Indian courts, clearly reported
Download today’s paperArchives

Saved newspaper

16 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition

Saved newspaper edition with 17 court reports.

Download newspaper edition · Paper archive

  1. Supreme Court Upholds Contractual Bar on Pre-Award Interest
  2. Supreme Court Grants Bail After 20 Months in PMLA Case
  3. Supreme Court Questions RBI’s Silence as YES Bank Crisis Wiped Out ₹8,415 Crore in AT-1 Bonds
  4. Supreme Court Puts Sanjay Raut on Notice Over Criticism of CJI
  5. Supreme Court Refuses to Reopen Section 163 BNSS Validity, Agrees to Examine Delhi Protest Orders
  6. Supreme Court Warns States of Contempt Over Delays in Implementing Menstrual Hygiene Rights
  7. Kerala High Court Allows Limited Aadhaar Fingerprint Matching
  8. Delhi High Court Records Police Assurance on Connaught Place Protest
  9. Karnataka High Court Declines to Return Child to Canada
  10. Allahabad High Court Orders Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Elections Within Three Months
  11. Prosecutors Must Act Independently of Police, Madras High Court Rules
  12. Karnataka High Court Rejects Divorce Based on Unproved Mental Illness
  13. Calcutta High Court Denies Anticipatory Bail in Festival Ticket Case
  14. Meghalaya High Court Accepts Apologies for Lawyers’ Boycott
  15. Kerala High Court Strikes Down Order Allowing POCSO Prosecutors to Handle Other Cases
  16. Delhi High Court Says Women Can Face Gang-Rape Charges for Enabling Sexual Assault
  17. Madras High Court Rejects Plea to Scrap TVK Victory Over Use of Children in Campaigns

Supreme Court Upholds Contractual Bar on Pre-Award Interest

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court on 15 October dismissed a contractor’s appeal challenging the removal of pre-reference and pendente lite interest from an arbitral award. It held that the contract’s residual phrase “or otherwise” created an absolute prohibition under Section 31(7)(a) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act. The substantive award and post-award interest remained intact because post-award interest is governed separately by Section 31(7)(b).

Judge / Bench — Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi. Judgment authored by Justice Vipul M. Pancholi.

Advocates appearing — For the appellant — Siddhartha Dave, Senior Counsel. For the respondent — Shilpi Chowdhary.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Grants Bail After 20 Months in PMLA Case

Supreme Court · Editorial Team

The Supreme Court on 14 October granted bail to Sanjay Sureka after more than 20 months in custody in a money-laundering case involving alleged proceeds of ₹6,210.72 crore. The bench rejected his claim that a five-day delay in forwarding arrest material invalidated the arrest, holding that “immediately” under Section 19(2) of the PMLA means expeditiously and simultaneously, allowing only time strictly needed to compile voluminous records. It nevertheless found that the immense record, 97 accused and about 98 witnesses made an early trial unlikely. With the investigation complete against Sureka and the maximum sentence being seven years, continued detention would undermine Article 21. Bail is subject to trial-court conditions, passport deposit, a travel restriction and non-interference with evidence.

Judge / Bench — Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi. The judgment was authored by Justice Aravind Kumar.

Advocates appearing — For the appellant — Not named in the judgment. For the Directorate of Enforcement — Not named in the judgment.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Questions RBI’s Silence as YES Bank Crisis Wiped Out ₹8,415 Crore in AT-1 Bonds

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has sharply questioned the Reserve Bank of India’s oversight of YES Bank, criticising the regulator for remaining a “mere bystander” as the lender’s financial health deteriorated and serious irregularities came to light. The Court also raised concerns over YES Bank’s sale of high-risk Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) bonds to individual investors, stressing that stricter scrutiny was needed before retail customers were exposed to such complex financial instruments. A Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih made the observations while dismissing appeals filed by YES Bank, the RBI and the Union government. The ruling upheld the Bombay High Court’s decision to quash the bank’s move to write off AT-1 bonds worth ₹8,415 crore in March 2020. The Bench noted that YES Bank’s Common Equity Tier-1 (CET1) capital ratio had fallen to an alarming 0.6%, questioning how the situation could deteriorate to that extent without more effective regulatory intervention. It also pointed out that irregularities in the bank’s operations had surfaced earlier and that criminal proceedings had been initiated against some of its personnel. Passing the consequences of administrative failures on to investors, the Court observed, would be deeply unfair.

Court flags questionable handling of AT-1 bonds

The judges expressed serious reservations about the conduct of the RBI, YES Bank and the bank’s administrator during the lender’s reconstruction in March 2020. Their handling of bonds valued at more than ₹8,500 crore was described in the judgment as questionable, with the Court examining whether the write-off had been carried out in accordance with the governing legal framework. The Bench also highlighted evidence suggesting that YES Bank had marketed AT-1 bonds to retail investors despite regulatory restrictions on offering such high-risk securities to individuals. It referred to an email dated December 28, 2016, purportedly sent by a senior manager and financial adviser of YES Bank in Chennai, offering the instruments to individual investors. The Court said tighter scrutiny should have been exercised before individual investors were drawn into securities carrying such substantial risks.

Why the ₹8,415-crore write-off was struck down

The dispute originated during YES Bank’s financial crisis in March 2020, when the Central government imposed a moratorium and introduced a reconstruction scheme to stabilise the lender. An initial draft of the scheme proposed permanently writing down the bank’s AT-1 bonds. However, following objections from investors, the provision was deliberately omitted from the final version. Despite that deletion, the administrator extinguished the bonds on March 14, 2020, a day after the reconstruction scheme came into force. The Supreme Court held that the administrator lacked the authority to proceed with the write-off after the relevant provision had been removed from the final scheme. The Bench warned that permitting such an action despite the government’s deliberate decision to exclude the provision could expose the authorities to allegations of acting clandestinely and committing a fraud on the public. It clarified, however, that it did not believe the government had intended such a result. Instead, the Court concluded that the administrator had proceeded under the mistaken understanding that the power to write down the bonds remained available even after the reconstruction scheme took effect.

Financial rescue cannot override prescribed procedure

The judgment also addressed the regulatory framework governing AT-1 bonds, which permits such instruments to be written down in specified circumstances. The Court made clear that the existence of that power did not mean it could be exercised by any authority or without following the prescribed procedure. The decision had to be taken by the competent authority in accordance with the applicable rules. The argument that writing off the bonds was necessary to rescue YES Bank’s finances did not persuade the Bench to overlook those requirements. By dismissing the appeals filed by YES Bank, the RBI and the Union government, the Supreme Court left the Bombay High Court’s ruling intact. The decision underscores a central principle in the handling of financial crises: stabilising a bank does not dispense with legal safeguards, and investors cannot be made to bear the consequences of administrative action taken without proper authority.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Puts Sanjay Raut on Notice Over Criticism of CJI

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has asked Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut to explain his remarks targeting the judiciary after he criticised Chief Justice of India Surya Kant for declining to meet Rahul Gandhi and other Opposition leaders. A Bench comprising CJI Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi issued the direction while hearing a petition filed by Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders challenging the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls and raising concerns over the functioning of the Election Commission of India (ECI). Raut is also among the petitioners in the case. The Court has allowed Raut to participate in the proceedings for now, but made his continued participation subject to an explanation of his conduct. “In W.P. (C) No. 1351/2026 (Item 25), the petition on behalf of Petitioner No. 6 is entertained on a provisional basis, subject to his explaining his conduct,” the Bench stated.

Raut's remarks on the judiciary

Raut had questioned the CJI's decision not to meet Gandhi and other Opposition leaders, who had sought an audience to discuss concerns surrounding the Election Commission. In his criticism, the Shiv Sena (UBT) MP alleged that judges were willing to interact socially with political leaders but refused to meet Opposition representatives when they sought to raise issues concerning democracy. He also claimed that around 80 Supreme Court and High Court judges had been seen playing badminton with political leaders in London. “You can meet them, play with them, have dinner or lunch with them, with Chief Ministers. You can suddenly resign to join a political party. You don’t care for principles and law then but when we want to meet you to save democracy…you say we will not meet political leaders,” Raut had said. In a separate media interaction, Raut alleged that judges attended political events organised by the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), while BJP Chief Ministers hosted dinners in their honour.

Contempt proceedings also in focus

The matter comes amid a separate move to initiate criminal contempt proceedings against Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle over their comments concerning the CJI and the judiciary. Attorney General R Venkataramani has granted consent for the initiation of such proceedings following a request from the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA). In its plea seeking consent, the SCBA also disputed the context in which certain photographs had been presented. It clarified that images described as showing judges participating in a badminton event in London were, in fact, from an event held at New Delhi's Thyagaraj Stadium in November 2025. The Supreme Court's latest direction leaves Raut's participation in the electoral rolls case provisional until he addresses the concerns raised over his conduct.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Refuses to Reopen Section 163 BNSS Validity, Agrees to Examine Delhi Protest Orders

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has declined to entertain a constitutional challenge to Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), the provision that allows authorities to impose restrictions on public gatherings to prevent potential threats to public order. However, the Court will examine specific prohibitory orders issued during the recent Delhi protests and a separate challenge to the police powers granted under Section 172 of the law. A Bench comprising Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi is considering a series of petitions arising from demonstrations against the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls and Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. During the hearing, Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal questioned the use of BNSS provisions to impose restrictions in connection with the protests. The challenge also questioned the constitutional validity of Section 163. The Bench, however, declined to revisit the provision's validity, pointing to an earlier Supreme Court ruling that upheld the corresponding Section 144 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC). “Oral submissions were made with regard to the vires of Section 163 BNSS. However, as the pari materia provision of Section 144 CrPC has been upheld in Babulal Parate v. State of Maharashtra, (1961) 3 SCR 423, we are not inclined to entertain the same,” the Court observed. Section 163 BNSS empowers designated executive magistrates to issue urgent orders where intervention is considered necessary to prevent danger to human life, public safety, disturbances of public tranquillity or other specified threats. The provision replaced Section 144 of the former CrPC and can be used to restrict assemblies, processions and certain public activities. Section 172 BNSS challenge to be examined While declining to reopen the broader constitutional question surrounding Section 163, the Court has agreed to examine a separate challenge to Section 172 BNSS, which deals with compliance with lawful police directions. The provision requires people to follow lawful directions issued by police officers and permits the police to detain individuals who resist such directions or obstruct the discharge of police duties. The petition, filed by Samriddhi Das, questions the constitutional validity of the provision. The Bench issued notice to the Central government, the Delhi government, the Delhi Police Commissioner and other concerned authorities. “ issue notice, returnable on 19.11.2026, only on the limited issue pertaining to the constitutionality of Section 172 BNSS,” the Court said, fixing November 19 for the next hearing. Delhi protest restrictions under scrutiny In connected proceedings, the Court has directed the Union government to produce the prohibitory orders issued under Section 163 BNSS in Delhi. Petitions challenging individual orders will also be taken up on November 19. The wider batch of cases raises concerns over alleged police excesses, restrictions on public movement, the exercise of police powers and the removal of Jantar Mantar's designation as a protest site. The Court has scheduled November 3 to hear petitions concerning the Delhi demonstrations, police action and related issues. A separate petition concerning allegations of sexual harassment of women journalists covering the protests is listed for November 5. Meanwhile, petitions challenging the SIR exercise, including one filed by Congress leader Rahul Gandhi and other opposition political leaders, are scheduled for October 27. The Bench has also directed nodal counsel to classify overlapping petitions by October 28 so that separate, comprehensive counter-affidavits can be filed. The proceedings will therefore continue on two distinct fronts: the validity of specific restrictions imposed during the protests and the constitutional limits of police powers under Section 172 BNSS.

Read current report and source

Supreme Court Warns States of Contempt Over Delays in Implementing Menstrual Hygiene Rights

Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Supreme Court has given States and Union Territories a final opportunity to explain how they are implementing its directions on menstrual health, warning that non-compliance could trigger contempt proceedings against the concerned Chief Secretaries. A Bench of Justices JB Pardiwala and R Mahadevan expressed concern over the failure of several States and Union Territories to respond to the Centre’s requests for information on the steps taken to enforce the Court’s directions. The Court made it clear that it would not allow its recognition of menstrual health as a fundamental right to remain a declaration without practical consequences. “If what we have said in the judgment is only going to remain on paper, how is the Union, States/UTs going to give effect to this fundamental right?” the Bench asked. It added that the judgment was intended to protect young girls, particularly those in remote parts of the country, who are forced to miss or abandon their education because of inadequate menstrual hygiene facilities. The Bench warned that if the Centre reported continued non-compliance at the next hearing, contempt notices would be issued to the Chief Secretaries of the States concerned.

Menstrual health recognised under Article 21

The proceedings concern the Supreme Court’s January 30 judgment, which recognised menstrual health as an integral part of the fundamental right to life under Article 21 of the Constitution. The ruling directed the nationwide implementation of the Union government’s Menstrual Hygiene Policy for school-going girls and laid down mandatory requirements for both government and private schools. Under the directions, States and Union Territories must ensure that schools have functional, gender-segregated toilets with running water, accessible toilet facilities for children with disabilities, free sanitary napkins, dedicated menstrual hygiene management corners, covered waste bins and safe disposal systems. The Court subsequently revisited the matter on September 1, directing States and Union Territories to address identified shortcomings and submit details of the corrective measures taken.

Centre flags lack of responses

During the latest hearing, Additional Solicitor General Aishwarya Bhati informed the Bench that the Union government had taken up the matter with all States and Union Territories and sought information on compliance with the judgment. However, several administrations had yet to provide the requested details, prompting the Court to question why they were not responding to the Centre’s communications. The Bench directed the Union government to obtain written responses from every State and Union Territory, with particular attention to the requirements outlined in the September 1 order. That order had criticised authorities for submitting basic statistics or simple “yes/no” responses instead of explaining the actual conditions in schools. The Court had asked States to identify the facilities that remained unavailable, explain the reasons for the gaps and specify how much time would be needed to address them. It had also called for a gradual transition towards environmentally friendly menstrual products. To ensure that the responses provide meaningful information, the Supreme Court said the Centre could prepare a questionnaire covering the relevant directions and circulate it to all States and Union Territories. The underlying concern remains whether the facilities mandated by the Court are reaching the girls who need them, rather than merely appearing in official compliance reports. The matter is scheduled for its next hearing on December 14.

Read current report and source

Kerala High Court Allows Limited Aadhaar Fingerprint Matching

Kerala High Court · Editorial Team

The Kerala High Court on 14 October directed UIDAI to compare unidentified crime-scene fingerprints with records for Coimbatore district and inform investigators of matching persons’ whereabouts. The court said CDAC could convert the prints into the necessary format and treated the direction as exceptional and non-precedential. The request arose from an unsolved 2016 double murder after one suspect’s fingerprint had been identified.

Judge / Bench — Justice G. Girish.

Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — Public Prosecutor; Director General of Prosecution; P. Narayanan, Special GP to DGP and Additional PP; Sajju S., Senior GP; M. Muhammed Shafi, Additional State PP. For the respondents — Suvin R. Menon, Senior Panel Counsel, and O.M. Shalina, Deputy Solicitor General of India.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Records Police Assurance on Connaught Place Protest

Delhi High Court · Editorial Team

The Delhi High Court on 15 October recorded the Union government’s assurance that authorities had taken steps to regulate and control a proposed Connaught Place protest after vendors expressed concern about disruption. The connected petitions will next be heard on 3 November.

Judge / Bench — Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma.

Advocates appearing — W.P.(C) 15495 petitioners — Sacchin Puri, Sr Adv, Sanjay Podar, Sr Adv, Harsh Ahuja, Harsh Vardhan, Abhishek Singh, Swastik Bhuchar, Abhishek Gupta, Surender Sinha, Ashna Bhola, Shubhnavi Shivhare, Mehak Ghaloth, Sunil Kumar, Dhan Singh, Puneet Sharma, Sanjay Bobby Sharma, Krisha Shukal and Ayushi Chugh. W.P.(C) 15500 petitioner — Sanjay Poddar, Sr Adv, Sachin Puri, Sr Adv, Govind Kumar and Sameer Pandey. Respondents — Chetan Sharma, ASG, Amit Tiwari, Ashish Dixit, Jivesh Tiwari, Apoorv Shukla, CGSC, Amit Gupta, Shubham Sharma, Umar Hashmi, Naman, Jivesh Kumar Tiwari, CGSC, Ritu Bhardwaj, GP, Nandini Aggarwal, Ashish K. Dixit, CGSC, Akshay Chopra, Amit Acharya, Kalyan Babu Singh, Devendra Kumar, Kamaldeep and Rahul Kumar Sharma.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Declines to Return Child to Canada

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court on 9 October dismissed a father’s habeas-corpus petition seeking his daughter’s return to Canada. It held that the mother’s custody was protected by a subsisting Family Court injunction, while the Ontario order neither declared that custody unlawful nor awarded sole custody to the father. Jurisdiction and the child’s best interests require fuller determination in proceedings where both parents have joined issue.

Judge / Bench — Justice Anu Sivaraman and Justice T.P. Vivekananda. Judgment authored by Justice Anu Sivaraman.

Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — Prabhijit Jauhar for Deepa J. For respondents 1 and 3 — Ranjith Kumar, HCGP. For respondent 2 — Arun Govindraj and Siddhant S. Darira.

Read current report and source

Allahabad High Court Orders Uttar Pradesh Panchayat Elections Within Three Months

Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team

The Allahabad High Court on 14 October ordered Uttar Pradesh to complete village-panchayat elections within three months under the existing reservation system, including 27% OBC reservation. It rejected challenges to the administrator and election-notification provisions while allowing the dedicated commission to continue its empirical inquiry.

Judge / Bench — Justice Ajit Kumar and Justice Garima Prashad.

Advocates appearing — Petitioners — Birendra Kumar (in person), Jalaj Singh, Kripa Shankar Yadav, Mohammad Qais, Mohd Aadil Raza, Neha Rani, Pawan Kumar Yadav, Raghav Arora, Rajneesh Kumar Srivastava, Ray Sahab Yadav, Satyvendra Singh Yadav, Shashank Pandey, Priyanka Srivastava, Vinod Kumar Jaiswal; Ashish Kumar Singh, Sr Adv, with Rajneesh Kumar Srivastava, Dhirendra Kumar Srivastava, Raghav Arora and Raj Kumar Singh. Amicus — Samir Sharma. Respondents — Udayan Nandan, Aditi Pandey, CSC, Kaushlesh Pratap Singh, Prakhar Saran Srivastava, Pramod Shukla, Ramesh Kumar Tiwari, Satendra Kumar Singh and Ten Singh. State — Manish Goyal, AAG, with A.K. Goyal, ACSC. State Election Commission — Tarun Agarwal, Sr Adv, with Prakhar Saran Srivastava and Satyendra Kumar Singh. Dedicated Commission — Shashi Nandan, Sr Counsel, with Udayan Nandan.

Read current report and source

Prosecutors Must Act Independently of Police, Madras High Court Rules

Madras High Court · Editorial Team

The Madras High Court on 13 October dismissed a lawyer’s petition seeking Bar Council action against a former additional public prosecutor. The court held that the allegations did not constitute professional misconduct, while stressing that prosecutors serve justice rather than the police or complainant. They must evaluate the record independently, disclose material favouring the accused and avoid pursuing a case as persecution.

Judge / Bench — Justice G.R. Swaminathan and Justice M.D. Sumathi. Order authored by Justice G.R. Swaminathan.

Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — K.T.K. Janakiram. For respondents 1 and 2 — K.R. Shivashankari, Additional Government Pleader. For respondent 3 — K.R. Laxman, Standing Counsel. Respondent 4 — No appearance. Respondent 5 — Notice dispensed with; advocate not named.

Read current report and source

Karnataka High Court Rejects Divorce Based on Unproved Mental Illness

Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team

The Karnataka High Court on 24 September dismissed a husband’s appeal seeking divorce on cruelty and mental-disorder grounds. The court found that hospital records had not been proved through a doctor or expert and did not establish the statutory threshold for mental disorder. It said unsubstantiated allegations attacking a spouse’s mental health can themselves amount to legal cruelty, but irretrievable breakdown is not a statutory divorce ground available to the High Court.

Judge / Bench — Justice Ashok S. Kinagi and Justice Subramanya Rangarao. Judgment authored by Justice Subramanya Rangarao.

Advocates appearing — For the appellant — Prakash Yeli. For the respondent — S.B. Hangarki.

Read current report and source

Calcutta High Court Denies Anticipatory Bail in Festival Ticket Case

Calcutta High Court · Editorial Team

The Calcutta High Court on 15 October rejected former West Bengal minister Indranil Sen’s anticipatory-bail plea in a case alleging public deception through festival-preview tickets and misuse of government tenders. The court said State material concerning his family’s association with the society and entities awarded departmental contracts disclosed possible abuse of office and trappings of corruption that could not be ruled out during investigation. Documentary custody and his no longer being a minister did not eliminate the claimed need for custodial interrogation.

Judge / Bench — Justice Tirthankar Ghosh.

Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — Jishnu Saha, Sr Adv, Ayan Poddar, Soham Dutta, Shounak Mondal and Gargi Mukhopadhyay. For the State — Rajdeep Mazumdar, AAG, Kallol Mondal, PP, Aditya Tiwari, Moyukh Mukherjee, Sayan Mukherjee and Koustav Lal Mukherjee. For the de facto complainant — Atanu Ghosh.

Read current report and source

Meghalaya High Court Accepts Apologies for Lawyers’ Boycott

Meghalaya High Court · Editorial Team

The Meghalaya High Court on 14 October accepted unconditional apologies from advocates who joined a call to abstain from court work, discharged them from suo motu contempt proceedings and closed the PIL. The bench said the boycott was withdrawn promptly after notices were issued, the apologies showed genuine remorse and the advocates assured the court they would not support future stoppages. It held that these steps restored the majesty of law, while dropping proceedings against two lawyers who had continued appearing and two former office-bearers who had resigned before the resolution.

Judge / Bench — Chief Justice Revati Mohite Dere and Justice H.S. Thangkhiew. The order was authored orally by Chief Justice Dere.

Advocates appearing — For the petitioner — Not named in the order. For the respondents — N.D. Chullai, AAG, with A.S. Dey, Sr GA, and S. Laloo, GA.

Read current report and source

Kerala High Court Strikes Down Order Allowing POCSO Prosecutors to Handle Other Cases

Kerala High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Kerala High Court has struck down a State Government Order allowing Special Public Prosecutors appointed to handle cases under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act to also conduct cases under other laws, including the Juvenile Justice Act. A Division Bench comprising Chief Justice Soumen Sen and Justice Syam Kumar VM held that prosecutors appointed specifically for POCSO cases must be exclusively assigned to such matters. “The Government Order permitting Special Public Prosecutors appointed for POCSO cases to conduct non-POCSO cases cannot be sustained,” the Court observed. The ruling came in a public interest litigation filed by the District Court Bar Association at Thodupuzha-Muttom and its Secretary, Shaji Joseph. The petition challenged the State's decision to allow POCSO prosecutors to take up cases under the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. In its October 14 judgment in District Bar Association & anr v State of Kerala & ors, the High Court relied on a Supreme Court ruling delivered in 2020. The apex court had clarified that Special Public Prosecutors appointed under the POCSO Act should not be entrusted with cases falling outside its scope. It had also directed States to appoint dedicated public prosecutors for courts exclusively established to try POCSO offences. Finding the State Government Order inconsistent with these directions, the High Court set it aside and directed Kerala to appoint public prosecutors exclusively for POCSO cases within six weeks.

Court flags need for more POCSO courts

Beyond the question of prosecutorial assignments, the Bench examined the infrastructure available for handling cases involving offences against children. Taking note of an affidavit filed by the Registrar (District Judiciary) on the requirement for additional POCSO courts, the Court directed the State government to consider setting up 13 additional permanent POCSO Special Courts — one in every district except Ernakulam. The Bench also asked the Registrar to ensure that all existing POCSO courts have the facilities mandated under the POCSO Act and the applicable guidelines under the Juvenile Justice Act. The State government was further directed to provide the financial assistance needed to upgrade court infrastructure. With these directions, the High Court brought the public interest litigation to a close, emphasising the need for dedicated prosecution arrangements and adequately equipped courts to deal with cases under the POCSO Act.

Read current report and source

Delhi High Court Says Women Can Face Gang-Rape Charges for Enabling Sexual Assault

Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees

A person need not physically commit rape to face charges of gang rape. The Delhi High Court has ruled that a woman can also be prosecuted for the offence if she allegedly acts alongside others or facilitates the crime in furtherance of a common intention. Justice Anup Jairam Bhambhani, while interpreting Section 70 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), held that the provision does not restrict criminal liability to male participants. The ruling came in a case in which an accused woman challenged the gang-rape charge framed against her. “There is no rationale or basis to restrict the word ‘persons’ appearing in the phrase ‘one or more persons constituting a group’ to mean only a group of men,” the Court observed, stressing that the term must be understood in a gender-neutral manner.

Physical participation in rape not essential

The Court clarified that an accused need not personally carry out the physical act of rape to attract a gang-rape charge. A person who allegedly helps others commit the offence, acting with a shared criminal intention, may also fall within the scope of Section 70. Explaining this principle, the Court noted that a woman who is not among those physically committing the rape may nevertheless have acted to facilitate the assault on the victim. To underline the point, the judgment invoked a German proverb: “He who holds the ladder is as guilty as the thief.” The Court concluded that there was no legal basis to hold that a woman could not be charged with gang rape under Section 376D of the erstwhile Indian Penal Code (IPC), now replaced by Section 70 of the BNS.

Allegations involving minor daughter

The case arose from allegations that the accused woman had forced her minor daughter to engage in sexual relations with a man. It was further alleged that the woman was present during repeated sexual assaults on the child between December 2023 and July 2024. A criminal case was registered in July 2024 under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act, 2012, and the BNS. The trial court subsequently framed a gang-rape charge against the woman under Section 70 of the BNS. Challenging that charge before the High Court, the woman argued that she could not be prosecuted for gang rape because she was female and the statutory definition of rape under Indian law identifies a man as the perpetrator. The High Court rejected her plea in its judgment delivered on October 15, holding that a woman can face a gang-rape charge when the legal requirements of the offence are met, provided she is not the sole accused.

Question of a woman being the sole accused left open

The Court drew a distinction between a woman participating in a gang-rape offence with others and a woman being charged with the offence as the only accused. It observed that charging a woman alone with gang rape would, at first glance, appear inconsistent with the statutory definition of rape under Section 375 of the IPC, as amended in 2013, and Section 63 of the BNS. However, the Court did not conclusively settle whether a woman could ever be the sole accused in such a case. It left that question open for consideration in an appropriate future matter, particularly in view of the expanded definition of rape, which includes additional acts that may be committed by a non-male offender. The judgment also made clear that it was not deciding whether the term “man” in the provisions prescribing punishment for rape should itself be interpreted as gender-neutral. The ruling establishes that gender alone cannot shield an alleged participant from a gang-rape charge where the law's requirements concerning group involvement or common intention are satisfied.

Read current report and source

Madras High Court Rejects Plea to Scrap TVK Victory Over Use of Children in Campaigns

Madras High Court · Sheikh Rayees

The Madras High Court has ruled that involving children in political campaigning to influence their parents' voting decisions may be distasteful, but the practice alone does not provide sufficient legal grounds to invalidate an election. Justice D Bharatha Chakravarthy made the observations while dismissing an election petition challenging the victory of Tamizhaga Vetri Kazhagam (TVK) candidate R Rajendran in the Salem North Assembly constituency during the 2026 Tamil Nadu elections. The petition was filed by DMK candidate K Sivakumar, who lost the election to Rajendran by 14,034 votes. Sivakumar alleged that the campaign had relied on children to exert pressure on family members, amounting to undue influence under the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The Court strongly criticised the practice, particularly the creation and circulation of social media videos featuring children attempting to persuade their parents to support a political party. Justice Chakravarthy described the involvement of young children in such activities as inappropriate, adding that turning these acts into politically motivated social media reels reflected poor judgment by the adults responsible. However, the Court distinguished objectionable campaign tactics from the legal threshold required to set aside an election. It held that emotional persuasion by children did not automatically establish undue influence, which must interfere with an individual's freedom to exercise their electoral rights.

Social media videos at the centre of the dispute

Sivakumar's petition referred to a speech delivered by TVK president Joseph Vijay, now Tamil Nadu Chief Minister, on April 21, 2026. According to the petitioner, Vijay had encouraged children to press their parents to vote for TVK, comparing the appeal to children demanding chocolates such as Kinder Joy. The petition also cited social media videos allegedly showing children threatening family members to secure votes for the party. The examples included threats to throw cow dung at a parent, commit suicide and poison a father's food if he refused to vote for TVK. Sivakumar argued that these incidents violated Election Commission guidelines prohibiting the use of children in election-related activities and should be treated as grounds for invalidating Rajendran's victory. The Court acknowledged that children can hold considerable sway over their parents, particularly in Tamil Nadu, where they are often accorded a prominent place within family life. Nevertheless, it found that such influence, even if the allegations were accepted as true, could not by itself be equated with overpowering an adult voter's free will. The judge also pointed out that adults had introduced the children to the political messaging, encouraged them to perform the acts, recorded the videos and helped circulate them.

Election guidelines do not automatically invalidate results

The Court further held that violating the Election Commission's circular prohibiting children's participation in campaigning did not independently constitute a ground for setting aside an election under the Representation of the People Act. It also ruled that Vijay's speech could not automatically be treated as a corrupt electoral practice attributable to Rajendran without establishing the required connection between the speech and the candidate or his election agent. The judge observed that whether the use of children in political campaigns should be expressly prohibited or made a specific ground for invalidating election results was a broader policy question for Parliament to consider. Finding that the petition failed to establish a legally sustainable basis for challenging the result, the Court dismissed Sivakumar's plea at the threshold. The ruling draws a distinction between conduct that the Court considers politically and socially inappropriate and conduct that meets the legal requirements for overturning an election.

Read current report and source