Saved newspaper
9 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 12 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Overlapping Agreements Do Not Block Arbitration Reference
- Delayed Medical Examination Cannot Defeat Disability Evidence
- Unproved Custom Cannot Exclude Tribal Women From Inheritance
- Bank Letter Cannot Restrict Fundamental Right to Travel
- Delhi High Court Protects Surgeon From Deepfake Medical Claims
- Bombay High Court Confiscates Phone Used to Record Proceedings
- General Candidate Cannot Fill Available EWS Post
- Bombay High Court Limits Anticipatory Bail Window in Child Rape Cases
- Delhi High Court: Fake Caste Certificate Alone Cannot Justify Striking Advocate Off Rolls
- Kerala High Court Orders Corruption FIR Against Pinarayi Vijayan in CMRL-Exalogic Case
- Bombay High Court Denies Anticipatory Bail in ₹7.17 Crore Digital Arrest Scam
- Delhi High Court Targets 125 Websites Accused of Misusing Jio Brand for Lottery and Gaming
Overlapping Agreements Do Not Block Arbitration Reference
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court has held that overlapping disputes under related commercial agreements do not, by themselves, justify refusing an arbitration reference at the threshold.
Shubham Equipment and Rothwell Water had entered a licence agreement, a joint-venture agreement and a memorandum of understanding. The court found that the instruments operated in distinct fields, even though some disputes overlapped with an arbitration seated in Korea.
It said the limited inquiry under Section 11 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act did not permit the court to resolve those substantive questions. Whether a wholly owned subsidiary that did not sign one agreement could be bound was also left to the tribunal.
Allowing the petitions on October 8, 2026, the court appointed former Bombay High Court Chief Justice Ramesh Dhanuka as sole arbitrator.
Read current report and source
Delayed Medical Examination Cannot Defeat Disability Evidence
Madhya Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has held that medical evidence of permanent disability cannot be discarded merely because the doctor examined a motor-accident claimant about a year after the crash.
The tribunal had rejected the disability evidence on timing alone. The High Court found that approach unsustainable, noting that the doctor’s testimony and certificate still required proper assessment.
Rather than reopen the entire compensation calculation, the court awarded an additional lump sum of ₹50,000 with interest at the rate fixed by the tribunal. Interest was excluded for the period from January 31, 2014 to August 13, 2024 because of delay attributable to the appeal.
The insurer was directed to pay the enhanced amount within two months. The decision was delivered on September 29, 2026.
Read current report and source
Unproved Custom Cannot Exclude Tribal Women From Inheritance
Jharkhand High Court · Editorial Team
The Jharkhand High Court has refused to enforce an alleged Munda custom excluding daughters and widows from inheritance because the asserted rule was not proved.
The court said a custom departing from general law must be shown to be ancient, uniform, certain, continuous and compulsory. The evidence in the land-compensation dispute did not establish those requirements.
The opposing side also failed to prove that the Hindu Succession Act governed the parties. The bench therefore applied justice, equity and good conscience rather than accepting an unverified discriminatory custom.
It upheld Daho Devi’s half share in the property and the quarter share of Mohan Munda, now represented by his legal heirs. The appeal was dismissed in the judgment pronounced on October 5, 2026.
Read current report and source
Bank Letter Cannot Restrict Fundamental Right to Travel
Madras High Court · Editorial Team
The Madras High Court has rejected a bank’s attempt to restore a travel restriction against a borrower, holding that a lender’s letter cannot displace the constitutional right to travel abroad.
Bank of Baroda sought review of an earlier order removing a lookout circular. The court said personal liberty under Article 21 may be curtailed only by law and that a bank manager’s communication to immigration authorities does not meet that requirement.
The bench added that a mortgage or loan default does not extinguish a citizen’s fundamental rights. It declined to treat an order of the Supreme Court in another case as creating a universal rule authorising such restrictions.
The review petition was dismissed on October 1, 2026.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court Protects Surgeon From Deepfake Medical Claims
Delhi High Court · Editorial Team
The Delhi High Court has permanently restrained online misuse of cardiac surgeon Devi Prasad Shetty’s name, image, voice and likeness in fabricated medical endorsements.
The suit concerned AI-generated and deepfake material that falsely attributed health claims and cures to the surgeon while also using trademarks associated with Narayana Health.
The court made its earlier injunction and takedown directions absolute. It allowed the plaintiffs to notify platforms of later substantially similar links through an affidavit, requiring action in accordance with law.
The judgment recognised the risk that manipulated medical content could exploit public trust in a prominent doctor and mislead patients. The plaintiffs did not press damages or costs, and their request for a declaration concerning a well-known mark was reserved.
Read current report and source
Bombay High Court Confiscates Phone Used to Record Proceedings
Bombay High Court · Editorial Team
The Bombay High Court has ordered the confiscation of a mobile phone used to record court proceedings without written permission.
The suo motu matter arose after an employee was found recording in the courtroom. The court accepted his apology but stressed that unauthorised recording is expressly prohibited and undermines the administration of justice.
After permitting the removal of personal data, the bench directed that the device be seized and confiscated. It also ordered the employee to deposit ₹10,000 with the legal services authority within two weeks, authorising recovery from salary if he defaults.
The court warned that any repetition could attract contempt proceedings. Compliance is to be reported on October 19, 2026.
Read current report and source
General Candidate Cannot Fill Available EWS Post
Uttarakhand High Court · Editorial Team
The Uttarakhand High Court has quashed the selection of a general-category candidate for an Assistant Professor post reserved for economically weaker sections.
The division bench found that an eligible EWS candidate was available and that the recruitment rules did not prescribe a minimum interview score. Nor had the university recorded that the petitioner was unsuitable.
The court rejected the university’s attempt to justify filling the reserved Statistics post from the general category. It said the selection process could not disregard the reservation merely because the chosen candidate received higher marks.
The university was directed to consider the petitioner for appointment and, if otherwise eligible, issue an appointment letter within three weeks. The judgment was delivered on October 6, 2026.
Read current report and source
Bombay High Court Limits Anticipatory Bail Window in Child Rape Cases
Bombay High Court · Editorial Team
The Bombay High Court has held that the statutory bar on anticipatory bail for alleged rape of a girl under 16 is not an absolute jurisdictional prohibition, but leaves only a narrow preliminary window.
The Nagpur bench said a court may examine whether the complaint and material disclose the essential ingredients of the offence. It cannot, at that stage, conduct a detailed assessment of credibility or evidence.
The ruling came in two applications involving girls aged 15 years and five months, and 14 years and four months. The allegations included pregnancy in one case and threats involving obscene material in the other.
Finding prima facie material in both matters, the court held that the bar under Section 482(4) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita operated. It rejected the applications as not maintainable.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court: Fake Caste Certificate Alone Cannot Justify Striking Advocate Off Rolls
Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The submission of a disputed or fabricated caste certificate does not, by itself, justify removing an advocate from the State roll. The Delhi High Court has ruled that authorities must establish that the alleged fraud or misrepresentation was instrumental in securing the lawyer’s enrolment.
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma delivered the ruling while setting aside the Bar Council of India’s (BCI) decision to remove advocate Dipinder Kaur from the rolls of the Bar Council of Delhi (BCD).
The Court clarified that Section 26(1) of the Advocates Act does not confer an unrestricted power to strike off an advocate’s name simply because an incorrect statement was made or a questionable document was submitted during the enrolment process.
In Dipinder Kaur v. Bar Council of Delhi & Ors., the Court emphasised that the crucial question was not merely whether a disputed document had been furnished, but whether the advocate had obtained entry on the State roll through fraud or misrepresentation concerning an essential fact.
The Court observed that an allegation of fraud must be examined in the context of its actual bearing on enrolment. The submission of a fabricated certificate, without establishing its material role in securing admission to the advocates’ roll, would not automatically attract the relevant provision of the Advocates Act.
Justice Sharma distinguished such cases from situations involving forged law degrees or mark sheets used to establish eligibility. Similarly, falsely claiming a reserved-category status to obtain a relaxation or benefit essential for enrolment could provide grounds for action.
Disputed OBC certificate at the centre of election controversy
The case arose during the 2026 Bar Council of Delhi elections, when complaints were filed questioning Kaur’s OBC certificate.
Following the complaints, the BCI ordered her removal from the advocates’ roll on May 7. The BCD Election Committee subsequently cancelled her candidature on May 12.
Kaur challenged the decision before the High Court.
During its examination, the Court noted that the disputed caste certificate had not helped her secure admission to the LLB course or obtain her law degree. This was a significant consideration in determining whether the alleged misrepresentation had played a decisive role in her enrolment.
The Court also examined her academic record. Although Kaur had obtained 44.5% marks in graduation, the BCD’s resolution dated March 15, 2019, permitted candidates with less than 45% marks to be considered for enrolment if they had subsequently obtained a law degree from an institution affiliated with the BCI.
These circumstances undermined the basis for treating the disputed certificate as sufficient grounds for striking her name off the roll.
Court reprimands advocate over certificate
While setting aside the BCI’s removal order, the High Court did not give Kaur a clean chit on the disputed document.
The Court maintained the finding that she had furnished the disputed caste certificate and reprimanded her for doing so. Its intervention was confined to the legal basis for removing her from the advocates’ roll.
The ruling thus draws a distinction between establishing that a questionable document was submitted and proving that it secured an advocate’s enrolment through fraud. For removal under the relevant provision, the latter connection must be demonstrated.
Read current report and source
Kerala High Court Orders Corruption FIR Against Pinarayi Vijayan in CMRL-Exalogic Case
Kerala High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Kerala High Court has directed the State Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB) to register an FIR against former Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan and other suspected persons in the CMRL-Exalogic case, acting on information supplied by the Enforcement Directorate (ED).
Justice A Badharudeen passed the order while allowing a petition filed by advocate KM Shajahan, who had challenged the State government's decision to initiate a preliminary inquiry through a Special Investigation Team (SIT) without first registering an FIR.
The Court set aside that decision, holding that the allegations disclosed possible offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, which fall within the investigative jurisdiction of the State's vigilance agency.
It directed the Director of the VACB to obtain the information forwarded by the ED under Section 66(2) of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act (PMLA) and register an FIR against all suspected persons for the offences disclosed in the communication.
The Court also directed the head of the SIT or the Director General of Police, who had custody of the ED's information, to transfer it to the VACB without delay. The ED was instructed to forward all supporting documents necessary for the registration of the case.
ED's communication leaves no room for another preliminary inquiry
Explaining the legal basis for its decision, the Court said State police authorities are obligated to register an FIR when information shared under Section 66(2) of the PMLA discloses a scheduled offence that falls within their jurisdiction.
The Court clarified that this obligation does not eliminate the possibility of an independent preliminary inquiry in every case. However, it found that the material supplied by the ED's Cochin Zonal Office contained sufficient details about the alleged financial irregularities involving Cochin Minerals and Rutile Limited (CMRL) and Exalogic Solutions Private Limited.
The communication, dated September 7, 2026, contained adequate preliminary material indicating the possible commission of cognisable offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act, the Court held.
In these circumstances, the Court concluded that no further preliminary inquiry was necessary before registering the FIR and that the State police were required to act on the information provided.
Dispute centres on financial transactions involving Exalogic
The case concerns allegations of corruption linked to financial transactions between CMRL and Exalogic Solutions, a company owned by Veena Thaikkandiyil, the daughter of Vijayan.
The ED had shared information with the Kerala police following its investigation into the transactions. According to the allegations raised in the petition, the material warranted an investigation into possible offences involving Vijayan, his daughter, her husband and former Minister PA Muhammed Riyas.
Instead of registering an FIR, the State government had constituted an SIT headed by Crime Branch Additional Director General of Police H Venkatesh to conduct a preliminary inquiry.
Shajahan challenged that approach, arguing that the information provided by the ED disclosed potential offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act and the PMLA. He sought an FIR against those allegedly involved, along with the transfer of the investigation to the VACB.
He had also sought directions requiring the State police and the Vigilance Director to act on complaints he submitted on September 22.
ED backed demand for FIR; State questioned petition
During the proceedings, the ED supported Shajahan's demand for registration of an FIR. Its standing counsel, Jaishankar V Nair, submitted that the agency had identified several transactions requiring investigation by the State police or another competent authority.
The State, represented by Advocate General Jaju Babu, raised a preliminary objection to the petition's maintainability. He argued that although Shajahan had presented the matter as one involving public interest, the proceedings had been instituted as a private writ petition.
The State also contended that receiving information from the ED did not prevent its agencies from independently assessing whether the material disclosed an offence warranting an FIR.
The High Court rejected the objection concerning Shajahan's standing, holding that he was entitled to approach the Court as an Indian citizen and whistle-blower.
With its ruling, the Court has directed the State's vigilance machinery to move beyond the preliminary inquiry and formally register a corruption case on the basis of the material supplied by the ED.
Read current report and source
Bombay High Court Denies Anticipatory Bail in ₹7.17 Crore Digital Arrest Scam
Bombay High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Bombay High Court has refused anticipatory bail to a man whose bank account allegedly received ₹4.03 crore from a ₹7.17 crore digital arrest fraud, observing that custodial interrogation was necessary to trace the money and identify those behind the crime.
Justice RM Joshi, sitting at the Aurangabad bench, rejected the plea filed by Anuj Saxena in Anuj Saxena v. State & Anr., stressing the growing threat posed by digital arrest scams.
The case originated from a complaint by a doctor in Maharashtra who was allegedly coerced into transferring ₹7.17 crore to fraudsters posing as authorities. During the investigation, officials discovered that ₹4.03 crore of the defrauded amount had entered Saxena’s bank account before being withdrawn.
Saxena maintained that he operated a charitable institution and had shared his bank details in anticipation of a promised donation of ₹20 lakh. He also claimed that his mobile phone had been hacked.
The Court, however, noted that no evidence had been placed on record to substantiate the alleged hacking. It was not persuaded to grant him protection from arrest on the basis of his explanation.
Highlighting the seriousness of such offences, Justice Joshi observed that an increasing number of people were falling victim to digital arrest frauds.
The Court also cautioned against accepting casual or belated explanations from individuals whose bank accounts receive money linked to criminal activity. Such justifications, it observed, could encourage the commission of similar offences.
Emphasising the need to establish the full chain of the alleged fraud, the bench held that custodial interrogation was essential to investigate the transactions, identify the actual perpetrators and uncover the wider network involved.
The Court accordingly rejected Saxena’s anticipatory bail plea.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court Targets 125 Websites Accused of Misusing Jio Brand for Lottery and Gaming
Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Delhi High Court has ordered the suspension of 125 websites and domain names allegedly exploiting Reliance Industries Limited’s Jio trademark to promote lottery, gaming and related services.
The interim order was passed by Justice Purushaindra Kumar Kaurav on October 7 in a trademark infringement case brought by Reliance Industries against Rahul Meena and several other parties.
The Court also directed Google to take down a webpage hosted on its Blogger platform that allegedly violated Jio’s trademark rights.
Court flags websites allegedly exploiting Jio’s identity
Reliance Industries approached the Court claiming that multiple websites were unlawfully incorporating its registered Jio trademark into their domain names to attract users to lottery and gaming platforms.
The company argued that the use of names and marks such as JIO, JIO LOTTERY and JIO LOTTERY GAME was identical or deceptively similar to its registered trademarks, creating a risk of confusion among consumers.
The disputed domains included jiolotteryi.com, jiolotterylogin.com, jiolotterygame.com, jiolottery.club and jiolottery.store.
According to Reliance Industries, these platforms were using the Jio name in connection with lottery, gaming, payment-related and allied services without authorisation.
Court applies test for identifying rogue websites
After examining the websites and their contents, the Court found that they prima facie met the criteria for classification as rogue websites under the principles laid down by the Delhi High Court in its 2019 decision in UTV Software Communication Ltd. v. 1337X.to.
The earlier ruling established that courts must assess a website’s primary purpose and overall effect rather than simply count the amount of infringing material it contains. The assessment, therefore, must be qualitative rather than merely quantitative.
The judgment also recognised that blocking individual web addresses may prove ineffective because operators can shift to new URLs to evade restrictions.
Applying these principles, the Court restrained Meena from registering, operating, controlling, promoting or otherwise using domain names and marks identical or deceptively similar to Jio.
It also directed the domain name registrars named in the proceedings to suspend the identified websites and associated accounts until further orders.
125 domains face suspension
The annexure to the order listed 126 web addresses, including mirror sites, redirecting domains and websites with similar structures. Of these, 125 were covered by the suspension directions, while a separate takedown order was issued against the Blogger webpage.
The domains were registered or hosted through several service providers, including NameCheap, GoDaddy, Dynadot and Spaceship.
The case also involves Google, the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology, and the Department of Telecommunications, among other defendants.
Recognising the urgency of the relief sought, the Court exempted Reliance Industries from mandatory pre-institution mediation under the Commercial Courts Act.
The Court issued summons in the suit and scheduled the interim application for further consideration on November 30.
Read current report and source