driving Case

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court has refused to remove a culpable-homicide charge against a father accused of repeatedly allowing his 14-year-old son to drive a car involved in a collision that killed three people.

Judge / Bench — Justice M. Nagaprasanna.

Rejecting Nadeem Ur Rehman’s petition on 16 October 2026, the court said fatal consequences alone cannot convert negligence into culpable homicide. But the charge-sheet alleged a positive act of handing over the keys and repeated permission to drive. Those allegations could not be discarded by accepting his defence that the child took the vehicle without consent.

The prosecution must prove the knowledge required by Section 304 Part II IPC. The trial court must determine culpability independently, uninfluenced by the High Court’s observations at the discharge stage.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner — Pallava R. Respondent 1 — B.N. Jagadeesha, State Public Prosecutor-I, with Rashmi Patel, High Court Government Pleader. Respondent 2 — Not named in the order.

Read current report and source

Bombay High Court Rejects Compassionate Pension Claim After Disciplinary Finding Of Theft

Bombay High Court · Editorial Team

The Bombay High Court has rejected a former court employee’s claim for compassionate pension after his removal for theft, holding that the circumstances did not warrant special consideration under the Maharashtra pension rules.

Judge / Bench — Justices Kishore C. Sant and Jitendra Jain; judgment by Justice Jitendra Jain.

The 19 October 2026 judgment concerned Waman Shamrao Kulkarni’s claim for the period between his 1998 removal and 2004 dismissal. The court treated compassionate pension after removal as discretionary under Rule 101, rather than applying the separate prohibition concerning dismissed employees to that interval.

The employer’s reasoned refusal disclosed no unfairness or perversity. Length of service did not outweigh the disciplinary theft finding, and unexplained delay independently defeated relief. The petition was dismissed.

Advocates appearing — Petitioner — Neha B. Kamble. Respondent — Rajendraa Deshmukh, senior counsel, with Meenal S. Deshmukh, instructed by Mukul Kulkarni.

Read current report and source

Chhattisgarh High Court Quashes COVID Wedding Fines Imposed Without Adjudication

Chhattisgarh High Court · Editorial Team

The Chhattisgarh High Court has quashed fines imposed by a Sub-Divisional Magistrate over an allegedly overcrowded wedding during COVID restrictions, finding no authority for unilateral monetary penalties without the prescribed adjudication.

Judge / Bench — Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad.

The 13 October 2026 order in Saroj Sahu’s petition and two connected cases held that the Disaster Management Act required a complaint and lawful adjudication. Section 3 of the Epidemic Diseases Act did not independently empower executive authorities to levy fines. The underlying FIR had already been quashed.

The court set aside all three penalty orders and directed Ambikapur Municipal Corporation to refund the marriage-garden proprietor’s deposited ₹4.75 lakh within three months of receiving a certified copy. It made no costs order.

Advocates appearing — Petitioners — Prafull N. Bharat, senior advocate, with Vishal Sahu. State — Akhilesh Kumar, government advocate. Municipal Corporation — Anand Pandey, on behalf of Bhupendra Singh.

Read current report and source

Madras High Court Requires Written Summons And Diary Records For Police Enquiries

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court has directed police to use written summons specifying the date and time of attendance when calling a person named in a complaint or a witness for enquiry or investigation.

Judge / Bench — Justice G.K. Ilanthiraiyan.

Disposing of Crl.O.P. 15130/2026 on 15 October 2026, the court addressed seven petitioners’ allegation of harassment during a pending complaint enquiry. It required summons under Section 179 BNSS and recording of enquiry minutes in the police station’s general, station or daily diary.

Police must refrain from harassment and strictly follow the Supreme Court’s Lalita Kumari guidelines on preliminary enquiry and FIR registration. The court recognised legitimate investigative powers while stating that complaints of harassment could warrant intervention under Section 528 BNSS.

Advocates appearing — Petitioners — G. Mageshkumar. Respondents 1–2 — A. Amarnath, Additional Public Prosecutor. Respondent 3 — Not named in the order.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Orders Contempt Proceedings After Dismissing FIR-Quashing Petition

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court dismissed a petition seeking to quash an FIR after the petitioner failed to bring the deceased complainant’s legal heirs on record, and ordered criminal-contempt proceedings against his counsel.

Judge / Bench — Justice H.P. Sandesh.

In V.M. Kumarswamy v State of Karnataka, decided on 17 October 2026, the court held that a complainant’s death did not end prosecution of the alleged cognizable offences. The heirs required an opportunity to participate before the quashing plea could be decided.

The court recorded repeated adjournments and counsel’s refusal to take the required steps. It directed the Registrar General to initiate contempt proceedings; the order does not record a contempt conviction.

Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — M. Shashidhara. For respondent 1 — Suhas Gowda M., High Court Government Pleader. For respondent 2 — Not named in the order.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Protects Property Share From Auction Amid Mortgage Forgery Dispute

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court has protected Shashi R. Jatia’s one-third undivided property share from auction pending adjudication of disputed loan documents, while leaving enforcement against the remaining shares unrestricted.

Judge / Bench — Justice Jasmeet Singh.

The 13 October 2026 judgment relied on prima facie forensic material and an Economic Offences Wing report concerning allegedly forged signatures. Because the challenge went to the existence of the security interest, the ordinary alternative-remedy rule did not preclude writ intervention.

The court did not finally determine forgery or the validity of the mortgage. Those questions remain for the competent forum; the protection prevents irreversible third-party rights over Jatia’s share meanwhile.

Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — Vaibhav Gaggar, senior advocate, with Abhijeet Chauhan and Mayank Singhal. For respondent 1 — Rajiv Nayar, senior advocate, with Naveen Soni. For respondents 3–4 — Sidhant Kumar, Om Batra and Anwita. For respondent 2 — Not named in the judgment.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Rejects Vague Lawyer-Negligence Plea To Reopen Commercial Decree

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court has refused to reopen an ex parte commercial decree, finding that vague allegations against a former lawyer did not explain the litigant’s failure to attend crucial hearings.

Judge / Bench — Justice Dinesh Mehta and Dr. Justice Aditi Choudhary; judgment by Dr. Justice Aditi Choudhary.

In Pawan v Amit Gupta, decided on 15 October 2026, the appellant claimed his lawyer had stopped answering calls. He provided no specific dates or adequate explanation for not contacting her personally or checking court records.

The court stressed that relief under Order IX Rule 13 CPC depends on sufficient cause for absence on the relevant hearing dates. Lawyer negligence does not confer automatic immunity from a litigant’s own lack of diligence. The appeal against refusal to set aside the decree was dismissed.

Advocates appearing — For the appellant — Neeraj Kumar Singh and Abhinav Kr. Singh. For the respondent — Sarthak Ahuja and Nitisha Soni.

Read current report and source

Mumbai’s Pollution Crisis Alarms Bombay High Court as Judges Slam Lax Enforcement of Firecracker Ban

Bombay High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Bombay High Court has expressed serious concern over Mumbai’s worsening air quality, questioning how the city known for its sea breeze and open spaces is now recording pollution levels that rival or even exceed those of Delhi. A Bench of Justices Girish S Kulkarni and Neela Gokhale, hearing a suo motu public interest litigation concerning noise and environmental pollution, criticised the authorities for failing to enforce restrictions on firecrackers and loud music during public celebrations. The Court observed that repeated violations of its directions suggested that enforcement remained weak despite clear instructions to the concerned departments.

Court questions failure to curb pollution

The Bench pointed out that organisers were continuing to use sound systems during processions without obtaining prior permission or providing assurances that prescribed decibel limits would be followed. Firecrackers were also being burst on crowded public roads without adequate intervention from the authorities. The judges expressed disappointment that such violations were continuing despite earlier judicial directions intended to protect residents from excessive noise and air pollution. Justice Kulkarni highlighted Mumbai’s geographical advantages, including its coastal winds and relatively open spaces, questioning why these natural factors had failed to prevent the city from experiencing such severe pollution. The Bench also noted that visibility in Mumbai had fallen below 500 metres on Tuesday, underscoring the seriousness of the situation. Questioning the apparent lack of urgency among enforcement agencies, Justice Kulkarni remarked that officials needed to recognise the gravity of the crisis while large numbers of residents continued to suffer its effects.

Authorities warned over failure to enforce orders

In its written order, the Court criticised the slow pace of official action, observing that even basic preliminary steps required under its earlier directions had not been carried out with the urgency expected. The Bench made it clear that police inaction in enforcing restrictions on noise and firecracker use would not be treated lightly. It warned that failures affecting citizens’ constitutional protections under Articles 14 and 21 could invite serious scrutiny and accountability for the officials concerned. The Court stressed that merely issuing instructions would not be enough; authorities must ensure that restrictions are implemented on the ground and that those violating them face appropriate action.

Police, civic bodies directed to step up enforcement

As part of its latest directions, the High Court ordered the Mumbai Police Commissioner to convene a meeting with the heads of all police stations and develop a standard operating procedure (SOP) to ensure stricter enforcement. The Commissioner has also been directed to file an affidavit confirming that restrictions on firecrackers being burst on public streets and the use of unauthorised sound systems are being implemented effectively. The Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) and the Maharashtra Pollution Control Board (MPCB) have been instructed to issue public awareness notices through social media by October 24. Both bodies must also submit affidavits detailing their compliance with the Court’s directions. The matter will be heard again on October 26. The Court’s observations place the spotlight on the gap between pollution-control orders and their actual implementation, with the Bench signalling that continued violations and administrative delays could have consequences for the officials responsible for enforcement.

Read current report and source

Telangana High Court: Accepting Sale Money for Years Undermines Fraud Claim Against Lok Adalat Award

Telangana High Court · Sheikh Rayees

A party cannot accept and retain money arising from a property transaction for years and then seek to invalidate the settlement by alleging fraud, the Telangana High Court has ruled while dismissing a challenge brought a decade after a Lok Adalat award. A division bench of Justice Moushumi Bhattacharya and Justice Renuka Yara delivered the ruling in Smt. M Nagalakshmi and Another v. The Chairman, Mandal Legal Services Committee, Cyberabad and Five Others. The dispute concerned four acres of land in Raidurg Nava Khalsa village in Telangana’s Ranga Reddy district. The case stemmed from a 2011 agreement to sell the property for ₹1 crore. M Ganga Raju, acting as the agreement of sale-cum-general power of attorney holder, received ₹85 lakh as an advance. In 2013, a Lok Adalat at Kukatpally recorded an award settling the dispute, under which the remaining ₹15 lakh was to be paid when the sale deed was registered. After Ganga Raju died in 2014, his wife and daughter received another ₹30 lakh between April and September 2015. The payments were acknowledged as part of the sale consideration. Despite receiving the money, the legal heirs later sought to set aside the Lok Adalat award. Following unsuccessful attempts through civil proceedings, they approached the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, alleging fraud and arguing that the settlement lacked a separately signed compromise document and exceeded the Lok Adalat’s pecuniary jurisdiction. The bench found the attempt to challenge the transaction difficult to reconcile with the petitioners’ acceptance of its financial benefits. A party, the Court observed, cannot take advantage of a transaction and subsequently deny its validity. The principle applies particularly when one side has substantially enjoyed the benefits of an agreement before questioning the remaining obligations. The Court also rejected the fraud allegation, stressing that such a claim must be supported by specific material particulars. Retaining the sale consideration, it observed, was fundamentally inconsistent with the petitioners’ attempt to portray the transaction as fraudulent.

Separate settlement document not mandatory

The bench also addressed the argument that the Lok Adalat award was invalid because the parties had not executed a separate memorandum of settlement or compromise beforehand. It clarified that the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987 does not require parties to sign such a document before approaching a Lok Adalat. The petitioners had also failed to establish any violation of the statutory requirements governing a valid award or the applicable regulations.

Jurisdiction objection raised too late

The challenge faced another hurdle: its timing. The award dated back to 2013, but the writ petition was filed only a decade later. The petitioners raised the objection concerning the Lok Adalat’s pecuniary jurisdiction for the first time in a rejoinder dated August 13, 2026, after oral arguments had concluded. The Court held that an objection of this nature must be raised at the outset rather than introduced at such a late stage. Finding no sufficient grounds to invalidate the award, the Telangana High Court dismissed the petition. The ruling reinforces a clear principle in settlement disputes: accepting the benefits of an agreement while allowing it to stand for years can seriously undermine a subsequent attempt to challenge its validity.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court: Archived Court Hearing Recordings Cannot Be Claimed as a Right Without Judicial Approval

Karnataka High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Karnataka High Court has ruled that litigants cannot demand copies of archived audio-visual recordings of court proceedings as a matter of right unless the concerned bench specifically authorises their release. Justice CM Poonacha delivered the ruling while dismissing a petition filed by 72-year-old A Sathyanarayana Swamy, who challenged the rejection of his request to obtain recordings of proceedings connected with an appeal. At the heart of the dispute was whether the Karnataka Rules on Live Streaming and Recording of Court Proceedings, 2021, entitled a litigant to access archived recordings even without a specific court order. The Court concluded that they did not.

Archived recordings are not automatically part of the official record

Swamy had applied under Rule 8(3) of the 2021 Rules, seeking copies of recordings that were not available on the Court's website or other digital platforms. The High Court administration rejected his request by invoking Rule 10(1)(ii). That provision makes clear that archived data does not become part of the official record of court proceedings unless the bench directs otherwise. Challenging the decision, Swamy approached the High Court seeking to set aside the rejection and secure access to the recordings. He argued that Rule 8(3) permitted applications for copies of recordings that had not been uploaded online. He also contended that the administration's decision violated Article 14 of the Constitution, which guarantees equality before the law and equal protection of the laws. In addition to seeking the recordings, Swamy asked the Court to direct the authorities to formulate and publish clear guidelines or standard operating procedures governing applications made under Rule 8(3).

Court finds no enforceable right to obtain the recordings

Justice Poonacha examined Rules 8 and 10 together and held that the provisions did not create an independent right for litigants to obtain archived recordings without judicial permission. The Court clarified that the mechanism for applying for recordings could not be interpreted as an automatic entitlement to receive them. Unless the bench specifically orders otherwise, archived material remains outside the official record of proceedings. Since Swamy could not establish a right under the rules to obtain the requested recordings, the Court found no basis to interfere with the administration's decision. The High Court consequently dismissed his petition, reinforcing that access to archived recordings depends on a specific judicial direction rather than a litigant's request alone.

Read current report and source

Kerala High Court Stands Firm on 10-Year Sentence in Assault Case Involving 73-Year-Old Woman

Kerala High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Kerala High Court has upheld a 10-year rigorous imprisonment sentence for a man convicted of sexually assaulting a 73-year-old woman after claiming he could rid her of evil spirits. Justice A Badharudeen dismissed the convict’s appeal, holding that inconsistencies over the date of the incident, a 19-day delay in reporting it and the absence of visible injuries during the medical examination did not undermine the survivor’s account. The ruling reaffirmed the trial court’s finding that the man was guilty of rape and sexual harassment under the Indian Penal Code (IPC). The High Court also cancelled his bail and directed him to surrender before the trial court to serve his sentence.

Claim of Removing Evil Spirits Led to Assault

The case dates back to October 8, 2022, when the accused, Muhammed, visited the elderly woman’s home in Thrissur. She had contacted him on the advice of her son, and the man was already known to her, having visited her residence on three earlier occasions. According to the prosecution, Muhammed claimed that evil spirits were present in the woman’s body and offered to remove them. Under this pretext, he sexually assaulted her, touching her breasts and private parts and inserting his finger into her vagina. The trial court subsequently convicted him of rape and sexual harassment. It awarded him 10 years of rigorous imprisonment and imposed a fine of ₹1 lakh for rape. For sexual harassment, he received a three-year prison term and a fine of ₹25,000. Both sentences were ordered to run concurrently. After the trial court delivered its verdict in September 2024, Muhammed challenged the conviction before the High Court.

Court Rejects Attempts to Discredit Survivor’s Account

The accused questioned the reliability of the woman’s testimony, pointing to differences in her statements about whether the assault took place on October 7 or October 8, 2022. He also cited the testimony of the woman’s son, alleging that a property dispute had prompted her to falsely implicate him. The delay in approaching the police was another ground raised in the appeal. The High Court found these arguments insufficient to overturn the conviction. It noted that the woman had corrected the date in a subsequent statement to the police. Telephone records also supported her account, showing three calls between her and the accused on October 8. The Court further observed that the son himself had differences with his mother. His testimony, therefore, could not be treated as sufficient grounds to reject her allegations of sexual assault.

No Injuries Did Not Mean No Assault

The absence of injuries during the woman’s medical examination was another point raised by the accused. The Court, however, found no merit in using that fact to discredit her testimony. The doctor had explained that the examination took place around 20 days after the incident, leaving enough time for any injuries sustained during the assault to heal. The Court also addressed the delay in registering the First Information Report (FIR). It accepted the explanation that the woman had waited to consult her children before approaching the police, finding that the delay did not, by itself, invalidate her allegations. After examining the arguments and evidence, the High Court found no reason to interfere with the trial court’s decision. Dismissing the appeal, Justice Badharudeen upheld the conviction and sentence, concluding that the survivor’s testimony was sufficient to sustain the findings of guilt.

Read current report and source