Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Supreme Court

Gold and silver ornaments recovered from accused insufficient to prove murder: Supreme Court acquits life convict

The Supreme Court held that the prosecution had failed to establish a reliable chain of circumstantial evidence, observing that recovery of a victim’s jewellery cannot, by itself, establish the accused’s guilt for murder.

The Supreme Court has overturned the murder conviction of a man sentenced to life imprisonment in a case involving the death of a woman whose body was discovered stuffed inside an iron drum in Karnataka.

A Bench of Justice Prashant Kumar Mishra and Justice Vipul M Pancholi held that the prosecution had failed to establish a complete and unbroken chain of circumstances pointing towards the accused’s guilt.

The Court emphasised that merely recovering the deceased woman’s gold and silver ornaments from the accused’s house was insufficient to establish that he had committed the murder.

The appeal challenged a Karnataka High Court judgment that had upheld the man’s conviction under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), now corresponding to Section 103 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), along with the life sentence imposed by the Sessions Court.

Woman’s body found inside iron drum

The case dates back to 2013, when the woman’s body was discovered inside an iron drum in Harapanahalli, Karnataka.

According to the prosecution, the accused was allegedly involved in an illicit relationship with the deceased and suspected that she was also seeing another man.

The prosecution claimed that, driven by jealousy, he strangled her using a plastic strap and subsequently took away her jewellery.

It was further alleged that the accused led the police to his residence, where gold and silver ornaments belonging to the deceased were recovered.

The Sessions Court had rejected the testimony of two witnesses, PW-13 and PW-14, concerning the claim that they had last seen the accused with the deceased. Their statements had been recorded after an unexplained delay of 58 days.

Despite rejecting this evidence, the trial court convicted the accused primarily on the basis of the jewellery recovery. It also acquitted him of the charge of causing the disappearance of evidence under Section 201 IPC, now corresponding to Section 238 BNS.

The Karnataka High Court subsequently relied on the last-seen-together evidence as well and upheld the murder conviction and life sentence.

Defence challenges reliance on circumstantial evidence

Before the Supreme Court, Senior Advocate A Sirajudeen argued that the entire prosecution case rested on circumstantial evidence and failed to satisfy the principles laid down in Sharad Birdhichand Sarda v State of Maharashtra.

The defence contended that the alleged motive had not been established and questioned the circumstances surrounding the discovery of the woman’s body.

It was also argued that the High Court had relied on the last-seen-together testimony without properly addressing the Sessions Court’s finding regarding the unexplained 58-day delay in recording the witnesses’ statements.

Relying on the Supreme Court’s decisions in Sanwat Khan v State of Rajasthan and Raj Kumar @ Raju v State (NCT of Delhi), the accused argued that recovery of the victim’s ornaments could not independently sustain a conviction for murder.

Opposing the appeal, Additional Advocate General Avishkar Singhvi submitted that the prosecution had established the homicidal death and the motive behind the crime.

The State also argued that the accused had failed to explain the recovery of the jewellery and that the theft and murder were part of the same transaction.

Alleged illicit relationship could not establish motive

After examining the evidence, the Supreme Court found serious shortcomings in the prosecution’s attempt to establish the alleged motive.

The Bench observed that both the Sessions Court and the High Court had wrongly treated general knowledge or suspicion about an alleged illicit relationship as proof that the accused had a motive to commit murder.

The deceased’s nephew, PW-5, and her husband, PW-7, had admitted during their testimony that they had no personal knowledge of the alleged relationship.

Neither witness established that the accused suspected the deceased of being involved with another man or that any quarrel had taken place between them over the alleged affair.

The Court therefore concluded that the prosecution’s theory regarding the motive was based on assumptions rather than established evidence.

It observed that the alleged motive was a matter of conjecture and surmise and could not be treated as a proven circumstance against the accused.

Last-seen evidence requires independent corroboration

The Bench also referred to Kanhaiya Lal v State of Rajasthan while examining the prosecution’s reliance on the last-seen-together circumstance.

Reiterating the settled legal position, the Court explained that merely establishing that an accused was last seen with the deceased does not automatically establish guilt.

Such evidence must be supported by proximate and independent circumstances connecting the accused with the commission of the crime.

The Supreme Court also examined the Sessions Court’s decision to reject the statements of PW-13 and PW-14 because of the unexplained delay in their recording, a finding that the High Court had not adequately addressed while relying on their testimony.

Ultimately, the Bench found that the circumstances relied upon by the prosecution did not form the complete and unbroken chain required to sustain a conviction based entirely on circumstantial evidence.

The Court accordingly allowed the appeal, set aside the Karnataka High Court’s judgment and acquitted the accused of the murder charge.

Share this story