The Supreme Court has overturned Odisha government’s 2021 land acquisition for a mining project involving Dalmia Cement in Sundargarh district, ruling that the State ignored crucial legal safeguards, including mandatory consent from gram sabhas and affected families.
A Bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma set aside the acquisition covering land in three villages, namely Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna. The ruling also overturned a September 2024 decision of the Orissa High Court that had upheld the State’s action.
In Bibol Toppo v. Odisha, the Court found that the acquisition had proceeded despite the gram sabhas of the affected villages rejecting the proposal in January 2020. It criticised the High Court for treating the statutory requirement of gram sabha consent as little more than a procedural exercise.
The Bench observed that there was not even documentary consent from the gram sabhas, let alone any meaningful approval for the acquisition.
80% consent requirement could not be bypassed
The dispute originated in 2015, when Dalmia Cement approached the Odisha government seeking acquisition of surface rights over agricultural land to expand its mining operations. The company already held a mining lease valid until 2040.
The villagers challenged the acquisition, arguing that the State had ignored their objections and failed to follow the safeguards prescribed under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013.
The Orissa High Court had previously ruled that consent from 80 per cent of affected families was unnecessary because ownership of the acquired land would vest in the State. It had also observed that such consent, if required, could be obtained at different stages of the acquisition process.
The Supreme Court rejected this interpretation.
It clarified that the nature and purpose of the acquisition determine which statutory safeguards must be followed. Since the land was being acquired exclusively for mining operations by a private company, Section 2(2)(b) of the 2013 Act required the prior consent of at least 80 per cent of affected families.
The Bench emphasised that this consent had to be obtained during the social impact assessment process, before the government proceeded to consider the acquisition proposal. Approval collected at a subsequent stage could not rectify the initial violation.
Gram sabha approval mandatory in Scheduled Areas
The Court also highlighted the constitutional and statutory protections applicable to the affected villages, which fall within a Scheduled Area under the Fifth Schedule of the Constitution.
Referring to Section 41(3) of the 2013 Act, the Bench held that prior consent of the gram sabhas was independently mandatory before acquiring land in such areas.
It clarified that this requirement could not be dispensed with even when the government invoked urgency provisions.
Social impact assessment process found deficient
The Supreme Court identified further irregularities in the acquisition proceedings, particularly concerning the mandatory public hearing on the draft social impact assessment report.
Information obtained under the Right to Information Act indicated that the hearing could not take place because of COVID-19 restrictions. The final assessment report also failed to reflect the views and concerns of the affected residents.
The Bench additionally questioned the independence of the expert group tasked with evaluating the assessment report. A land acquisition adviser associated with Dalmia Cement had been included in the group, raising concerns about the fairness of the evaluation process.
The Court remarked that the arrangement effectively turned the expert group’s deliberations into a predetermined exercise, likening it to a “fixed match”.
It further clarified that Dalmia Cement’s existing mining lease did not give the company or the State any exemption from the requirements of the land acquisition law. Once Odisha decided to acquire the land under the 2013 Act, compliance with its statutory protections became compulsory.
Finding multiple violations of the law, the Supreme Court quashed the land acquisition proceedings along with the connected notifications and government orders.