The Court ruled that the Housing Board could not charge the developer afresh for alternative land provided in exchange for property acquired from its predecessors, particularly after the Board’s own faulty allotment forced a second land exchange.
The Supreme Court has dismissed appeals filed by the Uttar Pradesh government and the Uttar Pradesh Avas Evam Vikas Parishad, rejecting their attempt to recover ₹388 crore from real estate developer Gaursons India Pvt. Ltd. for alternative land allotted to it.
A Bench of Justice PS Narasimha and Justice Alok Aradhe upheld the Allahabad High Court’s decision quashing a June 2022 order issued by the State Chief Secretary and the consequential demand notice raised by the Housing Board in September 2022.
The dispute originated from the acquisition of 12.047 acres belonging to the predecessors-in-interest of Gaursons for the Housing Board’s Vasundhara Scheme in Ghaziabad.
In 1995, the Supreme Court disposed of the Housing Board’s appeal on the basis of a compromise under which the acquired land would be adjusted within the scheme. Part of it was to be used for water purification-related construction, while the remaining portion was to be kept open. The arrangement expressly provided that neither party would pay any additional value or compensation for the exchange.
A faulty allotment triggered years of litigation
Under an Exchange Deed executed in 2004, the Housing Board allotted two parcels of land, bearing Khasra Nos. 948 and 1454, in Arthala village to the original landowners.
The parcels were subsequently sold to Gaursons in 2005. However, it later emerged that the land had already been resumed by the District Magistrate in 1994 for a bird sanctuary. Revenue records also described the properties as lake and banjar land.
Consequently, the original beneficiaries could not obtain possession of the allotted land.
Following years of litigation, the Housing Board executed another Exchange Deed in 2016, providing Gaursons with alternative land under the Siddharth Vihar Yojana.
Gaursons paid ₹32.45 crore towards land conversion charges and subsequently constructed 2,476 general housing units and 450 economically weaker section (EWS) and lower income group (LIG) flats. These residential units were sold to homebuyers.
The controversy resurfaced following a public interest litigation before the Allahabad High Court and a report submitted by a Special Investigation Team (SIT).
In June 2022, the Chief Secretary directed that the land be allotted to Gaursons at the prevailing bulk sale rate. Acting on that direction, the Housing Board issued a demand notice seeking ₹388 crore from the developer.
The Allahabad High Court subsequently struck down conditions (ii) and (iii) of the Chief Secretary’s order, along with the consequential demand notice. The State government and Housing Board challenged that decision before the Supreme Court.
State argued that residential use violated the original land conditions
Before the Supreme Court, the State government and Housing Board contended that the 1995 compromise and Clause 4 of the 2004 Exchange Deed restricted the land’s use to water purification-related purposes.
They argued that the 2005 sale deed incorrectly described the property as residential and that the subsequent 2016 exchange had disregarded the original restrictions.
The authorities also relied on the SIT report, alleging collusion between Housing Board officials and Gaursons.
Opposing the appeals, Gaursons maintained that the Housing Board had retained and commercially developed the original acquired land within the more valuable Vasundhara Scheme without paying compensation to the original landowners.
The developer argued that the 2016 Exchange Deed was not a fresh commercial allotment attracting payment at prevailing bulk sale rates. It also pointed out that ₹32.45 crore had already been paid as conversion charges.
Supreme Court says Housing Board cannot transfer consequences of its own mistake to builder
Examining the 1995 compromise, the Bench clarified that the expression ‘said land’ referred specifically to the property acquired from the original landowners and required the Housing Board to adjust that land within its scheme.
The Court rejected the argument that the original compromise imposed permanent restrictions on every alternative parcel subsequently allotted by the Housing Board.
“The compromise does not attach a perpetual restriction to whatever land the Housing Board might eventually give in exchange,” the Bench observed.
The Court then examined how the Housing Board had allotted the Arthala properties despite their prior resumption for a bird sanctuary and the adverse entries in the revenue records.
It found that the authorities had failed to exercise due diligence before making the 2004 allotment, leaving the original landowners unable to take possession despite having committed no fault themselves.
The Bench agreed with the High Court that the 2004 Exchange Deed had failed because of the Housing Board’s own shortcomings. The Board was therefore required to arrange alternative land in place of the originally acquired property.
Since the 2004 deed could not survive the defective allotment, its restrictions could not subsequently be imposed on Gaursons through the 2022 government order.
The Court accordingly upheld the High Court’s decision to strike down condition (iii) of the Chief Secretary’s order, which sought to reintroduce the earlier land-use restriction.
2005 sale deed transferred rights over replacement land
The Supreme Court also rejected the contention that the alternative land could not have been transferred to Gaursons.
It observed that the property had been allotted in exchange for land belonging to the original owners, who were entitled to transfer their rights.
“It is trite law that a person possessing title over a property has the absolute right of transferring and alienating the same to a third person,” the Bench held.
Examining the 2005 sale deed, the Court found that it transferred not only the allotted property but also the right to receive any other land that the Housing Board might subsequently provide in its place.
Consequently, the rights arising from the later allotment also vested in Gaursons.
2016 Exchange Deed treated as a fresh registered arrangement
The Bench attached particular significance to the 2016 Exchange Deed, noting that it was a separately registered instrument executed with the State government’s no-objection and concerned a different plot under a different housing scheme.
Unlike the earlier arrangement, the 2016 deed expressly described the substituted property as a residential freehold plot and permitted residential construction.
The Court further examined Clause 13 of the deed, which incorporated the condition from the 1995 compromise that no additional value or consideration would be payable.
It held that the parties had consciously chosen which terms of the original compromise would apply to the substituted property. The restrictions contained in the failed 2004 Exchange Deed could not automatically be extended to the 2016 arrangement.
No justification for additional ₹388-crore payment
Rejecting the demand for payment at the prevailing bulk sale rate, the Supreme Court considered the terms of the 2016 deed, the comparatively lower circle rates applicable in the Siddharth Vihar Scheme and the ₹32.45 crore already paid by Gaursons as conversion charges.
The Bench also noted that the Housing Board had retained and developed the originally acquired land in the Vasundhara Scheme, which was more valuable than the replacement property, without paying compensation to the original landowners.
In these circumstances, the Board could not demand an additional amount from Gaursons for the substituted land.
The Court also considered the State’s reliance on the SIT report alleging collusion between the developer and Housing Board officials, noting that Gaursons had disputed both the constitution of the SIT and its findings.
Finding no merit in the appeals, the Supreme Court dismissed Civil Appeal Nos. 9025 of 2026, 9026 of 2026 and 9027-9028 of 2026, thereby upholding the Allahabad High Court’s judgment.
The Bench also extended by three months the two-month period previously granted to the Uttar Pradesh government for allotment of the 450 EWS/LIG flats.
The parties were directed to bear their own costs.