The Court stressed that security personnel must receive confidential mental health support and periodic assessments, particularly before being entrusted with firearms, observing that discipline cannot come at the cost of their well-being.
The Karnataka High Court has called for a comprehensive mental health support system for police officers and personnel serving in armed security forces, emphasising that those entrusted with protecting the public must also receive adequate care and support.
Justice Suraj Govindaraj observed that security agencies have a responsibility beyond assigning duties to their personnel. They must also take reasonable steps to safeguard their physical and psychological well-being.
The Court stressed that personnel should be able to seek counselling and medical assistance without fearing stigma or disciplinary repercussions. Their need for treatment, family support, rest or temporary relief from specific responsibilities must be recognised.
Highlighting the connection between mental health and public safety, the Court said authorities should introduce psychological assessments before issuing firearms to personnel and conduct periodic evaluations thereafter.
In its November 12 order, the Court also called for fresh assessments whenever circumstances raise concerns about an individual’s mental well-being.
It further said that access to firearms should be regulated wherever genuine safety concerns arise. However, such safeguards must not be used as punitive measures or automatically result in a person’s exclusion from service.
The observations came while the Court was allowing a petition filed by a woman Sub-Inspector serving in the Central Industrial Security Force (CISF), who sought discharge from a criminal case registered against her in 2022 under Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code, which dealt with attempted suicide.
The officer had allegedly attempted to take her life using a firearm issued by the force. Her counsel submitted that she was experiencing severe psychological distress because of her inability to conceive.
She was subsequently subjected to disciplinary proceedings, which resulted in a major penalty involving reduction by one stage in her pay for the remainder of her service, along with denial of promotions for five years.
Examining the circumstances, the High Court underlined that members of the police and security forces are not immune to personal struggles. Like anyone else, they experience grief, anxiety, financial difficulties and other pressures that can affect their mental health.
The Court said the expectation that personnel should remain ready to perform their duties at all times, irrespective of their emotional condition or personal circumstances, needed reconsideration.
“Discipline and dedication are essential, but they cannot be demanded at the cost of ignoring the basic human needs of personnel,” the Court observed.
On the criminal proceedings, the High Court set aside the trial court’s refusal to discharge the officer. It found that the lower court had failed to properly consider Section 115 of the Mental Healthcare Act, 2017.
The provision creates a presumption that a person attempting suicide is experiencing severe stress and requires care and support. Such a person should not be prosecuted or punished under Section 309 of the IPC unless the prosecution establishes that the individual was not under severe stress.
The High Court noted that the law seeks to approach suicide attempts through treatment, rehabilitation and support rather than punishment.
It also issued broader directions concerning the mental health welfare of personnel serving in the police, armed forces and other security organisations.
The Court called for accessible, professional and confidential mental healthcare arrangements, stressing that the welfare of personnel and the operational security of forces must go hand in hand.
It observed that organisations which take care of their personnel’s mental and physical health are better positioned to maintain discipline, operational efficiency and public safety.
The Registry was directed to forward a copy of the order to the Director General of the CISF, the Director General of Police in Karnataka and the heads of other State organisations whose personnel are entrusted with firearms.
Advocate Tarunn Surana appeared for the CISF Sub-Inspector, while High Court Government Pleader Ranjith Kumar represented the State.