Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives
Karnataka High Court

Karnataka High Court Allows Hate Speech Probe Against Former BJP MP Pratap Simha to Continue

The Karnataka High Court has declined to quash criminal proceedings against former BJP MP Pratap Simha over alleged inflammatory remarks concerning stone-pelting during Hindu religious processions, observing that the speech requires further investigation into possible attempts to provoke communal violence and outrage religious sentiments.

Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde, in an October 8 order, held that the allegations disclosed sufficient grounds to continue the investigation against Simha. However, the Court quashed the proceedings against three event organisers, finding no material to suggest that they had encouraged or instigated him to make the controversial remarks.

The case arose from a public programme held in Shahapur, Yadgir district, on September 21, 2024, coinciding with the immersion of Ganesh idols. Simha attended the event as the chief guest.

According to the complaint, Simha questioned incidents of stone-pelting during Hindu religious processions and challenged those responsible to identify instances of Hindus throwing stones during Eid Milad processions.

He reportedly remarked that Hindus account for nearly 80 per cent of India’s population and questioned what could happen if members of the majority community also resorted to stone-pelting.

The speech also referred to India’s nuclear capabilities and questioned whether Hindus were incapable of making petrol bombs. Simha further called upon Hindus to put aside caste differences and unite, warning of circumstances similar to those faced by Hindus in Bangladesh if the community remained divided.

Following a complaint lodged on September 23, 2024, Shahapur police registered an FIR against Simha and the event organisers under Sections 192 and 299 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS).

The accused subsequently approached the High Court seeking quashing of the criminal proceedings. They argued that the speech did not constitute the alleged offences and that the police had failed to follow the procedure prescribed under Section 173(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS).

The State opposed the petitions, maintaining that Simha’s remarks were intended to disturb communal harmony and hurt the religious sentiments of a particular community.

Examining the allegations, the High Court observed that determining whether Simha intended to provoke rioting would require an investigation rather than being decided at the preliminary stage.

The Bench noted that no actual riot had followed the speech, meaning the first part of Section 192 of the BNS was not attracted. However, it clarified that the provision’s second part could still apply even where rioting had not taken place.

The Court said investigators must examine whether Simha had the requisite malicious intention to provoke such violence and submit an appropriate report based on their findings.

It also found that the complaint contained the basic ingredients necessary to investigate the alleged offence under Section 299 of the BNS.

While allowing the investigation against Simha to proceed, the Court granted relief to the three event organisers, holding that there was no material connecting them to the alleged provocation.

Accordingly, the proceedings against Simha will continue, while the case against the three organisers stands quashed.

Share this story