The Court ruled that criticising a political statement or sharing a news report does not automatically amount to promoting communal hatred, particularly when there is no reference to hostility between two communities.
The Karnataka High Court has quashed criminal proceedings against a man accused of promoting religious enmity through a social media post suggesting that former Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah intended to distribute the country’s wealth to Muslims.
Justice Rajesh Rai K held on November 6 that the contents of the post, even if accepted as alleged, failed to establish the essential elements of an offence under Section 153A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC), which deals with promoting enmity between different groups on religious grounds.
The Court noted that the accused had shared a TV9 news report carrying a photograph of Siddaramaiah, accompanied by a headline about distributing the nation’s wealth to Muslims. The accompanying message reflected his disagreement with the reported statement.
It found no specific reference to two separate communities or groups that could establish an attempt to create hostility between them.
“In the absence of any specific reference to two distinct groups or communities, such an act, by itself, would not attract the ingredients of Section 153A of IPC,” the Court observed.
How the criminal case began
The proceedings originated from a complaint filed on April 29, 2024, by a Congress party worker. The complaint alleged that several individuals had been publishing posts from April 22 through a social media account operating under the name ‘BhikuMhatre (Modi’s Family) @MumbaichaDon’.
One of the posts featured Siddaramaiah addressing the media and carried a caption claiming that the Congress manifesto specifically referred to Muslims in connection with the distribution of wealth.
The complainant alleged that the post was intended to create hostility between Hindus and Muslims, disturb public peace and damage the reputation of the Congress party.
Following the complaint, Bengaluru Cyber Crime Police registered an FIR against Nayak under Section 153A IPC and Section 66(C) of the Information Technology Act, 2000.
Petitioner argued that sharing a news report was not a criminal offence
Appearing for the accused, Senior Advocate Aruna Shyam submitted that her client had merely circulated a news clip published by TV9.
She argued that the post neither targeted nor humiliated any particular community and contained no attempt to provoke hatred or violence.
The petitioner’s side also questioned the police investigation, pointing out that the authorities had not verified the authenticity of the underlying news report before registering the criminal case.
It was further argued that the complaint was driven by political motives.
Opposing the petition, the State government contended that the post was intended to generate communal hostility by suggesting that the Congress party planned to take wealth belonging to Hindus and distribute it exclusively among Muslims.
The State maintained that the investigation was still at an early stage and the allegations required further examination.
Court explains why Section 153A was not attracted
Examining the material, the High Court noted that the TV9 report carried the headline, “I will share the wealth of the nation to Muslims: CM Siddaramaiah”.
The Court also took note of the absence of any investigation into whether the news report itself was genuine.
Reiterating the scope of Section 153A IPC, it explained that the provision requires an attempt to promote enmity, hatred or ill-will between at least two distinct communities or groups.
A statement that merely provokes feelings within one community, without targeting or referring to another group, would not automatically fall within the provision.
“Merely inciting the feeling of one community or group without any reference to any other community or group cannot attract Section 153A,” the Court observed.
It further explained that the provision is intended to address conduct prejudicial to communal harmony and acts that disturb, or are likely to disturb, public tranquillity.
The Court also emphasised that expressing disagreement or dissent through legitimate and lawful means is protected under fundamental rights, subject to reasonable restrictions.
Another factor recorded by the Court was that the complainant had not appeared despite receiving notice.
It cautioned that allowing criminal proceedings to continue on the basis of frivolous or vexatious complaints could cause serious damage to an accused person’s reputation.
Concluding that neither the complaint nor the FIR disclosed the essential ingredients of an offence under Section 153A IPC, the Court held that continuing the proceedings would constitute an abuse of the judicial process.
Accordingly, the High Court allowed the petition and quashed the FIR along with all consequential proceedings against the accused.
Advocate Suyog Herele also appeared for the petitioner.