The Bombay High Court has directed Bosch Limited to pay compensation of ₹25 lakh each to hundreds of temporary workers from its Nashik manufacturing facility, holding that the company had used transfers as a means to force surplus employees out of service without complying with the statutory retrenchment procedure.
Justice Sandeep V Marne held that the transfers were not driven by genuine operational requirements but were designed to ensure that the workers eventually lost their employment by failing to report at distant locations.
The Court observed that Bosch, being a large organisation, was expected to function as a model employer rather than adopt methods aimed at removing more than 500 temporary workers through transfers to locations across the country.
In its November 19 judgment in Bosch Vs NETW Kamgar Sangh, the High Court upheld the Nashik Industrial Court’s finding that the company had engaged in unfair labour practices. However, it modified the direction for reinstatement and ordered monetary compensation instead.
Bosch has been directed to pay ₹25 lakh to each eligible worker within six weeks. Failure to comply will attract interest at the rate of 8% per annum.
Background of the dispute
The case arose from the employment of New Entrant Temporary Workmen (NETWs) at Bosch’s Nashik manufacturing facility.
The company attributed the decline in work to stricter emission standards and decisions by major automobile manufacturers, including Maruti Suzuki and Honda, to discontinue diesel passenger cars. This had significantly reduced demand for diesel injectors, according to Bosch.
Amid the reduced workload, the company introduced a system called ‘Red-Light Activation’, under which workers were prevented from reporting for duty on days when sufficient work was unavailable.
The workers challenged the arrangement and obtained orders directing Bosch to pay wages even for days on which they were not assigned work. These directions were subsequently upheld by the Supreme Court.
In August 2024, Bosch called the workers back to duty. However, within weeks, it issued transfer orders posting them to different locations across India.
The company also initiated disciplinary proceedings against those who did not report to their new postings. The workers’ union stated that 235 employees were eventually dismissed following these developments.
Court finds transfers were intended to eliminate workers
Examining the circumstances surrounding the transfers, the High Court concluded that the exercise was not a genuine administrative measure but an attempt to remove workers whose services the company no longer required.
The Court observed that the actual objective was to get rid of the employees, with transfers being used as the instrument to achieve that outcome.
It also criticised Bosch for adopting a course of action that would effectively force workers out of employment by posting them to distant locations and subsequently treating their failure to join as grounds for dismissal.
Reinstatement replaced with compensation
Although the High Court upheld the finding of unfair labour practices, it decided against directing the reinstatement of the workers.
Taking note of the reduced manufacturing activity and the possibility that reinstatement could prolong the dispute, the Court considered monetary compensation a more appropriate resolution.
Bosch had initially offered ₹14 lakh per worker before subsequently indicating its willingness to increase the amount to ₹18 lakh.
However, considering the workers’ length of service, their statutory entitlements and the company’s financial position, the Court fixed compensation at ₹25 lakh per worker as a full and final settlement.
The direction requires Bosch to complete the payments within six weeks, with an annual interest liability of 8% in case of default.