The Court refused to quash criminal proceedings against a woman accused of running an online harassment campaign involving fabricated allegations, morphed content and inflammatory claims against a man.
The Karnataka High Court has cautioned that having a social media account does not give anyone unrestricted freedom to publish whatever they wish, emphasising that online expression must remain within the constitutional boundaries of free speech.
Justice Suraj Govindaraj made the observation while dismissing petitions seeking to quash criminal proceedings against a woman named Shubha and another accused, Mohan, over allegations of defamation, threats and the circulation of inflammatory material targeting Thanusha M Shetty.
“A social media handle being available would not give a free license to any person to post any message that a person wants. The messages which are posted ought to be within the exercise and limits of Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution,” the Court observed.
Allegations of online harassment and fabricated content
The dispute arose from a complaint filed by Shetty, who alleged that he had been targeted through a coordinated social media campaign involving morphed images, fabricated material and false claims about his religious identity.
According to the complaint, the accused circulated content portraying him as belonging to the Christian community, allegedly with the intention of creating hostility against him.
The posts also allegedly accused Shetty of committing rape, forcing an abortion, having links to the Sowjanya murder case, insulting Hindu temples and involvement in offences under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences (POCSO) Act.
The allegations further included an attempt to murder Shetty by running him over with an autorickshaw.
Court refuses to interfere with criminal proceedings
In an order dated October 15, the High Court rejected Shubha’s plea to quash a criminal case involving allegations of circulating inflammatory material and attempting to commit an offence under Sections 353(2) and 62 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), 2023.
Through a separate order passed on the same day, the Court also dismissed another petition filed by Shubha and Mohan seeking to quash proceedings under Section 353(2) BNS in connection with the alleged online campaign against Shetty.
The accused had argued that the criminal proceedings were initiated out of political and personal vengeance because of their support for the Dharmasthala temple.
The Court, however, found no sufficient grounds to accept that argument or terminate the proceedings at the present stage.
It observed that the complaint, when considered on its face, raised allegations that warranted a proper investigation into the circulation of allegedly fabricated and inflammatory content through social media.
“The allegations in the complaint, taken at face value, disclose a case requiring investigation into the alleged circulation of false and inflammatory material through social media. The petitioners have not established that the FIR is liable to be quashed at this stage,” the Court held.
The High Court therefore declined to interfere, leaving the allegations to be examined through the criminal investigation and trial process.
Advocate Kethan Kumar appeared for the petitioners, while High Court Government Pleader Ranjith Kumar N represented the State.