Saved newspaper
12 Oct 2026 — The Lawyers' Post — Daily Edition
Saved newspaper edition with 14 court reports.
Download newspaper edition · Paper archive
- Supreme Court Acquits POCSO Accused After Identification Failure
- Seniority Between Temporary Appointees Runs From Regularisation
- Supreme Court Finds Prima Facie Contempt in Delhi Metro Shutdown Row, Seeks Officials’ Replies
- Bank-Initiated Lookout Circulars Cannot Survive Completed Investigations
- Preventive Detention Materials Must Be Supplied in Known Language
- Sikkim High Court Condones Delay Despite False Pleading
- Allahabad High Court Upholds Sanction Based on CVC Advice
- Trustee Discharged From Drug Case Lacking Specific Allegations
- RTE Students Cannot Demand Transfer Between Private Schools
- Madras High Court Restores Elderly Widow’s Right to Shared Home
- Patna High Court Reduces Attempted Rape Conviction to Molestation
- Special Marriage Act Cruelty Must Persist Since Marriage Solemnisation
- Bombay High Court Orders Release of Seven Detained During Anti-ECI Protests in Goa
- Delhi High Court Gives Meta 72 Hours to Remove Fake and Obscene Content Targeting Kangana Ranaut
Supreme Court Acquits POCSO Accused After Identification Failure
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court has acquitted a man convicted under the POCSO Act after finding that the prosecution failed to establish his identity as the perpetrator beyond reasonable doubt.
Justices Vikram Nath and Sandeep Mehta noted that the child and her cousin did not identify the appellant in court. Their accounts also contained material inconsistencies, the disclosure was delayed and a teacher who received the first account was not examined.
The bench found further support for a credible alibi and held that the evidentiary gaps could not sustain the conviction. It set aside the Meghalaya High Court judgment and trial-court conviction, ordering Charming Rupon’s immediate release unless required in another case. The judgment was delivered on 9 October 2026.
Read current report and source
Seniority Between Temporary Appointees Runs From Regularisation
Supreme Court · Editorial Team
The Supreme Court has held that inter se seniority for temporary or special-category appointees ordinarily runs from regularisation unless governing rules clearly prescribe another method.
Justices S. V. N. Bhatti and Shree Chandrashekhar rejected a claim by compassionate appointees to count temporary service from 1981 ahead of direct recruits appointed in 1983. The compassionate appointments were regularised only in 1984, and the relevant framework did not authorise retrospective seniority.
The court said length of ad hoc or temporary service cannot displace regularly appointed employees without a clear legal basis. It disposed of the connected appeals with modifications to the seniority determination in M. Prema’s case on 9 October 2026.
Read current report and source
Supreme Court Finds Prima Facie Contempt in Delhi Metro Shutdown Row, Seeks Officials’ Replies
Supreme Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Supreme Court has found a prima facie case of contempt over alleged non-compliance with its directions on restrictions imposed on Delhi Metro and railway services during protests held on October 10. A Bench of Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana issued notices to Union Home Secretary Govind Mohan, Delhi Police Commissioner Anurag Kumar and Delhi Metro Rail Corporation (DMRC) Chairperson D Thara, directing them to respond by October 13. The proceedings stem from a contempt petition filed by advocate Shailendra Mani Tripathi, who alleged that authorities failed to comply with the Court’s October 9 directions concerning public transport restrictions ahead of demonstrations demanding the resignation of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. After examining the petition and hearing the submissions, the Bench concluded that a preliminary case had been established to warrant a response from the officials concerned. The three respondents have been asked to submit counter-affidavits along with a report detailing compliance with the earlier order. The Court has, for now, exempted them from appearing personally.
Dispute over Metro station closures
The controversy centres on restrictions imposed ahead of protests linked to the Election Commission of India’s Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, which has drawn criticism from opposition parties. On October 9, the Supreme Court questioned the apparent overreach in notifications proposing restrictions on public transport ahead of the demonstrations. It directed the authorities to reconsider plans to close 57 Metro stations, ensure regulated train operations and publicise any revised arrangements so that commuters would not face unnecessary hardship. A contempt petition was subsequently filed, alleging that Metro stations continued to remain closed despite the Court’s directions against a complete shutdown of public transport. During the hearing, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta rejected the allegation that the authorities had disobeyed the order. He told the Bench that Metro services had operated normally, although 45 of Delhi Metro’s 303 stations were closed as a law-and-order precaution. He further submitted that all stations had reopened by 10 PM on October 10, train operations were running normally and internet connectivity had been restored.
Detention allegations also before the Court
The Bench also took up a separate petition alleging that thousands of people, including opposition leaders, were unlawfully detained during the handling of the protests. Notice was issued in that matter as well. The contempt proceedings, the detention-related petition and other connected matters are scheduled to be heard on October 13. The latest order marks a preliminary judicial finding that the allegations warrant examination; it does not, by itself, establish that the officials are guilty of contempt.
Read current report and source
Bank-Initiated Lookout Circulars Cannot Survive Completed Investigations
Delhi High Court · Editorial Team
The Delhi High Court has quashed bank-initiated lookout circulars against petitioners whose criminal investigations had concluded and resulted in charge sheets.
Justice Amit Mahajan held that a lookout circular cannot continue routinely merely because a person faces trial. A bank’s financial claim and an unsubstantiated fear that the accused may leave India do not, by themselves, justify an indefinite restraint on travel.
The court left separate circulars issued at the CBI’s request for the trial court to consider and made clear that pending proceedings and lawful travel conditions remain unaffected. It allowed the petitions filed by Sirajuddin Qureshi and others on 7 October 2026.
Read current report and source
Preventive Detention Materials Must Be Supplied in Known Language
Kerala High Court · Editorial Team
The Kerala High Court has set aside a preventive-detention order because the detainee was not supplied the order and relied-on documents in a language she understood.
Justices Anil K. Narendran and Muralee Krishna S. held that meaningful communication is a constitutional safeguard, not a formality. Providing materials in an unfamiliar language deprived the detainee of an effective opportunity to make a representation against detention.
The court invalidated both the detention order and its confirmation, directing Ayishath Ruksana’s release unless she was required in another case. The judgment, delivered on 9 October 2026, reiterates that every document forming the basis of preventive detention must be made intelligible to the person detained.
Read current report and source
Sikkim High Court Condones Delay Despite False Pleading
Sikkim High Court · Editorial Team
The Sikkim High Court has condoned a 223-day delay in a civil revision but imposed costs after the applicant advanced an unverified and later withdrawn explanation blaming former counsel.
Justice Bhaskar Raj Pradhan applied a justice-oriented approach to limitation, finding that the dispute should be heard on merits despite the defective pleading. The court stressed, however, that litigants must approach courts promptly and cannot casually attribute delay to a previously engaged advocate without proper verification.
The application was allowed subject to payment of ₹50,000 to the Sikkim State Legal Services Authority for rehabilitation of POCSO victims. The order was delivered on 8 October 2026.
Read current report and source
Allahabad High Court Upholds Sanction Based on CVC Advice
Allahabad High Court · Editorial Team
The Allahabad High Court has upheld prosecution sanction in a corruption case, rejecting an argument that an earlier internal view amounted to a final refusal.
Justice Subhash Vidyarthi held that the competent authority could accept advice from the Central Vigilance Commission and reconsider the matter on fuller material. The earlier departmental communications were not a conclusive order declining sanction, and disagreement with vigilance advice would have required referral under the applicable process.
The court found prima facie material supporting cognisance and no failure of justice in the sanction decision. It dismissed Jay Pratap Singh Chauhan’s petition challenging the proceedings on 8 October 2026, leaving the evidence for assessment at trial.
Read current report and source
Trustee Discharged From Drug Case Lacking Specific Allegations
Bombay High Court · Editorial Team
The Bombay High Court has discharged a managing trustee from a prosecution under the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, holding that a public charitable trust cannot automatically be treated as a company or association of persons under Section 34.
Justice Ranjitsinha Raja Bhonsale found that the complaint did not describe A. P. Hinduja’s operational role or allege how he was responsible for the institution’s day-to-day conduct. His office as managing trustee, without specific factual allegations, could not create vicarious criminal liability.
The court said continuing the case would amount to an abuse of process and allowed the petition, setting aside the proceedings against him. The judgment was pronounced on 1 October 2026.
Read current report and source
RTE Students Cannot Demand Transfer Between Private Schools
Chhattisgarh High Court · Editorial Team
The Chhattisgarh High Court has held that children admitted under the Right to Education Act cannot demand automatic transfer from a closed private unaided school to another such institution.
The court said the statutory framework does not create an enforceable right to continue free education in a different private school after closure. It nevertheless directed the state to place the affected students promptly in nearby government schools, with priority for English-medium facilities where available.
Authorities must prevent transfer certificates or missing records from delaying admission. The court disposed of the petition filed by Atharv Gupta and other students on 6 October 2026, while requiring practical arrangements to protect their continued education.
Read current report and source
Madras High Court Restores Elderly Widow’s Right to Shared Home
Madras High Court · Editorial Team
The Madras High Court has restored residence and protection directions for a 73-year-old widow while staying an appellate order that had displaced them.
The court said legislation protecting senior citizens cannot be reduced to a monetary arrangement when residence and security are at stake. It directed the district administration and police to ensure Mahalakshmi’s safe re-entry into the shared home, while clarifying that the interim order does not decide title.
Her son must pay ₹15,000 a month, and police must make daily visits and file reports on her safety. The directions remain interim while the criminal revision proceeds, with the next hearing fixed for 29 October 2026. The order was pronounced on 9 October 2026.
Read current report and source
Patna High Court Reduces Attempted Rape Conviction to Molestation
Patna High Court · Editorial Team
The Patna High Court has replaced an attempted-rape conviction with a conviction for assault or criminal force against a woman, finding that the prosecution proved an outrage to modesty but not an act sufficiently proximate to penetration.
Justice Sandeep Kumar said preparation becomes an attempt only when the accused performs an overt act directly moving towards commission of rape. The evidence in Md. Ainul Haque’s appeal did not meet that threshold.
The court affirmed the house-trespass conviction, reduced both custodial sentences to time already served and imposed a ₹25,000 fine under Section 354 IPC, payable entirely to the prosecutrix. The amount must be deposited within eight weeks. The decision was delivered on 8 October 2026.
Read current report and source
Special Marriage Act Cruelty Must Persist Since Marriage Solemnisation
Karnataka High Court · Editorial Team
The Karnataka High Court has dismissed a husband’s appeal seeking divorce under the Special Marriage Act, finding that he failed to prove cruelty or qualifying mental disorder.
Justices Jayant Banerji and K. V. Aravind distinguished Section 27(1)(d) of the Special Marriage Act from the Hindu Marriage Act. The provision requires proof that the respondent has treated the petitioner with cruelty “since” solemnisation, rather than merely at some point “after” marriage. The evidence did not establish that continuous statutory condition.
The court also found no reliable medical evidence showing incurable unsoundness of mind, a qualifying mental disorder or psychopathic disorder of sufficient severity. It therefore upheld the Family Court’s dismissal of the petition in MFA No. 2480 of 2022 on 7 October 2026.
Read current report and source
Bombay High Court Orders Release of Seven Detained During Anti-ECI Protests in Goa
Bombay High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Bombay High Court’s Goa Bench has ordered the immediate release of seven people detained by police during protests against the Election Commission of India (ECI) at Azad Maidan in Panaji, observing that their detention appeared unauthorised in the absence of prohibitory orders. A division bench of Justices Valmiki Menezes and Amit S Jamsandekar passed the order during a special Sunday hearing on a habeas corpus petition filed by advocate Malisa Zemira Simoes. The Court questioned the legal basis for the detentions, noting that no prohibitory order under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) had been issued. “In the absence of prohibitory orders under Section 163 of the BNSS,” the Bench observed, the detention might not have been authorised.
Police cite oral instructions from Executive Magistrate
The petition concerned Afreen Shaikh, Jack Sukhija, Bupesh Bind, Aditya Parulekar, Listan Noronha, Shamino Fernandes and Milind Rane. According to the plea, the seven were forcibly taken from Azad Maidan and held at Pernem Police Station without formal prohibitory orders or stated reasons for their detention. Police officials from Panaji and Pernem informed the Court that the North Goa Collector had rejected the group’s application to hold a public gathering on October 9. They further submitted that Executive Magistrate Dattaprasad Toraskar, who was present at the location, had orally instructed police to detain the group after they allegedly entered Azad Maidan. The Bench, however, expressed concern over whether the detention was legally authorised in the absence of a prohibitory order.
Phones to be returned; medical check-ups permitted
During the hearing, counsel for the petitioners gave an undertaking that the seven individuals would not stage a protest at Azad Maidan overnight. Following this assurance, the Court directed the authorities to release them immediately. The Bench also ordered the return of their mobile phones and allowed them to undergo medical examinations at Goa Medical College in Bambolim, if they wished to do so. Senior advocate Norma Alvares appeared for the petitioners alongside advocates Om D’Costa and Mayank Suri. Additional Public Prosecutor Pravin Faldessai represented the State of Goa. The ruling came amid protests targeting the ECI, with the Court examining the legality of the detention rather than the merits of the demonstrators’ grievances.
Read current report and source
Delhi High Court Gives Meta 72 Hours to Remove Fake and Obscene Content Targeting Kangana Ranaut
Delhi High Court · Sheikh Rayees
The Delhi High Court has directed Meta Platforms to remove fake news, derogatory posts and obscene online material targeting actor and BJP MP Kangana Ranaut, granting her interim protection in a personality rights case. Justice Vikas Mahajan issued the directions on October 8 in Kangana Ranaut v. Meta Platforms Inc. and Others, ordering Meta, which operates Facebook and Instagram, to take down the objectionable material identified by Ranaut within 72 hours. The Court also directed the Union Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology and the Department of Telecommunications to instruct the concerned internet service providers and telecom operators to block access to websites hosting the flagged content within the same timeframe.
AI-generated material among the complaints
During the hearing, Ranaut raised concerns over fabricated news circulating online and obscene material allegedly created using artificial intelligence. Her plea seeks protection against the unauthorised and harmful use of her identity and the circulation of content that infringes her personality rights. The Court had issued notices to social media intermediaries and other entities accused of publishing or hosting the disputed material, seeking their responses to the allegations. In its interim order, the Court also allowed Ranaut to flag additional offending content discovered after the case was filed. This would cover infringing URLs, social media accounts, channels and other material. The Court clarified that she would not need to initiate fresh proceedings every time further objectionable content came to light. Once notified of the additional material, the concerned defendants would be required to remove it or disable access to it in accordance with the order.
Next hearing in February 2027
The directions provide a mechanism for addressing further instances of allegedly infringing content as they emerge online, rather than limiting the relief to material already identified in the original plea. The matter is scheduled to come up again before the Delhi High Court on February 3, 2027, when the proceedings are expected to continue.
Read current report and source