Saved newspaper
10 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 13 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Supreme Court Restores Acquittal in Criminal Breach of Trust Case
- Power Subsidy Tied to Operating Costs Is Taxable Revenue
- Widow’s Limited Estate Becomes Absolute Under Succession Law
- False Promise to Marry Charge Cannot Apply Against Woman
- Marriage-Based Will Revocation Survives Constitutional Challenge
- General Abuse Without Sexual Remarks Does Not Trigger Harassment Charge
- Cattle Transport Cases Did Not Justify Preventive Detention
- Kerala Must Prioritise Consumer Commission Staffing and Infrastructure
- Allahabad High Court Mandates Transparent State Counsel Appointments
- Motor Accident Interest Runs From Claim Date Absent Special Reasons
- Fresh Vigilance Review Permitted in Caste Scrutiny Proceedings
- Guest Faculty Cannot Claim Regularisation Beyond Available Work
- Courts Need Cogent Grounds Before Declaring Accused Absconders
Supreme Court Restores Acquittal in Criminal Breach of Trust Case
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
India’s Supreme Court has restored an acquittal for criminal breach of trust, holding that the prosecution failed to prove entrustment, misappropriation or dishonest intention.
In Ramkrushna Dongardive v State of Maharashtra, decided on 8 October 2026, the Court found that the High Court had overturned the trial court’s acquittal by effectively shifting the burden to the accused. Suspicion surrounding the handling of funds could not replace proof of the statutory ingredients.
The Court allowed the appeal and reinstated the acquittal. The judgment reiterates the additional restraint required when an appellate court reviews an acquittal: a plausible trial-court view cannot be displaced merely because another inference is possible.
Read current report and source
Power Subsidy Tied to Operating Costs Is Taxable Revenue
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
India’s Supreme Court has ruled that an electricity subsidy linked to a manufacturer’s actual power charges is a taxable revenue receipt rather than a capital receipt.
In Mepco Industries v Commissioner of Income Tax, decided on 7 October 2026, the Court applied the “purpose test” to the scheme’s immediate design. Because the payment reimbursed operating expenditure after production, it supported the business’s day-to-day costs instead of financing creation of a capital asset.
The Court rejected the argument that the State’s broader industrial-development objective converted the payment into capital support. It dismissed the company’s appeal, reinforcing that tax character turns on how a subsidy operates in the recipient’s hands.
Read current report and source
Widow’s Limited Estate Becomes Absolute Under Succession Law
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
India’s Supreme Court has held that a widow’s limited estate in agricultural land became an absolute ownership right under Section 14(1) of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
In Sultan Singh v Financial Commissioner, decided on 9 October 2026, the Court said the Delhi Land Reforms Act’s reference to personal law incorporated later changes made by the succession statute. Khajano’s pre-existing maintenance interest therefore matured into full ownership, allowing her sons to inherit after her death.
The Court rejected the argument that Section 14 could not affect rights created before the 1956 Act. It dismissed the appeal and upheld the succession claimed through Khajano.
Read current report and source
False Promise to Marry Charge Cannot Apply Against Woman
Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team
The Karnataka High Court has held that a woman cannot be prosecuted under Section 69 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita for obtaining sexual intercourse through a false promise to marry.
In H.K. Prathibha v State of Karnataka, decided on 25 September 2026, the Court said the statutory offence is framed around conduct by a man toward a woman. It therefore quashed the Section 69 allegation against the woman co-accused.
The ruling did not end the investigation. Authorities may continue examining allegations that data or photographs were transferred, and may proceed under other applicable provisions if supported by evidence. The petition was consequently allowed only in part.
Read current report and source
Marriage-Based Will Revocation Survives Constitutional Challenge
Kerala High Court · Editorial Team
The Kerala High Court has upheld Section 69 of the Indian Succession Act, which automatically revokes specified wills when the testator later marries.
In the judgment reported as 2026:KER:77525, the Court rejected arguments that the provision unlawfully discriminates or conflicts with the rule that marriage does not itself create property rights between spouses.
The Court reasoned that Section 69 neither transfers property on marriage nor prevents a person from making a fresh disposition. It only revokes the earlier will; if the estate is not otherwise dealt with, it may pass under succession law to the new family. The constitutional challenge therefore failed, and the connected reference was answered accordingly.
Read current report and source
General Abuse Without Sexual Remarks Does Not Trigger Harassment Charge
Kerala High Court · Editorial Team
The Kerala High Court has held that abuse directed at a woman does not attract the offence of making sexually coloured remarks unless the words carry a sexual character.
In Prasad Mahendragiri v State of Kerala, decided on 16 September 2026, the Court quashed the charge under Section 354A(1)(iv) of the Indian Penal Code because the alleged language, though offensive, was not sexually coloured.
The Court did not terminate the prosecution. Counts alleging obscene words, criminal intimidation and insult to a woman’s modesty were allowed to continue, as their ingredients and the accused’s intent require assessment at trial. The ruling narrows one statutory offence without treating general verbal abuse as legally inconsequential.
Read current report and source
Cattle Transport Cases Did Not Justify Preventive Detention
Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court · Editorial Team
The High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh has quashed preventive detention based on criminal cases alleging unlawful cattle transport, finding no material showing communal tension or a public-order disturbance.
In Din Mohd Wani v Union Territory of J&K, decided on 6 October 2026, the Court found that the detention grounds reproduced the police dossier without independent assessment. It also held that the detainee had not been informed of his right to make a representation to the District Magistrate before government approval.
The Court ordered his immediate release unless required in another case. The judgment distinguishes ordinary law-enforcement allegations from the higher threshold required to justify preventive detention under public-order powers.
Read current report and source
Kerala Must Prioritise Consumer Commission Staffing and Infrastructure
Kerala High Court · Editorial Team
The Kerala High Court has directed the State to prioritise staffing and infrastructure for consumer commissions, warning that shortages are obstructing adjudication and enforcement of orders.
In an interim order dated 7 October 2026, the Court noted a ₹1 crore modernisation sanction and a proposal to create 229 posts. It required the Finance Department to provide details within three weeks and stressed that timely facilities for adjudicatory bodies remain the State’s responsibility.
The order does not finally decide the proceeding. It keeps the matter under supervision, with the next hearing fixed for 2 December, while seeking concrete progress on vacancies, facilities and execution capacity in the consumer-dispute system.
Read current report and source
Allahabad High Court Mandates Transparent State Counsel Appointments
Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team
The Allahabad High Court has directed Uttar Pradesh to make appointments of State Law Officers through a need-based, transparent and merit-focused process.
In a batch decided on 5 October 2026, the Court required workload assessment, objective selection criteria and publication of the process. Candidates should have no disqualifying criminal antecedents, and existing law officers must report criminal cases to the Advocate General.
The guidelines also call for adequate representation of women, prior permission before State counsel act against the government, and examination of whether government lawyers should contest Bar elections while holding office. The Court disposed of the petitions after setting the framework, emphasizing that public legal appointments are not patronage but professional offices tied to the administration of justice.
Read current report and source
Motor Accident Interest Runs From Claim Date Absent Special Reasons
Gujarat High Court · Editorial Team
The Gujarat High Court has held that interest on motor-accident compensation ordinarily runs from the date of the claim petition and may be withheld only for recorded special reasons.
In the appeal decided on 8 October 2026, the Court increased compensation by ₹277,432, taking the total award to ₹619,460. It directed payment of 9% annual interest from the filing date and required the insurer to deposit the amount within 12 weeks.
The Court said delay connected with service or ordinary procedure did not, without more, justify depriving the claimant of interest. The ruling treats interest as part of effective compensation for the period during which a claimant is kept out of the awarded money.
Read current report and source
Fresh Vigilance Review Permitted in Caste Scrutiny Proceedings
Bombay High Court · Editorial Team
The Bombay High Court has held that a caste scrutiny committee may seek a fresh vigilance examination when material before it raises genuine doubts about a document or earlier inquiry.
In Rupali Shigwan v State of Maharashtra, decided on 5 October 2026, the Court sustained the committee’s invalidation order and the resulting disqualification. It found that the claim relied on a fabricated document and a tampered genealogy, making renewed scrutiny justified.
The judgment treats the committee’s power to verify evidence as inherent to its statutory task, rather than confined to accepting an initial vigilance report. The Court also urged the State to frame rules or standard procedures for the recently introduced appellate mechanism in caste-certificate disputes.
Read current report and source
Guest Faculty Cannot Claim Regularisation Beyond Available Work
Madhya Pradesh High Court · Editorial Team
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that guest faculty members have no vested right to regularisation and may continue only while work is available and until a regularly appointed or transferred incumbent takes charge.
In a batch decided on 6 October 2026, the Court upheld the State’s recruitment framework, including reservation and age-relaxation measures. It rejected claims that prolonged guest service itself created an entitlement to permanent appointment.
The Court nevertheless directed that a displaced guest faculty member should be offered the nearest available post in the relevant subject, where one exists. The decision balances continuity for temporary teachers with the State’s authority to fill sanctioned posts through regular recruitment.
Read current report and source
Courts Need Cogent Grounds Before Declaring Accused Absconders
Delhi High Court · Editorial Team
The Delhi High Court has quashed a prosecution for failing to appear, finding that the accused had been declared an absconder after court processes were repeatedly sent to addresses that the record showed he did not occupy.
In Tajinder Mohan Singh v State, pronounced on 9 October 2026, the Court directed trial courts to record cogent, objective reasons before treating an accused as absconding or proclaiming an offender. Courts must scrutinise service and warrant reports, seek evidence where an address is doubtful, and personally assess the material.
The complainant should provide verified physical and electronic service details. The ruling stresses that coercive procedure cannot substitute for proof that service was genuine and avoidance deliberate.
Read current report and source